im conflicted on miyazaki-san's new film
i saw the boy and the heron recently and i had the privilege of seeing it in a proper real imax theater (only a handful in my country). i have thoughts. they are very conflicting.
this wasn't a bad film, i found the first half of the film to be pretty captivating. its the other part of the film where my feelings toward it are much more mixed.
before i get to that, i jus wanted to say that the score n the vocal performances were actually pretty good. the underground world where the film takes place later on is probably my favorite that ive seen in a ghibli film. seeing the sun rays burst through the clouds and beam onto the sea was such a sight to behold, especially in imax.
what the hell happened in the later half of the film. there are some really beautiful setpieces, but it wasnt really enough to distract me from the confusion that clouded my mind while watching. the world is beautiful but theres a lot that isnt explained and makes me wish that this film was longer so it could explain it. theres a thing about a door that lets u time travel, or so its implied (?) but they also say "oh if u let go ur stuck" like how do u know that, did u do that? what are these cute but weird lil guys n how do their purposes make sense, wha?? if this film had maybe 20, 30, maybe even 40 mins added to its runtime, i feel like it wouldve had time to explain the things that it couldnt in 2 hours (its length).
another thing is that this film in japan was called "kimi tachi wa dou ikiru ka? (how do you live?) the same name as the book that served as a main inspiration for miyazaki-san. the book is also mentioned as a major-ish plot device thing to push mahito to enter the other underground tower world. other than that, this film doesnt seem to ask that question in a meaningful way, like it has a meaning or reason to ask it. maybe i just dont get it, but it felt like this was trying to say something but i couldnt understand what it was trying to say. maybe if it was longer it wouldve been more clear?
i really wanna like this movie, n i do like a lot of parts of it, especially the artstyle n backdrops, but its hard to like it when i was thinking these kinda things even while i was watching the movie. it says something, doesnt really get enough time to explain it, moves on, and im left here thinking "wait come back im a little lost". it could have benefitted from being significantly longer so i could understand more.
otherwise, it was a gorgeous film to see, especially in the tru imax theater that i happened to see it in. if it was longer and could explain more of the underground world, i would have liked it a lot more.












