I stumble across this Brecker album in my library from time to time, and I always find myself wondering why it's been so long. Numerous features, both musical and extra-musical, combine to make this a stunning album. For one, it's Brecker's last; he died shortly thereafter of a bone disease. Further, the "sidemen" are giants in their own right: Metheny, Mehldau, DeJohnette, Hancock, and Patitucci. The compositions are incredibly infectious, and there's a lot of technique on display.
However what I love most about Pilgrimage is that it pairs musicians who don't normally play together, and as a result everyone's playing is elevated to a level that it doesn't necessarily reach in each musicians' respective personal projects. There's a long precedent for albums like this in the jazz canon; for example, much of the Blue Note discography features incidental collaboration of several musicians who likely had not played together before. Still, there's some special essence in Pilgrimage that sets it in it's own class. Maybe it's Brad Mehldau's shifty piano solo on "Tumbleweed," with right hand and left hand melodies weaving in and out of a crazy two hand rhythmic pattern. It's the kind of solo Brad would never play with Larry Grenadier and Jeff Ballard (although, I guess it was Jorge Rossy at this point).
I'd like to believe that this diversity comes from the musicians' different backgrounds. Though Brecker obviously demonstrates that he can destroy a more straight-ahead setting, he's evidently a product of the jazz/funk/rock scene. Mehldau has his own curious path through the Young Lions like Joshua Redman. Patitucci's background is admittedly unknown to me (I suppose I'll have to do further research), but DeJohnette brings his experience with Jarret and his various fusion forays to the table. Then, of course, there's Metheny's flirtations with minimalism. All of the these elements mix in a very appealing way on Pilgrimage.













