At the beginning I was really enjoying Bly Manor and then I got to around episode 5 and stopped watching. I know I shouldnât but I keep on comparing it to Hill House. Overall, I enjoyed Hill House a lot more (yes, I canât have much views on Bly Manor because Iâve only seen half of it but I think I watched Hill House in one go which is what Iâm basing this opinion off of) There are certain aspects to Bly Manor I like a bit more than Hill House- all these strangers coming together, the deeper insight into sexuality and how it becomes much more of a focus (rather than just a passing characteristic as seen with Theo) but to me, Bly Manor lacks the complexity Hill House had. It lacks a unity within the episodes. MF did everything for Hill House from directing to editing and it shows how much that works, when it is just one person with one end goal doing it all, how much more uniformed the episodes are, how easily they link together. Bly Manor is written by a bunch of different writers (I know Hill House too didnât have MF writing all the eps but he did direct them all) and a bunch of different directors for every episode. To me Bly Manor is not a seamless ten-hour long movie broken into 1 hour parts like Hill House was. Bly Manor was a TV show. A good TV show but not one that was an extended movie. I know I should look at Bly Manor as a separate piece of Media but I canât. That association with Hill House will always be in my head, I will always be comparing the two and that is the thing that puts me off watching Bly Manor. Until that association is broken I just donât think Iâll be able to watch and/or enjoy it to itâs full potentional.
Now regarding the different writers thing: Hill House, as I said, did have different writers but to me, it came across as just one mind. MF had a plan with Hill House and it was a plan his team of writers followed. Bly Manor...everyone had their own idea. It doesnât make Bly Manor worse than Hill House for this, Iâll always encourage the idea of everyone getting a taste and say in a collaborative work, but having this one mind just ran so much more seamless to me.











