Broken Lens Reviews: 'Watchmen' Episodes 1-4
Comics, comics, comics. People love them, myself included, and few comics are as beloved as Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons' 'Watchmen'. Being a casual comic reader myself, I'll admit that I didn't actually read the thing until hype for the Zack Snyder film was in full swing; the visuals and tone of the trailers sparking my interest for the source material. It's not an easy read. It's gruesome, political, and wordy in its philosophical musings. I loved it and I loved the idea of messy superheroes. What would a superhero do in the real world? In a way, it's the opposite of franchise comic book movies. Most franchise super films make us feel transported into a world where men can fly. The original Watchmen made us feel as if superheroes were thrown into our world, a messy one that doesn't have the clear moral lines of say, Superman. Alan Moore has been vocal about his disdain for film and television adaptations of his work, and for good reason. The problem with HBO's Watchmen is that it doesn't need to exist. The original was so satisfying with its morally ambiguous ending, we really didn't need to see anymore. I always wanted to cosplay as Rorshach, now not so much. I love that the show tackles white supremacy and the Tulsa Massacre, I just wish one of my favorite comic characters' legacy wasnt reduced to fodder for the new Klan. It just doesn't make much sense to me and feels like a slap in the face to Alan Moore. It's beautifully shot, check out the 'American Hero Story' segment to see what I mean. It presents some new, interesting ideas. But reducing the events of Watchmen to a rural Oklahoma town seems to take away from the scope of the original. It's also clunky in its narrative, giving us segments of a now deranged and trapped Ozymandias that seems to have nothing to do with the rest of the plot. Its messages seem to be in your face rather than subtle. What's disappointing about the show is it's wasted potential. Watchmen has been reduced to such a small scale that it seems smothered. Without the original graphic novel, we wouldn't have Garth Ennis' gritty 'The Boys', but now, The Boys on Amazon has become the Watchmen we truly deserve, updated for today. If you want a dark, twisted, and modern take on superheroes gone bad, stick to The Boys. It asks the question "who watches the Watchmen?" better than HBO's attempt to cash in on a popular title.
















