four — a long analysis on Alexander and Eliza in Hamilton: The Musical
Alexander Hamilton's character is so complex. There's never really knowing what it will take for him to finally reach a level of content; of relaxation and security regarding his place in the world, and yet it's understandable. His hunger for doing something significant in the world had been one of the main concepts in the musical— it wouldn't be a stretch to say it isn't too far from the truth either. It's easy to over-complicate it and say he needs to take a chill pill. And yet, it's understandable.
He's spent majority of his childhood thinking all there was to his life was getting through each day, barely hanging onto the skin of his teeth. Going through so much devastation at such a young age leaves indefinite scars on people. Alexander went through a whole lot of it, to the point where his *self-preservation has completely disintegrated. Those experiences of his became a huge factor as to why his perception of himself and his value has been reduced to nothing. He wasn't capable of losing anything else anymore, so what was there to keep going for?
Until his second chance at having a life worth of something appears; he's given the chance to start anew in New York, and he aims to do exactly just that, which he actually did. His mind helped him get there. If it weren't for his intellect and brilliance, he would have spent the rest of his life thinking he would never **live past the age of twenty. Of course it's only natural that he relies on it a little too much— to an extremely unhealthy extent (or as Eliza had said, it became an obsession).
And then enters Eliza, the woman who Understands™. There's always been a little distinction between her and Angelica in terms of how Alexander attracted them, I guess. Angelica loved Alexander for his mind, while Eliza loved Alexander despite his mind. The difference is little, but the impact is massive.
Still, the part of Alexander that is unknowable remains unknowable. No one really understands this at first, and for one too many times he's been told to take a break by the people around him, Eliza as well. For everyone else, Alexander is a force to be reckoned with, fueled by his hunger to die being something, to be while he hasn't died yet. No one completely grasps what goes on in Alexander's mind. Everyone else has stopped trying to find out and carried on with their lives after some time.
Save for Eliza. She stops trying to figure out why Alexander is the way he is, instead she starts accepting the fact that she will never understand that part of him that yearns for so much. The first two pictures completely capture this certain aspect of their relationship.
And it just gets me each time. Those lines. It perfectly captures how Alexander will always have that desire inside of him, and Eliza understands that she will never understand how it feels— Which brings me back to what I said earlier: Eliza chose to love Alexander despite of his mind.
The three pictures that follow are a couple more references to Alexander's hunger. There's Eliza in That Would be Enough who acknowledges Alexander's complexity, and subtly resigns to the fact that she will always come second to this massive part of him. It sucks. It's completely different to the kind of love everyone has come to know. It wasn't supposed to be this powerless. It was supposed to conquer and all that. Then again, love comes in different forms for different people. It just so happened that this was how Alexander loved Eliza: by giving her the parts of him that he's grown to love and be confident about, strictly keeping the shameful pieces hidden until he's proven them worthy to be seen. Completely blinded by making himself worthy to the point that the idea of someone loving him despite the imperfections sounds so impossible— And this was how Eliza loved Alexander.
Then comes Angelica in Burn, who knows Alexander will never be satisfied with just being, in that time period. This makes her a lot more careful than Eliza, and it makes sense because Eliza married Alexander, not Angelica. She probably could have been in too deep, but she didn't. Judging by her character, she would have drawn the line where it's necessary. A far cry to Eliza's forgiving and understanding nature.
The last goes back to Eliza (still during Burn). And even with everything that Alexander has done up to that point, she doesn't sneer and spit venom at his "obsession," she only says these words from a place of hurt. Sure, no one really knows how she felt at that time, nor will we ever find out, but the musical version of their characters turned out like this. And it's just so freaking amazing.
I'm done geeking out. Do what you will with this, if you ever read it up until the end.
*Self-preservation refers to Alexander's line about Aaron Burr in Ten Things, One Thing: “I never had his instinct for self-preservation.”
**Live past the age of twenty in My Shot: “See, I never thought I’d live past twenty.”