Batboy Scenarios: Apologizing for the Cheating Incident
Feat: Dick Grayson, Jason Todd, Tim Drake, and Damian Wayne
After a three week of ignoring him and moving back into your old apartment Dick finally seemed to get the message that you wanted nothing to do with him. Of course it sucked, having lost someone that brought you so much joy, but it pained you more thinking that he had so little trust in you that he’d go as far as to call you a cheater. You had gotten home early from work today and sighed as you entered the lonely apartment, your body could sense someone else in the home and you groaned in annoyance pulling out your pocket knife. Just as you entered the living room you swung your arm to the left just barely missing Barbara’s head, with your knife now lodged in the wall you groaned and plopped onto the couch face first.
“What do you want?”, you growled.
“To come make things right, look you’re both miserable and it’s my fault. I’m sorry I didn’t think Dick was going to react that way so I came to fix my mistakes.”, Babs’ explained slowly rolling towards you to give you a present.
You glared at the medium sized box and sat up before taking it into your hands, you opened it to reveal a gorgeous sapphire blue dress that looked way to expensive for you to afford.
(A/n: we’ll imagine something similar to this 💙)
“The Wayne Gala is tonight and Dick wanted you to be there, he went and picked out this dress for you, even had it custom made just so it would fit you perfectly. He wants to apologize for being a huge idiot but he hasn’t been able to get through to you so that’s why I’m here.”, Barbara explained giving you a small box that held a beautiful simple diamond necklace in it, “He knows you’re not materialistic but tonight he wanted to show off to everyone that he had the most gorgeous woman in the whole world at his side. Every Prince Charming needs his Princess to make him look good. Just think about it, okay?”
She left without another word leaving you to stew alone in your thoughts, the Gala started tonight at seven, and Babs was trying to fix her mistake so it was only fair that you let Dick try to fix his. You called Alfred asking him to pick you up for the Gala and the old butler couldn’t sound happier to hear you again, you got ready trying to make yourself look just as good as the dress. Tonight was gonna be the night that was going to make or break your heart so it only seemed fair to go out in style. Alfred happily arrived at your home in a Limo at exactly 6:30 sharp and smiled seeing you come out of your apartment building in the gorgeous gown. He said nothing and just smiled as he drove you to the Wayne Manor, cameras littered the whole entrance, reporters hungrily trying to snap shots of the powerful men and women entering the Mansion.
“Alfred can I go through the back I don’t feel to comfortabl-“
“A star deserves her spotlight Miss (Y/n), now go show them how a true star shines.”, he replied.
You sighed and smiled at the old butler kissing his cheek sweetly before exiting the Limousine. Everyone gawked at your gorgeous appearance, shouting and snapping photos of you until you made it inside. You knew exactly where the main hall was and smiled once you entered seeing it brimming with idle chatter and powerful faces from all of Gotham.
“(Y/n)! Oh my gosh you came!”, Babs cheered seeing you in your gown.
“Hey Barbara.”, you spoke softly leaning down to hug her tightly, “So where’s Prince Charming at?”
She pointed behind you towards the wall where an all to depressed looking Dick was parked, he was leaning against the wall with the saddest looking frown you’d ever seen draw across his face.
“It’s a good thing I’m great at making him smile.”, you joked making your way to him. He saw the bottom of your dress before he saw you but brushed you away thinking you were one of his exes trying to steal a dance from him. “You wouldn’t happen to know where I could find a handsome young prince now would you?”
His eyes widened in shock as he stared up at you upon hearing your voice, you couldn’t help but smile seeing his hopelessly confused expression. You leaned against the wall next to him and smiled looking out over the sea of guests, he wanted to say something but the words were stuck in his throat so you said it for him, “I forgive you.”, you sighed watching tears spill from his sweet blue hues.
“W-what? B-but I-I haven’t…-“
“Babs told me about how depressed you’ve been without me. She told me how much you regretted what you said and gave me this outfit you bought me just so I could come. You’re trying that’s what matters, I counted every call, every message…I know you’re sorry I’m just still hurting from what you said that’s all.”, you explain feeling tears prick at the corners of your eyes.
You stared up at the ceiling trying to calm yourself down before you ruined your makeup but Dick quickly wiped them away making sure to be gentle and careful. He finally faced you and stared into your eyes making you smile, “You’re ugly.”, you teased watching his sadness melt away with a laugh. He brushed his tears away with his sleeves and finally took in your whole appearance smiling at your gorgeous glow, “This is how beautiful you look to me every single day. I know that I don’t say it enough but you are beautiful (y/n) and I’m an idiot for saying something so stupid to you, I’m sorry.”, he sighed slowly pulling you into a hug as your own walls came down.
You weren’t trying to cry again but something about his warmth, his strength, his scent, all of it brought you so much comfort and joy that you couldn’t help but cry. He pulled away for just a moment and smiled at you pressing his forehead to yours as he whispered, “Tell me how I can make your pain go away, that way we can start over and I can earn you back.”
You smiled at him and puckered your soft gloss covered lips up at him, “Kiss me and make the pain go away.”, you hummed. Dick didn’t hesitate for a moment, his lips were glued to yours in seconds peppering soft kisses against your lips until they eventually became longer and needier. Each kiss burning with a passion that you missed, you were left peacefully love drunk by his kisses but he hadn’t had his fill of you yet.
As if Alfred wasn’t already the greatest friend of all time he requested a special song from the band. The very song that you and Dick danced to when you first met began to play and you smiled. Dick stepped away from you and offered you his hand with a bright smile, “(Y/n), my love, may I have this dance?”
You giggled and took his hand, he pulled you close and slowly moved towards the dance floor with you. With both hands holding your waist firmly he slowly began to dance with you staring into your eyes, pecking your lips till your lip gloss made his shine, and complementing you for the Queen you are. You danced the night away with him until you eventually ended up asleep in each other’s arms in his room, he wouldn’t dare let go again.
You were on an assignment for Batman, tracking down and taking down Black Mask’s sex trafficking gang and returning him to Arkham Prison. Simple enough right, well he wasn’t expecting your rage fueled mind to blow your cover so easily and turn the ferry docks into a war zone. Your bullets were almost running out but you were sure to take out as many crooks as you could before being forced into hand to hand combat. You had secured a good enough shield behind one of the empty storage containers and shot from that spot but with the flurry of gunshots shooting off you hadn’t heard the man sneaking up behind you with a crowbar until a louder gunshot made you jump from behind you. The man was shot dead just a few feet away from you and you groaned seeing the red hooded vigilante just a few containers away from you.
“Shit Red Hood’s here! Everyone scatter!”, Black Mask ordered trying to hide between his fleeing men but you made sure to catch him with one of your grappling hooks going right through left calf.
You pulled him toward you with pure annoyance and shoved a cloth in his mouth to muffle his screams and cries. A loud thud echoed behind you but you refused to turn around and talk to him, “You know normal people would say thank you for being saved.”, you gritted your teeth in annoyance and walked away as Police arrived to take in Black Mask. Even now while you’re mad at him he had the nerve to be sarcastic with you!
“Hey! Babe come on I’m sorry. How many times do I have to say it?”, Jason followed behind you keeping pace with you even as you tried to lose him.
“I’ve told you leave me alone!”, you snapped slapping his hand away as he tried to grab your wrist.
He sighed and took off his mask allowing you to look him in the eye, “Then look me in the eyes and say it to my face.”, you glared at him but the words were stuck in your throat. You clicked your tongue and stormed off only for him to continue following after you.
“(Y/n), beautiful, I know you’re angry but I don’t think you know what you’re angry for anymore. Are you angry about me claiming you for being a cheater when you weren’t? Or for not noticing small details about you? Tell me!”, Jason growled swiping at your feet to make you fall. Just as your face was about to hit the metal he grabbed you by your waist and held you like a sack of potatoes.
“Put me down Jason!”, you screamed squirming in his grip.
He pinned you down to the ground, sitting on your waist to keep you still despite your constant kicking. He held your wrist above your head with one hand and cupped your cheek with his free one before planting a hot wet kiss on your lips. You tried to stop your body’s reaction to his tongue claiming your own but still he managed to pull a moan from your lips. He pulled away after a few seconds leaving your head fuzzy and warm before speaking again.
“You avoid eye contact whenever your scared or know you’re wrong, you start to scratch your thumb when your anxious, and you play that you’re angry to hide the fact that you want to cry.”, he spoke softly watching you come back to your senses with each little habit he’s picked up from you. He stares into your eyes pouring out his apology from his deep blue hues and you find yourself leaning up for another kiss, he doesn’t deny you it. His lips melt against your, kissing you ever so softly until he lets go of your wrists to hold your sweet face in his hands.
“You aren’t a slut, you aren’t a cheater, I’m sorry I’m such a fucking idiot but I love you, I love you with all my heart and I can’t bare to stand you ignoring me another day. Please…please forgive me (Y/n).”, Jason begs, desperation lacing every word.
You groan in annoyance as your tears finally spill, you’re so hurt, so happy, so confused, honestly you aren’t sure anymore but you want him so much.
“You can list out every small scratch or stitch I have but I can list out something even more important that you have.”
“A-And what would that be?”, you hiccup sitting up as he gets off of you and pulls you to your feet.
He hugs you tight, allowing you to listen to his heartbeat as he whispers, “You have my whole heart.”
Tim goes to your home immediately after the incident but your brother makes sure to keep him away from you. He isn’t even allowed in but he can hear your heartbroken cries, it makes his heart tighten in regret as he tries to push through the mammoth wall you called a brother until he’s pushed down your door steps.
“Stay the fuck away from this house, don’t ever come here again you sick bastard and to think that my sister actually wanted to spend the rest of her life with you.”, Your brother growls slamming the door shut on him.
Tim tries to call you but you don’t answer, he tries hacking into your phone to force the call to go through but he forgets that he set up his personal blocks to keep you safe, no matter what you wouldn’t answer him and the guilt killed him. Stephanie wanted help but Tim wouldn’t let her since he was so furious with her so he decided to try again tonight during patrol there was just one little problem…you didn’t know that he was Red Robin. How would you react if a superhero just showed up to your house in the middle of the night?
“No I have to do it. This only issue started because I didn’t trust her…but I do…I do and I can trust her with this secret. I want to spend the rest of my life with her so I can’t bare to lose her now over a stupid prank.”, Tim shakes from the emotions piling up inside of him but even as tears spill from his eyes he realizes that he’s got something important he has to do.
Gotham City soon turns dark as the moon dances over the sky giving way to the scum of the night to emerge and start their activities. Thankfully Nightwing is able to convince the rest of the Bat Family to take over the patrol and lets Tim wander off to find you. He expected you to be asleep by now but to his surprise you were on your rooftop holding yourself in your arms with the saddest frown and puffiest eyes he’s ever seen. He quietly lands on the ledge and takes off his cape and places it on your shoulders. You jump in fright from the sudden warmth and whip around to see who it was only to be met with the masked face of Red Robin.
“O-oh hello. Y-You’re Red Robin…I-I’m umm…I’m a huge fan.”, you stutter.
“A bit cold out tonight isn’t it? You should be inside where it’s safe love.”, Red Robin tries to hide his voice with an accent but he fails miserably making you giggle. You sigh and take off the cape returning it to him with a sad smile and tell him you’ll go back inside but his gloved hand catches your wrist drawing you back to him.
“I’m sorry.”, he apologizes staring at your confused expression.
You want to say something but just as you open your lips to say something shock washes over your face as Tim removes his mask. Your frozen still in shock trying to comprehend how your boyfriend was behind the mask of your favorite hero.
“I’m sorry (Y/n) about what I did today, I-I just didn’t know about the prank. I should’ve never doubted you, let alone thought you’d actually cheat on me. Please forgive me Love Bird.”, he sighs cupping your face.
“W-wait…wait I-I’m overwhelmed. H-How? Why would you reveal your identity to me?! Are you crazy what if someone sees you? Put your mask back on you idiot.”, your worried, gently placing his mask back over his blue eyes and scanning your whole rooftop for any nosy eyes that might’ve been watching. This is exactly why Tim loved you, you were always so caring and considerate of others even if you were tired or in pain.
“(Y/n).”, he called stealing your attention again, “I’m sorry.”
Your mind is running circles right now but his words are sincere you can tell, you’re about to cry again but he kisses the corners of your eyes and smiles at you making you smile back. He takes something out of his utility belt and gets down on one knee overwhelming you more then you already were. He opens a small black velvet box to expose the sweet engagement ring that rested in the middle of it. Your face flushes red from ear to ear as you stare at him, new tears spill from your eyes but you can’t help but be happy.
“(Y/n), I know I messed up today but I want the chance to make things right I showed you who I am because I trust and love you. I want to make it up to you each and every day if you’ll let me, please become my Mrs. Drake, that way I can love you and make up for my mistake the rest of my life. I promise I’ll never hurt you, embarrass you, or doubt you again so please marry me.”, he smiles watching your legs go weak from shock.
He catches you in his arms and holds you, gently brushing his hand over your soft hair until you sob your response, “Hkk-…Y-Yes. I accept your apology, I accept your proposal. Yes.”, you cry out kissing his chin and cheek ever so sweetly. He smiles and places your ring on your finger sealing his promises with a kiss on the diamond before stealing a kiss from your lips.
His communicator goes off and Steph’s voice goes off saying they need help, Tim sighs and wraps his cape around you once more. “I’ll be back, get some sleep love bird, I’ll see you in a bit.”, he smiles free falling off your building with the happiest look on his face.
He disappears into the night and you stay there baffled and happy with your future husband.
The tension between you both was suffocating, neither of you would look or speak to each other but every one could sense the lingering guilt and tension between you two. Damian avoided you at all costs practically limiting his time at Titans Tower and staying posted in Gotham instead of facing you. You were boiling with rage, it was evident in your new training and fighting style. Damian had left your face scarred, from the corner of your lip to the tip of your cheek giving you a sinister half smile that terrified many. You updated your hero costume just to have a full mask that would cover your whole face but everyone knew that the mask was just there to hide how scared and lonely you felt. Conner offered you as much support as he could but it just wasn’t enough, so he decided to do something about it even if both of you hated him for it.
“So you just gonna avoid her until she finds someone else or what? You two haven’t spoken to each other in like two weeks at this point she’s free game.”, Conner whispered to the young Robin.
“Don’t you dare.”, Damian growled.
“Oh no not me. I’ve got a friend back home that thinks she’s pretty, he’s looking for a bit of arm candy so I thought I’d introduce them I’m just checking to see if you two are officially over?”
Damian stood to his feet grabbing the young Kryptonian by his collar and yanking him towards him. “If you so much as take her from the Tower I swear I will kill you.”, He hissed tossing Conner to the side.
“It’s not like you’re talking to her, you haven’t even apologized yet. You think this will go away just because you’re avoiding her and putting your walls back up? Dude seriously at this point did you even love her?”, Conner continued to badger him until eventually Damian exploded.
“I can’t bring myself to face her because I’m scared! I’m scared I’ll hurt her again and I’m scared that once we’re alone she’ll leave me! (Y/n) is the best thing that’s ever happened to me and I fucking ruined it by scarring her! Don’t you get that? I’m hiding because I’m to afraid to lose her!”, Damian roared loud enough for everyone to hear, little did he know that Conner had you on a call and you heard everything.
You were bundled up in your blankets sighing as another depressive wave washed over you until you got that call, listening to Damian’s confession made your whole body warm but you also couldn’t help but laugh. You knew Damian had a hard time expressing himself but this was just stupid, avoiding the inevitable just because he was scared? As if some higher being was listening to you a black portal that you recognized as Raven’s opened up above you and Damian came falling through. He caught himself, hovering just above you, your noses touching as he shrunk back in fear.
“Hello?”, you spoke in a soft voice evidence that you had just been crying.
“(Y-y/n) I-I umm…I need to go.”, he stuttered trying to leave but you didn’t let him.
You grabbed his wrist and pulled him back onto the bed, you pinned him down by sitting on his waist before slamming your lips on his until you felt him melt in your arms. You eyes were closed enjoying the feeling you missed so much while Damian took his time trying to figure out what was going on. You pulled away once you couldn’t handle your breathing but you noticed the way Damian’s lips chased after yours for more.
“So you’re scared huh?”, you teased watching as the gears in his head clicked and he realized what had happened.
He tries to stutter out an explanation but you plant another kiss on his lips to shut him up, “I know you don’t have a good comprehension on relationships because you’ve never really been in one but ignoring me and avoiding me isn’t going to help the situation. Damian you hurt me, you have to live up to that because if you don’t then I really will leave y-“
“Don’t! Don’t do that!”, Damian yells shutting you up, “Don’t even say it, I know I messed up, I hurt you, but I didn’t know what to do about it. I gave you space because that’s how Father and Selena were after their arguments I thought it’d pass and we’d be back to normal again. (Y/n) I don’t know what to do, and that scares me. I-I thought if I gave you space we’d go back to normal but it’s been two weeks and I can’t take it anymore.”
You stared at him in awe, the young son of Batman didn’t know that his parents would still talk to each other once they had calmed down. You couldn’t help but laugh making Damian glare up at you, you giggled as you leaned down to steal another kiss.
“You’re an idiot you know that. Bruce and Selena would take a break from arguing to calm down, once they’d calmed down they’d talk it out and come to a solution. That’s why you’re plan hasn’t been working all you’ve been doing is avoiding me instead of trying to work things out with me you ass.”, you sighed collapsing on top of him, “You’re an idiot.”
Damian knows he’s an idiot, but feeling your warmth again makes him so happy. His arms wrap around you hugging you close while you press soft kisses against the crook of his neck, “I’m sorry Habibti will you please forgive me?”, he begs softly. You smile and agree wrapping your arms around his neck.
“Sorry you’ve got to deal with having an ugly girlfriend with an uglier face.”, you hummed earning a glare from the young Robin.
He rolls you both over pinning you to the bed and glaring down at you, “You aren’t ugly nor will you ever be in my eyes. If you say it again in my presence I will prove you wrong.”
“But I am everyone at school says it even civilians, this scar makes me super ug-mmm~”, your voice is drowned out by his soft lips pressing against yours. He rolls you both back over enjoying your full weight against his body, his rough hand cups your scarred cheek gently brushing his thumb over it while his other hand reaches down to your waist to hold you.
Damian begins to make up for lost time apologizing, complementing, encouraging you with each kiss. Damian was an idiot but at least he was your idiot.
Kumori-Suwan’s Taglist: @steadyconnoisseurnacho @candid-confetti @simonsbluee @thisuserlovesyouandyouandyou @fawnstudio @overlookedla @avengers-of-middle-earth @superheroesaremyjam113263
