Comparative Plum Paper Planner vs. Practical Paper Co. Planner
Photos can be viewed here: Â https://flic.kr/s/aHskC7f4F1
Just received my first Practical Paper Co. Planner, and as a Plum Paper gal, I had to do a quick review between them. Admittedly, I use the MAE (morning-afternoon-evening) vertical Plum, and my new Practical Paper is horizontal, but I can still review the basic differences.
I am a HUGE fan of Practical Paper’s traveler’s notebooks and I would recommend them to ANYONE!  So, when I needed a new horizontal planner for work, I checked into Practical Paper’s planner options and decided—for many reasons—to give them a go.
First, the shipping for Plum is far higher (as is product cost), so if COST is vital to you, Practical Paper with their similar up front cost, but FREE shipping USPS will save you a lot of money. Secondly, Practical Paper has some coupon codes for as much as 30% off for some folks, but I’ve never seen a coupon for more than 10% from Plum Paper anywhere.
Now to the nitty gritty.  I ordered my Practical Paper on the 13th of June and it was delivered by USPS here on June 24th.  That is almost twice as fast as my two previous Plum Paper orders (due to shipping by Plum Paper who does NOT use USPS unless you pay extra).  Today’s planner was packaged nearly identically to my Plum Paper orders of the past, in both bubble wrap and a sturdy cardboard box. It also contained a pencil, a roll of washi tape and a coupon for $10 off my next $25 order, which was nice. This planner was shipped and arrived at my house within four days…..both of my Plum’s took over three weeks (due to their shipping option).
Both companies advertise 70# paper, and while the weight is similar, I think the Plum is “slicker” just slightly.  The Practical Paper seems slightly rougher and appears more “photocopied” than Plum for lines.  All Practical is greyscale, while Plum is color coded more by month. That’s not at all important to my needs, but it will be to some.
The horizontal lines and writing space is more on Practical Paper, which is the primary reason I went with this company for this specific need.  They have 9 lines to write on per horizontal day and each space is 1 3/8” tall.  Now, I NEEDED that extra space, but the way Practical gets that done is that there is nothing “extra” on that page (like a small monthly calendar), other than a “notes and goals” section at the end of every week. Â
The weeks run Monday through Sunday like Plum, and I admit I normally don’t like that…..but it’s growing on me. J  The months are divided by color-coded tabs like Plum, but here is where the REAL difference is seen.  Plum has their tabs covered by plastic lamination while Practical does not.  This makes the tabs in Practical BEND very easily.  While this won’t bother me that much, my daughter’s reaction was “Oh heck no….just NO.” In addition, the dividers seem to be less “firm” cardstock than Plum, and are printed only on one side.  There is also no place for monthly goals ON that page like Plum’s reverse side. Â
Finally, the cover and coil. The coil is smaller but same weight as my Plum, BUT this new planner is thinner than my plum.  I didn’t ask for as many add on pages to the Practical.  The cover is only a cardstock sheet laminated, which is fine for my needs, but it’s not as “pretty” or “finished looking” as the Plum to my eyes. However, it IS very firm and feels durable.  Â
The only real “complaint” and this will have to stand the test of time to see if it plays out, is that there isn’t as much “real estate” from the punched holes on the Practical to the end of the sheet. I’ll share photos of that so you can see, but my fear is that it will tear our easier than it should due to this. Time will tell on that, however. You can also have them do disc binding, but I wanted coil, so I can’t speak to the disc binding at all. Â
Pens and all that wrote and erased just like Plum. The washi and stickers adhered well and repositionable ones removed properly.  No shadowing of the pens I tried (Frixion, Ink Joy, Steadler Fineliners, and my trusty Bic stick blue pen were all I tried.  Clearly, due to the difference in size of the lines, stickers will fit differently, but I care little about that…..this is a tool for me and I won’t be decorating it other than to create more functionality, so if it’s not quite “perfect” it won’t matter at all to me.
All in all, the quality overall of Plum seems better, BUT the Practical is a nice value option for my newest need.  I think it will serve this new need well enough. Where Practical shines is their shipping and customer service. This is my third order from them, and they’ve not let me down yet.  I also usually get a reply to my emails within a day (even on weekends).  Amy, one of the agents of the company, emailed me back to a query while she was on a mountain bike ride one weekend even! Â
So, to say these two are “similar” would be accurate.  To say they’re “the same’ would be in error….It truly depends on how hard you are on a planner and your basic overall needs.  Practical is the ONLY company I’ve found thus far that even COULD have met my space needs for this new project, and this will be perfect for that reason.  You just need to be honest with yourself on what your needs are and weigh those against your “desires.” Â
The paper inside, from a functional standpoint, is the same basically, so it will be the cosmetic/esthetic value that will be your deciding factor, I think.








