GOD okay listen I know we in fandom talk a lot about the representation that James McGraw gives to gay and bisexual men in media but like.
Honestly, the thing that gets me so choked up about this goddamn pirate in his goddamn pirate show is how few tells the show gives you that he is a man who fucks men. (As a note I DO headcanon James as bisexual but for this discourse I’m specifically talking about how he has sexual relationships with men so i’m gonna refer to that as him being ‘gay’. But like. We do not stan bi-erasure on this blog.)
You know he’s gay because the show gives him a lover, because he tells you, because his feelings for Thomas are very clearly romantic and sexual, but there is nothing in his dress or physicality or actions that gives it away. So often in media when there is a gay character - especially a main gay character - you clock them immediately based on a part of their look or movement or word choice. They’re always the soft characters, the weaker, smarter guys, or they have nice hair, or really care about their looks or are fragile, not the leading sort.
(This is just a screenshot of the first search page when i put in ‘gay characters in tv shows’, to try and explain the Look I’m talking about. It’s the hair style, the clothes, the actor’s face type even, that, if you watch enough gay media, you can clock who the gay character is by those choices.)
And then Black Sails came along and said ‘You know that character we’ve repeatedly shown to just go off the fucking rails, who doesn’t give a shit if people disagree with him, who is educated but also oh my god so terrible with people, who gets dirty and bloody and doesn’t complain about it, who we had beat a guy to death with his bare hands in the very first episode?
And then they just…seamlessly integrated it with his character in the smallest, most poignant ways. Like it is a huge part of who Flint is but there’s not ‘before the viewers knew I was gay and after they knew I was gay’ moments - he is just always that. And they never take away anything else from the first season Flint, they never sacrifice his masculinity to achieve that.
The scratch on his cheek, the weird clothing lines! This is a man who only keeps his hair that long so he doesn’t have to brush it and routinely forgets to take his shoes off in the house.
They allow him to be dirty and bloody and scrappy and not always put together. They put him in the same kinds of clothes the others wear and in fact a lot of the times he is pointedly not the prettiest one on screen he looks just like everyone else and I just -
As a gay guy it can feel a lot like you need to perform your sexuality. Even in queer spaces the tendency to ‘act gay’ is so strong it has literally shaped the identities of gay men I know(myself included). And part of that is the desire to be visible, right, but I feel like it it’s also because there are so few characters in popular media like Flint who just. Are. Gay. No frills. No ‘here’s how you know.’ And if you never see the difference you think ‘god, is there something wrong with me that I like men but don’t look like that?’
To see a show just go ‘yeah this character is gay but we’re not gonna play it for laughs or shits or have the trope of gayness thrust upon him but just - he’s played like a real goddamn guy.
Black Sails really just saw every trope around masculinity and queerness and then went