Tightrope - Chapter 2 (Arthur Morgan x Reader)
Note: Tumblr doesnât show posts that have links now?? weird. Anyway the first chapter to this is in the masterlist in my bio so check that out!
Arthur woke up on his cot, letting out a small groan. He tried to open his eyes more, urging them to adjust to the light that was being let in through the opening of the tent. He sat up slowly, lifting his arms up and stretching his back. The man sat still for a few moments, running through the plans of the day in his head: âfind the girl, bring her back, make sure nothing bad happens to her, return her safely.â
Arthur nodded to no one but himself and pushed himself up from his cot, standing up. He knew what he had to do today, and a part of him was reluctant to do it, but another part of him knew that Hosea and Dutch were right. The longer you knew about the gang and their plans, the more threatened they were. Arthur wasnât sure what Dutch planned to do with you when you arrived at the camp, but he had a feeling that it wouldnât be so pretty.
He picked up the jacket from the side of his cot and threw it over his shoulders, then headed out of his tent. His first stop was a cup of coffee. He walked over to the steaming pot and took out a small cup from his satchel, filling it with hot coffee, before walking off to find Hosea. Arthur knee that after your meeting with him yesterday, and the aggressive nature of it, you most likely wouldnât agree to come to the camp so easily, and Arthur didnât want to use force. He thought that having Hosea there would offer some sort of reassurance, as the elder man seemed harmless. Of course, Arthur and the gang knew otherwise, but it wouldnât hurt if you didnât.
Arthur found Hosea in Dutchâs tent, and Hosea gave Arthur a smile as he approached, âAre you ready to leave, boy?â
The brunette nodded, âIâm ready when you are.â He watched Hosea mumble something quietly to Dutch and then stand up from his seat. Arthur furrowed his eyebrows at this, but didnât care to ask too many questions. Business between Hosea and Dutch wasnât his main priority, it was finding you. Hosea approached Arthur and gave him a curt nod.
The pair began walking towards their horses, but were stopped when they heard Dutch call from across the camp, âRemember, I want her alive!â Arthur shook his head at this, not once had killing you crossed his mind. He knew you were just an innocent girl who happened to get caught up in Trelawnyâs antics in the saloon. He knew better than to kill you.
Arthur approached his horse, Boudicca, and gave her a pat, pulling an apple from his satchel and feeding it to her. He pulled himself up onto her saddle, patting her again. She was a large horse, but she had speed, and Arthur had never grown more attached to a horse in his lifetime. Some lasted a matter of days with the gang, some lasted months. But Boudicca? She had been with Arthur for years, through thick and thin.
Hosea looked over at Arthur, who gave him a subtle nod, and the two began their ride into Blackwater. Hosea was up front, and shouted behind him to Arthur, âAny idea where we can find her? The town is fairly big, I donât want to be out all day, and I suppose you donât either.â
Arthur thought for a few moments, then shouted back, âShe was in the saloon yesterday. We should try there first. If we ainât finding her right away, ask for a girl named (Y/N).â The rest of the ride to Blackwater was quiet, with only Hosea making small comments here and there, and Arthur grunting in agreement. He wasnât so up for chatting this morning, just as he wasnât up for bringing you back to camp. But what was he supposed to do? Tell Dutch no? Never.
Eventually, they came to stop in front of the saloon in Blackwater, and the two of them dismounted quickly. Hosea turned to Arthur, âSo, whatâs the plan, my boy? You met her yesterday so Iâm assuming sheâll know your face when she sees it.â
Arthur frowned, âI wouldnât exactly say we met, Hosea. More like I threatened her about what she knew and left her scared. I say we go in, ask around and if she ainât there we tell Dutch sheâs no where to be seen.â
Hosea understood Arthurâs reluctance to find you. Heâd seen what Dutch had done to others who had found out about the gang, who had threatened their plans. Maybe this time would be different, you were, after all, just an innocent young woman who had gotten caught up in the wrong moment with Trelawny. Hosea nodded, âSounds like a plan, letâs get in there.â
The two walked up the steps slowly and Arthur pushed open the doors of the saloon, holding them just long enough for Hosea to walk in after him. His eyes scanned the room, looking for a (H/C) woman, which he figured wouldnât be too hard to find as yesterday you seemed to be the only woman in there. He sighed to himself when he caught no sight of you, and began to approach two men sat at a table, drinks in hand. He cleared his throat, ââscuse me gentlemen, you havenât seen a girl, (H/C) hair around this height.â He used his hand to gesture your height.
The men turned to each other, then laughed loudly, doubling over as they did. One of them caught their breath, then spoke, âWhat would a man like you want with a woman like her?â
Arthur furrowed his eyebrows and crossed his arms, âCan you fellers just tell me where she is? Or if she even came in here?â Arthur was growing impatient, he didnât care about who liked or disliked you, he only cared about finding you and taking you back to Dutch. Securing the safety of the gang was all that mattered to him.
The other man shrugged and pointed over to the bar, âProbably over there, waiting for trouble. Or causing it. Always seems to find her.â Arthur thanked the man quietly, thinking over his words carefully. He wasnât sure whether to trust the manâs word, but maybe you actually werenât as innocent as you seemed?
Arthur didnât pay much more attention to what he had heard as he started walking over to the bar at the back of the saloon. He realised as he approached that you were there, stood between a group of men. He furrowed his eyebrows as he neared, trying his best to be as quiet as possible so he could listen in on exactly what the man were saying to you.
One of them leaned towards you, his hand on your thigh, and whispered, âThe things I would do to youâŠ.â Arthur saw you visibly tense up, and he knew that he couldnât just leave you there with the strange men. He had to intervene.
Arthur approached them and grabbed one of them by the collar, pulling them backwards until they lost their footing and fell on the ground. His voice was gruff and deep as he shouted, âWhat the HELL do you think youâre doinâ? â
Another man that had been surrounding you turned to Arthur, âWhat does it look like?â
Arthur chuckled and stepped towards you and the other men, âYou better step away from the girl, gentlemen.â Arthur noticed that throughout this whole ordeal, you had not turned to face him once. Even though he was saving you, his best bet was that you were scared of him, after all, he did threaten you the day before.
The man who Arthur had thrown to the floor had stood up, and was suddenly as confident as ever against the outlaw, and he spoke in a loud and clear voice, âOr what?â
Arthur didnât hesitate to pull his guns out, one aimed at the man stood behind him, and one aimed at the men surrounding you. Gasps could be heard from all around the saloon, but Arthur didnât care. âOrâŠ.iâll shoot ya.â He growled, cocking his guns. The men all moved away from you slowly, and Arthur shouted at them as they did, âMove! Get outta here!â
In all the commotion, Arthur didnât notice that you had slipped away from him, out of the back door of the saloon. You walked quickly around the backstreets, trying your best to remove yourself from the scene, and distance yourself from the man you knew only as Mr Morgan as much as you could. Little did you know, he was following right behind you, keeping up with you as you manoeuvred through the mud.
You heard someone clear their throat from behind you, and you froze up. Then, you heard his voice, âI just saved your skin and I donât even get a thank you for that?â You turned and saw Mr Morgan stood with his hands clutching his belt, a smirk on his features.
You took a shaky breath, âThank you, Mr Morgan.â The two of you stood in silence for a few seconds more until you spoke quickly and panicked, âI havenât told a soul, I swear.â You remembered his threat. You knew he wasnât someone youâd want to pick a fight with. You definitely hadnât told anyone, so why was he back looking for you?
Arthur sighed, âLook, I know just as well as you that you ainât told a soul about the robbery, but the rest of the gang ainât too sure. They just want you to come back to the camp so they can have a few words with ya and then theyâll let you go. Sound alright?â
You shook your head quickly. No. Definitely not. That did not sound alright to you. It was one thing to have an interest in gangs and outlaws, and to like hearing about their stories, but it was another to actually be face to face with a real life gang of outlaws. You knew that you were damned when you started pressing Trelawny with questions yesterday, but you couldnât help yourself. You just had to know.
You turned your back and began walking away quickly, leading Arthur to sigh and mumble under his breath. âI really didnât want it to come to thisâŠ.â He ran up beside you and swept you off the ground, throwing you over his shoulder as gently as he could. He cringed as you struggled against him, pushing against his back and shoulders in an attempt to free yourself from his grip, but after a minute you stopped the struggle, giving into him. Arthur walked round to the front of the saloon where he met Hosea.
Hosea raised his eyebrows and chuckled at Arthur Morgan, stood in front of him with a girl on his shoulder. He spoke calmly, âI see it took a lot of convincing.â
Rolling his eyes, he put you down on the floor in front of his horse and you huffed, shoving hair out of your face, âI guess I have no choice now?â Your eyes were narrowed at him, and your arms were crossed. The last thing you wanted to do was visit his gang, but what else could you do? A total stranger knew about their plans, and they most certainly werenât willing to take your word for it when you said you didnât tell anyone, as Arthur had demonstrated when he threw you over his shoulder so abruptly.
He sighed and spoke quietly, âLook, I donât wanna bring you to camp as much as you donât wanna be there. So really, weâre both sufferinâ. If that makes you feel any better.â He mounted his horse and offered you his hand to pull you up, which you reluctantly took.
You werenât sure how you felt about Mr Morgan. He had saved you from a group of creepy one minute, and the next he had thrown you over his shoulder and was planning on kidnapping you for the rest of the day. He certainly did give off mixed signals, and you werenât sure whether you liked him or not.
The two men rode back to camp quickly, you werenât sure why they were in such a hurry to get you back there, and on the journey there your mind wandered to what they could possibly plan on doing to you. Would they torture you? Kill you? You werenât so sure, and the two men escorting you there hadnât been much of a help, the silver haired man only gave brief answers, and Mr Morgan flat out ignored you.
The ride only took around 10 minutes or so. You would have expected their camp to be further away from the town, but what did you know about gangs and outlaws? Arthur pulled his horse into some trees, that then revealed a small clearing. You saw tents lined up at the side of the camp, people chatting to each other and wagons that probably held supplies scattered around. You gave a small smile. It was nice here, you liked the openness and had often wished for a life like this in your dreams.
Arthur hitched his horse up and pulled you off, setting you on the ground. He looked over at the silver haired man and spoke quietly, âTell Dutch sheâs here.â Hosea nodded and walked into the camp and towards a large tent where a man with slick back hair and narrowed eyes stood. He whispered something to who you assumed was Dutch van der Linde, and Dutch smirked, his eyes landing on you. You bit your lip, you still werenât sure what his motives were, and now you were feeling the fear.
Arthur put his hand on your shoulder, and you looked up at him, but he didnât look back. Arthur understood that first meetings with Dutch could be scary, and he wanted a way to reassure you that everything would be fine. And somehow, it did. Arthur led you over to Dutch, his hand now on your back. He nodded at Dutch, then spoke, âWe got her.â
Dutch gave a loud chuckle, âIndeed you did. Dutch van der Linde.â He extended his hand for you to shake it, and you did, introducing yourself alongside the gesture.
Dutch gave you a smile, which you could tell was fake and spoke, âI assume there wasnât too many troubles with you coming to camp? Everything went smoothly?â
You nodded, âYeah, I had no problem at all.â You heard Arthur give a small laugh from behind you, his mind wandering back to images of you rushing out of the saloon, being thrown over his shoulder, forced to come here. But, he would only allow you, Hosea and himself to know that, to spare any trouble with Dutch.
Dutch grinned, and put his hand on your back, âGood.â His hand on your back didnât have the same effect that Arthurâs did. You felt a threatening presence, a feeling that you could be hurt. You didnât like it, but you let him lead you over to his tent anyway, refusing to object. He sat you down on a seat, then mumbled to Arthur, âFetch the boys.â You tensed up at this, wondering what they were going to do with you. Dutch must have noticed and he chuckled, âDonât worry Miss (L/N), we just want to talk.â
Before you knew it, you were surrounded by six men, two of them you knew, one you recognised. Dutch went round the group, introducing the men, âLenny Summers, Micah Bell, John Marston, Hosea Matthews. And of course, you know out Arthur Morgan here. Gentlemen, this is (Y/F/N).â The men introduced as Lenny and Hosea nodded at you, a kind, sympathetic smile on their lips. John didnât do anything, and Micah just scowled at you.
Arthur sighed and stepped forward a little, âWhat exactly is she doinâ here, Dutch? Sheâs innocent, Trelawny should have never opened his mouth to her.â Arthur didnât know why, but he felt the need to stand up for you. It wasnât your fault that Trelawny talked, and it wasnât your placed to be wrapped up in this business. He couldnât go against Dutch, but he could sure as hell make sure nothing happened to you.
Dutch sighed, âArthur, have a little faith in my motives. I was hoping that she could tell us what Trelawny said, and if she knows anything about the ferry.â All eyes were on you, and youâd never felt more threatened.
You cleared your throat, and spoke quietly, but just loud enough for everyone to hear, âHe just told me you were planning on robbing the ferry. I donât know much about the ferry but I know that itâs carrying money, a lot of it, from New York. The townâs been advised to stay inside on the night it arrives to avoid any danger with the law. Apparently men from all around West Elizabeth are coming to guard the ferry and the town.â
John sighed, âDonât tell me youâre still planninâ on robbinâ this ferry after what the girlâs just told us.â
The man introduced as Micah, who hadnât given you the warmest welcome, snarled at John, âShut it, Marston. Weâve got it under control.â
John was just about to square up to Micah, but Dutch interrupted them, âGentlemen, now is not the time for fighting. Weâre going to rob this ferry, that I can assure you of. What Miss (L/N) has given us is nothing but valuable information. I have a plan, donât you worry.â
Arthur shook his head and stood forward, speaking to Dutch directly, âThis is crazy. And you know it. You canât rob that ferry with half of West Elizabeth out on the streets!â
Dutch raised his eyebrows at Arthur, âYouâre still set on not helping us, I see.â
Arthur sighed, âDutch, me and Hosea have a score. A patch of cheap, good land that weâre so close to gettingâ a good deal on. We could buy it, call it our own. Live normal lives.â You looked up at Arthur as he spoke, and you could tell thatâs what he really wanted, more than anything. But then, you looked back at Dutch, and you could see his distaste for the idea of not living as outlaws.
Dutch shook his head, âDo what you must. We ARE robbing this ferry, gentlemen. Thatâs final. I have a plan, and I hope you trust me enough for it to execute properly.â Dutch looked over to you, âNow, Miss (L/N), do we have to keep you at camp until the ferry job is over, or are you a willing to be a participant in this job?â
Arthur scoffed, âWhy would she have to stay here with us?â You were just as confused as Arthur, but you thought you would wait until Dutch explained his motives to make a decision.
Dutch chuckled, âHave you completely lost your head, Arthur? She could tell anyone about our plans if we just let her go! So, Iâm willing to offer her an ultimatum. You can either stay here for a week until the job is over, or Iâll let you go back to your father if you agree to help us.â
You bit your lip. You knew that if you stayed here with the gang, your father would be looking for you, and he would bring a gang of people if it meant getting you back. But you also werenât keen on being involved with the plans. You sighed, having made your mind up, âWhat kind of help do you need, Mr van der Linde?â
Arthur was about to speak out in protest but Dutch raised his hand, silencing him, âWhatever you can offer us will be more than fine.â
You bit your lip and smiled a little, âIâm quite the actress.â You had taken lessons in the dramatics when you were only a few years younger, hence why you could work your way around anyone in the saloon in Blackwater.
Dutch smirked at your proposition, and you spoke about a plan. You were to distract the guards however you liked while Dutch and the gang snuck onto the ferry, and then you were free to go. Unless things went south, then Dutch would use you to get away from law enforcements. You werenât too keen on the second part of the plan, but you had no choice but to agree.
Dutch smiled at you, âYouâre free to go, Miss (L/N. Arthur, do you mind riding her home?â
Arthur sighed, nodding at Dutch. He had hoped that Dutch would have asked him that before the two of you devised a plan. You stood up, and he put his hand on your shoulder, leading you to his horse. He lifted you up quickly, then pulled himself up onto the horse. He rode out of camp slowly, then picked up the pace a little, causing you to hesitantly wrap your arms around his waist to steady yourself. You felt him tense under your grip, and you bit your lip.
After a minute of silence, Arthur spoke, âYa donât have to help with the plan if ya donât want to, Miss. Donât let Dutch talk ya into something. Thatâs what heâs good at.â
You bit your lip and thought over Arthurâs words, then answered him quietly, âItâs okay. I wanna help. Iâm fed up of my boring life, a little excitement would do be nice. Plus, I think I owe you and your gang, and why not put my skills to use? I ainât gonna use them anywhere else.â
Arthur shook his head, âNah. You donât owe us. Trelawny owes us, Dutch just likes to involve anyone he can in his plans. I just donât want you wrapped up in this.â Arthur felt the need to protect you, just as he often felt the need to protect innocent people, protect their freedom.
You furrowed your eyebrows, âWhy do you care so much whether I help your gang or not?â
He bit his lip, and after a minute he responded to your question, âLook, if you get caught up with gang business, youâre stuck with us. There ainât no gettingâ out of this life until people get fed up of chasinâ you, and trust me, they hardly ever get fed up of chasinâ. I just donât want you giving up your life now to run from the law.â Arthur came to a stop just outside of Blackwater and waited for you to get off of the horse, which you did.
You bit your lip, âIâll be fine, Mr Morgan. Iâm willing to give everything up for this. Iâve already agreed to this. I canât back out now, but I appreciate the concern.â You offered him a small smile, and then turned away and began walking towards the town.
He sighed, watching you walk away, and shouted after you, âIâll see you soon!â
You just turned and gave him a small wave, then continued walking away from him. You knew exactly what you had gotten yourself into, and you couldnât decide whether you regretted it or not. Were you really willing to give up your life now for people you hardly knew? A life of crime? Maybe.
Arthur dismounted his horse at camp and almost immediately his name was called by Hosea from the small bench in the middle of camp. He sighed and patted his horse, then walked over to Hosea and sat down next to him. âWhat do you want?â
Hosea chuckled, âAlways nice to see you, Arthur. Iâve managed to get a meeting with the landowner about the land weâre thinking about buying in two days. Go out, buy yourself some nice clothes. You need to look the part Mr Swinton.â
Arthur groaned, âYer getting me to act again? You know I donât like that, Hosea.â The last time Hosea had Arthur acting resulted in a shootout, which Arthur didnât appreciate.
Hosea shrugged, âWell, if we want a chance to buy this land we need you to look less like a tough, brash outlaw and more like a fancy upper class man. Remember to buy some clothes.â Arthur sighed and stood up, walking over to his tent.
He sat down on his cot and pulled out his journal, writing an extract next to a small picture of a you and Dutch:
âDutch made me bring the girl to camp and somehow managed to get her to agree to help with ferry job. Not sure whether Iâm okay with that, but I donât wanna question Dutch. He seems to know what heâs doing more than the rest of us. Just hope everything turns out alright. She hasnât done anything wrong.â
Tags (let me know if you wanna be tagged in future uploads!):
@0dobi0 @sylviassaloon (ps iâve probably been so annoying with tags but iâve had to take it down and reupload so so many times!)