My critical analysis on Mawaru Penguindrum. Unbelievable.
WARNING: CONTAINS SPOILER. Read at your own risk.
(January 7, 2018: This remains a Work in Progress.)
Within 2 days (Yes), I watched another Madoka-level depressive anime. Good job. Why am I keep watching this kind of anime? What is pushing me to the cliff of depression? It's not like I'm that kind of person And, in fact, I am quite savage, online and offline, check my post history, but I just keep going to this kind of shit. So...Listen, you lowlifes, who will never amount to anything! Obtain the Penguin Drum! This is nonsense. I get what the author trying to say, but this is still nonsense.
First time writing an analysis. Probably amateur as hell.
This Linux meme I saw on a trash website.
So I went to search for its raw sauce source, which leads to me watching this. I thought it was some good entertaining shit, but turns out it’s another Madoka-level calice.
The main theme, core idea, whatever.
First of all, let’s compare the statements that the characters made. The apple girl said:
I love the word "fate". Because, you know how they talk about "fated encounters"? A single encounter can completely change your life. Such special encounters are not just coincidences. They're definitely... fate. Of course, life is not all happy encounters. There are many painful, sad moments. But this is what I think: sad and painful things definitely happen for a reason. Nothing in this world is pointless.
And that was episode 2. In contrast, Shouma said:
I hate the word "fate." Birth, encounters, partings, success and failures, fortune and misfortunes in life. If our lives are already set in stone by fate, then why are we even born? There are those born to wealthy families, those born to beautiful mothers, and those born into the middle of war or poverty. If that's all caused by fate, then God is incredibly unfair and cruel. Because, ever since that day, none of us had a future and the only certain thing was that we wouldn't amount to anything...
And that was episode 1. The end proved them both right. Nice catch. But they’re too extreme. And animes are always featuring extreme situations so that they can be animes, right? That’s why I don’t take animes as lessons. They’re not something we will encounter.
What I believe is: You might love it, or hate it, but such concept of “fate” is a suggested course. It should not be taken as the truth set in stone (Shouma), or surprises that jump out randomly (Ringo), but rather a neutral advice. You can follow it, or you can break it, depending on the situation, which can bring positive and/or negative consequences, known as “taking risks”. Such “fate”, as a suggested course, is fitted to everyone individually. Let’s break this down.
Such concept of “fate” is a suggested course.
By “suggested” I didn’t mean it’s necessarily good. It is rather close to being balanced, which is what the world has been turning about: Positive and negative connect to each other, spread across the whole lifespan of “fate”.
...but rather a neutral advice.
Following such “fate” makes you what a balanced world (which is neutral, at least it should be) want you to be.
You can follow it, or you can break it, depending on the situation.
Two points. First of all, only you can change your fate, not a fucking diary, which succeeded in transferring fate after a high price was paid. Second of all, I said depending on the situation, which means that there are certain moments in your life that you have no other options (Will describe later).
Such “fate”, as a suggested course, is fitted to everyone individually.
To balance out the society, positive and negative elements coexist.
This world is corrupt. It's all about winning and losing. Who is ranked above and below you. The profitable and unprofitable. The accepted and unaccepted. The chosen and unchosen. They never try to give... All they care about is taking! What a miserable world we live in. A world ruled by those who will never amount to anything. This is already a Frozen World. But fortunately for us, the Flame of Hope is still burning strong. The holy flame. Tomorrow, we will cleanse the world with that flame. Now's the time to take back... The beautiful world where the mankind only need true things to survive! This is our Survival Strategy!
“They never try to give... All they care about is taking!” Isn’t that communism you want? Soviet anthem plays So this is a commie anime then. Woah. The author is just too sophisticated. I never expected to see such an accurate portrayal of communism in a fucking anime!
Jokes aside. Needed or unneeded won’t exist if people’s direct benefit In the anime, such goal is portrayed by a terrorist group, which sucks. I think this goal is perfect: It is something I would definitely agree on, given the stories of the kids’ families in the anime...aside from the method to establish it: Trying to establish an equal society by a massacre against the innocent creates way more inequality. But the problem is, communism is always established using bloody methods (Just two famous examples. There’s more...Plus they didn’t establish true communism later on.) which makes any peaceful solution impossible. After all, you can’t change the whole society: Once you take the benefit, you wouldn’t share it.
This picture generally illustrated the flow of “apple” (= Penguindrum = Fruit of fate) throughout the timeline, showing the cycle of fate. This is a representation of "true things” (= Equality) presented in the previous section.
But why killing Himari to teach them a lesson? If they’re living happily, and they accept each other as family members while none of the three siblings are biological, in what perspective does killing her necessary? Of course, you can say, “Fate.” But that makes a loophole because now we can say, “Everything is connected by fate”. Here comes dialectical materialism, a theoretical base of communism which proved this anime to be commie again. They believe that...
A thing will go back to its original form after being reversed twice.
Everything is created by conflicts.
Such ideology is dangerous, as it’s a loophole proving itself right. And that makes communism dangerous.
I guess it’s very clear: Pretty entertaining in the beginning, depressive in the end. Personally, I believe the distribution of both parts in Penguindrum is more balanced than Madoka.
First of all, why would Ringo want to imitate her dead sister? She’s dead already, so she won’t change. Tabuki is 16 years older, and he will change drastically. Why would you follow a guide written 16 years apart? Materialism again? “If my mind become alike to Momoka’s, I’ll become Momoka herself, because materialists believe that minds are composed of matters.” No, no, no!
Summarizing the end of the story, it’ll be: Reviving one should-be-dead girl at the cost of erasing two boys completely from the earth, plus giving a girl some burn, and 2 women + 1 man depression. In any way, I believe that the princess of crystal (the hat, in short) should be directly responsible for the result of 2 dead 4 injuries. That’s first-degree murder. Even if the two brothers agreed to take their lives to save Himari, that’s still murder. Even if their parents are terrorists and the fate said their kids have to be punished, that’s still murder (Committed by whoever executed the fate). Even if the scorpion burning on Ringo got transferred to Shouma, that’s still attempted murder on Ringo. BEGONE THOT! She should be cursed and Himari should die gracefully. In fact, Himari already realized that her disease can’t be cured, so she even prayed to “return the present of life”, which is a pretty ungraceful death. So here comes the problem:
Why’d the princess revive Himari?
“Obtain the Penguindrum”, which is the fruit of fate (apple), revealed in the end. We already analyzed the “cycle“. Or maybe she (As a part of Momoka, revealed in Episode 23, or the worse part as written here) just wants to murder the guys?
Well...I don’t think I should analyse each characters separately.