SO true. I was 100% all about a friend companion, and that was always going to be Nick (still is!) but I was so surprised, my plan was my SS was not going to have a romantic relationship at all after what happened to her husband and the hunt for a baby. I get quite invested in my characters, and I just didn't think a Mother searching for her child would even be able to consider finding love in this horrific new world she's woken up in.
She wakes up, a woman out of time, husband dead, baby gone; she's a lawyer and a new mother, for goodness sakes! She has to literally crawl out through the fallout, somehow survive the commonwealth with the sheer determination of a parent who has lost her child, which is why my OC looks visibly battle scarred as the game has gone on - I wanted her to look like someone who had suffered and fought and crawled and gritted her teeth to survive in a literal hellscape.
She meets Preston, a rare, decent person in this new world, and a gang of misfit survivors and helps them and they set up some kind of community in Sanctuary. Then on to Diamond City, and she rescues Nick Valentine who becomes her first closest friend, synth, a man wit false memories as lost in time as she is.
They end up in Goodneighbour to visit Dr Amari, and out comes Mayor Hancock, dealing out brutal punishments to those who deserve it - but after doing some work for him, he realises he's become too comfortable in his position in Goodneighbour and wants to get out and see the world, seeing the real struggle. As time goes on, Hancock reveals that he's questioning his authority and whether he's really doing the right thing or turning into a tyrant like Goodneighbour's previous mayor, Vic. He becomes vulnerable, and ends up opening up about his childhood as John McDonough and his brother, his kindness to the exiles from Diamond City and how Mayor Hancock his just his mask, and really he's consumed with self doubt.
The common theme with a lot of the Fallout companions is that they're all "out of time" and misfit, drifting or carving out a life filled with rage and doubt.
BAM. Hancock is just Hancock, not Mayor John Hancock, but just a man in a mask, lost and lonely and trying to do good, like the SS herself. Despite her focus on finding her lost baby, she manages to make friends, allies, enemies - but also love.
I didn't expect to identify and sympathise with his character as much as I thought, and ended up really loving him because, like Nick, he has vulnerabilities but is trying to do good in a bad world.
Even though the main storyline can almost be a disappointment, I don't think the connections the SS makes with her (or his) friends or companions are. I genuinely think the story is more about the SS making a life in a new world despite losing everything she's ever known or loved.
Come on love, let's get this freak show on the road.