Warnings: Some swearing. Descriptive sexual acts. Anal, threesome, oral, fluids, double penetraton.
Just like all my other stories, this has not been proofread, but please enjoy.
Gifs & photos do not belong to me.
Main Masterlist ♡ AEW Masterlist ♡ Jon Moxley Masterlist ♡ Eddie Kingston Masterlist
Summary: Eddie & Jon both want the f/Reader. She can't choose between them.
YN's POV:
I have no idea how I ended up in this situation but it is my own fault. I should of just picked one of them, but I couldn't.
I am a selfish woman I guess and when two gorgeous looking men want to be with you, how can you pick?
Well I couldn't.
I couldn't pick between Jon and Eddie and they were both vying for my attention.
I met them on my first day as being a makeup artist and I knew after meeting them, I was done for.
Eddie with his gorgeous eyes and gorgeous smile. Jon with his gorgeous eyes an his hands, my God his hands looked strong and as I can feel them gripping my throat, I was correct.
From our first meeting and almost every other chance encounter we had, they were asking me out.
At first I kept saying no as I didn't want to be with anyone from work but then they sent flowers, candy, chocolate and gift cards.
Eddie even bought me a new car and I returned it to the dealership right away.
Jon bought me a motorcycle and I returned that as well.
I also didn't want to get between these two best friends. But that all changed after I went out with a few of my friends drinking and I woke up to text messages, photos and videos that I sent to the two of them.
I told them that the only way I can be with either of them is if I get to be with both.
I then sent each of them photos of me naked standing infront of my full-length mirror.
I also sent them each a video of me masturbing and moaning both their names over and over again.
I made sure to call into work sick as I just needed to spend the day at home, trying to wrap my head around what I started.
I also spent the day masturbing to the photos the two men sent me. When I saw their dicks I knew I was done for. I knew I would end sleeping with both of them.
So after two days of calling in sick, I knew I had to go to work, so I did. I went to work and did my job.
But I didn't see either of them while I was there and I breathed a sigh of relief. I knew I wanted them but I didn't want to have a conversation just yet.
So I left work happy that I had atleast one more day to think about what I was going to say.
What I was not expecting was to find the two men, sitting in Jon's truck, waiting for me to come home.
And fuck they both looked good, but then again they always do.
I stood there biting my lip trying to decide if I should let them in or ask them to leave and we can discuss this another day.
But my feet seemed to decide for me as I walked to passengers side of the truck.
"Come." Was all I said and I turned and walked towards my house. I heard the truck doors open and then slam close and they two men were right behind me.
I opened the front door and I walked in my front foyer. Eddie was right behind me and Jon came in last. He closed the door and locked it.
I put my keys in the bowl and I took a few deep breaths and turned around. Jon and Eddie was staring at me, waiting for my move.
To see if this is actually going to go in the direction that the three of us knew would eventually happen.
So I made the first move. I walked the few feet and wrapped my arms around Eddie's neck and stood on tippy toes and kissed him.
He wrapped his arms around my waist and pulled me flush against his body. The moan that left my mouth as I can feel how hard he already is.
But I pulled away from his lips and turned towards Jon. He placed his hands on my ass and lifted me up. I wrapped my legs around him as he kissed me much harsher than Eddie did.
I groaned as I felt how hard he was as well. Jon pulled his lips away from mine and kissed and bit down my neck.
I am a whimpering mess in his arms and I am ready to take him and Eddie right here. But thankfully one of us still had some common sense left.
"Bedroom?" Eddie asked. But my mind didn't register what he said until I felt a slap on the ass.
"He asked you a question YN." Jon growled at me.
"Down the hall, third door on the right." I whimpered.
I was expecting Jon to put me down but no, he just walked down the hall with Eddie right behind us.
I was placed on my bed and the two men looked around my room, but then their focus turned to me.
"Are you sure about this YN, because if we do this, this changes everything for us." Eddie said to me. Jon was nodding his head in agreement.
"We both knew we wanted to be with you and we don't want you to choose, so if you are okay with it, us three in a relationship?" Jon gruffly said.
Was I hearing this right?
"We can discuss this later but are you sure about us doing this YN?"
With a soft yes leaving my lips, it was like something awoke inside of them.
They both took off their clothes and with both of them telling me to strip, I did. I had less clothes on than them so I was naked before them, so them taking off each article of clothing was a beautiful site to me.
I already knew what I wanted to do to them. I have been dreaming of this moment since I met them.
So I got off my bed and got on my knees infront of them, trying to pick which one to take in my mouth first, but they decided for me.
Jon placed his hand on the top of my head and brought my head closer to his dick, which he was jerking off in the other hand.
My mouth watered at the sight of him doing it and I wrapped my lips around the tip. The moan that left his mouth had me moaning.
"Fuckin' hell YN." He looked down at me and I just winked up at him and took more of him into my mouth, until he was completely down my throat. My face was in his pelvis.
He pulled out slightly and thrust back in. Jon did this a few times until he figured I was comfortable enough.
I put both of my hands on his thighs as he started to fuck my face. I was moaning around his cock and I kept my eyes on his gorgeous face.
His head was flung back as he enjoyed the pleasure that my mouth was giving him. "Shit YN, always knew you would be a good cock sucker." I moaned at the dirty compliment.
A few more thrusts and Jon pulled out of my mouth completely. I was gasping for air and my chin was soaked with my drool. One long strand of silvia from my mouth was connected to his dick.
"Do you want Eddie's cock?" Jon asked me, while still gripping my hair. I moaned out that I did and before Jon let go of me, he leaned down and kissed me.
He stopped kissing me and took a step to the side. Before I even could think or say anything, Eddie had both of his hands on the side of my head.
"Open." I opened my mouth and stuck my tongue out and he thrust into my mouth. He was thicker than Jon and I had a harder time sucking him off, but I did.
But Eddie made sure to use my throat as his own personal flesh light and I loved every single fucking moment of it.
I have tears streaming down my face and I could hardly keep my eyes open.
"Eyes open YN and on me." Eddie told me.
I did as he asked and I could of came from him watching me alone.
"Come on man." Jon said somewhere off to the side. "You can cum down her throat another time, I need to fuck her."
A few more thrusts and Eddie pulled out of my throat as well.
The next thing I knew, I was being lifted and placed on the side of my bed and Eddie was between my legs.
He had two fingers in my pussy and was slowly adding a third one to stretch me. His tongue was licking my pussy on the outside and the inside. His lips would randomly wrap around my clit and suck.
"Fuck Eddie." I moaned as I held his head against me.
Jon, who was feeling left out got on the bed next to me and kissed me. I moaned into his kiss as Eddie continued to eat me out.
Jon and I kissed for a few moments and then he started to kiss down my neck once more and towards my chest.
He had one hand groping and one breast as he took the nipple into his mouth and sucked and bit on hit softly.
"Jon." I moaned. My tits have always been sensitive.
"Fuck YN, I can feel you baby. You're close aren't you?" Eddie asked me. My mouth was hanging open as I said yes, and with a smug smile, Eddie went back to eating me out.
My legs were shaking as the pleasure was becoming too much for me. I was close, so close.
But the fuckers pulled away from me, leaving me to cry out in frustration.
"The first time you cum with us, we want to be inside of you." Jon said to me. My whole body was over stimulated.
I needed to cum but they obviously have other ideas.
Eddie stood up and got on the bed and layed against the pillows I had propped up against the headboard.
"Come here gorgeous." Eddie said to me as he was slowly jerking himself off. Jon literally picked me up and helped me get situated over Eddie. My legs on either side of him, me just hovering over him slightly.
Eddie and I gasped as my pussy made contact with his cock. Eddie placed his other hand on waist, he slowly lowered me down.
My hands were on his chest, and I actually dug my nails into his skin slightly as he stretched me open.
"So big, fuck Eddie." I cried out as I now am impaled on him. It feels like he is in my stomach.
"Ride me pretty girl." Eddie said through clenched teeth. I raised myself somewhat and then back down.
I did this slowly a few times just enjoying the feel of him and Eddie was laying there, a smirk on his face.
I felt the bed dip behind us me slightly and then I felt a Jon kiss my shoulders and back. I shivered as I felt his lips.
I sat up slightly so I could reach my arm back and place it around Jon's neck, but before I could do that, I felt something cool and wet against my asshole.
Jon's fingers were slowly trying to work their way in and once I relaxed, it was easy for him to slide his fingers inside.
"Gonna fuck your ass baby. You did tell us you wanted this." Jon said to me and the text came back to me as I did say that.
Eddie told me to lay on him and I did. Jon stretched and fingered my ass for a few minutes until he felt it was time.
I tensed up slightly when I felt his cock at tight entrance. My face was in Eddie's neck as Jon slowly started to slide into my ass.
"Oh shit YN. Eddie man, you gotta fuck her ass. So tight, so fuckin' tight." Jon said.
"I plan on it. You gotta feel her pussy man. Fits me like a god damn glove."
I once again moaned at the sound of their voices.
The only sound you can hear in the room is our heavy breathing and then my gasp as Jon was now fully inside of me.
I have never felt so full in my life. Never thought I would ever do this but shit, I am glad I went out that night and had too much to drink.
"Move." I moaned.
That was all they needed to start fucking me. They started off slowly and then they got faster and faster.
Jon was gripping my ass and practically pulling me back and forth and Eddie was thrusting up into me so fast and hard, it was all starting to became too much for me.
I felt Jon put his hand on my shoulder and pull me back so my back was against his chest.
Neither one stopped fucking me. I felt Jon's hand grip my throat and I was done for.
"Cum for us pretty girl." I don't know who said it but with a literally scream of their names, I came.
Eddie chocked out the word fuck and I felt him cum in me. My name leaving his lips over and over again.
Jon's hand on my throat got tighter and then with a groan, he came in me. My mouth was hanging open, trying to breath and thankfully Jon let go of my throat.
With one last kiss to my shoulders, Jon slowly pulled out my ass and Eddie lifted me up and placed me on the bed next to him.
Jon got into bed with us and the three of us laid there, just enjoying the after glow of our sexual experience with one another.
Looking at the two of them, maybe I should take them up on their offer?
Why pick one when I can have both?
Tag List: if you would like to be added, please let me know. @eddie-kingstons-wifey @lghockey @lilaviolet @iloveeddiekingston @jazzy-bella02 @wwenhlimagines @hungmanhorsecarriage @ecarroll1978 @anaeve @crowleysqueenofhell @thenerdybaker523 @eddiekingstonsgirl89
izzy806
prguitarman
snowghoul
jacobvanloon
tangentwithtanner
areudirty
andulkaphoto
titsay
