In Gaza, surviving each day is a battle, and carrying the weight of an entire family on your shoulders makes it even heavier. 💔
I’m Hamza. Before everything changed, my biggest dream was to wear a white coat and become a doctor. Today, my reality is trying to keep my elderly parents alive and safe as their sole provider. I have to be strong for them every second, even when I am running on empty.
I won't give up on my parents, and I won't give up on my education. With your help, I can protect my family today and build a future where I can heal others tomorrow. Every dollar and every share brings us one step closer to safety and hope. 🎓🩺
🙏 Stand with Hamza and his family:👇🏻🔗
To Donate👇🏻
watch this video please My Story: My name is Hamza, and when the war began, I was in the ninth grade. Today, I should be in the eleventh gra
Vetted by @gazavetters, Number (#760) on this list
Time is bleeding out in the ICU. Mohammed is slipping away, his condition worsening with every tick of the clock. We are desperate for a miracle to stop the shadows from taking him. Please, help us before it’s too late.
My son’s world is turning to black right before my eyes. It shatters my heart to see his light dimming before he even gets to live. We are begging for your mercy to save his sight and his life.
Please don't scroll past this nightmare. Mohammed is just a little boy fighting a battle he cannot win alone. Your kindness is the only bridge to his survival. Every second of delay costs us everything.
My name is Nasreen, I am 39 years old, and I am a widowed mother of four beautiful children:
We are at a breaking point and exhausted of all hope except for you. Please donate or share now—not tomorrow, but right now. Help us bring Mohammed back from the brink before his light vanishes forever.
"No One is an Alien! Except All of the Aliens.": How Superman Media, Writers, and Fans Endorse Assimilation
Note: I've discussed this topic before in a bit of detail here, here, and here, but I'm taking this opportunity to hammer out the common threads between these posts using explicit textual evidence. I am fully amenable to correction or further discussion, especially as it pertains to more recent comics. This essay/meta strictly contains textual analysis of the Superman media and presumes the audience has a working knowledge or concern about Superman, xenophobia, assimilation, and cultural socialization in adoption. The audience is 1) encouraged to do their own research and 2) remember that this contains no strictly academic sources.
Introduction
A prevalent problem within Superman fandom — writers, long-timers, and "normies" alike — is the failure to recognize when the tropes and proclivities viewed as an essential staple of Superman lore implicitly promote assimilation and xenophobia. Putting aside those who deny the fact of Superman being an immigrant, many people will pay lip service to the immigrant narrative but in fact regularly embrace interpretations which undermine the full exploration of his relationship with his Kryptonian heritage. This includes, most especially, any version of Superman that makes the forsaking of Krypton seem like a moral imperative or the logical narrative conclusion. Even the iterations which do not actively demonize Krypton — i.e., depict just about all non-Earth-raised Kryptonians as dangerously ignorant, draconic, warmongering, or incapable of empathy or complex emotion — are nevertheless fine with minimizing its presence outside of mentioning it as fodder for easy conflict (or conflict resolution). The result has been an image of Krypton which encourages both Superman and the audience to distance themselves from Krypton, if not reject it outright. Instead, Superman is encouraged by the narrative to retreat into the arms of the cozy conservative Americana of Smallville, which is then defended and excused by Krypton's prior lack of relevance and/or consistent evilness. To the extent either of those claims are actually true, they are a product of authorial and editorial decisions which minimized Krypton's positive impact and narrative importance from the outset, with the intention of eschewing Superman’s immigrant identity.
"Krypton’s Never Been Important,” and “Has Always Been ‘Evil’”: Common Reasons Fans Refuse to Acknowledge Assimilationist and Xenophobic Rhetoric
The presumed unimportance of Krypton is a significant aspect, if not the foundation, of the tendency to treat Kryptonian lore as either negligible or unworthy of a mostly positive status quo. Sans the aforementioned use of Krypton and its inhabitants as plot fodder, the excision of Krypton — or its most positive and impactful elements — is often deemed a critical aspect of Superman storytelling. Some fans will offer the “believability” of (modern) Krypton’s disregard for humans and of Superman’s distance from his culture, while others insist that Krypton’s inclusion somehow degrades the importance of Earth. It stands to reason, then, that if it's demonstrable that this current attitude was not inherent to Superman media and is the result of (malicious) authorial, editorial, and otherwise creative intent to remove or misrepresent Krypton, then this claim no longer holds water.
Krypton's lore on Earth-1, the universe of the Silver and Bronze Ages of DC Comics, was highly developed in Superman stories for a long-dead planet. Not only did Superman frequently time travel to try and save the planet or simply have a strange experience there, to the point where it was canonized that Superman was named after himself [e.g. Superman (1939) #123, #141; World's Finest Comics (1941) #191; World of Krypton (1979) #2], but Superman (1939), and occasionally other associated lines, contained a secondary story series called "The Fabulous World of Krypton", in which Kryptonian lore, including myths and history, was developed quite fervidly. (In this post, I discussed some of them.)
The Superman Family #182 & Superman #282, respectively
Far beyond that, Krypton's legacy — in the form of Superman himself, Kandor, Supergirl, Krypto, Beppo the Super-Monkey, Brainiac, the Phantom Zone, and in the many results of its absence — continued to feature in Superman (1939), Action Comics (1938), DC Comics Presents (1978), Superboy (1949, 1980), Adventure Comics (1938), Supergirl (1972, 1982), Superman Family (1974), World's Finest Comics (1941) and other Superman-adjacent series until the effective end of the Earth-1 universe in the Crisis on Infinite Earths event. Despite being dead, Superman’s Kryptonian parents Jor-El and Lara are mentioned or featured in hundreds of stories from this era.
So, the question of Krypton's (un)importance to Superman lore isn't reducible to non-inclusion or non-relevance; despite the planet exploding around 3 Earth decades prior to the canon timeline of Earth-1, writers back then constructed the lore in ways that allowed Superman to discover the vestiges of Kryptonian culture and people. It was through a combination of the Kandorians, his own technology, the occasional trip through space and space-time, and sheer luck that Superman was able to retain a connection to his heritage, the foremost of which he confirms in [DC Comics Presents #21].
DC Comics Presents (1978) #21 and Superboy (1949) #79 respectively
The idea that Krypton is unimportant is typically intertwined with the claim that Krypton has "always been that way," i.e., full of morally egregious, emotionally constipated beings — the logic being that Krypton's supposed unimportance means that negative depictions of Kryptonians are tolerable and even encouraged for story purposes. However, we know again from the pre-crisis lore that their supposed inherent evilness is emphatically not the case. Superman himself explicitly described Krypton as a mostly peace-loving, technologically advanced society whose people did not believe in the death penalty and were likely more morally enlightened than Earth's people [e.g. World's Finest Comics (1941) #292, Action Comics (1938) #565]. (Given that science is a fundamentally philosophical pursuit, such that it was not even considered wholly separate from today's notion of philosophy until around the 1800s and still has subfields of philosophies dedicated to specific sciences, this is not outside of the realm of believability.)
Superman’s description is fully corroborated by other stories outside of these. The people of Krypton do not accept tyranny or slavery, they combat it [e.g. Superman (1939) #176, #264; Superman Family (1974) #182]. They do not kill their most heinous criminals [e.g., The Phantom Zone (1982)]. They live in a science-based society that values its members’ well-being, including providing mass inoculations and therapy [e.g., Superman (1939) #307–309, #409]. Most importantly, they couldn’t colonize other planets even if they wanted to, but they believed in interplanetary cooperation to the extent they could practice it without working spaceships [e.g., Action Comics (1938) #574] and were on good terms with Kryptonians who were not part of their intraplanetary federation [e.g. Krypton Chronicles (1981)]. Jor-El and Lara even named an alien named Rol-Nac Superman’s godfather [e.g. Action Comics (1938) #378]. The idea of Krypton as this awful, colonial place simply does not gel with the depictions of it in pre-crisis Earth-1.
(Even the New Earth universe established that Kryptonians physically couldn’t colonize other worlds, albeit for a different reason.)
Thus, when some fans and writers claim that the influence negative depictions of Krypton have on future Superman storylines and on audience engagement with the planet doesn't matter, one must wonder why it supposedly doesn't matter, given that Krypton was a regular and positive aspect of Superman stories prior to the Crisis on Infinite Earths event in 1985. Despite Krypton having its flaws — the existence of Bokos Isle, the over-obstinate Science Council, and the Phantom Zoners to start — those never undermined the tragedy of Krypton's explosion or diminished the importance of Superman's connection to his heritage. Rather, it added a complexity and a realness to a planet that was otherwise utopian. How could the reputation and significance of Krypton seemingly change overnight?
"No One is an Alien, except All of the Aliens": Superman’s Distance from Other DC Aliens and the Veneer of Multiculturalism
When people extol Superman’s virtues and discuss his impact in the DC universe, on the audience, and on wider pop culture, there’s a peculiar focus on emphasizing Superman's humanity. Of course, at least in English, “humanity” is another term for “morality,” such that the language encourages such a conflation. However, the way people use the term “human” to refer to Superman reveals that the conflation is actually quite crucial in obfuscating the truth. That is, when the term humanity is juxtaposed against Superman’s very real alien identity (in this case, alien relative to Earth), it functions as a denial of that identity and the experiences which accompany it. Encompassing Superman in humanity — which seems inclusive yet transparently never includes other famous DC aliens, by the way — is a covert method of enforcing assimilation. People don’t say this as a means to recognize Superman as a fellow moral agent or capable of empathy; they’re saying it to distance him from his alienness, as if being human is the highest standard and ultimate reward one can achieve.
(Interestingly, the term "human" in pre-crisis was applicable to species outside of Earth, including the Kryptonians. Intelligent life on Earth was referred to as "tellurian," "terran," and simply "Earth people," [e.g. Superman (1939) #249, 307; Action Comics (1938) #500 and #518]. One must wonder why this usage fell out of favor.)
The devaluation of nonassimilative alienness is most apparent when comparing Superman’s experience and treatment to that of his fellow aliens. For them, Superman’s assimilation, real or perceived, is actually a very pronounced flaw; not only is it harder for them to relate to him generally, but Superman’s disconnection from his Kryptonian culture, real or perceived, seems to make him lesser. That’s not in the sense of his value as a person or a hero; it’s in how his losses and feelings of difference compare to their own. (Depending on the interaction, it can also subtly mimic real-life dynamics between “acceptable” and “unacceptable” (usually racialized or culturally connected) immigrants.)
World’s Finest (1941) #256
It is important to note, as I did in this post, that the Thanagarians were somewhat unfair in their judgments here. Many of Superman’s stories from this same era/universe, i.e., Bronze Age Earth-1, reckoned with his feelings of being an alien and a permanent outsider on Earth. Earth-1 Superman was a constant victim of hate speech, psychological manipulation, and social ostracism for being an alien. (He was even hate-crimed in the story right after this one [World’s Finest Comics (1941) #257]). Had they been honest with him, Superman likely would have understood their plight. Moreover, genuine or not, the Thanagarians were strangely unsympathetic to Superman, given the fact that his planet had been destroyed. He was as connected to Krypton as he could be given his circumstances, and undermining that when he was trying to express sympathies was cruel. Even so, Superman felt a connection to Earth that the Thanagarians did not, having lived most of his life there and, in his own words, been given a home by Earth when he was homeless. It’s understandable that two people who ultimately felt no connection to Earth at all would be exhausted of it — and [World’s Finest Comics #256] still introduces valid distinctions between their alien experiences, even if they weren’t expressed well.
Superman (1939) #309
That said, the Thanagarians’ comments in [World’s Finest Comics #256] were more aptly articulated in the post-crisis/New Earth universe, where Martian Manhunter told Superman that their experiences with being alien are not the same.
Martian Manhunter (1998) #0
The Superman of New Earth was born in a birthing matrix on Earth rather than naturally on Krypton, courtesy of John Byrne’s Man of Steel (1986). He had little desire to use the knowledge of Krypton, which was conferred to him through Jor-El’s technology or to really identify as Kryptonian. While the austerity of Superman’s attitude lessened with Byrne’s removal from the books in 1988 and was officially nixed by Mark Waid’s Superman: Birthright (2003), there was and still is a pronounced tendency for Superman to associate more with humanity than with Krypton. In contrast, New Earth’s Martian Manhunter was similarly a victim of a planetary cataclysm, as stated above and depicted in J.M. DeMatteis’ Martian Manhunter (1988), but was a participant in the Martian culture and people long enough to not identify with Earthpeople. This contrast is why Martian Manhunter’s words do not carry the same misunderstanding of New Earth Superman’s character that the Thanagarians’ assessment of Earth-1 Superman had. While the Thanagarians were operating off of underinformed beliefs about Superman’s connections to Krypton and Earth, Martian Manhunter was not; the fact that they had functionally equivalent experiences (outside of their ages when their planets were destroyed) allowed him to make these observations correctly. Martian Manhunter was Martian, and Superman didn’t have very much tying him to Krypton at all. While some authors would pay lip service to Krypton when mining it for storylines, Superman as a representative of Kryptonian culture or people — Krypton as something meaningful to Superman that could exist simply for its own sake — was basically dead in the water. Put succinctly, Martian Manhunter was just… correct.
Man of Steel (1986) #6 & Superman (1987) #2 respectively
Even the very concept of there being other living Kryptonians from New Earth was on an embargo, hence the convoluted writing decisions necessary to include characters like Supergirl and Zod without really using them. While this editorial decision did eventually lead to the expansion of the Superman Family in interesting ways, that expansion came heavily at the expense of Krypton’s original denizens. For example, New Earth’s Kara Zor-El (Supergirl) wouldn’t be reintroduced into Superman lore until Superman/Batman (2003), despite other versions of Supergirl existing in the 90s. Thus, New Earth’s Superman didn’t even have the luxury of speaking to a real (and non-hostile) Kryptonian for a long time.
Speaking of Kara Zor-El, her depiction in the post-crisis/New Earth universe and beyond make the persistence of negative depictions of Krypton and of the belief that Krypton doesn’t matter extremely questionable. Time and again, as recently as Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow (2021), Kara mourns Krypton (or Argo City) and her life there. She’s uncertain about her path as a resident of Earth and often somewhat resents her cousin Kal (Superman) for not having many memories about his Kryptonian heritage. This is so common that some fans call her the real child of Krypton, for much of the same reasons that Martian Manhunter felt the need to differentiate his experiences as an alien from Superman’s own. Now, Kara’s backstory — whether she was the older cousin born and raised on Krypton prior to an accident causing her to land on Earth 30 years after Kal or the Argo City denizen who left at 15 — makes having Kara adopt a similar attitude to post-crisis Superman far more difficult to get away with. Moreover, given that Kal was already fairly distant from Kryptonian culture at the time of Kara’s reintroduction, it’s likely that writers believe using Kara as the vessel for Kryptonian cultural representation lessens the need for Kal to engage with Krypton himself while also lessening fan criticism about Krypton’s noninclusion. However, neither of the aforementioned reconciles or justifies perpetuating the idea of a warmongering Kryptonian culture in Superman books. Rather, Kara’s response to Krypton’s demise just becomes unintelligible when the tragedy of Krypton’s explosion is undermined by draconian renditions. And in general, there is an emotional and relational distance between the Supercousins that didn’t exist on Earth-1.
Supergirl (2016) #21 and Batman/Superman (2022) #8, respectively
Between Kara, Martian Manhunter, and the Thanagarians, the picture of why people believe that Krypton isn’t or shouldn’t be relevant to Superman’s lore — at least in such a way that would warrant a consistent, mostly positive depiction — begins to take a better shape. The distinction between the portrayal of Superman’s alien status/immigrant identity and those of other aliens is largely his connection to Earth. There is no version of the Superman mythos where this connection does not exist at all, but it is emphasized and prioritized in some universes more than others. Why? Recall the last statement of the opening paragraph: “People don’t [reference humanity] as a means to recognize Superman as a fellow moral agent or capable of empathy; they’re saying it to distance him from his alienness, as if being human is the highest standard and ultimate reward one can achieve.” When Superman fans and writers express their love for Superman’s humanity, it is only in a sense that it is not and cannot be extended to other aliens. Including them would transparently contradict the characters’ wider lore and understanding of themselves, while Superman’s lore provided the necessary foundation for this portrayal to take root and be accepted with a bit of effort. His backstory is that he was raised on Earth past infancy or toddlerdom. A common attitude toward adoption, particularly crosscultural or international adoption, holds that the erasure of the child’s original cultural background is acceptable. The expectation that parents try to encourage them to embrace that culture has only recently become more popular; many believe that being forcibly disconnected is a sign that the child shouldn’t or won’t ever care. In other words, the children are treated as blank slates, not products of their context. This is often amplified when the adoptive parents are white Americans or Europeans, and the children are not, with the presumption of the adoptive culture being superior to the original culture justifying the erasure. The result is that Superman, the Kryptonian orphan from the stars adopted by a lovely rural American couple, is thought to be far better off on Earth than Krypton.
Recall the question presented in the last section of this essay: “How could the reputation and significance of Krypton seemingly change overnight?” The answer to that question should be more obvious now. John Byrne’s Man of Steel (1986) changed the reputation and significance of Krypton, with significant help from successive comic runs that compounded or failed to address the underlying biases his work instilled within the lore. The editorial mandate forbidding the presence of other living Kryptonians in New Earth, remaining in place even after Byrne left Superman, dealt the killing blow.
All of the aforementioned is why the “no one is an alien” theme common to modern Superman media, including the most recent movie, finds its ally in the U.S. American “melting pot.” The melting pot is seen as the metaphorical bastion of multiculturalism. People from all countries, religions, and cultures can come to the United States and find their place amongst the teeming masses. Allegedly. As the term suggests, the melting pot actually functions to homogenize, sterilize, and erase the various cultures within the country. However, the faux promotion of multiculturalism and unity makes the melting pot seem like a progressive conception. The people who extol Superman’s immigrant identity while refusing to engage with it or their understanding of Krypton on a deeper level are functionally the same as the liberals who espouse melting pot theory, right down to the refusal to acknowledge that cultural differences are acceptable and even often necessary to gain a broader understanding of the world.
It’s in this vein, fans will decry the use of “alien” to describe Superman, despite “alien” being a relative term meant to denote foreignness and unfamiliarity; it is only prejudice that confers unsavory connotations. The refusal to use it only gives people room to ignore or deny that Superman is an alien to Earth. Ostensibly in the pursuit of inclusion, those people tend to dismiss anything that coincides with him being an alien as unimportant. Writers do this too: his connections to Krypton, his status as an immigrant who feels outside of American and Earth culture, and his struggles with having lost his home planet are brushed over to the point where people assume he has no trauma related to it. If they do believe he has trauma, it’s only in the sense that they want Superman to pursue being human. His loneliness (if he feels it at all) is framed as an inherent result of being an alien and not attributed to the people who do or would ostracize him for that; his feelings of not belonging can only be resolved by blending in rather than being accepted as he is; and his isolation is addressed by letting others dictate how he exists in a space rather than finding others like him. His appeasement of others for his own safety and relative ability to “fit” is framed as his problem and not a societal one — or if it is a societal one, it’s the result of people wanting to retain culture rather than discard it in favor of a nebulous American identity. There’s nothing wrong with Superman, per sé, other than that pesky Krypton. He’s just overthinking his place and clutching onto "the old world," complete with all of its flaws and none of its virtues. In other words, a Superman who is attuned with his Kryptonian culture is refusing to join the melting pot. (This is also the reason people insist that “Superman is just what Clark does”; conflating his Kryptonian identity with his hero moniker allows them to dismiss the Kryptonian connection as overplayed or receiving too much focus.)
Hitman (1996) #34
We know from Earth-1 that the false dichotomy between Earth and Krypton, and for Earth to always be the “right choice,” doesn’t have to be the case. It is possible to establish an equilibrium, and Superman doesn’t need to join the melting pot in order to be a great hero. Yet despite the fact that the “No Kryptonians” mandate was dropped decades ago, resulting in the more prominent original Kryptonians reappearing in the 2000s, many fans and writers simply refuse to accept (explicitly and tacitly) another path for Superman. That is to say, there isn’t a need to return to the exact framing of Earth-1, but even the stories for Prime Earth which seek to rectify New Earth’s flaws still carry the echoes of the melting pot. The nuance of Superman’s experiences and perspective on Earth has been compromised in the wider conversation of his lore, and many people seem to prefer that compromise despite its origins and implications. Fortunately, this can be fixed. Unfortunately, this is an issue that transcends mediums.
“It happened in Smallville!”: the Complicity of (Modern) Superman Adaptations
The list of Superman adaptations which have contributed to the devaluation of Krypton in the wider Superman mythos is lengthy, given that they are both products of and influences over the comics that were in production at the time of their development. However, some adaptations are both more popular and more recent than others and thus have more immediate relevance to this essay. Those are Smallville (2001–2011), My Adventures with Superman (2023–ongoing), and Superman (2025).
Smallville (2001-2011)
Smallville (2001–2011) is a widely acclaimed television series that aired on the WB/CW channel. It followed Clark Kent (Superman) prior to his adoption of the Superman moniker, who was embroiled in a never-ending battle against the various “freaks of the week,” heinous criminals, and the pitfalls of young adulthood. Most of the Superman fans who have watched the show, even those who disdain certain narrative decisions, would agree that Smallville largely warrants its praise. However, as Smallville pertains to this essay, it is one of the main purveyors of assimilationist rhetoric in Superman media outside of the comics.
As mentioned in the introduction, Krypton is typically used as fodder for conflict, and this was as true for Smallville as it is for the comics. Beginning very early in the show, Clark blames the A.I. of his Kryptonian father Jor-El, his powers, his being an alien, and other things associated with Krypton for his life troubles. As the seasons progress, whichever Kryptonian persons, states of being, and artifacts become relevant are also more severe. The most notable examples of this are Kal-El as a reference to “alien Clark,” the distortion of villains as being Kryptonian creations, and the portrayal of almost all Kryptonians beyond Clark as antagonists.
Superman’s Kryptonian name “Kal(-El)” was used to refer to Clark in states where he was “unrecognizable,” most notably when he was hyped on Red Kryptonite, often considered a substitute for drug use in the show. In the episodes “Red” [S2:E04], “Exile” [S3:E01], “Phoenix” [S3:02], and “Crimson” [S6:E13], Clark used his Kryptonian name as an alias while unabashedly engaging in dangerous, selfish, and destructive behaviors, regardless of the person or people with whom he is interacting. Amongst his transgressions were theft (of credit cards and from banks) underage club attendance, engagement party-crashing, and flagrant disregard for others. The show heavily insinuated that Clark on Red K is more uninhibited than he is controlled by the Kryptonite. This became even more pronounced in “Upgrade” [S9:E17], when Zod’s clone took advantage of Clark’s addled mind to try and convince him to take over the planet Earth. While it is true that Red Kryptonite could make Superman act out of character in the comics [e.g., Superman (1939) #163], that was far from the only or the most prominent effect it had on him. Strange transformations — changes in his weight, height, powers, appearance, and abilities — were all more common. Moreover, combined with the fact that Kal-El was hardly used to refer to Clark otherwise, this caused many audience members to associate his Kryptonian name and identity with inconsiderate, rash, and “alien” behaviors. The show clearly insinuated that a version of Clark not hellbent on being “human” (metaphorically or literally) would be ruthlessly criminal and distant on his best day, a far cry from Clark’s actual behavior on Earth-1 (or Earth-2).
Blaming villains’ existence on the Kryptonians themselves was also common. Putting aside the fact that the aforementioned “freaks of the week” were actually Kryptonite-infected, the villains Brainiac and Doomsday were created by Kryptonians on Smallville. Brainiac was built by Jor-El to help win a civil war on Krypton before being corrupted by Zod and being used by Kara’s father Zor-El to destroy the planet [S7] . Zod also created Doomsday as a “son”/weapon with his wife Faora, as revealed in “Bloodline” [S8:E08]. On Earth-1 (again, the Silver and Bronze Age universe), Brainiac was first an alien, then a computer from the planet Colu, which helped secure the Kryptonians’ near-extinction by stealing Kandor for his collection. Kandor contained most of the people who believed Jor-El’s claim that the planet would explode and the space arks intended to be used to evacuate Kryptonians from the planet before its explosion [e.g., World of Krypton (1979) #2]. Doomsday was created for the Death of Superman arc in 1992, for the New Earth universe. He’s an ancient Kryptonian monster who managed to free himself from his prison and make his way to Metropolis, where he tore through the city until Superman fatally confronted him. Though the Superman mythos has since further complicated Brainiac (and has attempted to do so for Doomsday), it was and remains disturbing that clear bastions of Kryptonian suffering have since been used to blame them for their trauma and mass extinction.
The last point is simple and partially deduced from the previous paragraphs. All of the Kryptonians who were born and raised on the planet — besides Clark’s mother Lara’s clone, his cousin Kara (who is still repeatedly encouraged to try to “fit in,” which she understands as hiding), and his father’s former assistant trapped within the Phantom Zone — just about every Kryptonian present in the show is or becomes a villain. Zod and his clan, Aether, Nam-Ek, Zor-El, and Jor-El himself through the A.I. were just a handful of examples. Kryptonian artifacts like the aforementioned Brainiac, the Phantom Zone, and the crystals forming the Fortress are destructive either in themselves or because of human flaws (for which they still receive the blame). (Even the explosion of Clark’s rocket, caused by Clark in an attempt to circumvent Jor-El, led Martha to miscarry after it magically cured her infertility in the first place [S02:E23].)
In Smallville, there is very little from Krypton in this show that isn’t villainized, derided, or only valuable for how it could further the plot.
My Adventures with Superman (2023)
Somewhat like Smallville, My Adventures of Superman (2023), often abbreviated as “MAWS,” follows the life of a young adult Clark Kent in the first days of his being/becoming Superman. He’s a college student and Daily Planet intern who’s new to the Metropolis scene. Unlike Smallville, MAWS predicates the entirety of its Kryptonian lore and its second season on the concept of Krypton being a colonial empire. The planet Krypton was destroyed by Brainiac, who was once again an A.I. built for warmongering purposes, just on a galactic rather than planetary scale [S02:E10]. This time, Brainiac purposefully destroyed Krypton as punishment for abandoning their colonial and imperial tendencies, fearing that he would be deactivated and hating the betrayal of their ideals [again, S02:E10]. It’s confusing in a meta sense. Brainiac’s creation by the Kryptonians is clearly an attempt to victim-blame them for their own destruction, again as it was in Smallville, yet the justification was simply that they tried to repent and pursue peace. (Mind, the peace talks only occurred after the Kryptonians found a planet they couldn’t take over, which somewhat undermined the sincerity of their desire.) The Kryptonians were not even allowed the luxury of realizing their errors because Superman’s origin story requires that the planet explodes regardless of what they do. Once the fact of Brainiac’s nefarious purpose was established, he was simply the easiest way out. What better excuse than an A.I. programmed to cause destruction to deliver the lore’s greatest cataclysm, while simultaneously eroding the narrative opening for redemption?
MAWS is all the worse for using Kara — again, whose second comic backstory includes having been born on Krypton, witnessing the theft of Kandor, and surviving the explosion of Krypton herself — be Brainiac’s arm of destruction. Kara was brainwashed, yes, but without digressing, that seems to be a common trope which facilitates her distance from her cousin Kal by playing on (and ultimately demonizing) her trauma and loyalty to Krypton.
Superman (2025)
As with the previous entries, Superman (2025) is well-liked by audiences and critically acclaimed. It followed Superman over the course of one week, beginning after he lost a fight to a masked villain named the Hammer of Boravia, the fight being retribution for interfering with Boravia’s invasion of its neighboring country Jarhanpur. As the plot unfolded, the villain Lex Luthor stole and released a video of Jor-El and Lara Lor-Van, Superman’s Kryptonian parents, directing him to take over the planet Earth and form a harem of human women by which to resurrect Krypton. Superman was told to rule without mercy over these simple, confused beings who are weak in mind, body, and spirit. Humanity promptly abandoned Superman, and Luthor, took advantage of the opening to imprison and torture him as well as shoot another immigrant named Malik Ali. By the end of the movie, the reputational, relational, physical, and other ramifications of the video’s release are essentially resolved, with the exception of Superman’s view of his Kryptonian parents being utterly compromised.
Now, the movie’s lesson that a person can choose who they become regardless of outside pressure and should take personal responsibility for that is perfectly fine, even very necessary in this era where all kinds of violence and bigotry are increasingly common and encouraged. However, that lesson need not, should not, come at the expense of Superman’s immigrant narrative — which is only technically allegorical in the sense that aliens aren’t real — and is probably all the more useless for choosing to sacrifice that narrative. Superman being an immigrant (refugee) is intrinsic to his history and lore, bar none. Demonizing Superman’s home planet, its culture(s), and its people using xenophobic (and white supremacist) narratives of immigrants infiltrating the country to impose their laws, rape the women, and replace the white citizenry is doing a disservice to the character and, more importantly, to all of the fans and writers who are or were victims of these narratives in real-time — including his creators Jerry Siegel and Joe Schuster. In the same vein, having the xenophobic villain character be validated in his hatred by a message which confirmed his biases rather than using that as an opportunity to educate the audience on xenophobic propaganda was an extremely out-of-touch misstep on Gunn’s part, considering he went out of his way to market the movie as an immigrant narrative.
Portraying Superman as a victim of these xenophobic narratives — from being brutalized by the police, imprisoned without trial because he as an alien doesn’t have rights, slandered by the media, and distrusted by random citizens who loved him a moment ago, his teammates, and having Lex call him the wrong species on purpose — and then doing everything on a meta and grander narrative level to undermine what these scenes were meant to be criticizing before the scenes even occur is truly impressive. The message‘s content and the fact that it’s undoctored implicitly justified all of the treatment Superman received as a result by way of prejudiced confirmation bias, which is amplified in countries (such as the United States) in which pretenses to safety and “cultural cohesion” should erode immigrants’ civil and criminal rights. The hatred and fear of the other is cultivated in people specifically so that they do not question what governments do to those people, whether they are guilty of something or not. Gunn making the message true without criticism, and having just about every character not care about Superman’s well-being, very blatantly made this seem acceptable.
Moreover, the framing of the message and the response to it encouraged the negative judgment of Kryptonians as a group and thus motivated both Superman and the audience to want Superman’s distance from Krypton.
For one, the lack of other Kryptonians in the film, save for an inebriated Kara at the end, de facto made Jor-El and Lara the representation of all other (born-and-raised) Kryptonians, which in turn invited the rejection of Kryptonians as a species and culture(s). Some respondents, if this gains any real traction, may argue that that’s not the case; but it’s not really difficult to conceptualize that people who are part of minorities need diverse representation in order to avoid conveying unsavory messages about those minority groups. As it was, many audience members came out of the Superman movie either believing that it was good that Superman was raised on Earth and/or praising Gunn for not making Superman “too alien” by having him discard Jor-El and Lara’s message. In fact, the scene where he is comforted by Jor-El and Lara’s message is explicitly called back to at the end, where their message is replaced by videos of the salt-of-the-earth Kents. Considering that Superman had those videos the whole time, one must wonder why that was supposed to be significant if not for the fact it signaled a fundamental attitude shift — not toward the overt message of choosing who he is as a person (since Superman’s personality didn’t change, just his attribution for why) but toward being human. No longer will Superman be comforted by foreign videos with foreign videos and foreign people; he’ll fully embrace being human, complete with kindly old American farmers.
For two, none of the characters in the movie actually provided evidence that Superman was going to act on those directives before Superman was wrongfully attacked and imprisoned, yet all it took was for Lex Luthor to accuse Superman of grooming to further legitimize his mistreatment. This was an obvious attempt to compound the already diminished goodwill of the human (American) populace toward Superman, and it worked. In order to be distanced from the mental category of “Other” in people’s minds, Superman was forced to rescue the entire planet from Lex’s pocket universe malfunction while weak from Kryptonite torture and about 50 other things and then give a speech about how he was actually just like the humans. There was no real meditation in the film about how everyone’s (sans Lois, the Kents, and Terrific) treatment of Superman after the message was unethical and unjustified on multiple levels. Superman being victimized was wrong because he was a nice person who was “different” from the other “old world” Kryptonians, not just in general. In a time where immigrants are actively being targeted by multiple prominent administrations during a huge right-wing political shift, this was, at minimum, an egregious writing mistake.
I encourage people to go read @jesncin and @polytropic-liar ‘s posts on this for further elaboration.
Conclusion
When Superman’s immigrant narrative is neglected, villanized, or diminished — when there’s no pathos added by the loss of Krypton, his family, and culture — the result is just a guy with powers. A conspicuously American (for there is no true “neutral”), humanity-obsessed guy with powers. As was argued in an earlier section, this is a key function of the melting pot; to sterilize, homogenize, and erase cultures and differences in the pursuit of one “unified” culture. People are entitled to their preferences; but there is nothing interesting about a Superman who is disconnected from Krypton beyond the minimum expected by the backstory, and many writers thus far have been unable to avoid perpetuating extremely assimilationist narratives. So much of Superman’s previously established lore, which comes from Earth-1, functioned on the inclusion of Krypton and its vestiges eventually, in ways outside of the villainization or exclusion of the entire planet. Conscious choices to excise Krypton despise that result in, at best, extremely uninspired stories. More importantly, choosing to remove or demonize Krypton contradicts the Doylist purposes of making him an alien outside of explaining his powerset: to represent immigrants and to be a champion for the common, oppressed people. It’s not difficult to find that Clark bears a striking resemblance to his Jewish creators, who were second-generation immigrants themselves, or that Superman was created at the tail end of the Great Depression just prior to World War II, during which millions including 6 million Jewish people, would be murdered. Hiding his identity, personal history, and place of origin is a fundamental part of Superman’s lore. One could argue, for the most part, that Krypton itself as a concept was not important until the 1950s; but the expansion of that aspect of his lore has only ever increased the potency and longevity of the larger allegory, and the urge to remove, undermine, and villainize Krypton decades after that expansion, as I have demonstrated, is borne of xenophobic and assimilationist intent bar none.
I will clarify here: the portrayal of Kryptonians as unabashedly evil, colonial, draconic, and what else would be xenophobic and assimilationist even if almost everything presented in this argument was untrue or unsupported. The first goal of the essay was merely to prove that the stark contrast between the Kryptonians of Earth-1 and the Kryptonians of later renditions provides undeniable evidence, if not absolute proof, that the “evil” depictions were xenophobic in intention or heritage. The second goal was to explain how and why these depictions are (or come off as) assimilationist and xenophobic using direct textual evidence as opposed to word-of-mouth accusations. The third and final goal was to convey how deeply embedded these tendencies have been in Superman media and express that Superman’s immigrant identity is essential to his character. Writers have to decide what to do with it; but ignorance to the nuances of immigrants’ lives or plights isn’t absolution for missteps, and blatant jingoism simply shouldn’t be tolerated.
Here are some simple questions you can ask in an interview when they ask you "So do you have any questions?" (Hint: Always ask a question)
Why is this position open? (Lets you know if the work environment is toxic bc the last person quit cuz they couldn't take it anymore. It's open because the workload increased/the company grew is a good sign--not only are they successful, but they hire new people instead of just working their current employees to death.)
What are the primary goals/measurements of success for this position? Ie, what you have to do to get a "good job/thumbs up, you're doing your job. (Lets you cut to the core of what the job actually is for your own information and demonstrates you're interested in doing a good job.)
What do you think will be the hardest part of the job? and/or What do you think are the most essential skills to have for this position? (Gives you a chance to follow up with saying how you have those skills/are good at the hard part/are prepared to do a good job/are well suited for the challenge.)
What do you (the interviewer) like and dislike about working here? (Gives you more insight into the working environment, gives them a chance to be introspective, gives you a chance to follow up with saying why you think you're a good fit for the working environment.
Very last/if you don't have any other questions: Do you think there's anything else I should know? and When can I expect to hear back from you? (leads into the natural conclusion by discussing timetables and the next steps of the interview process.)
Bonus: If there's anything you think is particularly cool about the work there, especially if it's something you went to school for, let your enthusiasm bleed through a little bit and/or ask more questions about the technical stuff, it will probably win you points. If you can fake it that might work too.
the backstory for why i draw indo food in so much detail is cuz i got mad at a white author for doing less than the bare minimum when depicting asian food in their graphic novel. i took that personally and held a grudge ever since
stay safe @alternative-alan - Tumblr Blog | Tumgag