There was definitely some miscommunication happening here, and the problem was that Marlene wasn’t sure just how far it went. There was still the question of this earlier conversation that Atticus seemed to remember having with them that Marlene had absolutely no recollection of… but it was hardly his problem if they’d been getting so drunk lately that they couldn’t even keep their encounters straight… It was just more of the same escapism that had driven him away in the first place… and bringing that up now certainly wasn’t going to do either of them any favors. The larger frustration at the moment was that Atticus seemed to be misinterpreting their offer as some kind of demand for reciprocation when it was nothing of the sort. But they could hardly blame him for that… he had a lot on his plate recently, which had been the whole point of their offer in the first place. After all, he’d been one of the first people Marlene had thought of upon hearing the news, even in the slurred drunken state they’d been in at the time.
Maybe that was part of the whole problem- they kept letting themself reach out to him when they were not exactly in a fit state to do so, and then they wondered why they weren’t being properly understood… why he would be confused about their intentions, when they did nothing but jump from one extreme to another… This wasn’t fair to either of them, but more than their own pain this time Marlene felt the guilt weighing down on them at having let it get so bad… While they’d been fooling around with Atticus, they’d somehow let themself shift into a form they didn’t like very much- one that was utterly dependent in their vulnerability, whose grief demanded too much attention. They hadn’t seen it before it was all too late, but it was honestly what they’d always feared they’d become since the fire. They felt that sorrow down to their bones like a bruise.
Sighing softly, Marlene slid into a barstool beside him without being invited, perched on the edge of the seat so as to make a quick escape if it became clear they weren’t welcome there. They just felt so tired suddenly, and the pain was beginning to get to them, the spike of anxiety that they couldn’t quite chase down making them feel on edge, pulling all of their muscles taut to attention. But they didn’t say anything about that, determined as they were to focus on Atticus for now and sort out their own problems later… They put a soft hand on his shoulder as his mind processed this new realization, much different from their usual touch which they supposed was too heavy for him… this was a light, encouraging thing, with a touch of comfort but also a calmness Marlene didn’t exactly feel, themself… It was a fleeting thing, just a small press of their warm hand, and then it was gone again and they put their hands in their lap.
“And I’m not trying to put any extra burden on you,” they elaborated, trying to make him see their offer for what it was- a resource if he ever came to need it, and specifically not something he should worry about. “I know you’re under an enormous amount of pressure, and that’s not fair at all, Atticus. It shouldn’t all be on you. I know there’s not a lot I can do, I’m not in the same position as you… I can’t help you fight that battle… I’ve never been much of a fighter, anyway… But I do want to help… you know there’s more I can do for you than provide an escape.” He’d been to their flat, after all, and would have crossed through the shop below to get there. He knew about their capabilities, and they hoped he’d come to trust them at least in some small way.
“I think I’ve learned by now not to expect things from you that you can’t provide, and honestly I’ll be fine on my own, I’ve taken care of myself for this long haven’t I? …Anyway, what I’m saying is… you don’t have to act on this now. I’m not asking you to let me help right this second… I’m saying if you ever need me, you know where to find me, okay? And that I can put my own shit aside if it means helping you… I know that must be hard to believe but… I just want to to know you have somewhere to go if you need it. You have someone else who gives a shit about what you’re going through so just… don’t hesitate to ask me if you need something… That’s all.”
Marlene realized they should have gotten up them and left him in peace, but there was something about this situation that reminded them so much of when they’d met that they found it hard to leave. Still, they were prepared to do so if it became clear that they were just making him uncomfortable with their continued presence.
He had the urge to tense under their light touch, but he kept himself from doing so. Part of it was that he didn’t think that he could handle dealing with more on top of all of his own shite, without making a fatal mistake, but a bigger part of him didn’t think that Marlene should actually be trying to help other people as much as they were offering just now. Even though when he had met Marlene had had made it perfectly clear that all he wanted was something physical, they had given him more anyway, which he had realized was just what they were like, unable to let things seep over no matter how hard they tried. It wasn’t a fault, in fact, he admired their vulnerability, wished that he had grown up with more of that being encouraged than he had, but it also just showed him that there was so much that Marlene needed to deal with themself before they could have something verging on a normal friendship. They needed to take the time to deal with their own things, before trying to fix other people’s problems.
Maybe it was just another form of escapism. It would’ve made sense, all things considered. And it would’ve been hard for Marlene to see it like that themself. But maybe somewhere deep down they weren’t just trying to run away from their past by drowning themself in booze and trying to distract their body as best they could, maybe that stuff had stopped working––it had from what he’d seen first hand, the way that the more often they had slept together the more obvious it was that they were still dealing with the consequences of their past. But that was a cruel thought, too, wasn’t it? They probably really did want to help him in some small way if they thought they could, and he did appreciate, but he wasn’t sure that it was healthy for either of them. That was part of the reason that he had gone radio silent on them in the first place.
It felt like everything just made it clear how different things were for both of them. They were both dealing with massive problems, but they were so different that it was hard to know how to compare them. It all made him even more aware of their differences; Marlene had experienced the war firsthand, when he was just a kid. He desperately wanted the chance to move forward without having to be burdened by things that he wasn’t even around for, and they needed to spend time coming to terms with the past if they wanted to live in the present.
“I know you’re not. And I do appreciate it, I swear, but...” he trailed off with a sigh, trying to decide how to phrase what he was thinking without sounding pushy or cruel. “Maybe I’m worried that you won’t be fine on your own, though, because it’s clear that you need help just as much as I do. But I don’t have potions and remedies to give you. I’m not even good at listening to problems when I’ve got a mind so full myself. I can’t handle the past when I have to think of the present, and I guess maybe I feel like you should also be doing that, except the other way around. Reconcile the past before you deal with the present. I dunno, I’m just talking out of my arse. Thanks for saying all that, really. But I don’t know what to say back.”