I came to you
Lord, because of
the fucking reticence
of this world
no, not the world, not reticence, oh
Lord Come
Lord Come
We were sad on the ground
Lord Come
We were sad on the ground.
Thatâs Jean Valentine for you, in all her pithiness, a sublime accrual of minimalism, the poem amplifying the deafening silence â etymologically derived from the Latin reticentia "silence, a keeping silent"; Â however, we are not here to establish how a myriad-mouthed curiosity of a seemingly simple word snowballed into a critique of one of the most poignant films Iâve watched lately.Â
And yet Thomas Stuberâs film âIn the Aislesâ (In den GĂ€ngen), takes a cue from the word âreticenceâ and subverts it with muted panache. I will not give anything away, as far as the plot goes, the screenplay is adapted by a short story from Clemens Meyer, but one must exalt, applaud Peter Matjaskoâs cinematography and Stuberâs vision to paint us a film, rooted in German romanticism and philosophically laced with a quiet stoicism. Stuber choreographs his film mostly away from the ârepoussoirâ and towards the âRĂŒckenfigurâ figure, emblematic of Caspar David Friedrich, giving the viewers a proxy view. Stuberâs cinematic idiom is one of subtlety and restraint, where intimacies are built around blue-collared workers working with forklifts; not with the pace of an anticipated frenetic brushstroke but a languid waltz, a Chopin nocturne at an andante tempo. Matjaskoâs camera lingers coquettishly on HĂŒller and Rogowski; vignettes provisionally captured that brings wider allusions to play; a semi-erotic languorous seduction with a nod to Wang Kar Wai in its affinity for transience and elegant, ruptured passion felt, but not consummated. The diegetic sound of the forklifts frolicking on the shopfloor, to be interrupted by Suite No. 3 in D by Bach is a touch of brilliance.Â
The reticence, the silence is representative of a larger societal malaise and while each workerâs individual strife is salient, even cruel, the film offers redemption and hope by way of a tender camaraderie, little acts of kindnesses; a collective celebration of the human spirit. Multiple motifs ricochet between scenes to highlight a collegial tenderness, that shimmers, then builds to a crescendo, where the dappled translucence gives way to a solemn covenant between people. One scene, in particular, is poignant, where on Christmas Eve, all the workers are feasting on expired sausages and beer, a surreptitious gift stolen from the dust bins: a secret shared by all the workers as kin, as family united by their hunger, and their gratitude for small mercies. I had tears in my eyes at the profundity of that one scene.                               *** âEverything conspires to make us forget the socially constructed, and hence arbitrary and artificial, character of investment in the economic game and its stakes: the ultimate reasons for commitment to work, a career or the pursuit of profit in fact lie beyond or outside calculation and calculating reason in the obscure depths of a historically constituted habitus, which means that, in normal circumstances, one gets up every day to go to work without deliberating on the issue, as indeed one did yesterday and will do tomorrow.â â Pierre Bourdieu Another significantly important prism to deconstruct the film, with reasonable temerity would be a brief social commentary invoking Bourdieuâs cultural capital in three forms: embodied, objectified, and institutionalised. The anxiety, the permanent stress of insecurity and uncertainty is visible, albeit in a concealed manner, where the precariousness of the workerâs situation reflects in the fastidiousness with which they go about their jobs; the lather-rinse-repeatedness of their 15-minutes break to alleviate the tedium of their mundane jobs. Mastering the forklift becomes both a credible threat, and acquired competence for Rogowski. The entire squad waits with bated breath, as he clears his test and acquires his forklift licence, the crowd bursting into a rapturous applause on successful completion. Immensely moved by the film, I came away thinking of another poem by Komunyakaa:
My father could only sign His name, but he'd look at blueprints & say how many bricks Formed each wall. This man, Who stole roses & hyacinth For his yard, would stand there With eyes closed & fists balled, Labouring over a simple word, almost Redeemed by what he tried to say.









