Homestuck Music Reviews

Reviews of the music and albums from the Homestuck library.

[beat-bro]

By Seth “Beatfox” Peelle

What a way to sign off. By turns it’s morose, sentimental, and triumphant. The fanfare section is spectacular, starting at 4:13 (what an unremarkable coincidence). Its slow, ascending buildup in pitch and tempo peaks with a soaring final rendition of Homestuck Anthem to close out the album.

[beat-bro]

By Alexander Rosetti

I love these sorts of genre-subverting remixes. Is 'subversion' even the right word to use here? It seems preposterous to suggest that a Homestuck song could subvert the genre of any other Homestuck song. Whatever, I'm going to go with it.

The original track's bumbly and goofy. This one maintains that same sort of feeling (you can't really generate a lot of dread and tension with a flexatone, after all), but in full-on orchestral HD.

[beat-bro]

By Marcy Nabors. Features contributions from several artists; see the song’s Bandcamp page for details.

An epic, orchestral arrangement, cut from the same cloth as [S] Act 7.

Unlike Creata, this one does feature a live choir. The first one ever to appear on a Homestuck music track, to my knowledge. I didn’t think that the ‘Warhammer of Zillyhoo’ chant could become any more ecclesiastic, yet here we stand. Especially starting at 6:30, it's fantastic (the soprano really comes through).

[beat-bro]

By Max “Imbrog” Wright

Warm and memorable. I like the contrast of the long, drawn-out lead melody against the staccato, wandering background.

[beat-bro]

By Malcolm Brown

All about the most unsinkable ship in Homestuck. This song draws inspiration from prior themes for Rose and Kanaya, but there’s an impressive amount of variation to it. Darling Kanaya (2:44), done in violin and strummed acoustic guitar, is almost unrecognizable (and very cool).

The bit at 1:30 seems particularly fitting for a scene in Vriskagram, with Rose and Kanaya reading together quietly… 

… until Vriska wanders in and butts her way into their business. Dammit, Vriska!

[beat-bro]

Song is composed by Joren “Tensei” de Bruin.

I think Aradia sums up my own thoughts on this one.

Part one of this little comic's over here.

[beat-bro]

By Jeremy "Solatrus" Iamurri

The nature of the rest of Homestuck Volume 10 leads one to think that the smooth, rising siren synth must lead to a big transition. Possibly one involving bass, and/or its displacement downwards in the vertical dimension. But that doesn't happen. That rising siren folds right back into the melody. There's something deeply satisfying about that effect. It's hard to explain. But I love it.

This is my favorite track on the whole album. Just a fantastic groove, all the way through.

[beat-bro]

By Erik “Jit” Scheele

Jazzy and relaxing. Rose and Kanaya sit in a French cafe, sipping coffee, watching as the people pass by on the sidewalk.

[beat-bro]

Composed by Luke “GFD” Benjamins. Production and Arrangement by Robert J! Lake.

A cool main riff, with hyped-up synth insanity wrapped around it in layers like a psychedelic onion.

[beat-bro]

Arrangement by Michael Guy Bowman, Marcy Nabors, Clark Powell, and Erik Scheele. Instrumental contributions by Erik Scheele, Tensei, Paul Henderson, Marcy Nabors, and Jamie Paige Stanley.

A sweeping medley / mashup of Ruins, Flare, and Explore. The first half of the song’s pretty much directly sampled from the first two songs on that list, but that lead-up pays off big time starting around 2:00. This album has more ‘whoa’ moments on it than any other before it.

Solid production values, too. Starting with Solar Voyage, all the way through Thanks for Playing, the tracks flow together in smooth transitions. Nothing is sacrificed in the stand-alone songs, yet it all comes together as one solid half-an-hour of music.

[beat-bro]

By Curt Blakeslee

Back to Homestuck's musical roots with an improvisational take on his original Beatdown. It’s probably the simplest track on the album. I really like the freestyle flow of it, kept pace by that heavy ‘splat’ downbeat.

This song has my favorite piece of track art, too. With all of Dave’s recent revelations about his upbringing, the picture’s 50% comical, 50% disconcerting. I think my exact reaction was “heh heh…. Oh.”

[beat-bro]

By Thomas “EidolonOrpheus” Ferkol

Atmospheric. The liner notes mention that EidolonOrpheus was inspired by Calliope, hiding deep in the Furthest Ring. It was a place of temporary refuge, but one subject to an ever-present threat of annihilation. The instrumentation reinforces that feeling: light, yet somehow sad.

[beat-bro]

By Seth "Beatfox" Peelle

I've been waiting for this one with great anticipation ever since Beatfox released a WIP snippet of it last year. The first half of Volume 10’s pretty heavy, so it’s a nice break when this impossibly upbeat, impossibly catchy tune rolls around.

The song is an homage to the soundtrack of The Neverending Story. Homestuck itself has its share of homages and references to that movie, as well, including this smug self-insert riding a long magic dog, hidden far in the background of the track art. Bullies beware.

I've never seen The Neverending Story. A part of me’s especially glad I didn't see it when I was a little kid. Falcor’s face is all kinds of uncanny-valley weird. The canine snout… the strangely infantile facial features… the lifeless black marbles for eyes… yeesh. Eight-year-old-me had a hard enough time dealing with that scene in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory where Violet turns into a giant blueberry.

[beat-bro]

By George Buzinkai

Cool main melody, but the background melodies are something else: rolling percussion in the first half, mournful, arpeggioed organ in the second. Really scratches that Castlevania itch. It's a shame this one was released after Homestuck wrapped up; I'd love to see what kind of remix potential this one has.

[beat-bro]

By David “A Lunatic’s Daydream” Ellis

Smooth jazz fusion. What’s jazz fusion, you say? Lots of people like it! On a personal note, I played alto sax for a long time. It's the reason why I come down on badly sampled sax, yet extoll the live stuff. My ear for it’s ingrained through hundreds and hundreds of hours of play. And this is all I could hope for.

[beat-bro]

By Robert J! Lake

More than any other single Flash animation in Homestuck, Descend has inspired a lot of after-the-fact musical attention. After Descend’s release, Tensei wrote a new soundtrack for it, sort of as a personal challenge (and as a fan-song, not an official release, to boot!).

That song, at one point referred to as Descend2, later became the first part of Cascade.

The game of musical telephone continues on Volume 10. Tensei’s work on Descend2 inspired RJ to make his own version, which has been released on this album as Freefall. Three different composers, three very different songs, and all thematically tied to the events that occur in the End of Act 4 flash.

Freefall is very different from Tensei’s track. The hints of similarity are still there (compare 1:20 in Freefall to 1:32 in Cascade), but I doubt I’d recognize its inspirational source on my own. Where Cascade is a constant build-up of energy, Freefall’s mostly more mellow, more flowing.

[beat-bro]

By Thomas “EidolonOrpheus” Ferkol

A whole ‘Strife’-style album could be culled out of the hard-rockers on Volume 10. Like Beatdown, Skaian Ride sees a heap of attention on this album, including this punk garage-band version. The drum work here is relentless: you’d need three foot-pedals to keep the bass drum going at this kind of pace.