Kimagure Orange Road has become somewhat of a comfort show for me over the past few years, standing on many streaming services as a heartfelt time capsule to 1980s Japan in a way that your typical YouTube citypop playlist could never capture. It's a silly, templated, often juvenile, and always fun ripoff of more beloved Rumiko Takahashi shows, but that doesn't mean it's not worth your attention. Good artists borrow, great artists steal, after all.
So after running through the show for a second (third?) time, I decided to finish off with the OVAs and the final movie, I Want To Return To That Day - basically everything that was already on the Cronch that I just hadn't gotten to, yet. I tend to like anime movies more than anime shows, but have a healthy skepticism for movies that follow their respective shows, especially movies that are essentially unvetted continuations of already completed stories. One of my favorite shows,Touch - which is faithfully referenced in this movie, funnily enough - has not one, but two pretty terrible spinoff movies that no one would ever consider canon. And since KOR was born of less-than-original ideas, anyway, one could expect I Want To Return To That Day to have a straight-to-video treatment.
But here's the funny thing: I Want To Return To That Day is not just a faithful continuation of KOR, but quite simply the best 70 or so minutes of KOR, period.
I Want To Return To That Day is KOR stripped down to its basic parts: Madoka, Hikaru, and Kyosuke engaged in a love triangle - no magic, no hijinks, no street fighting, just romantic drama. Except this movie asks the question, What if Kyosuke actually had to make a decision?
As it turns out, the answer is a bit more complicated than it seems. Thanks to Madoka's prodding, Kyosuke decides to break up with Hikaru and actually goes through with it. Except Hikaru doesn't accept this development, latching onto Kyosuke even after he and Madoka have made their love affair official.
A lesser movie might have taken this turn as an opportunity to highlight how clingy Hikaru has been throughout the entire series, but that's not what this movie does. Kyosuke is ridden with guilt, because he understands that his wishy-washiness has led to this complication, and he has to bear Hikaru's tears knowing there's nothing he can reasonably do to stop them. Madoka is also somewhat at fault, recognizing that she never admitted to her own jealousy of seeing Kyosuke and Hikaru as an item. And Hikaru's behavior is not beyond reproach - clinginess is most certainly not a virtue.
Basically, this is a love triangle where all three get hurt because they all share some blame in their situation. But I don't believe anyone deserves that much blame. These are high schoolers, after all, and high schoolers have to make these mistakes at some point in their lives. Sometimes two wonderful girls fall in love with an average boy, and there's no outcome that leaves everyone without at least a little bit of heartbreak.
The added production value of a movie-sized budget makes this an enhanced experience over your typical KOR episode, and with it comes some cinematic choices that almost make this good enough as a standalone movie. There are also some bangers in the dialogue, like when Hikaru tells Madoka, "If it's for him, I can do anything." What a line.
There's a review of this movie on MyAnimeList that connects I Want To Return To That Day with the bursting of Japan's 1980s bubble economy, essentially highlighting that the happy-go-luckiness of the original show got a conclusion that only a masochist would find uplifting. Kyosuke gets the girl, Hikari gets the part, and Madoka finds her path - but no one's happy about it. All the color of the show fades into grayscale by the end of the movie, because sometimes that's how the innocence of adolescence develops. Perhaps that's not the best representation of KOR, but it's the first time I finished anything related to the show and thought, "Wow, that was something."
And maybe it's because I've already advanced past my twenties, I know that these kids are ultimately going to be alright. That in 10 years' time, they will forget about how much this little romantic tryst meant to them as they face bigger challenges (yes, I've read the synopsis for the 1996 movie - no, I am not eager to watch it). But they can dance in the sweet memories whenever they want, even if their current world looks a little sadder by comparison. 9/10