Rain’s Creepypasta Masterlist
── ⟢ ・⸝⸝
─────────────────────────────────── gasoline - halsey
── .✦ do not copy, translate, or plagiarize any of my works. dividers by me.
✦ . characters, scenarios, and conversations are all fictional. enjoy!
────────────────────────────────────────────
HOW I SEE THE CHARACTERS
multi
Kinktober 2024
Kinktober 2025
Good Vibrations {jeff the killer} {eyeless jack} {ben drowned} - in which you own a vibrator
Sick Days - The Creepypasta guys are feeling a little under the weather. You, their lovely partner, spend the day taking care of them (whether they like it or not).
A Little R & R (Rest and Relaxation, Raw and Rough) - From breaking and entering, to scaring you half to death, the proxies have never been conventional lovers. So why would relaxing with you after a hard day at work be any different?
The Quiet Violence Of Wanting - Helplessness, guilt, remorse, and isolation—all unacceptable emotions when you’re a proxy. You’ve got blood on your hands, and purposeful or not, the cops don’t care. Their job is so take you in. It’s okay to need saving—especially if it’s from a pretty killer lady who’ll do anything to make you squeal.
Seven Minutes in Heaven {jeff the killer} - Slender’s gone, the mansion is empty, and everyone has pent up rage they need to let out through illegal substances. And what better way to settle a squabble than through a good old-fashioned party game?
headcannons
All headcannon/reaction posts under this tag!
#rainspastathoughts
#rainspastadaddies
Creepypasta Men Twitter Links
Creepypasta Men Twitter Links - Part 2
Creepypasta Men Twitter Links - Part 3
Creepypasta Women Twitter Links
Creepypasta Twitter Links - Multi Edition
reactions
Sitting on their lap
blurbs
{one} {two} {three} {four}
one-shots
Do You Think About Her? - Jeff liked to tease Toby about his lack of experience with women. So, when coming home from a mission with the two, you decide to tell Jeff off, spurring him into a jealous fit to see how far he can push you both.
Clean Knife, Bloody Blade - When you refuse to get out of bed due to terrible cramps, Jeff tries his best to coax you back. But when you cry and whine to him, the killer presses to resolve your problem, willing to do whatever he can to help…
Three's A Crowd - Video games can be emotionally intense, especially when you’re butting heads with the two idiots yelling at each other. So when Jeff and Ben decide to break their tie in another way, you find yourself in the wrong place at the wrong time: right in the middle.
It's Not The Same Without You - Words hurt. Alice knows what it’s like to be the brunt of the joke. So, when an easy mission turns into a disaster that reopens old wounds, she spirals. Jeff doesn’t understand, worries he did something wrong, and seeks help from the only person he can think of—Ben. Wise words and a knock on the head are all Jeff needs to swoop Alice back into his arms and prove to her just how perfect she really is—in the language they both speak best.
Double-Edged - It’s not unnatural for brothers to fight—that’s just what they do. But when those fights turn to near-death squabbles and punches are thrown hard enough to break necks, somebody has to step in. Unfortunately, that somebody has to be you.
series
Coming Soon
headcannons
General - Basic, SFW, and NSFW head-cannons. My personal thoughts, feelings, and opinions about Jeff as a character.
blurbs
{one} {two} {three} {four}
one-shots
Just Relax - You’re stressed. Jack knows how to fix that.
Restless - Your demon boyfriend is struggling with a wave of insomnia. You’re willing to do whatever you can to help him relax.
A Hunter’s Moon - Beneath late summer nights, Jack always found you. Human and monster, two different worlds separated by a picket fence. But when he didn't return, you set out to look for him. You find him in rut, in pain, in the ache of something like love—and what kind of friend would you be if you refused him?
Monster Of Flesh, Eat Me Whole {part 1} {part 2} - Creating life is no easy feat, but sustaining it is a whole different realm. You’re a widowed scientist calling on the power of the heaven’s themselves to bring your love back to you. But the townspeople only see you as a witch, a monster—and it only worsens when a very large shadow begins to follow you around, especially when he begins to eat the livestock.
series
On Unholy Terms {part 1} - You’re an exorcist sent by the church to investigate a graveyard deemed to be unholy. After stumbling upon a ‘demon’, your determination quickly falters.
headcannons
General - Basic, SFW, and NSFW head-cannons. My personal thoughts, feelings, and opinions about Jack as a character.
blurbs
{one} {two} {three}
one-shots
Do You Think About Her? - Jeff liked to tease Toby about his lack of experience with women. So when coming home from a mission with the two, you decide to tell Jeff off, spurring him into a jealous fit to see how far he can push you both.
Return The Favor - Stumbling in on your neighbor’s chopped-up body, an unlikely friendship forms between you and Toby. Striking a deal, you agree to help the killer and his friends, buying them the necessary prescriptions. But when one visit turns to multiple, Toby becomes curious, finding a not-so-subtle love note hidden away.
My Muse - What if the Creepypasta characters were real-life killers idolized the same way horror movie slashers were? Kids dressing up as Ghostface or Pennywise? More like kids decorated as Jeff the Killer or Slenderman! You chose to dress as your favorite mass murderer, Ticci Toby- and, oh, how he couldn’t get enough of it. He had never seen someone look so good in his goggles.
I Hate That Boy - You hate Toby Rogers. Hate. He’s immature, and whiny, and gets in your way more often than not. Proxies are meant to work together, but you two just don’t. Fights are prone to happen, but when your hands accidentally find his throat, Toby accidentally finds out that he likes it. You hate him. And he hates you. So why can he suddenly not jerk off without thinking about your hands on his neck? Why does he want you to do it again??
series
Refuge For Two {part 1} - You decide to spend the weekend at your family’s cabin during a snowstorm after a particularly stressful week. When you find an injured Toby, your need to care for him turns into his need for you.
You And Your Friends {part 1} {part 2} {part 3}- When your name appears in your late great-uncle’s will, you sell your house and move out to the Estate. A victorian manor, an endless garden, and too many candles to keep up with now belong to you—and so do the groundskeepers that come with it. But behind all the intricate furniture and shiny tile, you find that all things have secrets—even the handsome ones.
headcannons
General - Basic, SFW, and NSFW head-cannons. My personal thoughts, feelings, and opinions about Toby as a character.
blurbs
{one}
one-shots
Behind The Veils - Hiking to capture the perfect sunrise photo for your portfolio, you stumble upon a supposedly abandoned cabin, your curiosity driving you to investigate. When you're met with two very large and very aggressive masked men, they decide that they'll put you to good use.
Let Me Hear You - Walking the same path every day while listening to music is your routine. Humming along, Masky makes it his routine to follow you. Until you wander somewhere you shouldn’t…
Outrun, Undone - Your body hurt, heaving and clawing to escape. They were catching up, laughter echoing through the dense trees as you ran, praying for your stamina to hold. But you knew you weren’t fast enough, and so did they…
Numb Fingers - Returning from a mission, the proxies get caught in a bad storm, causing them to seek refuge in a dingy motel. They’re rain-soaked, irritable, and—even better—there’s only one bed. They agree to keep it civil… until the storm knocks the power out, and you find yourself growing very cold.
series
Run Rabbit Run {chapter 1} {chapter 2} {chapter 3} {chapter 4}- When a cop with a knack for interrogation, a suspect who won’t break, and a game of cat and mouse where the truth is buried beneath layers of lies all unfold in a dingy police station, all hell breaks loose. Can he keep the mask on, or will the cost of truth destroy them both? Either way, Masky decides you’re not getting out of this unscathed.
You And Your Friends {part 1} {part 2} {part 3} - When your name appears in your late great-uncle’s will, you sell your house and move out to the Estate. A victorian manor, an endless garden, and too many candles to keep up with now belong to you—and so do the groundskeepers that come with it. But behind all the intricate furniture and shiny tile, you find that all things have secrets—even the handsome ones.
headcannons
Coming Soon
blurbs
{one}
one-shots
Keep It Rolling - You and your friend decide to see if you can find ghosts in an abandoned asylum as you record the whole thing. When you run into Hoodie, he thinks it’d be fun to record you instead.
Behind The Veils - Hiking to capture the perfect sunrise photo for your portfolio, you stumble upon a supposedly abandoned cabin, your curiosity driving you to investigate. When you're met with two very large and very aggressive masked men, they decide that they'll put you to good use.
Outrun, Undone - Your body hurt, heaving and clawing to escape. They were catching up, laughter echoing through the dense trees as you ran, praying for your stamina to hold. But you knew you weren’t fast enough, and so did they…
Don’t Kiss The Messenger - Letters, codes, word of mouth—carrying information is your specialty. The Slenderwoods are vast and diverse, so an impartial messenger is necessary to keep the peace. Your job is easy, your tasks are simple, and being nosy has its perks. But when one resident has an affinity for buying you drinks and keeping you company, you find it very hard to stay impartial after all.
Numb Fingers - Returning from a mission, the proxies get caught in a bad storm, causing them to seek refuge in a dingy motel. They’re rain-soaked, irritable, and—even better—there’s only one bed. They agree to keep it civil… until the storm knocks the power out, and you find yourself growing very cold.
series
You And Your Friends {part 1} {part 2} {part 3} - When your name appears in your late great-uncle’s will, you sell your house and move out to the Estate. A victorian manor, an endless garden, and too many candles to keep up with now belong to you—and so do the groundskeepers that come with it. But behind all the intricate furniture and shiny tile, you find that all things have secrets—even the handsome ones.
headcannons
Frat Boy Brian - fraternity brother headcannons (pre-mh)
blurbs
{one} {two}
one-shots
Whispers In The Woods - Prepped your whole life to complete a ritual to hand yourself over to a monster, you demand the reason why. When he gives you the answers, he demands your body.
Take It - Nightmarish visions drive you to seek out their sender, constant paranoia driving you mad. But when you find out he intends to make you work for him, he realizes you can’t be broken like the others. So he must take a more… intensive approach.
series
Coming Soon
headcannons
Coming Soon
blurbs
Coming Soon
one-shots
Three's A Crowd - Video games can be emotionally intense, especially when you’re butting heads with the two idiots yelling at each other. So when Jeff and Ben decide to break their tie in another way, you find yourself in the wrong place at the wrong time: right in the middle.
series
Coming Soon
headcannons
Coming Soon
blurbs
Coming Soon
one-shots
Don't Close Your Eyes Yet - From the first moment he laid his eyes on you at the fairgrounds, Jack knew he needed you. So going about it the only way he knew how, he began to give you dreams of him, preparing you for the night he would eventually take you himself.
It’s Just Your Imagination - Having an imaginary friend is a very normal part of childhood. What isn't normal, though, is when that imaginary friend begins to show up in the corners of your vision, leaving you presents and an uneasy feeling. What happens when babysitting a little boy turns into fending off his protector? The worst part? He thinks you're very, very pretty.
series
Coming Soon
headcannons
Coming Soon
blurbs
Coming Soon
one-shots
Smoke And A Light - When you're forced to remain a resident of the Slendermansion, hearing tales of the outside world is riveting. So, when Clockwork brings back some souvenirs, you couldn't possibly pass them up.
series
Coming Soon
headcannons
Coming Soon
blurbs
{one}
one-shots
Better Than Him - Nina wanted nothing more than to impress Jeff. So, as her best friend, she sought your help on how to get his attention. But when a quick lesson on how to kiss turns intense quickly, you feel it's only right to prove to her she's worth more than him.
Pretty Girl - The bar was Nina’s scene, her favorite place to be with you by her side. But when some creep tries to extract revenge in the middle of a crowd, you’re both forced to do what you do best. But when confidence falters, you have to show just how worthless guys like that can be.
series
Coming Soon
headcannons
Coming Soon
────────────────────────────────────────────
── .✦ rainrot4me2025, all rights reserved. ꩜ .ᐟ
