abracadabra! @abbacadabara - Tumblr Blog

countdown: two

chapter fifty seven | series masterlist | ao3

dean winchester x oc

i don't believe in god, but i believe that you're my savior

when you live a life that never allows you to understand the existence of home, you start to find it in other places. people, too. dean winchester's home is the driver's side seat of the impala, and always with sam next to him. bunny norton's home is across an ocean, and preferably as far away from dean winchester as possible. when they asked her all those years ago for her help, she'd come running. but dean makes her wish every day that she hadn't stayed.

slow burn, enemies to lovers. they hate bang in chapter four, but that's just to add flavor to the hate. canon is followed whenever i feel like it, tags will be updated as story progresses. slightly OOC dean in the first few chapters bc i like when the pretty man angry…

previous chapter

two 3 months, 22 hours, 16 minutes 22:16:01

It was almost an hour later, and the house was too quiet for a place where something had just died.

Dean moved through the living room with a cloth bunched in one hand and his gun still loose in the other, wiping down whatever he remembered touching because the job did not stop being the job just because the thing on the carpet was coming apart faster than a body had any right to. The place was nice in the way Henry Wilts’ house had been nice, soft and expensive and carefully warm, with a cream-colored couch arranged around a low glass table, framed school pictures on the mantel, a knitted blanket folded over the back of an armchair, and a television still murmuring silently to itself because someone had left it on mute before all hell broke loose. Lamps were glowing in the corners. There was a bowl of wrapped peppermints on the coffee table. There was blood on the plush carpet and a dead shifter folded in the middle of it like a thing dropped carelessly from a great height.

Caroline Hodge, or what had been wearing Caroline Hodge’s face, did not look much like her anymore.

It had held the shape for maybe five minutes after the silver round punched through its heart, long enough for the stolen face to slacken, the borrowed eyes to go glassy, the skin to pale under the living room light in a way that had looked almost peaceful if Dean did not know better. Then the body had started to shine. First at the cheeks, then along the throat, then at the hands where the fingers curled against the carpet, the skin taking on that waxy, wet look shifters got when death finally told the lie to let go. It was sloughing now, slow and disgusting, flesh loosening at the edges like bad paint in heat, the face softening into something unfinished while a sticky film gathered beneath the jaw and spread into the fibers below.

Shifter deaths were more mess than they were worth.

Dean knew that from experience. He knew the smell of them, sweet and rotten under the copper bite of blood. He knew the way they lost themselves after the fact, as if all the stolen faces they had carried were trying to crawl out at once and finding nothing left to hold onto. He knew that if they did not burn this one fast, the body would become an even bigger problem than it already was, something wet and nameless leaking into an innocent woman’s carpet. It should have bothered him more.

Maybe that was the sort of thing a man was supposed to worry about, in the little dead places inside himself where horror had become logistics, where a body melting on someone’s rug registered less as nightmare than inconvenience. But Dean had put down shifters before, had seen their skin come off in bathrooms and sewers and half-lit rooms that smelled like bleach and panic, and he knew with a tired certainty that he would see it again. Monsters died ugly. Hunters cleaned up after. That was the arrangement. That was the world, or at least the part of it he had been born into and never quite managed to crawl out of.

So no, the body did not bother him the way it probably should have.

Bunny did.

Not Bunny herself, exactly, because even now, even with the argument still sitting hot and unfinished somewhere behind his sternum, the thought landed wrong. It wasn’t Bunny that bothered him. It was the look in her eyes in the boiler room when he had told her to finish the sentence she had bitten in half. It was the way her face had changed when he said what he thought she had nearly said, the quick, offended hurt of it, like he had put a hand somewhere bruised and pressed before either of them could stop it. It was the fact that most of him knew she would never have finished that sentence with him at the end of it. Most of him knew Bunny better than that. Knew her teeth, her temper, her pride, the cold little rooms grief had built in her, and still knew she would not have looked at him under that ugly yellow light and said, it’s not like I’m torturing humans like you did.

Most of him knew.

The rest of him was jagged enough to catch on the possibility anyway.

Dean wiped his thumbprint from the edge of a side table and stared at the clean streak his cloth left behind in the dust. There were parts of him that expected pain like weather, from every direction, through every crack, even from the warm places. Especially from the warm places, maybe, because those were the ones that made a man stupid enough to take his armor off. Bunny had become one of those places without asking permission, a soft thing pressing itself against all his broken edges with stubborn hands and a sharp mouth and a wedding ring he looked at when he thought no one was watching. She soothed things in him he had not known could be soothed. She made some of the brittle pieces less likely to snap at the first wrong touch.

Which meant, naturally, that the ugly parts of him had started waiting for her to cut herself on them. Or worse, to decide they were not worth touching at all.

He rubbed harder at the table than he needed to, then stopped when the wood gave a faint, protesting squeak beneath the cloth. Across the room, the shifter’s body made a soft, wet sound as more skin loosened from the shape it had stolen. Dean didn’t look at it. He kept his eyes on the table, on the framed photo beside the lamp showing Caroline Hodge with a man and a little boy at some pumpkin patch in October, all three of them smiling under a hard grey sky while some monster wore her face to fool the world until Bunny dragged it underground and made it scream.

And the thing was, Dean knew torture was bad.

That sounded stupid even inside his own head, too clean and too flat for the kind of life he had lived, like something printed on a poster in a school hallway between recycling tips and fire drill instructions. He wasn’t standing there with his hands clean and his conscience polished, horrified by the mere idea of crossing a line. He had crossed too many lines to pretend he still knew where the first one had been. He had lied and stolen and killed, had burned bones and dug up graves, had left bodies in motel bathtubs and holes in the woods and blood in places no one would ever scrub all the way clean. Ethics, as far as Dean Winchester understood them, had gotten dragged behind the Impala over enough gravel to stop looking like anything useful years ago.

So no, it was not some bright moral rule making his skin crawl. It was the fact that Bunny had done it before.

It was the fact that she hadn’t looked ashamed when he walked in. That she had stood there in the heat and the noise with silver laid out in front of her like a surgeon’s instruments, cigarette between her fingers, music turned up loud enough to drown out screaming, and hadn’t understood, not at first, why the sight of her there made something cold and slick move down his spine. It was the methodology of it that kept catching under his ribs.

The preparation. The care. The silver chains, the blades, the syringe, the bottle of whatever-the-hell colloidal silver was—silver particles in liquid, she had said, all neat and clinical, like she was explaining a trick with salt rounds or a faster way to dig up a grave. He still wasn’t entirely sure what it meant, only that she had found out it hurt shifters without killing them, which meant she had tested it. More than once, probably. Enough to know dosage. Enough to know timing. Enough to know how much would make a thing scream without stopping its heart.

Loud music to cover the noise. Silver to hold it down. A kit rolled open like she had built herself a ritual and called it justice because justice sounded better than enjoyment.

Dean wiped at the table again, though the spot was already clean. If he and Sam hadn’t come through that door when they did, Bunny might have kept going. Maybe not as far as his mind wanted to take it, because his mind was a son of a bitch on a good day and a butcher on a bad one, always eager to hand him the worst possible ending and ask him to believe in it. But he had seen the look in her eyes. He had heard the way she said fun, bright and casual and terrible under all that heat.

Just having a bit of fun.

The sentence had been bouncing around his skull for the better part of an hour and a half, knocking into things he would have rather left alone. She had meant it. Maybe not lightly. Maybe not simply. But she had meant it, and that scared the shit out of him in a way the body on the carpet could not touch. Because he knew that feeling.

That was the part he couldn’t scrub off the table, no matter how hard he worked the cloth over the wood. He knew what it felt like to have the fear turned outward for once, to climb down from the rack with every nerve still screaming and find a hand putting a blade into his own. He knew the ugly relief of no longer being the thing begging. He knew the first time pain stopped being something done to him and became something he could do back, how it had opened in him like a door in a wall he had thought was solid. He knew the vicious little warmth of having a reason. They deserved it. They would do worse to you. They aren’t people. They aren’t innocent. They aren’t anything except what is under your knife.

Bunny’s reason was her mother’s scream. Molly’s blood. The thing wearing her father’s face.

A childhood gutted before she had even been tall enough to see over countertops, grief pressed into her bones so early that Dean didn’t know whether she would ever be able to pull it out and show him the whole shape of it. She had been six years old when the world taught her that a familiar face could open the door to Hell. Maybe there was no clean way to survive that. Maybe there was no version of Bunny who made it out of that house, out of all the years after, without some dark room of her own built around the need to make something pay.

Dean understood reasons. That was the problem. But the things under his knife had been people.

Not monsters, not really. Not once Alastair had finished with him. Souls. Human souls, or what had been left of them by the time they reached him, torn and terrified and still close enough to human that some part of him had known it even when he stopped letting that matter. People who had been bad, maybe. People who had been scared. People whose names he had never learned because names made things harder and Hell had been built to take hard things and make them useful. He had carved into them because he was broken, because he was weak, because he couldn’t take another year, another decade, another century of being split open while Alastair smiled down at him and called him talented.

He had carved into them because eventually he had wanted off the rack more than he wanted to be good.

The front door opened behind him.

Dean’s head lifted at once, the cloth still tight in his hand and the old memory of the rack snapping shut somewhere behind his ribs like a door he didn’t have time to stand in front of. Sam stepped inside with a folded tarp tucked under one arm, rain darkening the shoulders of his jacket and his hair curling damp around his ears, and for a second he only paused there in the entryway, looking from Dean to the body on the carpet and then back again with the careful expression of a man who had learned, through years of blood and bad rooms, when not to ask a question just because he had noticed there was one. He lifted the tarp a little instead, the plastic crackling softly in the quiet house. “From the trunk,” he said, voice low.

Dean nodded once and pushed whatever had been crawling through his head back down where it belonged, because the hunt had left a mess on somebody’s rug and no amount of thinking about Hell was going to make the shifter lighter. He crossed the room and took one end of the tarp from Sam, the plastic cold and stiff under his fingers, and together they unfolded it beside the body with the practiced silence of men who had done too many ugly chores in too many innocent houses. The tarp spread across the carpet in a dull blue square, covering part of the blood but not the smell, and Dean caught the edge with his boot to keep it flat while Sam knelt on the other side and looked at the shifter with open distaste.

The case had come together in the end because Bunny had found the seam no one else had thought to touch. Not the victims, not at first. The thing hadn’t cared about Henry Wilts or Eric Langley or the others as people, not in any way that mattered beyond access and opportunity. It cared about what they had. The jewelry, the paintings, the antiques, the pretty little objects with histories printed on appraisal sheets and auction certificates, all of them scattered after some rich bastard a few towns over finally died and left his estate locked in a trust until lawyers, heirs, and buyers could pick it clean. The shifter had decided those things belonged to it, or to the life it had once worn, or to some ugly little story it had built around itself in the dark. Dean still wasn’t sure which, and he didn’t particularly care. By the time monsters started talking about what was rightfully theirs, people were usually already dead.

It was almost funny, in a way that wasn’t funny at all. All that horror, all those bodies opened in houses full of family photos and coats still hanging by the door, because a monster had gotten attached to rich people’s junk and decided ownership was something it could enforce with claws. Dean had seen worse motives. He had seen stupider ones too. That didn’t make the carpet any less red or the body any less slick when Sam leaned down, face twisting before he even touched it.

“Ready?” Sam asked quietly, crouching near the shifter’s shoulders with his hands hovering for half a second like he was trying to pick the least disgusting place to grab.

Dean moved to the other end, jaw tightening as he reached for the ankles. “Nope.”

Sam glanced up at him, but the look was more tired than amused, and Dean gave him a short nod before either of them could think too hard about it. They lifted together, the body coming up with a wet, resistant pull from the carpet, and Dean had to swallow hard against the smell that rose with it, sweet and rotten and chemical all at once. The skin gave under his hands in a way skin wasn’t supposed to, waxy and loose over bones that felt too dense for the thing’s size, and the shifter landed on the tarp with a thick, boneless sound that made something in the back of Dean’s throat try to climb out.

“Son of a bitch,” he muttered, flexing his fingers. A strip of grayish skin had stuck to his palm.

Dean stared at it for one flat, horrified second before flicking it onto the tarp with a sharp, disgusted noise. It landed against the shifter’s thigh and immediately began sliding lower, as if even dead it had no interest in holding itself together. “That’s nasty.”

Sam’s mouth twisted as he wiped one hand against his jeans before thinking better of it and stopping halfway. “Yeah.”

Dean dug his handkerchief out of his pocket and scrubbed at his palm, rubbing until the skin there went red and the worst of the slickness came away. The handkerchief was a lost cause the second it touched him, old cotton darkening with whatever the hell shifter bodies became after the soul checked out, and he held it between two fingers for a beat before dropping it onto the tarp beside the corpse. He’d buy a new one. Hell, he’d buy five. There were some things a man couldn’t launder out.

He dropped to one knee across from Sam, the carpet plush beneath him and already ruined where the body had rested too long, then caught the edge of the tarp and started folding it inward. Sam mirrored him, quiet and methodical, his face drawn in that careful way he got when he was working and thinking at the same time. The plastic rasped over itself as they rolled the shifter once, then again, tucking the wet ruin of it into the blue like they were wrapping up an old carpet instead of a dead monster wearing the last scraps of someone else’s face.

Dean grunted as the weight shifted toward him. “Bastard’s heavier than I thought.”

Sam braced one hand against the bundle and pulled the tarp tighter. “Yeah, well, maybe decomposing into sludge adds a few pounds.”

Dean shot him a look, but it didn’t have much in it. The room smelled too bad, and the night had gone too long, and somewhere else in town Bunny was still not talking to him. He went back to folding the tarp, pressing the edge down with one hand while the other curled briefly into a fist, like his palm still remembered the feel of the shifter’s skin coming loose against it.

Sam pulled his side of the tarp tighter, his face pinching as the thing inside shifted with another wet, unpleasant sound. “You know,” he muttered, voice kept low beneath the hush of the muted television and the rain ticking at the windows, “we don’t actually know what kind of muscle mass is under all that skin. Could be denser than it looks.”

Dean looked at him over the half-wrapped corpse. “I don’t care if it’s built like a linebacker under there. Long as we get it torched before it turns into soup in my trunk, I’m callin’ it a win.”

Sam’s mouth twisted at the image, but he didn’t argue. He just tucked the tarp under the shifter’s shoulder and glanced up at Dean with that careful look he got when he was about to say something that had been circling the room for a while and had finally found a gap wide enough to slip through. “Speaking of your trunk,” he said, a little too casual, “how’re you feeling about letting Bunny drive the Impala around for a month?”

Dean frowned down at the bundle between them, more because that was easier than looking at Sam than because the question surprised him. The bet had been sitting somewhere at the edge of everything all night, ridiculous and sharp and suddenly less funny now that Bunny had been right, now that the shifter was dead, now that the thing she’d won had to be carried back into the quiet parts of their life like it hadn’t happened in the middle of a fight neither of them knew how to end. He helped Sam lever the wrapped body upright, one hand planted hard against the tarp as the weight slumped toward him, and held it steady while Sam moved around with a grimace and got himself under enough of it to lift.

“Not thrilled,” Dean said finally, because that much was safe. “Takes me long enough to get your hair outta the upholstery. Now I gotta let Wallace in there too? I’m never gonna keep the damn thing clean.”

Sam bent slightly under the weight of the shifter, getting it into a fireman’s carry with a strained breath and a look on his face that said he was cursing every meal the monster had ever eaten. “It’s not gonna be the end of the world, man.”

Dean got to his feet and moved ahead of him, stepping around the blood-dark patch in the carpet and crossing to the front door. The house seemed to hold its breath as they went, lamps glowing warmly over the kind of ordinary wreckage that would never make it into a police report the right way: a crooked rug, a coffee table wiped too clean in one spot, a family photograph set back exactly where it had been by hands that had no business touching it. He opened the door and glanced out before letting Sam through, the night beyond the porch damp and silvered, the neighborhood quiet in that post-midnight way that always felt more peaceful than abandoned.

Sam carried the body down the steps with his jaw clenched and his shoulders tight, boots landing carefully on the wet path while Dean pulled the door mostly shut behind them, leaving it cracked just enough that he could get back in if he needed to. The Impala waited two houses down where they’d left her under the cover of a maple, black paint slick with rain and moonlight, beautiful and loyal and about to be insulted in a way Dean considered deeply personal. He jogged ahead, keys already in his hand, and unlocked the trunk before Sam reached him.

“Easy,” Dean muttered, lifting the lid.

Sam gave him a look from beneath the weight of the tarp. “You wanna take over?”

With one ugly heave, Sam dropped the wrapped shifter into the trunk, the suspension dipping slightly under the weight before settling again. Dean winced despite himself, then leaned in to adjust the tarp so nothing wet pressed against anything it didn’t absolutely have to, because there were desecrations and then there were desecrations. The smell was already creeping up through the plastic, sour and chemical and sweet in the worst way, and he shut the trunk with more force than necessary, cutting it off with a heavy metallic thud.

He was halfway around the driver’s side when Sam’s voice stopped him.

“Hey.”

Dean paused with the keys tucked into his palm, metal teeth biting faintly into his skin, and looked back over the roof of the car. Sam was still standing by the trunk, rain misting over his hair and shoulders, hands dropping into the pockets of his jacket now that he didn’t have a corpse to carry. The streetlight behind him threw his face into uneven shadow, all long lines and tired eyes, and Dean knew from the set of his mouth that this wasn’t going to be about the body.

“What?”

Sam shifted his weight once, the same way he had when they were kids and he was deciding whether or not to ask something that might get him snapped at. “Do I need to worry about things being weird with you and Bunny again?”

Dean stared at him.

For a second, there was only the rain ticking softly over the Impala’s roof and running down the windows in thin, silver threads. Somewhere down the block, a porch light buzzed with trapped insects. The whole neighborhood slept around them, neat houses and dark lawns and curtained windows, nobody knowing there was a dead monster wrapped in a tarp ten feet away or that Dean was standing in the street with his kid brother asking him whether his marriage was about to turn into another kind of haunting.

Dean’s jaw worked. “What’s that supposed to mean?”

Sam shrugged, but it wasn’t careless. If anything, the gesture made him look younger, tired in a way that had nothing to do with hauling a body and everything to do with being trapped between two people he loved who had both spent years learning how to turn hurt into weather. “Just… you know.”

“No, Sam, I don’t know. That’s why I asked.”

Sam looked toward the house for a second, then back at him. “Things were weird after the Halcyon. Really weird. And before you two got together, you were kind of awful to be in the same room with half the time.”

Dean’s expression flattened. “Thanks.”

“I’m not saying that to be a jerk,” Sam said, voice lowering a little as if the sleeping houses might overhear something too private for the street. “I’m saying I remember what it was like when you two didn’t know what to do with each other except pick fights over anything and everything. And now you’re married, which is good, Dean, it is, but that doesn’t magically make you two normal every time something hurts.”

Dean looked away first, eyes catching on the Impala’s rain-slick hood because it was easier than Sam’s face. He wanted to say that nothing was weird. He wanted to say Bunny was fine, he was fine, they were both just pissed off and tired and covered in shifter residue, which was a perfectly normal marital speed bump in their line of work. He wanted to make a crack about vows not covering torture kits and Rod Stewart, wanted to shove the whole thing into the trunk with the body and drive until the smell of it was up in smoke.

But Sam was still watching him, and the question sat there between them, damp and stubborn and too fair to dodge cleanly.

“So what,” Dean said at last, voice rougher than he wanted it. “You want me to promise we’re not gonna get tense and snippy every time we have a disagreement?”

Sam’s mouth twitched, not with amusement so much as recognition. “Honestly? That’d be nice.”

Dean gave him a look.

Sam sighed and looked down at the wet pavement, then back up again. “I’m asking if I need to worry about you shutting down and her disappearing for three days while the rest of us pretend not to notice. I’m asking if this is gonna become one of those things where every room gets colder because neither of you knows how to say what you mean without using it as a weapon first.”

Dean’s brow pinched before he could stop it, jaw ticking once as the words found places to land that Sam had no business knowing about and absolutely every right to notice. He shifted his grip on the keys, feeling the bite of metal against his palm, then looked away toward the dark line of houses as if the answer might be standing somewhere under a porch light with its hands up. “I don’t know what the hell you’re talking about,” he said, because the lie was easier than saying anything else. “Me and Bunny didn’t get into a fight.”

Sam stared at him.

Dean felt the stare before he looked back, the full, heavy Winchester stare that said Sam had heard some truly impressive bullshitting in his life, but this was making a late run for the top ten. His eyebrows lifted slowly, his mouth going flat with disbelief, and for a second he looked so much like the kid who used to call Dean out on Dad’s orders in motel rooms with bad wallpaper that Dean almost snapped at him on principle.

“Really?” Sam asked. “So, what, you had a stand-in back at the boiler room? Because I’m pretty sure that was a fight.”

Dean scoffed and turned half toward the driver’s door, even though he didn’t open it yet. “That wasn’t a fight.”

Sam’s expression didn’t change.

“It wasn’t,” Dean insisted, and hated that the words came out a little too fast. “It was—” He cut himself off, glancing toward the trunk like the wrapped shifter might have an opinion from under the tarp. “It was an argument, okay? There’s a difference.”

“An argument about whether Bunny should be allowed to get revenge,” Sam said, and he said it carefully, not accusing exactly, but not softening it either.

Dean turned back so fast the keys shifted in his hand. “That’s not what it was about.”

“Dean—”

“No, Sam, that is not what it was about.” His voice stayed low because the neighborhood was still sleeping and because there was a body in the trunk and because volume had never actually made him sound less scared, but the edge in it sharpened anyway. “It was about whether or not she should be torturing someone.”

Sam’s face tightened around the word. Not disagreement, not exactly. More like he had expected it and still didn’t like hearing it laid out in the wet air between them. “That was her point,” he said after a beat. “She wasn’t torturing someone. She was torturing something.”

Dean gave him a hard look. “I don’t care if it’s a person, place, thing, who’s on first, whatever. We are not doing that, Sam. We’re not gonna start strapping things to chairs and cutting into them because we’ve got a reason shiny enough to make it feel good. That’s not how this works.”

Sam’s eyes flicked toward the trunk, then back again. “That’s not how what works?”

“This.” Dean threw one hand out, not big, not dramatic, just enough to take in the car, the house, the sleeping street, the whole rotten shape of their lives pressed into one damp Montana night. “The job. Us. Whatever the hell we’re calling the part where we still have to look in the mirror after. Monsters get put down. That’s it. They don’t get a torture playlist first because one of us decides they earned it.”

Sam was quiet for a second, and in that second Dean heard the rain ticking from the maple leaves onto the Impala’s roof, heard the faint metallic settling of the trunk behind them, heard his own breathing trying to stay even while his blood kept remembering the boiler room. Bunny in the heat. Bunny with the cigarette. Bunny saying fun like the word hadn’t crawled out of something dark and sat down at the table with them.

“And it wasn’t about revenge,” Dean added, because that part mattered for reasons he didn’t feel like looking at too closely. “So I don’t know where the hell you’re getting that.”

He turned to open the driver’s side door, ready to end the conversation by the simple and time-honored method of getting into the car and making Sam either follow or stand there talking to rain, but Sam scoffed behind him, quiet and incredulous enough to stop him cold.

Dean looked back.

Sam wasn’t moving toward the passenger side. He was still standing by the trunk, hands in his pockets, shoulders drawn up against the damp, and the look on his face had gone from cautious to tired in that particular way he got when Dean was refusing to admit the obvious and making everybody else walk circles around it. “You know damn well it was about revenge.”

Dean’s eyes narrowed. “No, I don’t.”

“Dean.”

“No.” He stepped away from the door, letting it stay shut between him and the easy exit he’d almost taken. “It wasn’t revenge. It was Bunny cutting a slice out of something that happened to be the same species as the thing that killed her family, and I get why that’s tied up in a bunch of other crap for her, I do, but that doesn’t make it right. At all, Sam.”

Sam tilted his head a little, rain shining in his hair. “What do you think we’re doing, then?”

Dean’s eyes narrowed. “What’s that supposed to mean?”

“It means we’ve been killing demons pretty much nonstop since Azazel,” Sam said, and there was something in his voice now that wasn’t accusation so much as exhaustion, the kind that had been building under his skin all year, through seals and omens and Ruby’s careful whispers and the ever-present shadow of Lilith sitting at the end of every road. “How is that different from Bunny killing shifters?”

Dean stared at him for half a second, the question landing wrong enough that he felt it spark somewhere behind his teeth. “Because we’re not fucking torturing them, Sam!”

Sam’s mouth tightened.

“We’re not—” Dean cut himself off before the rest of it could come out too loud, before the anger could carry across the wet lawns and wake some retired couple who’d look outside expecting raccoons and find two hunters arguing beside a car with a corpse in the trunk. He turned away hard and planted both palms flat on the Impala’s roof, bowing his head between his shoulders as the rain slid over his knuckles and cooled skin that felt too hot from the inside. The metal beneath his hands was cold, familiar, solid in a way very few things in his life had ever managed to be, and he pressed into it until the worst of his anger died somewhere in his throat.

He was trying to be better about that.

Trying was a hell of a word, really. Small, stupid, and usually useless, but it was the only one he had. He’d been trying not to snap every time something got too close. Trying not to turn every question into a door he could slam. Trying not to look at the people who loved him and see only where they might hit if they ever decided to. It wasn’t going great. Most days it felt like trying to hold back a house fire with a wet towel and a whole lot of denial, but his hands stayed on the Impala’s roof, and he dragged in one breath, then another, while rain ticked between his fingers and Sam stood quiet enough to let him have the few seconds.

Then Sam spoke again, softer this time. “Look, I know it’s not the exact same thing.”

Dean didn’t lift his head.

“And maybe Bunny shouldn’t have done what she did,” Sam went on, each word careful, like he was stepping through glass and knew it but couldn’t find another way across the room. “Maybe she crossed a line. I’m not saying she didn’t. But all I think about these days is getting Lilith’s head served up on a platter for what she did to you, so maybe I’m not the guy who gets to stand here and act like wanting payback makes somebody a monster.”

Dean closed his eyes.

The rain made a soft hiss against the pavement around them. Somewhere nearby, water trickled along the curb, carrying leaves and cigarette butts and whatever other little pieces of the night had come loose. Sam’s voice was still low, still Sam, still too honest in a way Dean had always found both irritating and impossible to ignore.

“I know Bunny’s not going after the same shifter,” Sam said. “I know that thing in the boiler room wasn’t the one that killed her mom and Molly. But it looked like it. It breathed like it. It wore somebody else’s face like it. And maybe after living with that for as long as she has, after knowing that the thing that ruined her life could’ve been anybody walking past her in a grocery store or sitting across from her in a diner, she wanted one of them to feel scared before it died.” He swallowed, and when Dean finally looked up, Sam was watching him through the rain with his hands still tucked into his pockets and his shoulders hunched like the words cost him something. “Maybe I get that more than I want to.”

For a moment, Dean didn’t answer.

He looked at his brother in the thin wash of streetlight and rain, at the sharp line of his face and the shadows under his eyes, and saw too many things at once. Sam at twenty-five, too tall and too haunted, talking about revenge like it was something he had already made room for in his body. Sam at twenty-three, standing over Azazel’s dead host while Dean held the Colt and the world cracked open around them. Sam at ten, furious and grieving in ways he hadn’t had words for yet, wanting their father to come back, wanting answers, wanting anything that would make the emptiness in their family look like it had a shape he could hit. And beneath all of that, John Winchester with grief eating him from the inside out, turning him harder year by year until the man Dean remembered from before the fire became something Dean spent most of his life chasing and defending and resenting all at once.

Revenge wasn’t what people made it out to be.

It didn’t burn clean. It didn’t end where it promised it would. It dressed itself up like justice at first because justice had better manners, but Dean knew better than most what happened when a life got built around a name on a list. Their father had chased Azazel for twenty-two years and called it purpose because purpose sounded nobler than grief, and maybe it had been purpose some days, maybe it had saved people and taught his sons how to survive and kept John upright when a softer man would’ve folded himself into the grave beside his wife. But it had taken its cut. It had hollowed out the house they never had, sharpened every lesson, turned love into orders and protection into weapons maintenance, until the man who used to lift Dean into his arms when he cried became the man who could leave two boys alone in a motel room with a shotgun and a warning not to open the door.

He’d seen hunters eaten alive by it, men and women who came into the life with one ghost, one vampire, one werewolf, one demon, one thing wearing a face they couldn’t stop seeing in their sleep, and by the time they caught it, by the time they burned it or beheaded it or sent it screaming back to Hell, nothing was waiting on the other side of the kill except the next thing that looked close enough. A whole world full of stand-ins. A whole life spent mistaking motion for healing, blood for payment, silence for peace.

Bunny had gotten her revenge. They knew that now. She had found the shifter that wore her father’s face, the one that remembered her mother’s screams and Molly’s blood like souvenirs, and she had put it down with all the rage a six-year-old girl had carried into adulthood because nobody had been there in time to save the people who mattered. That should’ve ended something. Maybe it had ended something. Dean wasn’t arrogant enough to think he understood the shape of her grief better than she did.

Behind him, Sam shifted near the trunk, his boots scraping softly over wet pavement, and Dean pushed himself up from the Impala with a slow breath that tasted like rain and exhaust and everything neither of them had said cleanly. He dragged one hand over his mouth, then let it fall, keys still biting into his palm as Sam looked at him with that careful, miserable honesty Dean had never figured out how to hate properly.

“I’m not gonna tell you not to be pissed,” Sam said quietly. “Not about what she did. I’m not saying you’re wrong.”

Dean looked at him, waiting.

Sam’s shoulders rose and fell beneath his damp jacket. “But she wasn’t going to say that.”

Something in Dean’s face went still.

Sam held his gaze anyway, big and rain-soaked and too damn earnest for a guy who could look terrifying with blood on his face and a knife in his hand. In the streetlight, with his hair plastered dark to his forehead and his hands tucked deep into his pockets, he still looked a little like a wet, kicked dog despite being six-foot-whatever and built out of stubbornness and bad decisions.

“She wasn’t,” Sam said again, softer. “I know she wasn’t. And I think you know that too.”

Dean’s jaw worked once.

Sam nodded like that was all he’d meant to leave there, like he knew better than to push his hand deeper into the wound just because he’d found it. “That’s all. I’ll leave it alone.”

For a moment, Dean said nothing. The rain kept ticking against the Impala’s roof, steady and patient, filling up the space where the easy answer should’ve gone. He could still see Bunny’s face in the boiler room when he’d said it, the quick flash of hurt before anger covered it, the offended disbelief that he’d thought she would aim Hell at him like that. Sam was right. Dean hated that he was right. Hated more that knowing it didn’t make the ugly little part of him unclench.

Finally, he turned and grabbed the driver’s side handle. “Just get in the car, Sam.”

Sam didn’t argue. Dean slid behind the wheel and slammed the door harder than he needed to, and by the time Sam folded himself into the passenger seat, Dean already had the engine cranked, the Impala rumbling awake beneath them like something old and loyal shaking rain from its shoulders.

Bunny would be at the motel by now. She had to be. They’d only had two addresses that it might have been at, and the shifter had been at theirs, which meant she’d gone to the other one and found nothing but dark rooms, bad wallpaper, and whatever was left of her temper. He’d figure out what to say to her on the drive back. Something that wasn’t an apology if he didn’t mean all of it, something that wasn’t an accusation if he could help it, something that didn’t turn the silence between them into another weapon.

Yeah.

Dean shifted the car into gear and pulled away from the curb, rain sliding silver over the windshield as the dead thing in the trunk rode heavy behind them.

He’d figure out what to say.

✩

The motel room was empty when they got back.

Not empty in the way a motel room was supposed to be empty, all stale air and bad curtains and beds made by somebody underpaid enough to stop caring about corners. Empty in the wrong way. Bunny’s blazer was still over the chair where she had left it, one sleeve turned inside out. Her bag sat open near the foot of the bed, shirts teeming forth like over-proofed dough. Wallace’s spare lead was looped over the back of the chair, her boots weren’t by the door, and the Bronco wasn’t sitting in the motel lot with its ugly green paint and stubborn engine and the kind of attitude only a vehicle owned by Bunny could manage. Dean stood in the doorway for half a second too long, keys still in his hand, all the words he’d been trying to scrape together on the drive turning to nothing at the sight of the bed she hadn’t come back to.

Dean had called her once from the Impala with the engine running and Sam still standing in the open motel doorway, rain ticking off the roof in silver lines behind him. The ringing had sounded close enough that Dean’s hand went still on the steering wheel before he understood why, and then he had dug into his jacket pocket with a sick, stupid little twist in his stomach and pulled out Bunny’s phone, screen lighting against his palm with his own name plastered across it like the universe had decided to be a real comedian about the worst possible timing.

There had been a minute of grumbling after that, because grumbling was easier than saying he’d been worried enough to feel it behind his teeth. He’d picked the damn thing up on instinct because she was always leaving it places, in diner booths and motel bathrooms and once in the freezer at Bobby’s because she’d been looking for ice and got distracted by something playing on the radio, and now his helpful husband reflex was biting him in the ass. Like it usually did. Sam hadn’t said anything to that. He’d only looked at the phone in Dean’s hand, then toward the empty room, and the silence had made Dean want to put his fist through something cheap and replaceable.

So now they were cutting through another neighborhood on the north side of town, the second address folded open in Sam’s lap with the map bleeding soft creases beneath the glow of the dashboard. The Impala moved slow under the streetlights, black paint slick with rain and the wipers dragging their steady rhythm across the windshield, left and right, left and right, like a clock counting down to something Dean didn’t want to reach.

Bunny wasn’t at the motel. Bunny didn’t have her phone. Bunny was somewhere ahead of them in the cold, wet dark, and Dean had already spent too much of the night imagining her standing alone in rooms he wasn’t in.

He turned down another narrow residential road, slowing as a trash can loomed too close to the curb. His mind snagged on the thought of those little belt clips people wore now for their cellphones. A hard plastic holster on the hip, ugly as sin and practical in a way Bunny would find morally offensive. For about three seconds, Dean pictured trying to talk her into one, pictured her looking down at him like he had asked her to wear a cowbell, one brow lifting while she said, in that crisp little voice of hers, that she would sooner swallow the phone whole than attach it to herself like a regional manager at a wireless store.

Then he pictured her losing the belt clip too, somehow. Detaching it without noticing. Leaving it hooked to a diner chair. Dropping it into a sewer grate while lighting a cigarette. Bunny was a damn good hunter, sharp enough to make innocent men confess and stubborn enough to back a monster into a corner on willpower alone, but she could lose things while actively holding them, like the universe had granted her tactical brilliance and then taken payment in object permanence.

The only things she held onto with any consistency were that stupid Kermit doll she’d had since she was little, her mother’s locket, the Bronco, and, hopefully, her wedding ring.

Dean’s grip tightened on the wheel, his own ring catching faint dashboard light as his hand shifted over the leather. He hadn’t seen her take hers off. He didn’t think she would. Bunny was pissed, maybe worse than pissed, maybe hurt in that quiet, flint-edged way that made her go polite enough to scare the hell out of everyone in range, but she wasn’t careless with symbols once they mattered. Not the things that tied her to people she’d decided were hers. Still, his mind went there because he was a son of a bitch with a shovel, always digging for the next place to bury something before it had even died.

Sam glanced up from the map, one finger tracing along a street grid gone soft at the folds. “Take Duncan,” he said, voice low in the car, careful not because the direction needed care but because everything did now. “Marsh should be up on the left in about two blocks.”

Dean leaned forward slightly, peering through the rain-streaked windshield for the street sign. The neighborhood here was older than the one they’d just left, houses set back behind thin lawns and bare-branched trees, porches sagging under the damp, mailboxes tilted like tired sentries beside the road. Everything had that washed-out late-night color to it, gray siding and black branches and yellow windows seen through rain, the kind of quiet that made every house look abandoned even when people were asleep inside them. He found the sign at the corner, green metal shining under a streetlamp, and turned onto Duncan with the Impala’s tires whispering over wet pavement.

They saw the lights almost immediately.

Red and blue, faint at first, pulsing through the rain like something wounded deeper in the neighborhood. The colors smeared across the windshield, caught on the slick road, flashed against the trunks of trees and the sides of parked cars as they turned and slid away and came back again. Dean’s foot eased off the gas without him telling it to. Beside him, Sam lowered the map slowly, the paper folding against his knee with a soft rasp that sounded too loud in the car.

Neither of them said anything for a few seconds.

The Impala rolled forward, slow as a confession, and with every yard the lights grew clearer, brighter, not on Duncan but ahead and left, bleeding out from what had to be Marsh. More than one cruiser. Maybe two. Maybe more. Dean could see the bounce of headlights through the trees now, the blocky shape of a vehicle angled wrong near the curb, the wet shine of the road catching emergency color and throwing it back at them like a warning.

Dean swallowed once, eyes fixed ahead where the flashing red and blue painted the rain in ugly, stuttering color. “What do you think the odds are,” he said, voice low and scraped thin, “that those lights have nothing to do with her?”

Sam didn’t answer.

Dean took the turn onto Marsh, and whatever had been left of his stomach seemed to drop clean out from under him. The whole end of the street was lit up in emergency colors, red and blue washing over wet pavement and dripping tree limbs and the pale faces of neighbors gathered behind the line of tape in bathrobes and raincoats, all of them standing too close together with their arms folded tight over their chests like proximity could make them safer from whatever had happened on the other side.

There were police cruisers everywhere, at least seven of them angled crooked along the curb and across driveways, their light bars throwing hard color over the rain. Two ambulances sat in front of a narrow white house with green shutters, back doors open, interior lights glowing sterile and bright against the dark, and farther down the block, parked half on the curb and half in the street like she had rolled up in a hurry and abandoned it before the engine could finish complaining, was Bunny’s Bronco. The driver’s side door was hanging open.

Dean threw the Impala into park so hard the whole car jolted beneath them, the engine still running as he got out. Sam said his name, or maybe he didn’t; Dean heard something behind him, one syllable swallowed by rain and sirens and the sudden roar of blood in his ears, but it didn’t matter because his hand was already digging into his jacket for the FBI badge and his eyes had locked on one of the ambulances with the kind of helpless, vicious focus that made the rest of the world go thin at the edges.

There was someone in the back of it. A woman, hunched over under one of those shiny thermal blankets, shoulders narrow, head bowed, wet hair dark against the silver, and she was about Bunny’s size. Close enough. Too close. Close enough that Dean’s mind stopped being a mind and became one long, frantic refusal beating against the inside of his skull.

No. No, no, no, no.

He crossed the street without looking for traffic, badge coming up only when someone stepped into his path and barked at him to stay behind the tape. Dean flashed it so fast it barely meant anything, a quick hard blur of fake credentials and real panic, and shouldered past before the cop had time to decide whether to argue. He could feel Sam somewhere behind him, hear the heavier rhythm of his brother’s boots catching up, but Dean didn’t slow down. He moved through the crowd of uniforms and rain-slick jackets and radios crackling nonsense into the wet air, past a patrolman talking into his shoulder mic, past a paramedic carrying an oxygen bag, past one of the neighbors crying softly into both hands while another one kept saying something about hearing screaming, and every step closer to the ambulance made the blanket-wrapped shape sharper and worse.

“Sir, you can’t—” someone started, catching at his arm.

Dean shook him off without stopping. “FBI.”

“That doesn’t mean you can just—”

Dean didn’t hear the rest. He reached the ambulance and caught the woman by the shoulder, not gently enough, not carefully enough, his hand closing over foil and damp fabric with every terrible thing in him already braced for the turn of Bunny’s face, pale and hurt and too still in the ambulance light. The woman flinched hard and whipped toward him with a frightened sound caught in her throat.

It wasn’t her.

For half a second, Dean couldn’t make himself understand that either. The face in front of him belonged to someone else entirely, older than Bunny by maybe ten years, rounder in the cheeks, eyes red from crying, hair plastered against her temples in dark strings. A little girl was curled under the blanket beside her, small hands fisted in the silver foil, her face pressed into the woman’s side with the blank, exhausted terror of a kid who had already cried too much and didn’t have anything left but shaking. The woman stared at Dean like he was one more bad thing arriving out of the rain, and the child made a small whimpering noise that cut through the ringing in his ears so cleanly it almost hurt.

Not Bunny.

The relief hit wrong. It didn’t soften him; it nearly took his knees out. Dean let go of the woman’s shoulder like he’d burned her, his hand hovering uselessly for a second before dropping back to his side, and all at once the world came rushing in around him with brutal clarity. The rain on his face. The ambulance lights. Radios chirping. Someone shouting from the porch. The smell of wet asphalt and blood and diesel exhaust. The little girl crying under the blanket. The woman clutching her tighter and shrinking away from him because he had just come tearing through a crime scene with terror in his eyes and a badge that wasn’t real.

A medic got both hands on Dean’s arm and pulled him back half a step. “You can’t be here.”

Dean turned on him, not angry enough for the way his face looked and too scared to make it sound normal. “I’m FBI.”

“I don’t care who you are, you can’t just grab—”

“I’m looking for a woman.” The words came out fast, rough, almost tripping over each other because his throat had gone tight and his brain still hadn’t caught up to the fact that the person in the blanket wasn’t Bunny. “Five-six, skinny, freckles. A lotta freckles. Brown hair, English accent. She was driving that Bronco.” He jerked his chin toward the open-doored truck without looking away from the medic’s face, because the second he looked at it again, he was going to start thinking about why Bunny would leave it like that. “Is she here? Is she okay?”

The medic’s grip on his arm loosened. That was the first bad thing. The second was his face.

Something flickered there, not recognition exactly, not the professional blankness people wore when they were trying not to give away how bad something was before they had permission to say it, but close enough to make Dean’s chest go cold. The man looked past him toward the house, toward the front walk and the porch lights and the cluster of uniforms near the open door, then back at Dean with his mouth pressed thin.

Dean didn’t wait for him to decide how to answer. “Where is she?”

The medic released his arm fully and nodded once toward the front of the house. “Over there.”

Dean turned. And somehow, what he saw was worse than if Bunny had been in the back of the ambulance.

She was sitting on the front steps of the narrow house, caught in the stutter of red and blue light like something somebody had painted there and forgotten how to finish. Not posed, not peaceful, not even really sitting so much as folded against the side of the railing where the porch met the steps, one shoulder tipped into the wet wood, head angled just enough for her face to catch the flash of a cruiser light and then lose it again.

She looked only half in her body, there and gone and there again, all pale skin and dark hair damp from the rain, eyes open but fixed somewhere past the house, past the street, past the uniforms and the neighbors and the ambulance where the woman and little girl shivered under foil. A thousand-yard stare, Dean thought distantly, and hated the phrase as soon as it came. It belonged to war movies and veterans in bars, not to his wife sitting alone in the rain with blood running down her arm.

His eyes found the injury before the rest of him could move.

There were cuts across her shoulder, shallow maybe, opened bright against the white of the cropped tank she’d been wearing in the boiler room less than two hours ago, the same damn tank his eyes had caught on when he should’ve been looking at anything else. Blood had soaked into the fabric near the strap and spread in dark, uneven petals, rain thinning it at the edges until it ran pink over her skin. She was leaning too much to one side, even sitting down, elbow tucked against her ribs and fabric bunched against it and blooming shades of crimson. Dean couldn’t see what she was hiding there, couldn’t see how deep it went or whether it was hers or someone else’s; but the sight of that small, protective curl made something at the base of his spine go cold and animal.

Wallace was draped across the step below her like he had put himself between Bunny and the rest of the world. His head rested near her ankle, ears low, chest rising and falling hard enough for Dean to see it from the ambulance, and there was blood dark around his mouth, streaking the pale fur beneath his muzzle and matting one side of his harlequin coat in a wide, ugly smear. A handprint, Dean realized after a second, because his mind had slipped into that awful clean place where details came without feeling attached to them. A bloody hand had caught Wallace by the shoulder or leaned on him or held him back, fingers spread dark over mottled fur, the mark too human and too desperate to be nothing.

Dean stood there in the rain and took stock like he wasn’t inside his own body anymore.

The woman from the ambulance had one arm locked around the little girl and the other hand wrapped in gauze, her face turned toward her daughter with a look Dean recognized from too many survivors and hated every time. A man stood beside the second ambulance, soaked through his t-shirt, collar torn, talking too fast to a paramedic while another medic pressed something white and thick against his forehead. Two more girls sat on the curb beneath an officer’s open raincoat, one maybe ten and trying hard not to cry because the younger one beside her, four at most, had both hands around a stuffed rabbit and kept looking back at the police lights like she was waiting for someone to tell her what kind of world she lived in now. Neighbors stared from behind the tape. Radios crackled. Rain fell. The house stood with its front door open and all its lights on, bright and ordinary inside, like it hadn’t just become the kind of place nobody in that family would ever remember without tasting blood.

It didn’t take much for Dean to come back into himself after the first blind terror of losing Bunny. It came in pieces, sharp and mean: the bite of cold rain down his neck, the fake badge slick in his hand, the medic still hovering behind him like he thought Dean might bolt the wrong way. Relief should’ve been somewhere in there. Bunny was alive. Hurt, but alive. Sitting up. Breathing. Wallace breathing beneath her. A shifter dead in his trunk. The family here, shaken and bleeding but not laid out under sheets while cops whispered words like homicide and massacre into the rain.

It should’ve been relief.

Instead, it was another kind of hurt, older and deeper, one that moved through him slow as a blade sliding between ribs.

Because Dean understood suddenly, with the ugly simplicity of a thing seen too late, what Bunny had walked into at the second address. A mother. A father. Three little girls. A house that had probably looked peaceful before the screaming started, before something wearing a familiar face got through the door and turned a normal night into the first page of a nightmare. It was all there in front of her, alive and flashing in emergency color, the family she’d lost rearranged into strangers who still had breath in their bodies because this time, Bunny had been old enough to hear the monster at the door and know what to do with the knife in her hand.

The thought went through Dean clean and terrible.

This could’ve been her house.

Not this house, not these people, not this narrow little porch in Montana with green shutters and police tape snapping wet in the wind, but the shape of it. The mother clutching a child. The father bleeding and dazed. The girls huddled together under a stranger’s coat. The monster coming in wearing a face that made somebody trust it long enough to let it close.

The only difference between then and now was that Bunny wasn’t six years old in a hallway somewhere, small and useless and too late to understand why the world had teeth. She was older now. Armed now. Quick enough, angry enough, trained enough to put herself between blades and children and make the ending come out different by sheer force of refusing to let it repeat.

And that was worse, somehow.

Worse because it meant she had saved them. Worse because it meant she had seen exactly what saving them would have looked like. Worse because some part of her, sitting there on those steps with blood on her body and Wallace at her feet, had probably already found the cruelest corner of the thought and crawled inside it: that if someone like her had been there when she was six, her mother might have lived. Molly might have lived. Maybe there would have been no year in America with a father who did things to her she still wouldn’t talk about. Maybe no little girl would have been dropped at Singer Salvage with grief packed into her bones before she was old enough to know what to call it.

Maybe this was the version of the story where somebody came in time.

Dean didn’t remember moving.

One second he was standing near the ambulance with rain in his eyes and the medic’s hand gone from his arm, and the next he was ten feet from the porch, close enough to see Bunny’s unlit cigarette between the fingers of her free hand. Close enough to see the silver rabbit etched into the Zippo resting open in her other palm, lid still tilted back like she had meant to light the cigarette and forgotten halfway through the act. Close enough to see that her knuckles were scraped raw, that the blood on her shoulder had begun to thin under the rain, that the cloth she held against her side was not a towel or gauze but the ruined remains of somebody’s t-shirt.

He knew with a terrible, shaking clarity that he would remember her like this for the rest of his life, however short that ended up being.

Not because she looked fragile. Even when she was hurt, even when small beneath the brutal wash of cruiser lights and the cold black weight of the rain, she didn’t look fragile. There was always something in her that refused to give the world the satisfaction, some stubborn, steel-threaded part that kept her chin from dropping and her spine from folding no matter how badly the rest of her wanted to come apart. But there was no performance left in her now.

No sharpness. No prim little mask fitted neatly over the damage. She was curled on the porch stoop with her elbow tucked against her ribs, blood soaking the white of her tank in uneven, dark blooms, her shoulder cut up from where something had thrown her into wood or glass or the edge of a table hard enough to split skin. Her hair hung wet around her face. Her locket rested at her throat, the silver teardrop bright against rain-chilled skin every time the lights hit it, and her wedding ring gleamed dull and fragile around the hand holding the useless lighter.

Dean saw that too. His eyes found it like they had been trained.

She didn’t turn when he lowered himself onto the step beside her. Didn’t acknowledge the shift of his weight or the creak of wet wood beneath his boots, didn’t even move when Wallace lifted his head from the lower step and looked at Dean with a tired, pleading sort of recognition before settling back down against Bunny’s ankle. The dog’s muzzle was still dark with blood, his breath coming hot and ragged through his nose, and one of his ears flicked at the sound of Dean sitting too close, but he didn’t growl. He only watched Dean for a second as if to say finally, and then pressed his body harder against Bunny’s feet.

Behind them, the house murmured with police. This was the softer aftermath, the lower voices, the radio static, the careful tread of boots over ruined floors, the questions asked too gently and answered too shakily. Dean could hear Sam somewhere near the curb, voice calm and low in that way he used when people needed to believe he knew what he was doing. He’d have his serious face on, the one with the kind eyes and the Fed posture, probably standing with some officer who didn’t know he was talking to a man with an armory in his brother’s trunk. Sam would get the story. Sam would make it useful.

None of it mattered.

Not the argument. Not the boiler room. Not the shifter in the trunk starting to rot through the tarp. Not Sam’s words in the rain or Dean’s miserable drive over with apology caught somewhere behind his teeth like a fishhook. None of it mattered in the first, brutal second of sitting beside her, because all Dean could think was that there was no heat coming off her. No adrenaline, no fury, no electric charge of Bunny after a hunt, all sharp corners and shaking hands and too-bright eyes. She sat beside him so still and cold that it felt, sickly and absurdly, like sitting next to a corpse twenty-three years late to the grave.

He turned his head, careful, like looking at her too directly might do something neither of them could fix. Her profile gave him almost nothing. The fine line of her nose. The dark fan of lashes wet against her cheeks. The freckles scattered over pale skin, stark beneath the rain and emergency light, not hidden now by smoke or laughter or the tilt of her mouth when she wanted him off-balance.

She was there. He could see her breathing. Could see the tiny movement of her fingers around the cigarette, could see the pulse fluttering at the side of her neck near the raised edge of the scar that climbed toward her ear. But it felt like looking at a house with all the lights on and nobody inside, the pretty facade still standing while something behind the windows had gone empty.

He didn’t have to ask what she was thinking.

Maybe that was arrogant. Maybe later she would tell him he didn’t know a damned thing about what went on in her head, and maybe she’d be right, because Bunny’s grief was not his to map just because he loved her. But he knew enough. He knew the weight of the locket sitting warm and silver between her collarbones, knew that it carried her mother and sisters and all the dead she had learned to keep close because distance had never brought any of them back.

He knew she was thinking about a family that had once been five people before illness made it four, before blades and borrowed skin made it two, before the last person with her name and blood became something she survived instead of belonged to. He knew she was thinking about how blood could thin a family down until it stopped meaning safety, stopped meaning home, stopped meaning anything except the person who gave her the jagged scar that bloomed from her neck to her ear and tried, years later, to finish what the monster had started.

Dean clasped his hands together and let his elbows settle on his knees, because if he didn’t give them somewhere to go, he was going to reach for her too fast and too wrong and maybe lose whatever thin thread was keeping her sitting upright beside him. The rain ran down the back of his neck and slipped cold beneath his collar, but he kept his eyes on Wallace instead.

Blood darkened his muzzle where he had clearly sunk his teeth into something and refused to let go until Bunny gave him the right word, some French command Dean hadn’t learned yet and suddenly hated himself for not knowing. There was a whole language between her and the dog that had carried them through this house before Dean ever got close enough to be useful. Wallace looked wrecked in a way Dean hadn’t expected to trouble him as much as it did, his ears low, his breathing rough, rain tracking clean lines through the blood in his fur, and maybe that shouldn’t have surprised him, not really. He and Bunny had always made a weird kind of sense together.

Both of them had come from violence. Bunny from the kind that took a family apart piece by piece until the little girl left behind had to become sharp enough to survive being the only one still breathing, and Wallace from whatever ugly chain of hands had turned him from maybe-police dog, maybe-working dog, maybe-somebody’s bright-eyed promise, into the scarred champion of a dog-fighting ring before Bunny found him in a freezer and decided that the world didn’t get to keep making him into a weapon without her permission.

Now he was ugly and massive and loyal enough to make Dean’s chest ache, a lapdog built like a threat, a creature that had once learned violence because violence was the only language anyone gave him and had somehow, impossibly, learned gentleness anyway. They fit each other in some sideways, broken-mirror way Dean didn’t like looking at too closely: two scarred things who had never asked to be scarred, two dangerous things that would’ve thrived if somebody had simply loved them before the world got its hands on them.

The thought landed so quietly that it almost didn’t feel like his own, and Dean had to look away from Wallace before it did something stupid to his face. He rubbed both hands along his thighs, over denim gone damp and warm beneath his palms, and some useless, practical corner of his mind noted that he needed to wash them soon. It was the kind of thought that belonged to another version of him, one where soap and hot water could make anything clean enough to touch. Here, on the porch beside Bunny, it felt almost obscene.

“There were two of ’em, apparently,” Dean said at last.

The words came out aimed somewhere north of humor and landed flat in the wet air between them. He heard it as soon as it left his mouth, that wrong, useless attempt to make the world smaller by giving it a case note, and Bunny didn’t turn toward him. She didn’t blink. Didn’t lift one brow or make some dry little remark about his investigative brilliance or ask whether he’d like a medal for arriving after the interesting bit. Not that he’d really expected her to.

Not some grand turning, not some sudden spill of confession where she looked at him and gave him every ugly piece of what was happening inside her because he had sat down and thought he deserved it. They were married, sure, but marriage didn’t make either one of them fluent in the parts of themselves they’d spent years learning how to lock up. He and Bunny knew how to share the things that got lighter when carried between two people. A cigarette. A bed. A joke sharp enough to keep fear from getting too comfortable. But this wasn’t that kind of hurt. This hurt too much to split cleanly.

So Dean did the only thing he knew he was any good at.

He touched her.

Slowly, first. Carefully enough that anyone watching might’ve thought he was approaching a skittish animal, and maybe that wasn’t far off, except Bunny was nobody’s animal and Dean knew damn well she’d bite down to the bone if he gave her a reason. His left arm curved around the space between them, not quite an embrace, not something that asked her to fall into it before she was ready. A steady, deliberate reach until his hand found the blood-soaked bundle pressed against her side.

The cloth was wet and warm under his palm, too warm beneath the rain, and he had to keep his face still when the pressure gave slightly, when he felt the ugly squish of fabric and blood and whatever cut lay hidden under the press of her elbow. Her arm was stiff beneath his hand, shoved against the makeshift bandage like letting go might mean something worse than bleeding. He pressed down gently enough to help, firm enough to mean stay with me, while his other hand moved toward the Zippo.

“I got it, princess,” he murmured, so low it almost got lost under the rain.

For a second, he thought she wouldn’t let him take it. Her fingers stayed locked around the lighter, white at the knuckles, the little rabbit etched into the silver case flashing in and out under the cruiser lights like a living thing. Then her grip loosened by degrees, not because she had decided to trust him, maybe, but because some part of her recognized his hand before the rest of her found its way back. Dean eased the Zippo from her palm, folding his fingers around it, and watched her blink once. Then again. Slow, almost puzzled, like she was surfacing from somewhere deep and cold and had found him sitting there beside her when she hadn’t remembered calling for him. Her eyes moved to his face.

Dean didn’t say anything.

There was too much in that look and not enough of her behind it, and if he opened his mouth too fast, he was afraid he’d fill the space with every wrong word he’d been collecting since the boiler room. He only turned the Zippo in his hand, thumb finding the wheel, and when Bunny’s fingers lifted toward her mouth with the unlit cigarette still resting between them, blood-stained at the filter and bent from the rain, he leaned in and struck the flame for her.

The first spark died in the wet air. He tried again.

This time the flame caught, small and stubborn, gold against the blue-red pulse of the yard. Bunny brought the cigarette to it with a movement so controlled it almost hid the tremor in her hand, but Dean saw it anyway. The shake passed through her fingers, a tiny hitch in her breathing when she drew in, and the tobacco finally took. He didn’t tell her she shouldn’t be smoking with a wound in her side. Didn’t tell her the cigarette was soaked half to hell and probably tasted like rainwater and blood.

When she didn’t pull away, Dean shifted closer.

Not much. Not enough to make a thing out of it, not enough to turn the small mercy of her letting him sit there into some big, stupid gesture that would ask more from her than she had to give. Just close enough that his shoulder brushed hers, close enough that the outside line of her body could lean into him if it wanted to and pretend gravity was the reason. His hand pressed more firmly against the cloth at her side, careful and steady despite the way his stomach turned at the warm wet give beneath his palm, and Bunny’s weight came toward him by inches. Not a collapse so much as a slow surrender to the fact that her body had apparently remembered he was there before the rest of her knew what to do with him. Her shoulder settled against his sleeve, light at first, then heavier, until Dean understood with a cold little pull behind his ribs that he might be the only thing keeping her upright now that she had found her way back into herself enough to know how far there was to fall.

Wallace shifted below them with a pained, restless sound, his muzzle lifting and then lowering again as if even that much movement asked more from him than he wanted to admit. Dean moved his boot back to give him room, and the dog used the space to stretch one bloodied foreleg across the lower step, pressing against Bunny’s ankle with the stubborn insistence of a creature who had been told to stay and had decided that meant stay, even if the sky came down.

Dean looked at him for half a second, at the blood crusting dark along his jaw and the damp fur rising and falling with every rough breath, then looked back at Bunny’s hands, at the cigarette trembling between her fingers, and thought, with a numb sort of clarity, that this was triage too. Not the kind with gauze and pressure and shaking hands, but the other kind. The kind where all you could do was make room for a hurt thing to keep breathing until it remembered it hadn’t died. He usually let Sam handle that kind of thing.

Bunny spoke before he thought she would. “There were two of them,” she said, and her voice came out so low and scraped that for a second Dean almost didn’t recognize it as hers.

He turned his head slightly, not enough to make her feel fully watched, but enough that he could see the edge of her profile when the police lights cut across it. She didn’t look at him. Her eyes stayed on the family near the ambulances, on the woman with the blanket and the little girl tucked into her side, on the older child sitting too still on the curb like she had decided that if she didn’t move, nothing else bad would happen tonight.

“It wasn’t wounded,” Bunny continued, each word slow, as if she had to pull it from somewhere deep and cold and lay it out carefully before it slipped away again. “Not like it should’ve been. Not if it had been the one from the tunnels.”

Dean swallowed. “Yeah,” he said softly. “I figured.”

Her body sagged another fraction against him, and Dean shifted with it, not crowding, not wrapping her up the way he wanted to, just letting his shoulder take the weight and his hand hold steady against her side. The cloth was going slick under his palm. He needed to look soon. He needed to make someone look. But Bunny had finally spoken, and God help him, he understood enough about coming back from the wrong place. He didn’t want to interrupt the first line thrown from her in the dark just because blood made him impatient.

“The other one’s in the trunk,” he said after a moment, because it was ugly but practical, and practical was sometimes the closest thing to comfort either one of them knew how to accept. “Ours. Sammy and I took care of it.”

Bunny nodded once, barely there.

A dim acknowledgement that the fact had landed somewhere inside her, that there had been two monsters and now, at least, there were none. Her eyes moved again toward the family, slow and fixed, and Dean saw something come back into them by inches. Not enough. But more than nothing. A little more. A pilot light catching in a house gone cold.

“It came as the dad,” she said.

Dean’s jaw tightened.

Bunny took another careful drag, and this time the smoke left her mouth thin and unsteady, breaking apart almost immediately in the rain. “Just like—” She stopped, throat moving around the word she hadn’t meant to reach for, and when she began again her voice was smaller in a way that had nothing to do with volume. “One of the girls opened the door for it, because why wouldn’t she? It was just her father, locked outside after taking the trash to the bins, maybe.”

Dean didn’t say anything. Couldn’t, maybe. His hand stayed pressed to her side, the blood warm between them, while the house behind them glowed bright and ordinary through the open door.

“I’d just pulled onto the street,” Bunny said, and now the words were coming unevenly, not fast, not frantic, but broken at strange places as if the memory kept snagging on itself. “I thought perhaps we’d wasted time splitting up, and that I ought to call you, and then I remembered I didn’t have my phone, and I was—” Her mouth pressed into a thin line, almost a smile and nothing like one. “I was angry about that. Stupid thing to be angry about.”

Dean felt the words hit and had to look down at the step, at Wallace’s bloodied fur, at anything that wasn’t her face. “Not that stupid,” he said, rough.

Bunny’s shoulder leaned heavier into his, and he let it. “Then I heard screaming.” Bunny’s cigarette trembled near her mouth, forgotten halfway there, smoke curling up around her rain-damp face and disappearing into the cold. Her eyes stayed fixed on the family, on the mother and father and three little girls breathing under emergency blankets beneath a sky that had not had the decency to stop raining for them. “It was already inside when I reached the door. And I don’t… I don’t…”

She blinked down at herself like the sentence had slipped out of her hands and fallen somewhere she couldn’t see, her gaze lowering slowly to the blood on her shirt, to Dean’s hand pressed over hers, to the cigarette burning uselessly between two fingers she didn’t seem to recognize as her own. For a second, Dean thought she might try to finish it, might drag whatever had lodged behind her teeth out into the rain and make both of them look at it, but she only went quiet again, her mouth parted slightly around a breath that didn’t quite know what to do with itself.

He didn’t ask. He didn’t tell her to explain, didn’t put his hand under her chin and make her look at him like answers could be coaxed out by contact, because he understood enough. She had saved this family while he and Sam had been cleaning up the one body she’d already carved into easy prey, and somehow, saving this family had touched closer to the primal wound, had gone past rage and straight into that old, unlit room in her where the worst day of her life was still happening with the lights off.

Dean could almost feel the static of it from where he sat. That dead television hum under the skin, the strange, metal taste of a memory dragging the present out of shape. Like licking a magnet, maybe. Or touching a wire that hadn’t been connected right but still had enough life in it to snap through bone. Like sitting on a porch in Montana and being six years old again in a hallway somewhere else, small enough that the screaming sounded too big to belong to people she loved.

Her mind had already started burying the last few hours under grave dirt, Dean could see that, shoveling fast and clumsy over the boiler room, the second shifter, the fight through the house, the family alive on the lawn, leaving behind only flashes: a knock, a child’s trust, her own boots slipping on wet porch boards, Wallace’s snarl, blood hot against her side, the awful mercy of being in time.

“Wallace lost a tooth,” Bunny murmured.

Dean looked down.

The dog lifted his head at the sound of his name, slow and miserable, his dark eyes moving first to Bunny and then to Dean as if he expected one of them to have an answer for whatever pain had settled in his jaw. Up close, the blood around Wallace’s muzzle looked worse, thick along one side where his lip had split, or something else had torn him, rain cutting little clean paths through the red and black.

He had fought the thing literal tooth and nail, because of course he had. Because Bunny had gone into a house where children were screaming, and Wallace had gone in after her, and somewhere in there he had bitten down on a monster hard enough to leave part of himself behind rather than let his person suffer alone.

Dean swallowed something ugly in his throat.

The prayer that went up then wasn’t aimed at angels. He had had more than enough of angels lately, enough wings and orders and cryptic appearances and holy judgment dressed up as concern to last him the rest of his shortened, miserable life. It wasn’t aimed at God either, because if God was taking calls, he had a hell of a lot to answer for and Dean wasn’t in the mood to leave a polite message.

He sent it instead to whoever or whatever had put Bunny in that freezer with a starved, feral fighting dog that had tried to kill her and instead became hers. Bunny had a habit of looking at violent, broken things and deciding the world didn’t get to finish ruining them. Whatever strange, brutal grace had made that happen had earned Wallace a steak. A whole one, once they got his mouth fixed and once Dean stopped feeling like the sight of the dog’s bloodied face was going to crawl under his ribs and stay there.

“We’ll get it fixed,” Dean said quietly.

Bunny blinked, her gaze still lowered toward Wallace, the cigarette forgotten again near her mouth. “What?”

“His tooth.” Dean kept his voice low, practical, because practical was the only shape tenderness could take without making either of them flinch. “We’ll get Wallace’s tooth fixed, angel.”

Her cigarette had burned low while she stared at the dog, the ash dark and damp at the end, smoke barely rising now in the rain. She hadn’t taken another drag in too long, and Dean could feel the cloth at her side growing slicker beneath his hand, warm blood and cold rain pushing through cotton that had already given up being useful. The medics were still busy with the family, and maybe some part of them had seen Bunny sitting upright and decided that meant she could wait.

Dean didn’t know, and he didn’t care. The fragile quiet between them had done what it could. Now the practical fear was coming back, cold and mean and unwilling to sit politely with the rest of the ghosts.

“You wanna try and stand up, sweetheart?” he asked, still low, keeping his hand steady against her side.

For a long second, she didn’t answer. Then her head turned toward him, and it was only the second time she had really looked at him since he sat down beside her. Her eyes were wide and green and too far away for him to trust whatever he saw in them, too empty at the edges, like she had come back to the surface but hadn’t yet remembered which parts of the world were solid enough to stand on. Rain clung to her lashes. Blood marked the corner of her mouth, a faint smear that might not even have been hers. Her face was so pale under the police lights that the freckles across her nose looked almost bruised.

“The girls,” she said.

Dean’s chest tightened.

“They’re okay,” he whispered, and the word came out before he could dress it up, before he could make it less intimate for the crowd of cops and neighbors and paramedics moving around them. “Yeah, baby. They’re okay.”

Bunny stared at him like she needed time to translate that into something her body could believe. Her eyes flicked once past him to the curb, to the girls under the officer’s coat, to the little one in the ambulance, still tucked against her mother beneath the shining blanket. All alive. All breathing. All ruined in ways Dean couldn’t fix but not gone, not gone, not laid out under white sheets or left behind in a house while someone screamed too late to matter. He watched the fact reach her only on the surface, watched it touch down without sinking very far, and knew it would have to be told to her again later. Maybe more than once.

“They’re okay,” he said again.

This time, Bunny gave the smallest nod.

Dean moved before she could disappear back into herself, tightening his arm around her side and easing the hand with the cigarette away from her mouth. It slipped from her fingers without protest and fell onto the porch, the ember dying almost instantly against the wet wood. “All right,” he murmured, shifting closer, already bracing his feet on the step below. “C’mon. We’re gonna stand up, princess. Nice and easy. I’ve got you, baby, we’re okay.”

Bunny’s arm came around his shoulders only because he put it there, her fingers dragging weakly against the back of his jacket before curling into the fabric at his shoulder with a loose, uncertain grip. For one terrible second, when he pulled, she came with him completely boneless, weight dropping into his side like her body had forgotten the part where it helped, and Dean’s heart lurched hard enough to make his voice catch. Then her boots found the step beneath them. Her knees trembled once, buckled half an inch, and held.

He kept his hand locked over the wound and his other arm tight around her wrist, taking as much of her weight as he could without making it look like he was carrying her in front of half the county, because Bunny would care about that later even if she didn’t have enough of herself available to care now. Wallace rose with them.

It was slow, painful, and stubborn as hell, the dog dragging himself upright with a low sound that made Bunny’s fingers twitch against Dean’s jacket, his scarred head staying close to her knee like he thought she might vanish if he let the distance get too wide. Dean shifted carefully down one step, then another, guiding Bunny with him through the rain-slick dark while the porch lights and cruiser flashes slid over them in broken color. Behind them, the house stayed bright and open and ruined. Ahead of them, Sam had turned at the curb, his face changing the instant he saw them moving.

Dean didn’t call out.

He only tightened his hold on Bunny and led her off the steps as carefully as he could, Wallace limping at their heels, the three of them moving together through the cold rain while the family she had saved breathed beneath silver blankets.

✩

The room smelled like rain, rubbing alcohol, and old motel plumbing.

Dean had never liked kitchenettes, not really. They were always too small, too yellow under bad overhead lights, with counters that were almost clean and cabinets that smelled faintly of stale coffee no matter where they were. This one was no different. A chipped laminate counter. A sink with a rust stain under the faucet. Two burners, one crooked drawer, and Bunny sitting on the edge of it in one of his shirts tucked up at the side, pale and quiet while he stood between her knees with a needle in his hand.

The slash along her left side was ugly but clean enough now, a knife wound that had cut deepest near the ribs before dragging shallow toward her hip. Dean didn’t ask how it happened. Not yet. She had already tried twice to explain the house and lost the thread both times somewhere between the screaming and Wallace’s name, and he wasn’t going to make her walk back through it just so he could have the shape of the blade that had done this to her. The wound told him enough. Years of motel room bandages had taught him to read skin the way other people read weather, and this said close fight, short blade, bad angle, Bunny turning just fast enough that it hadn’t gone somewhere worse.

Her shoulder had been easier. He had cleaned the thin cuts there first, wiping rain-thinned blood away with gauze while she stared past him at the closed bathroom door. Those hadn’t needed stitches. Glass, probably, or a picture frame breaking when something shoved her into the wall. Sam had come back with the med kit and the bare bones of the police story, and Dean had looked at the shallow lines across Bunny’s shoulder, at the little glittering bits caught near one cut, and put the rest together without asking. She didn’t need to remember it out loud for him to know.

This part was different.

Dean tied off another stitch with fingers he forced to stay steady, pulling the thread snug through skin that should have made her flinch. Bunny didn’t. That was the thing sitting cold in his chest, worse than the blood in the sink and the ruined shirt balled on the floor and Wallace lying under the counter, his muzzle cleaned as best as they could manage until they got him to the vet in the morning. She didn’t flinch when the needle went in. Didn’t hiss through her teeth or call him a butcher or threaten to take over because at least she knew how to sew in a straight line. She only sat there, hands loose in her lap, eyes fixed on nothing, present enough to keep breathing and gone enough that pain had to cross too much distance to reach her.

He wasn’t used to being on this side of it with her.

Sam, sure. Dean had patched Sam up in a thousand rooms like this, had taped gashes closed with hands that were too young the first time and too practiced by the hundredth. He had kept himself together with duct tape, whiskey, bar towels, dental floss; whatever was close enough to clean and strong enough to hold him together.

But Bunny had changed the rules when she started hunting with them and then just stayed, stubborn as sin and twice as inconvenient, showing up with her carefully stocked med kit and her old community college EMT knowledge and that sharp look that said if either Winchester tried to “walk it off,” she would personally tie them down until they behaved.

She was usually the one doing this. Or she did it alone, which Dean hated almost as much. A private thing in dirty motel bathrooms or the front seat of the Bronco, stitches pulled through her own skin with the door locked and Wallace guarding the gap like pain was something she had to hide. But she was here now, sitting on the kitchenette counter with rain still damp in her hair and his hand piecing her side together one stitch at a time, and Dean loved her so much it made him feel stupid and helpless and mean all at once.

He couldn’t say that. So he worked.

Another careful pass of the needle. Another pull of thread. A tidy knot, a snip, gauze set aside with the rest. He focused on the problem in front of him because that was what he knew how to do when the rest of the world got too big: clean the wound, close the skin, keep pressure where it mattered, don’t look too long at the vacant place behind her eyes unless he wanted his hands to shake. The argument was still there somewhere, buried under the night, under the boiler room and the porch and the family breathing beneath silver blankets, but it had gone distant enough that Dean couldn’t reach it without letting go of her.

It didn’t stay distant.

That was the thing about hurt, Dean had learned. It didn’t always wait its turn just because there was blood on the counter and thread between your fingers and a job that needed doing. It sat there in the corner with its hands folded, quiet as a corpse, until the room got still enough for a man to hear it breathing.

He had his head bent over Bunny’s side, suture catching in the cheap yellow light, one hand braced gently against skin still cold from the rain, and for a while he almost managed to keep himself inside the simple mechanics of it. In, through, pull. Knot. Snip. Gauze. Breathe. Her breathing. His breathing. The steady, ugly miracle of skin drawing closed under his hands.

Then the words started to itch.

At first, he thought he could ignore them, the same way he ignored a cracked rib until it stopped aching, or a cut across his knuckles until the scab broke and stained one of his flannels. But the apology sat under his tongue like something spoiled, sour and heavy and getting worse the longer he kept it there, and Dean realized somewhere between one stitch and the next that if he didn’t say it now, with Bunny silent and pale on the counter and the world narrowed down to the space between his hands and her wound, it was going to rot inside him until it came out mean.

“I’m sorry,” he said. The words were so quiet he barely heard them himself.

For a second, he wasn’t even sure he had said them out loud. His fingers kept moving out of sheer habit, drawing the thread through the next bite of skin with as much care as he could force into hands that had never been built for delicate work, and Bunny’s gaze, lazy and watery and far away, slid toward him as if the sound had reached her long after the meaning. Dean swallowed, cleared his throat, and tried again because if he was going to do this, he owed her enough to actually do it, not mutter it into a wound and pretend the bandages had heard him.

“I’m sorry,” he said, a little firmer, though the steadiness scraped on the way out. “About earlier. What happened in the boiler room.”

Bunny looked at him without really focusing.

Dean tied the stitch, tugging it snug, then reached for the scissors because his hands needed something to do or he was going to start talking too fast and ruin it. The metal clicked softly when he cut the thread. Wallace shifted under the counter at the sound, nails scraping once against the tile before he settled again with a tired huff, and Dean kept his eyes on the wound because looking at Bunny’s face made the rest of it harder.

“I meant what I said,” he went on, low enough that the words belonged only to the ugly little kitchenette and the two of them inside it. “About torturing things. Monsters, humans, whatever line we wanna draw when it makes us feel better. I meant it. I still mean it.” He paused, because that part mattered, because taking it back would be easier and worse, and Dean was done doing the easy thing just because fear had its hand around his throat.

“But I shouldn’t have—” His jaw worked once. “I shouldn’t have gone at you like that. Not there. Not with this case. I knew what this was for you. Hell, I knew when we were in that bar, and you were so damn sure it was a shifter.”

Bunny’s eyes stayed on him, open and wet and impossible to read.

Dean looked back down and picked up the needle again. “Made a bet out of it like an idiot. Turned the whole damn thing into some joke because I didn’t wanna look too close at what it meant.” The suture went in again, and Bunny didn’t move. Didn’t even breathe differently. Dean hated it enough that his voice dropped rougher around the next words. “And then I walked into that room and saw you with all that silver, and I got scared, so I got mad. Real mature, right?”

Nothing. The thread pulled through. Another knot. Another snip.

“If I’d been thinking,” Dean said, and there it was, the old poison blooming familiar and warm in his chest, the part of him that could turn any bad night into proof that he had failed if he tried hard enough, “I would’ve had you sit this one out. Would’ve called Bobby myself and told him to keep you busy, find a job for you in another state. Sammy and I could’ve handled it. Should’ve handled it. That’s my job. Keeping you away from—”

Her face changed.

It was small, so small most people would’ve missed it, but Dean was close enough to see the first tear gather heavy along her lower lashes before it slid down her cheek. Then another. Not rain this time. Not the damp still clinging to her hair or the water she hadn’t bothered to wipe from her face when they came in. These were hot and real and sudden, fat tears rolling over freckles and pale skin while Bunny sat there silent as if her body had decided to cry without asking permission from the rest of her.

Dean froze with the needle in his hand. “Bunny?”

Her mouth trembled once. She looked down at him, then past him, then nowhere at all, and when she spoke, the sound that came out of her was so soft and broken that Dean felt it more than heard it.

“I’m so sorry.”

His brows pulled together. “What?”

“I’m so sorry,” she said again, and this time her chest hitched around it, the words catching on a sob that seemed to tear its way up from somewhere so deep Dean didn’t know how she had kept it down this long. Her hands, loose in her lap a second before, curled suddenly against his shirt, fingers twisting in the fabric she was wearing like she needed something to hold and had forgotten those hands belonged to her. “I’m so sorry. I’m so selfish. I’m so selfish, Dean, and I can’t—” She shook her head, quick and jagged, tears falling faster now, her breath coming wrong. “I can’t help it.”

He stepped closer instinctively, the needle and thread suddenly obscene in his hand, the half-closed wound between them too practical for whatever had just torn loose in her. “Hey,” he said, soft and alarmed, because he didn’t know what the hell was happening but knew he hated it. “What’re you sorry for?”

Bunny shook her head, tears spilling faster now, her mouth twisting as if the words tasted rotten. “I’m selfish,” she repeated, and the prim edge of her voice was gone, stripped down to something small and bruised and horribly young. “I’m so selfish. I can’t—”

Dean stared at her.

For one sick second he thought she meant the family, meant the little girls breathing under blankets while she sat here thinking about the ones who hadn’t. Then he thought she meant the boiler room, the shifter in the chair, the way vengeance had looked too easy in her hands. Then another possibility rose out of nowhere, old and sharp and nameless, some fight they’d had years ago, some wound he had handed her and forgotten because forgetting was easier for him than admitting how often he had been cruel to people who stayed.

“It wasn’t supposed to happen like this,” Bunny said.

Her breathing hitched hard enough to pull at the wound in her side, but she didn’t seem to feel it, or maybe she did and couldn’t care. “None of this was supposed to happen like this. I did this to us.” Her eyes finally locked onto him, wide and wet and terrible. “I did this to you. I’m doing this to you. And it’s not— it’s not—”

The sentence broke apart into a sob. Dean didn’t understand.

That was the worst part, maybe, the fact that he had spent so much of the night thinking he could read the shape of her grief, could guess the ghosts standing behind her eyes, and now she was falling apart in front of him over something he couldn’t name. He didn’t know if she was talking about the hunt. The family. The argument. Hell, maybe Vegas, maybe the marriage, maybe all the years she had been in their orbit and every bad thing she thought had followed her into it.

He didn’t know if “this” meant the blood on her side or the shifter he’d sent Sam to burn earlier or Dean sitting there with an apology half-stitched into his mouth. The words didn’t line up with the wound he thought he had been treating, and for a second he felt helpless in a way that made him want to get mean, because helplessness had always been the shortest road to anger in him.

He set the needle down. Carefully, because some buried part of him still knew not to drop sharp things near bare skin, and then he reached for her. He moved slow enough not to pull at the wound, fast enough that she didn’t have time to mistake hesitation for rejection, one arm sliding around her back while the other came up to cradle the side of her head and guide her forward. Bunny came into him like something giving way under too much weight.

Her arms came up around his shoulders the second he touched her, fingers digging into the back of his shirt, her face burying hard against the place where his neck met his shoulder, and then she was crying for real, hot and broken and muffled against him while he stood between her knees in the yellow motel light with his hand spread careful over her back and the unfinished stitch line waiting at her side.

Her whole body shook with the next sob, and he tightened his hold without thinking, then eased it again when he remembered the wound, caught between the need to keep her pressed close and the need not to hurt her worse. She clung like she hadn’t meant to, like her body had made the decision before pride could argue, and Dean lowered his face into her damp hair and breathed in rain and smoke and antiseptic, eyes burning.

He was a blunt instrument. He knew that about himself. A soldier trained by his father, a good little weapon with a bad mouth and worse instincts, a man who had clawed his way out of Hell and come back with blood under his nails that no motel sink could ever touch. He was built for taking hits, for throwing them back, for loading shotguns and salting bones and driving fast enough that grief had to work to keep up. He had no business being the person Bunny broke against. No business being trusted with this soft, fleshy part of her when half the time he didn’t know what to do with his own hands unless one of them held a gun.

And yet, he was also the man who knew how she liked to be held.

That was a fact too, simple and devastating in the middle of all the others. He knew she liked pressure when the world got too big, liked his hand broad between her shoulder blades or low at the small of her back, liked to pretend she was only tolerating him until her body went loose and warm and all her sharp edges tucked themselves away for a while.

He knew how to make her laugh by flexing at stupid times, knew the exact kind of unimpressed look she gave him before she cracked, knew that she worked lotion into his shoulders with bossy little circles and made Buffalo Bill jokes while giggling to herself. He knew she hated being treated like glass but didn’t always hate being handled gently if he did it like he wasn’t asking permission to care.

So he held her the way he knew.

Careful of the stitches. Firm enough that she didn’t have to hold herself together alone. One hand at the back of her head, fingers in her wet hair, the other spread warm and steady between her shoulder blades while she cried against him like the night had finally found the seam it could split her through. He didn’t know what she was sorry for yet. He didn’t know whether the answer would make him angry or scared or break something open in both of them that neither one was ready to clean up.

Her hair was still damp from the rain, soft where it tangled around his knuckles and somehow brittle-feeling all the same, like everything in her had gone thin and breakable under the weight of whatever had finally come loose. Dean turned his face against it and pressed his mouth to the side of her head, not quite a kiss and not quite anything else, just the only promise he could make without words getting in the way.

“It’s okay,” he murmured, though he had no idea what he meant by it, no idea what part of this could be called okay by any sane man. The wound wasn’t okay. The house hadn’t been okay. The things she’d done in the boiler room weren’t okay, and neither was the thing it had dragged out of her afterward, and none of that stopped him from needing the words to be true with a force that scared him.

He needed her to be okay the way he needed his hands to trust the barrel of a gun, the way he needed the Impala to turn over when he put the key in, the way he needed Sam breathing; not because needing had ever saved anything, but because his whole damn life had rearranged itself around a few fixed points and somewhere along the way this freckled, impossible woman had become one of them.

For most of his life, the universe had been simple in one brutal way: Sam in the middle, everything else measured by its distance from him. Dad’s orders, the car, the hunt, the road, the bodies, the deals, Hell itself; all of it had bent around the fact that Sam was there and Dean was supposed to keep him there.

Then Bunny had come back into their orbit with her sharp mouth, and her careful hands and her stupid Bronco, and the shape of things had changed before Dean noticed it happening. She hadn’t replaced Sam. Nothing could. But she had become another center of gravity, another point his body checked for without permission, another name his mind reached for in the dark before he knew he was scared.

Wife was still a strange word sometimes, too clean and domestic for the blood under their fingernails, too official for something that had started with a Vegas hangover and two people trying not to admit they had wanted the answer sober too. But it was true. She was his wife, and she was crying against his neck like she had forgotten how to stop, and Dean couldn’t do a damn thing about the last twenty-three years except keep his arms around her now.

He held her until the sobs started to break apart.

They didn’t stop, not really; he could still feel the little aftershocks of them in her ribs, feel the way her fingers clenched and unclenched in the back of his shirt like some part of her was still trying to decide whether she had the right to hold on. But the worst of it eased by degrees, the hard hitch of her breath softening against his throat, the terrible tightness in her shoulders loosening just enough that she stopped feeling like she might splinter if he shifted wrong.

Dean waited longer than he needed to because moving away felt like a risk and because, selfishly, having her pressed against him was the first thing all night that had made the room feel like it contained anything he could protect. When he finally pulled back, he did it slowly, one hand sliding from her hair to the side of her neck, the other staying near her waist, ready to catch her if the counter or the world gave out beneath her. His thumb found the edge of her jaw and rested there, not forcing, only asking, and he bent enough to bring himself into her line of sight.

For the first time all night, Bunny really looked at him.

Not the hollow, sideways glance from the porch, when her eyes had passed over him like he was one more shape in the emergency lights. Not that startled, animal flash in the kitchenette when the apology broke out of her. This was still watery, still red-rimmed, still too tired to be steady, but there was something of her inside it now, a faint return of the woman beneath the shock, like a light seen through fog. Her pupils shifted as she focused on him, widening and then steadying in a way he recognized, and Dean felt the sight of it hit low in his chest, something close enough to make his own breathing hurt.

“There you are,” he said softly.

Bunny blinked at him, once, slow, and the smallest line appeared between her brows as if the words had touched some bruised place in her and she didn’t know yet whether to be grateful or offended. That, stupidly, almost made him smile. Not because any of this was funny, not because the blood had stopped or the stitching was nearly done or because crying once in a motel kitchenette fixed the jagged thing that had opened in her, but because there was a flicker of Bunny in that tiny offended wrinkle, a trace of the woman who would sooner swallow glass than admit being found had scared her. Dean brushed his thumb along the side of her neck, careful to avoid the old scar climbing toward her ear, and watched her follow the touch with a delayed, fragile awareness that made him want to both hold her tighter and step back before he asked too much.

“You know what I’m thinkin’ about?” he asked.

Her lashes lowered and lifted again. For a second, he thought she might answer, might give him some dry, wrecked little guess that would break him clean in half, but she only shook her head. The movement was barely there, more breath than motion, her cheek shifting against his palm.

Dean let his mouth tip, not all the way into a smile, just enough to keep the words from coming out too heavy. “Mostly,” he said, voice low and rough in the quiet, “I’m thinkin’ I gotta finish stitching you up before you bleed all over my shirt.”

For one second, nothing happened. Then Bunny’s mouth moved.

It wasn’t a smile the way she usually smiled, not sharp or pleased, not the kind she used when she was about to bait him into doing something stupid just to prove she could. It was smaller than that, unsteady and bruised, a wobbly little curve that barely survived on her lips before it trembled apart again. But it was there. A little seam of life showing through. Dean watched it like a man watching a match strike in a room that had gone dark, and he had to look down for a second because the tenderness of it was somehow harder to take than the tears.

“Sorry,” Bunny whispered.

“It’s okay, baby. Hated that shirt anyway.” The joke was thin, deliberately gentle, and it died almost as soon as he let it go. He didn’t try to chase it. He only watched her face to make sure it hadn’t landed wrong, and when Bunny gave the faintest breath through her nose, not quite laughter but not nothing either, he counted it as a win and shifted his gaze back to the wound. The needle looked smaller now, somehow, less like an accusation and more like what it was: metal, thread, one tiny brutal mercy after another.

“But I’m also thinkin’,” Dean said after a beat, quieter this time, as he picked up the suture and lined up the next stitch, waiting until Bunny’s fingers tightened once in his shirt to tell him she was ready, “that maybe we skipped a few of the fun parts of getting married.”

It took her a second to answer, long enough that Dean set the needle but didn’t pull it through, watching the shape of her mouth and the way her eyes moved over his face like she was coming at the words from a long way off. Her fingers were still curled in his shirt, loose now instead of desperate, and he could feel the small tremor in them every time she breathed too deeply and the wound tugged under his hand. Bunny swallowed once, the motion careful, her throat working beneath the damp line of her locket, and when she spoke, her voice came out wet and tired and faintly bewildered, as if she were reminding him of a fact he had misplaced rather than playing along with anything.

“But we got married in Vegas.”

Dean nodded, slow and solemn like she had made an important legal argument and not pointed out the messiest thing either of them had ever done with tequila in their systems. “Yeah,” he said gently. “Yeah, we did, baby.”

Bunny’s brows pulled together, the smallest crease of confusion returning to her face, and Dean let that sit for half a second before he looked back down at her side and drew the needle through. She didn’t flinch, but her fingers tightened once in his shirt, and he took that as permission to keep talking. Maybe it was cowardice, maybe it was genius, maybe it was just the only safe road he could see through the dark; give her something stupid and future-shaped to hold while he closed the skin the monster had opened, something that didn’t ask her to explain the old wound or forgive the new one before either of them had enough blood left in their heads to know what they meant.

“But I’m talkin’ about the other stuff,” he said, tying the stitch carefully, his voice kept low beneath the hum of the bathroom fan and the rain ticking against the window. “The good stuff. A bachelor party, for one.”

That got her eyes to move back toward him.

Dean pretended not to notice, because noticing was how you scared a wild thing back into the trees, and Bunny had already spent enough of the night feeling hunted by her own head. He reached for the scissors, snipped the thread, and set them down with a soft click. “Couple days from now,” he continued, like he was laying out a hunt plan and not building them a little ridiculous bridge across all the blood, “when everybody’s back to center, I’m gonna drag Sammy out to some terrible bar with sticky floors and beer that tastes like somebody strained it through a sock. And then I’m gonna make him sing karaoke.”

For one second, Bunny only stared at him.

Then a sound left her, barely more than breath, but it had the shape of amusement if Dean was generous, and he was suddenly willing to be generous about damn near anything. It came out thin and broken, catching somewhere between her ribs and the stitch line, and it hurt her; he saw the little pinch of pain across her mouth before she could hide it. But it was there. Not happiness. Not peace. Nothing that clean. Just one small, battered sound pushing up through the wreckage because some part of her was still alive enough to understand that Sam Winchester forced into karaoke was a tragedy worth imagining.

Dean smiled before he could stop himself.

Not big. Not smug. Nothing with teeth in it. Just warm, soft at the edges, the kind of smile he didn’t give away much because it made him feel like he’d left his chest unlocked. “Yeah,” he said, quieter still. “Exactly. Gonna be awful.”

Bunny blinked at him, tears still caught in her lashes, and her mouth moved again, the faintest curve struggling to stay put. “Are you going to sing a Rod Stewart song for me?”

Dean huffed, the sound gentle enough that it barely disturbed the air between them. “I’ll sing whatever you want,” he said, and the truth of that came out easier because he could dress it up as a joke, because it was safer to talk about karaoke than to say he would crawl through broken glass for her and probably complain about the glass the whole way. “Long as it’s not Jefferson Starship.”

This time, Bunny almost laughed.

It wasn’t much. A damp little exhale, a soft, startled break in her breathing that trembled apart almost as soon as it arrived, but it was closer than before, closer to the sound he knew, closer to Bunny sitting beside him in the Impala with her feet in his lap and some ridiculous pickup line waiting behind her teeth. Dean felt his heart rise out of his stomach for the first time since he had turned onto Marsh Street and seen the red and blue lights blooming through the rain, felt it come up slow and bruised and stupidly grateful, like the world had handed him back something he hadn’t realized he’d already started mourning.

Bunny wiped clumsily at her nose with the back of one hand with a sniff, missing more than she fixed, and Dean had to fight the ridiculous urge to do it for her. She was still only half in her body, her eyes drifting sometimes toward the wall and sometimes toward him, but there was a thread now, thin as sutures and just as stubborn, tying her back to the room. Her thumb rubbed once against the ring on her finger, not deliberately enough to be a gesture and not accidental enough for Dean to miss, and then she looked at him with the smallest shadow of suspicion beneath the exhaustion.

“Do I get one?”

Dean looked up from lining the next stitch. “One what?”

“A bachelorette.” Her voice scraped over the word, but the shape of her was clearer now, even if only by degrees. “If you’re taking Sam for your bachelor party, I want one.”

Dean stared at her for half a beat.

Then his mouth twitched. “You wanna take Sammy on a bachelorette party?”

“Yeah.” Her eyes flickered, almost focusing.

Dean let out a quiet laugh before he could stop it, low and relieved, because making too much of it might break the damn thing. “Yeah, alright,” he said, shaking his head as he pulled the stitch through. “Sammy’s got enough hair to get mistaken for one of the girls anyway. Put him in a sash, give him one of those stupid little plastic tiaras, nobody’s gonna question it.”

Bunny’s smile was small, and it hurt to look at because it was real enough to be fragile. “He’d hate that.”

“Oh, he’d hate every second of it.” Dean tied the knot, snipped the thread, and glanced up at her through his lashes. “Which is why I’m sayin’ it’s probably worth doing.”

The smile stayed for another breath.

Dean waited, because something in him had learned the shape of this moment and knew better than to rush it. The rain softened at the window. Wallace huffed under the counter, shifting in sleep or pain, his nails scraping faintly against the tile before he settled again. Somewhere in the next room, Sam moved around with the low, careful quiet of a man pretending not to listen and absolutely listening, and Dean hoped, with a fondness he would deny under torture, that Sam had heard enough to know he was apparently getting drafted into two separate post-wedding disasters whenever the world gave them the decency of a day off.

Bunny looked at him then, really looked, and the smile faded into something softer, something worn thin but present. Dean kept his hand near her side, kept the needle angled away, and leaned in slowly enough that she could turn away if she wanted. She didn’t. Her fingers tightened once more in his shirt, not fear this time, not quite need either, just recognition, and Dean pressed his mouth to hers in a brief, gentle kiss that tasted like salt and rain and antiseptic air. He didn’t deepen it. Didn’t try to make it into comfort bigger than it was. He only kissed her once, softly, then pulled back before it could ask too much of either of them.

Her eyes stayed closed for a second after. Dean watched her breathe. Then he brushed his thumb once along her thigh, a grounding touch more than anything else. “Gonna finish patching you up, okay? Then we’ll get you to sleep.”

Bunny opened her eyes. They were tired, red-rimmed, still carrying too much of the house in them, but when she nodded, it was steadier than the last one had been. “Okay,” she said, voice small and hoarse.

Dean squeezed her thigh once, careful and warm. “Almost done.”

He went back to work.

The last stitches were quieter than the first ones. Bunny still didn’t flinch much, but now her hand stayed twisted loosely in the front of his shirt, and every now and then, when the needle pulled through, and pain finally managed to cross whatever distance shock had put between her body and the rest of her, her fingers tightened, and Dean paused until they eased again. He didn’t apologize for the hurt every time. Didn’t make a production out of being careful. He just kept his touch steady and his voice low, telling her once when he was nearly finished, once when he had to pull the skin together a little more firmly, once when the knot was done and the scissors made their final soft click in the kitchenette light.

“There,” he murmured.

Bunny looked down at the bandage only after he had taped the gauze over the neat line of stitches, her eyes moving over his work with slow, exhausted attention. For a second, Dean braced himself for some faint insult about his technique, some half-dead little jab about the stitch spacing or his tragic misunderstanding of medical precision, and he wanted it so badly that the wanting almost made him sick. But Bunny only looked at the clean white gauze beneath his open shirt, then at his hands resting carefully beside her hips, then back at his face.

“Thank you,” she whispered.

Dean’s throat worked. He nodded like it didn’t hit him where he lived. “Yeah,” he said, because anything more would come out wrong. “Anytime.”

previous chapter

@kenn5tar @junescasualbookclub @magic-sprinkled-daydreams @aylacavebear @whatstruthgottodowithit @brycequinlanstan @sir-thisisadndserver @morphineh @saltymagazinejellyfish @ontheboundmp4 @foxyjwls007

want to be added to the taglist? fill out the form below!

abbacadabara's taglist!

Trending Blogs

Recently Viewed Blogs

abracadabra!