Things are not always what they seem.
Above is short video of a son coming out as gay to his father. This clip went viral over 5 years ago - A lifetime ago in the digital world.
I had never seen this video before and was first exposed to it via a written transcript. I imagined the setting of a quiet family residence, maybe his father is watching TV in the living room or sat at the table reading a newspaper or something equally low-key and private.Â
I later learned that it was done via a phone call from abroad, thus taking away that image of a personal interaction. Itâs an extended transcript where we also learn that there is a third party listening in on the dadâs side of the phone line. This immediately changes the deeply personal nature of the discussion, making it all the more difficult.
Lastly, the complete picture is given. We learn that he has filmed himself phoning his father (who was unaware of this at the time) in which the whole world was a invited to this very intimate moment.Â
The point is that these three depictions of the same thing create three very different pictures of the setting in which this took place and more importantly the thought process of the young man that did this. It goes from an interaction between 2 to 3 to everyone. This extra information changes how we as the audience perceive his word choice.
Does the fact that it was done via phone call diminish the importance of the occasion, maybe a text message would have sufficed? However, does the entirely public nature of the video show deep bravery to be able to tell the world with no fear on a matter that had been plaguing him for years. Or is something more cynical at work?Â
I wondered whether there was something quite calculating going on. It was a success on YouTube and he undoubtedly made a few quid off it. Why would a bunch of strangers care once youâve already told friends and family? Surely, once your loved ones know, so what, this is the 21st century? The âbraveryâ of the video is somewhat diminished due to the time lapse and as a result of this and I am pessimistic enough to brandish this a publicity stunt. It just goes to show how easily we can create projections and opinions and based on any information, whether or not we have the whole picture.
Just to be absolutely clear, I am not shunning the actions of this coming out, merely questioning the rationale behind the video.
FYI: Stay away from the comments section of the video, itâs a deeply troubling place.