BlackGirlNerd perpetuates misogynoir in fandom.
You may have seen a post today from blackgirlnerds talking about “crazy fandoms” particularly a group known as the Iris West Defense Squad. Unfortunately BGN does not support black female characters and when called out, she acted particularly petty. Namely never shutting up about it, going on a podcast to paint herself as the victim of bullying, and writing a hit piece with the goal of turning fans who protect black female characters into pariahs. Not only is she incapable of supporting black women TV characters, but she’s trying to get a come up by climbing on the backs of black women in real life, calling fans of Sleepy Hollow and Scandal uncivilized, which a huge micro aggression, if I’ve ever heard one. Every link in this post is a screenshot for proof.
BGN and Misogynoir
BGN doesn’t actually praise black women on TV. (After she was called out on this, she started to praise Fish Mooney, but personally I think she’s using that as a guise.)
Iris West isn’t the only black women character that BGN finds beneath her. When asked about Abbie Mills being sidelined, she replied that she didn’t “See anything wrong” with what they were doing. In the past she has demeaned the Sleepy Hollow and Olivia Pope fandoms, although most of those tweets have been deleted.
There is also an article on her website claiming:
“[Diversity] can’t be shoe-horned in places where it doesn’t make sense"
It goes on to speak out against Spiderman, Heimdall and Johnny Storm being portrayed by black actors.
The “love” she claims to have to black people on television, especially black women on television is shallow and peripheral. This is far more evident when you learn, like I did, that BGN is a huge fan of Felicity Sm**k. She’s admonishing the Iris West fandom while Olic**y fans send death threats to actresses, death threats to an actor’s wife, and cheer on the erasure of Diggle. In fact, A**ow fans were encouraged by Olic**y fans not to support more screentime for Diggle… Because then, somehow, magically, it will be give Iris West more screen time on The Flash.
In case I lost you, Iris West fans defend characters and people against racial slurs, and threats of violence. Her fandom: Sends death threats and promotes the erasure of black characters.
BGN claims that she’s never seen the dark side of her fandom. But that’s hard to believe, because she’s friends with one of the people who specifically said not to speak out on Diggle’s erasure.
BGN would have you believe that she was offering constructive criticism when she was brutally ravaged by the Beyhive— I mean, Iris West Defense Squad. She wasn’t. She was making pot shots on twitter. People came and disagreed with her. That’s it. Seriously, it is. Now apparently, when you disagree with BGN, she might reply once or twice, but after that she blocks you. There is no dissent allowed in BGNerdom. In fact for someone who claims she was rooting for her characters, BGN was surprised that Iris West even had fans. She portrayed the IWDS as a sort of shadowy monolith waiting in the darkest parts of twitter, waiting to victimize poor folks who share unpopular opinions.
Remember when she claimed she was open to civil disagreements? She isn’t.
Here are the tweets that BGN is referencing when she claims that’s she’s been bullied. She claimed not to post them to respect anonymity, but the truth is that no one was bullying her. In fact the last three, they were specifically speaking out abuse from fandoms.
Here are more tweets that FilmFatale_NYC and BGN claim were bullying and worthy of wishing violence on other black girls.
Here are tweets made after BGN blocked them for having the audacity to disagree with her and she wished violence on them. [Note: ActsofFaith is not a member of the IWDS. She is a black woman who has been demeaned by BGN in the past— See a pattern?]
Meanwhile here are the things that the IWDS fights against.
The fact is that BGN is painting the IWDS with a brush that racists and people who propagate misogynoir has used against black women for an eternity: They are Angry Black Girls. This isn’t true of course. Their go to when encountering Iris hate is simply asking why.
Whois The Iris West Defense Squad?
Thefirst evidence I have of anyone in the Iris West fandom makingcontact with BlackGirlNerds was 2 weeks ago, when a twitter user asked BGN if she’d be interested in highlighting Iris West and talk about the difficulties that particular character experienced. Most of which is Misogynoir. There was no response from BGN.
A week later, Bustle a social media and lifstyle website, published an article by Angelica Bastien with a section dedicated racism in the Flash Fandom. It introduced the Iris West Defense Squad, a team of WoC, mostly black, dedicated to defending Iris West’s right to exist.
The group was formed to fight against hate that Iris and her actress, Candice Patton, received online. Both fans and Candice herself have received a near constant litany of hate for her character. Most of it is racial.
They gained popularity, most notably when Orlando Jones reached out to them and asked to team up with Sleepyheads and help a trending event to Renew Sleepy Hollow. In fact Iris West fans have been acknowledged and reached out to by several fandoms for trending worldwide nearly every week. The most successful run was 6 worldwide trends in 5 weeks. Since then they’ve been talking to members of other fandoms, scheduling trends with the explicit goal of uplifting and protecting black women on TV.
BGN claims that they are bullies, and not fans. They claim that don’t care about the quality of her character. Since BGN didn’t bother to ask them, I did.
“She’s the female lead, right? I want her to be treated the way a white leading lady would” - Anonymous
"I want her to have agency, a point of view and screentime. I want her have an active role in her own story and I want to see deep and meaningful moments.” - W.
”I want Iris to be a fully realized character. She should be allowed to have every human emotion, whether it be anger, jealousy,fear, happiness and even pettiness. I want her to have agency over her sexuality and not be demonized.” - Kerrigan
BGN’s claim that Iris fans are incapable of taking constructive criticism is the probably the boldest lie in her hit piece. There are at least 4 hashtags (#DoYouHaveADaughterJoe, #WeNeedToTalkAboutIris, #WhereIrisWest and #IrisWestDeservesBetter.) completely dedicated to criticizing inconsistent writing, the lack of Iris’ POV and the general fact the show doesn’t seem to know what to do with her. The people who are constantly critiquing Iris and her interactions with other characters are Iris West Fans. They want more for her.
BGN’S Motive.
By all accounts, the IWDS and BGN interacted one tuesday, last week. Yet for the last week, she’s been seeming baiting them, subtweeting hourly, and continuously retweeting only those who agrees with her. Why is she so hell bent on painting the IWDS in a negative light?
BGN’s article was never mentioned or announced until hours after a member from IWDS announced that they’d be starting a podcast specifically about women of color on television.
This podcast would have 4 members of various fandoms: Empire, Scandal, Sleepy Hollow, The Vampire Diaries, Teen Wolf, and yes, The Flash. From what we know, it’s a round table featuring all black women who will discuss plot lines, writing quality, erasure, and misogynoir towards characters.
I can’t help but wonder if BGN feels a threatened by a show that wants to uplift black women on TV while at the same time constructively criticizing the writing and overall quality, seeing as BGN is getting by solely on snarky tweets with no substance.
By all accounts, this podcast if successful would be everything BGN claims to represent, except this show would contain depth, and at it’s core it would uplift black women on television, something that BGN is seemingly incapable of doing.
How can we trust BGN to support black women, when she’s trying to find a come up by tearing down and slandering black women in real life?
I think it's a good time to bring this back.




















