Hi! I just wanna say thank you for being really clear on your stand on the whole pan omni bi debate. All of your points are totally valid.
This being said, I know someone who identifies as Omni, and I'm really close with this person. I figured it would be better of me as a friend to accept them for who they were and support this, if this is how they really felt. Overall, I feel this might be a better approach...
so yes, you are correct, but do you think we just should be supportive? These things don't always have to be biphobic or transphobic or anything, this is just the label that they feel most comfortable with. The distinction matters to some people, and even if it doesn't make sense, maybe we should try to respect that???
idk, just my personal thoughts... :) I hope u have a nice day and don't take offense to this, that wasn't the intention I swear. Bi-Bye!!! :3 <3
First, I'm glad you find my explanations of my thoughts clear. Also, I don't take offense to what you're saying at all, I understand what you mean; however, I think you're making a dichotomy where there isn't one.
On this blog I argue against (what I see as) biphobic claims and arguments, and that includes various "pro m-spec" definitions. But, I don't think you should ambush all pan/omni people with arguments against their sexuality, or be unsupportive and hostile towards them.
However, I think there is a difference between supporting someone and affirming biphobic viewpoints. I won't confront people about their labels at inappropriate situations, but I refuse to respect people's views when they're insulting me. And, to be clear, every time I see people someone try to explain why they use their label over bisexual, or present some form of distinction between an "m-spec identity" and bisexuality, its always been biphobic.=
This is only tangentially related to this ask, but I want to make it clear that I don't think all pan/omni/poly/etc. people are actively biphobic, but I have yet to see pro m-spec reasonings that aren't clearly based on biphobic rhetoric. At the end of the day, a lot of these people are themselves victims of biphobia, which often contributes to their distancing themselves from bisexuality.
TL;DR: I think you can support someone without supporting offensive ideals. I hope my reasoning makes sense