“J…. Jenna.” Aria said. “You killed my friends. How dare you?”
“…why? How could anyone be so cruel?” Aria was in tears.
“Well, it’s your fault, Aria. You and your sluttish queen bee Alison. You see why Alison had such an overkill for a death? Because it’s me, Aria. You know how much we hate each other.” Jenna stated.
“So this is all because of… Ali?” Aria asked. Aria had begun to loosen the rope binding her wrists.
“No? It’s because of Toby.” Jenna looked enraged.
“Right…. Who you killed?” Aria rolled her eyes.
“I didn’t kill Toby. Why would I kill Toby?” Jenna was crying.
“W….who killed Toby?” Aria asked, loosening the rope with each diversion.
“Elaine. I sent her after the two to try to switch off the power… And she killed him….. So I killed her.”
“Y… You killed Elaine before today?”
“Yes. And since they’re twins…… you’ve been talking to the real Emily.”
“So where is she?” Aria got defensive.
“I’ll get to her soon. Don’t you want a Sobby backstory?”
“I mean. You’re gonna tell it anyway.” Aria said, being thankful for Jenna’s diversion.
“Here’s the story. From the start. The main target of my rage was Spencer. The bitch took Toby away from me. He spent more time with you guys than he ever did at home, with me…. In part, you’re as guilty as Spencer was. So, by luring in the 5 of you with false reunion hope , along with those you loved, I was able to test your morality and get my revenge that had built up in me for so long. I started with Alison. By killing Kenneth, I was able to weaken Alison into doing the game, I mean, she probably would have left. I had to give her the push to stay, as she was another target of mine. Emily and Elaine betrayed me by changing the Kenneth plan, so I had to get rid of what they loved most- Paige. I couldn’t acquire their dad, as we know, he’s deceased. Their mom is out of town on a family emergency. Paige was 3rd resort. Then, I started to kill off your peers. I again struck for something Alison related. After all, what doesn’t connect back to the DiLaurentis family in the end? You’re probably expecting me to tell you I’m a long-lost DiLaurentis or something, but I’m not. I’m a Marshall, born and raised. I did not, however, kill Jason. I mean, he was thrown under the bus by Noel.” Jenna paced back and forth as she told the -A story.
Aria was almost done with the binds.
“One by one, killing off each piece of the puzzle as I went, except for my Brother and Caleb, it lead back to you, Aria. But, I didn’t kill Alison. That was redcoat.”
“R…Red coat?” Aria asked.
The door opened. In walked red coat. They removed their hood and blonde wig. It was Emily.
“Stop.” Jenna silenced her. “This is who killed Alison. Am I really strong enough to fight that strong of a girl? By calming to the sound of someone she trusted, Alison was easier to subdue by Emily.”
Emily took a seat in a chair nearby.
“Now, next. Oh yeah, the 3 A’s. I, as stated, am Ubër A. But do you know who Big -A is, Aria?”
“No.” Aria said. “I’ve never hurt anyone.” Tears filled her eyes.
“Lies. You killed Ian, Aria.”
“…that was so long ago. I…I had to kill Ian. You made me kill Ian…. You blackmailed me.”
“Not to mention, you gave me permission to kill Jason. How is that worse than what I’ve done?” Jenna asked.
“Mona is A, too. I mean, can I really slide all these deaths past Mona? She assisted, especially in Jason’s REAL murder.”
“Where is Mona?” Aria was getting defensive.
“She’s fine. She’s just drugged.” Said Jenna, pulling a syringe out of her pocket. “That’s my story. Now. Two of us are going to walk out of here, Aria. Who will die? Will it be You, Mona, or Emily?”
“Neither.” Aria said, pouncing from the chair and punching Jenna in the nose. Jenna collapsed, dazed on the ground.
Emily rose, preparing to pounce on Aria.
“Emily, stop. She can’t control you anymore. We’re going to turn her in.” Aria comforted her. Emily cried. Elaine was gone.
Emily came to. “That Bitch… Took her from me….” Emily’s face turned. “No dad, no sister… Just me and Mom.”
“Let’s find Mona.” Aria said.
It wasn’t hard. She was on the floor of the cafeteria, knocked out.
The two woke her and called the Police.
“Y… Yes.. I’d like to report 10 murders…”
“11…” Emily said, including Elaine.
“1…11 murders.” Aria corrected.
The police came soon after. There was blood everywhere, of course. Jenna wasn’t expected to clean up though.
“This isn’t the last of me.” Were Jenna’s final words as she was led out the door in handcuffs.
Mike and Mona had been reunited, and the two were as happy as ever.
Emily returned home with her mom… She was never going to be over Elaine.
Jenna was sent to a psychiatric penitentiary that was out of the county.
Rosewood High provided funds for a section for the fallen, which would be, ironically, outside the Bio Room. The 10 bodies would be buried soon after. The valedictorian of the class of 2015, Spencer Hastings, would be honored by a plaque in the school. Veronica would take the award for her late daughter.
The DiLaurentis family was gone. There was no one left. Alison, Jessica, Kenneth, and Jason were all gone.
Aria had won. She would never recover. But now she had the freedom to eat chickpeas every day, if she wanted. A text rang on her phone:
"Crime Scene, Last Known Whereabouts, or Morgue. What will it be, bitch?
Aria, @spezriona, you are the winner of Whodunnit PLL, congrats!
If anyone wants to say a congrats, you’re encouraged to send us an ask so everyone can see!
Thank you all for playing! We hope you had as much fun playing as we did running it! Always feel free to ask questions about anything in the story or anything in general!
titsay
gummygunk
tangentwithtanner
dailybridgerton
discoholicmusic
