Super Mario : How Nintendo Conquered America
Few things are more grating than having an author regurgitate another author's work with less detail and competence. That's what Mr. Ryan manages to do with his book, Super Mario. The first half is largely a rehash of Game Over by David Sheff. If you haven't read Game Over, read it. It's a great book on the early days of Nintendo and how a hanafuda card company went on to dominate the video game industry.
Sheff's research is original and gives us an inside look into the players and events associated with Nintendo's rise to power. Ryan doesn't. Once he's expended Sheff's content, he largely sticks to giving us a bland run down of the games Nintendo has released. I don't need a journalist to tell me what Donkey Kong Country was like. I played it. I lived through it. I remember reading about it in Nintendo Power. And Ryan can't come up with anything that wasn't covered in gaming magazines of the era. Would it have killed him to interview some of the players? I realize the language barrier between English and Japanese is formidable, but he could have at least interviewed people at Nintendo of America. Harris did it for Console Wars. Why should Ryan get a pass?Ā
Ryan's run down of Nintendo's games isn't even that good. He describes Super Smash Bros Melee as follows: "[Melee] would have been unbearably in-jokey and obscure, if millions of fans weren't winningly enthusiastic about being able to, say, have the Ice Climbers attack Mr. Game N Watch with Ness's home run bat in the Pokemon Stadium, to win a Super Scope." Melee's reviews during it's release were largely positive, and these days Melee ranks on everyone's best Gamecube games list and is still being played in tournaments by die hard fans. One wonders if Ryan has played a game in the past twenty years. He describes Mario Sunshine's shadow Mario as being similar to Shadow the Hedgehog. Has he not heard of dark Link? Pretty sure that's where Nintendo drew its inspiration from.
Anyway, the book's not worth the paper it's printed on.














