nina the killer headcannons
-she was 15 when she first heard about jeff, 18 when she met him. he is 20.
-she became obsessed with jeff because she went to his same high school, starting two years after he abandoned his education to pursue a life of crime LMAO. i like to think nina has an older sister who was in the same year as jeff and she would always tell nina about how weird and crazy this jeff guy is in her class.
-nina was intrigued, doing some light research like asking teachers n students around school about him, looking at old yearbooks etc. he seemed like a normal smiling boy in freshman year but he became very dark and brooding in sophomore year right before he left.
-she became even MORE fascinated when she learned what he did around the time he dropped out.
-she obsessively searched the web for anything about him, even finding a video on liveleak of security camera footage of supposedly one of his murders and she noticed the passion behind his actions. so much intention and purpose that she started to admire him for it.
-i like to think she’s more than just a jeff fan girl tho
-all throughout high school (leaving half way through 12th grade cuz she got so caught up with jeff n whatever) she loved the internet.
-definitely had a fan page for jeff
-TW!!she’d post about him, her new findings n what she thought about them. she’d also make weekly video diaries about herself, as if she was to introduce herself to jeff. it started off as coyly telling him about her hobbies and passions and family, hoping one day he’ll see it somehow. the video diaries became increasingly more disturbing where she talks about her fantasies of meeting him, how she’d do anything for his attention, even self harming to prove her sincerity. her final video ever uploaded was where she carved the smile into her face.
-nina does not have burns or any sort of mutilations other than the smile.
-lovesss myspace her page is so adorable with pink and purple icons and tons of friends who would comment. she used to flirt with boys all the time on there, same with facebook, but removed them all when she decided she wanted to be jeff’s girl.
-she has snakebites and a nose stud, belly button pierced
-has a tramp stamp of a butterfly and a small quote, “love me to death.” under her collar bone on the left side.
-honestly just so beautiful.
-i think of her as like eastern european. she’s serbian and russian! full lips, beautiful big brown eyes, long dark wavy hair in a shaggy scene cut with different coloured stripes in it.
-her style is so y2k yk she’s got a closet full of juicy couture tracksuits, low rise jeans w studded patterns on the pockets.
-loves emo and scene accessories, changing her style to mimic what she knows about jeff. more simple clothing. hoodies, darker colours, adding her own touch.
-loves to make jewelry. she made a beaded bracelet with jeff’s name on it, making a matching one with only black and red beads with nina’s name on it. she made it to give to jeff when she meets him.
-i imagine nina took so much liking to jeff because she has had a pretty lengthy gore addiction before finding out about him and what he did. she would consume endless amounts of accidents gone fatal videos, execution tapes, snuff films, anything she could to make her feel a wave of terror so strong she’d shriek and look away, before clicking on a new one. an even more gruesome one. she was like the top viewer for sights like crazyshit.com and rotten.com (both real sites btw)
-i hc that nina found jeff some time after running away from home and stalked him for a few months. after loosing sight of him, she returned home, empty in the evening, only to find him there waiting for her.
-long story short he thought she was a cop or something (stupid of jeff to think a teen girl is a cop) and she had to do major convincing to prove she wasn’t and she was just fascinated by what he does.
-definitely think that they probably hooked up for a period of time but never ever dated cuz jeff genuinely didn’t like her in that way but thought she was hot and easy and her constant praise of him totally turned him on.
-they just sorta stayed friends, jeff pretending he’s more annoyed by her than he actually is.
-twisted friendship. he lead her to committing crime. starting first as getting her to steal, fight in public with strangers, take her to train tracks and make her stand there as an oncoming train screeches it’s bell, to coax her off the track. if she was to get off the track before he said, jeff told her that he would step on the track and let it hit him instead. he always pulled her off of the track just in time, tugging her into a hug where she’d shakily hold onto him, listening to him cackle at her weakness.
-jeff would put her in really dangerous and illegal situations and abandon her to face the consequences. he’s slip away after she was caught shoplifting or trying to buy booze underage. she was even arrested twice. once for theft and the other for careless driving with a g1 licence (meaning she didn’t half her full license yet). and this got her in so much trouble back home when she’s drop by, her family worried for her. but she only cared about jeff and how he was happy to see her be reckless and putting herself in harms way captured his attention—if only for a moment. it was worth it.
-finally, after she’d confided in him about her passion for bloodspill, he wanted her to prove to him that she could even compare to jeff in that sense let alone be held to the same esteem by him.
-she killed another teenager, a girl from her school who’s brother had repeatedly harassed nina’s sister mila. the brother was murdered a few months before nina killed this girl. unknown to nina, jeff had killed that guy after hearing about what he did to someone that was very important to nina. didn’t do it for her, just felt like that creep deserved it.
-nina was sobbing by the end of the night, having been forced to kill this innocent girl. surely she was fond of her considering she defended her brother against mila’s accusations. she sobbed, clinging to jeff and muttering a mess of questions asking if he will love her now, if she’s worthy of his attention, what else can she do.
-he simply kissed her, holding her face and softly saying, “i don’t want you.”
-nina is truly really hurt that he doesn’t return her feelings but forfeits those feelings for any connection to him.
-she’s determined to make him hers. just thinking of the best way to do it.
-and to her, that’s to match his ability in killing. but to never outshine the master for he will resent her for it instead of love her.
bro idk what this it’s 2:30am and i just wrote my own nina the killer story. i forgot it was headcannons like half the way thru BUT I LOVE HER SM she’s my new favourite creepypasta. i’ve been obsessed w jeff lately too i need him almost as bad as nina does😣🛌
