Preface: I’m really new to whump and I know nothing about this. I’m willing to be proved wrong on all the point that I will make, just please be kind
Ok, now that’s over with, I’d like to say, that I don’t really understand the appeal of the ‘boy boxed universe’.
I talked about it with my bf earlier, and I’ve got several bones to pick:
1.) Logistically in a world building setting it doesn’t make sense. There would have to be a BIG societal leap to having human pets normalized. There’s prob works that show these big changes, but from the stories I’ve seen so far I haven’t seen them.
What happened? Why did keeping a human pet become a societal norm in universe? Is this a recent event, or were people just doing this since we started living in caves?
What the fuck are whumpers doing for work??? How do they have all this extra money to feed a lil guy in their home?? That’s a lot of money, it’s like raising a kid. And that’s on top of torture equipment. I just KNOW the economy is fucked because of this. I don’t know a lot about economy stuff, but Im not sure how half the labor force being kept in cages is helping money problems
“Think of the children!!” No seriously think of the children. They are living in a world where it’s normalized to be kidnapped. Their options are to be kept inside their whole lives or be taken by creeps. Do parents just not love their children in this universe, do they sell them off at a young age?? If they are kept inside their whole lives, doesn’t that emotionally stunt them? Is this what fuels the in-universe normalized whump fire? Children growing up emotionally stunted and not knowing how to regulate their feelings, resulting in adults who torture people?? That makes sense. but seriously, do parents go out to the mall with their family and see a dude on a leash being dragged by another dude?
From the stories I’ve seen so far, possession of a whumpee is free for all. If you steal them from someone, they are yours now. That doesn’t make sense?? If society is gonna run like this and STILL have a system of justice, an ownership system has to be established. You’ve kidnapped your whumpee, now you have to register them and fill out paperwork to the IRS about tax deductibles.
Feel free to skip this part, IK it’s stupid to talk about human rights when talking about Whump. But seriously, WTH is happening with human rights???? Not EVERYONE is going to whip their pet on a daily basis, and it’s gonna freak someone out each time they see someone walking around with burned skin, or barbed wire, ect. Is some of the abuses that occur looked on in disgust? Is there a law system saying you can’t do certain things to your pet? If this thing is a recent event, is there people who are vehemently against it? Is there a group of caretakers that provide safe havens? HOW normalized is this? Does everyone have a pet or is it just an occasional practice? If basic human rights are being ignored, what’s happening to lgbt rights? Women’s rights? Racial rights?
Is there websites to get a whumpee? Is this more like Facebook market place or Tinder? Can you match with your whumpee, and if so does whumpee consent to this or no. Do they list themselves or does someone else do it for them
2.) Idk Im just not a big fan of it. I’m willing to be proved wrong, but normalization of human pets kinda bores me. As my bf said, it removes the horror of the situation. Kidnapping someone should be a deeply terrifying practice, and if it’s widespread it loses the fun. Plus, I like the stories where torture is an intimate thing. It’s no fun if you are being tortured by a regular shmo, it needs to be someone who’s unhealthily obsessed with you and wants to forcefully explore limits
Yea idk, willing to be proved wrong, and please feel free to send me works that explore these world building things!!
Thanks for interesting questions! I’m biased since I write in the BBU and I really enjoy it, particularly for the interesting collective worldbuilding. 😁 But not everyone is into that and the BBU is a sandbox without collective rules, so everyone can do their own thing and this is just my take.
I think changes which already are seen in the world has grown even worse in the BBU, rich people have gotten wealthier, poor people poorer. Cooperations have gained even more power and influence and money- fuelled lobbying has really affected political decisions. Changes to the labour market (AI and automatisation, perhaps?) have increased unemployment and created a group of people who aren’t really needed on the work market, but instead of shortened working hours (like a 30 hour work week to share available jobs), increased taxation of profits (from, for example automatisation) and strengthened welfare states (free healthcare and education, perhaps universal basic income) people without resources have basically been left to fend for themselves. Desperate people are willing to do desperate things - historically people have gone to workhouses or even to prison to avoid starving.
The big multinational company WRU has a lot of money to put on marketing, and they work hard to make becoming a pet seem like an attractive choice, sure, you won’t be a person, but you will live a life in luxury, you will have an owner who dotes on you, on-the-job-training suited to your talents and interests and all the creature comforts you might want. As an added bonus, you will forget all about a potentially traumatic past, and if you have any mental health or physical health problems, WRU will use its full expertise to fix them for you. You will be happy.
But not everyone can become a pet. The company is selective, they want beautiful, talented people who can please their wealthy patrons. If you are chosen into the program, you are lucky.
There are some rumours of bad things happening, sure, people being kidnapped and forced to join, pets being ill-used and even killed, but those things are obviously not legal. If they happen sometimes and the wealthy people pay their way through, well, corruption is to blame. In my version of the BBU, you are not allowed to abuse pets (though you may use physical discipline and have sex with them if they are trained for it) but it is hard to prove anything and wealthy owners and the company itself usually gets away with things. Also, they did sign up for it, so the general public is less concerned.
I don’t think everyone can become a pet, the WRU only selects candidates that they think they can sell. The training process is intense and requires trained (and unscrupulous) staff and is very expensive. In my version of the BBU, pets are fairly rare, mostly only wealthy people have them, and they are important status symbols. A few second hand pets might find their way to a middle-class or even poor owner, but there are no armies of human pets working in the service industry, for example. I don’t think that all owners are very abusive, but the whole act of owning a pet is dehumanising in itself.
Pets are seen as others, not really fit to be decision-making humans. This is, in my view, not that unrealistic. People that have been or are being seen like that in some parts of the world right now include but are not limited to: women, people of certain ethnicities, indigenous peoples, homosexual people, people with mental health issues, poor people and so on. It is apparently not that hard to single out a group of people and make others see them as different and less-than.
People do go to the mall and see pets, sometimes, it is seen as normal. You also see pets in movies/on tv. I explore the whole children/pet dynamic here and here.
You can not just kidnap a pet, though, again, if you are wealthy and influential enough I guess you might get away with it. You get registered as the owner of your pet and you are legally responsible for anything the pet does. (Like if your dog bites someone it is your fault.)
You buy your pet from WRU (or another competitor), you can choose them from a website and have them custom-trained for you. The pet doesn’t get to choose.
Lydia & Coriander - my main story in the WRU starts here. It is primary a recovery story but I enjoy worldbuilding so there’s quite a bit of that.
Here are some WRU writers with a focus on worldbuilding to check out.
@ashintheairlikesnow has written lots of interesting wordbuilding and also focused a lot on an underground resistance to the human pet trade: https://www.tumblr.com/ashintheairlikesnow/623908755816497152/masterlists-masterpost
@hold-him-down has a well-written and complex recovery arc that also takes sea some political questions in The Fighter: https://www.tumblr.com/hold-him-down/663890614856876032/summary-contains-18-content-institutionalized
@deluxewhump has a story in a frat house setting that also contains a lot of worldbuilding.
I also want to stress that we all like different things, and it is totally okay not to like WRU. :)
This was a bit of a ramble…😄 Perhaps other people have more things to add?

















