pairings: billy loomis x reader x stu macher, slight randy meeks x reader
warnings: swearing, sex, and cheatingā¦thats about it
a/n: this is my FIRST writing on here. I hope you all like it.
words: 2,396 + not proofread
and for you I keep my legs apart. and forget about my tainted heart.
the dark lightning was softening the edges of you allās features, but the candleās glow illuminating you all in innocent way.
there was nothing innocent about tonight though.
Sidneyās and Tatumās eyes both big and filled with mirth, Stuās eyes shining mischievously, Randyās eyes traced the shadows from the candleās flickering flame on your face, and Billyās eyes somehow getting deeper, but not giving any emotion.
āso y/n,ā Tatum began, ātruth or dare?ā
letting out a nervous giggle you paused before answering.
the dare could lead to awkwardness to come and the truth would do the same.
double edged sword in all honesty.
āuhhhā¦ā you mumbled to yourself.
ācome on sweetheart.ā Stu pestered before sticking his tongue out at you teasingly.
āyeah donāt keep us waiting. whatever it is isnāt that bad.ā Billy said peeking at you through his hair.
āwell I wouldnāt say that.ā Randy butted in. āit could be something unsanitary or flat out disgusting.ā this led to multiple groans around the room.
āsince when did I do things like that?!ā Tatum said in an exasperated tone.
ān-no. I just meanā¦okay I donāt know what I mean, but itās possible.ā Randy shrugged and gave a sheepish grin at the frowning blonde. she flipped him off from her place beside Stu.
āanyways!ā Sidney spoke up. ātruth or dare y/n?ā
āuh dare?ā you more so asked.
āthen dare it is. y/n I dare you to make out with Randy.ā Tatum said as she wiggled her eyebrows at you.
her and Sidney had been trying to get you and Randy together for a while now. now was their chance.
turning to gaze at the boy who was in front of you, you let a tight lipped smile go towards him.
his eyes searched your face before he reached out towards you. his hand reaching out to your face as you both pulled to your knees.
āif you donāt want to do this itās fine.ā he said before he dipped his head down. your lips both so close.
āitās okay.ā you whispered before his lips found yours.
you felt his hands trail from your face down to your neck and into your hair. his tongue pushed at your bottom lip after awhile before you granted him access. he tasted sweet like the candy you ate during the random horror movie you all had long forgotten.
āokay itās been long enough donāt you guys think?ā Stu said with one of his hands toying at his ear.
Tatum rolled her eyes at her boyfriends actions. she began to question his reasoning. there was no big deal.
ānaaah. let them go a little lon-ā
āokay thats enough.ā Billy said cutting her off in his monotone voice.
Sidney didnāt see the issue. āBill-ā
āItās enough!ā Billy exclaimed, shocking and silencing both Tatum and Sidney.
and at that, both of your lips parted with a pop before you backed back to your spot between Stu and Billy.
the kiss wasnāt bad at all. itās just something was off.
āwell that took forever.ā Tatum joked. Randyās face was tinted red under the low lighting. you felt yourself get hot in embarrassment at her words.
āanyways,ā Billy began as he sat up from his slouched position. āy/n give somebody a dare.ā
Randy spoke up at that. āItās truth OR dare. she can giveā¦ā
you tuned out at that point. you paid attention to your nails that needed a fill. that was way more interesting than hearing Billy and Randy go at it.
suddenly you felt Stuās hand on your soft thigh. looking up at him you saw him throw a grin at you.
āyou good?ā he asked you. you mustāve been zoned out for too long. you have him a smile smile and a nod before you felt another hand on your opposite thigh. looking over you saw Billy staring at you.
āgo ahead and dare him to do something.ā he told you.
you didnāt want to be mean and you werenāt good at being too creative when put on the spot. you went with something simple and not too bad.
āumm I dare you to tell us something youāve never told anyone before.ā you said.
āoh lord.ā Randy groaned as Carrie screamed on the TV near him.
āoh this is gonna be good.ā Sidney laughed before leaning in to hear the story.
yet here you were with both of your best friends boyfriendās hands still on your inner thighs caressing everything, but that one spot.
āopen wide sweetheart.ā Stu mumbled as he dropped down in your ear.
Stu and Billy both opened your legs wider before Stu dipped his hands to pull at your fishnets. Billy coughed to cover up the sound of them ripping a bit before Stu pushed his hand into your light blue panties.
this was all happening within a close proximity of your closet friends. each girlfriend having no idea about their respective boyfriend touching you.
you went to close your legs before Billyās grip tightened on your right leg. he used one of his hands to push up the jean mini skirt you wore before moving it back to his lap.
ākeep it open for him baby.ā he whispered to you.
Stuās fingers swirled over your clit before reaching down and wetting his fingers with some of your wetness that was quickly pooling in the seat of your panties.
your breathing quickened and the black zipped up jacket you had been wearing was getting too hot. you quickly reached up to unzip the clothing a bit, your nails tapping at the metal. clearing your throat to cover up a moan as you went along.
āwait you really did that?!ā Sidney exclaimed.
Tatum sat beside her boyfriend and had no idea of his actions beside her. Randy was right in front of you and had no idea either. Poor Sid didnāt notice your leg in her boyfriends lap, placed right beside where his right hand gripped her left one. Billy and Stu engaged in the conversation every now and then.
you started to bite your lip to muffle your moans. you being silent during a story wasnāt out of the ordinary.
however, you could start to hear your wetness and you wondered how long it would be before the others did too.
āthats it pretty baby.ā Stu mumbled to you. ācreaming all over daddies fingers like a good little slut.ā
with a shaking hand you reached down to grip onto Stuās wrist as you started to drip around him.
ānew game!ā Tatum said over all of the groups chatter.
with that you let your lip go, sighed in relief, and went to grab at the side of your jacket that had fallen down over your shoulder.
āhide or seek. not it!ā She quickly said, you, Sid, and Randy following suit.
Billy and Stu just looked at the rest of the group with bored expressions.
āwell I guess itāll be you two seeking?ā Randy smirked.
āyeah.ā Sidney laughed before Tatum blew the candles out and you all dispersed. the sound of shoes hitting the floor, doors closing, and giggles booming in each direction.
shakily standing you went to pull your skirt down before you felt two bodies cage you in.
suddenly the candle was relit and Billy was pulling you up onto Stuās couch.
āI- I gotta go.ā you said looking behind you at the boy. his girlfriend and the rest of your friends were all in the house hidden. they could come in at any moment.
ānot yet baby.ā Billy said as he unzipped your jacket again. stopping at the sight of you in a thin tank top and no bra.
āyou wanted this?ā he asked and he pulled the top down to expose your breast and scrunched the rest of it at the top down to your waist. your back was flush against his chest and suddenly your legs were pushed back.
Stu had positioned himself between your legs before pulling your skirt off, ripping your fishnets the rest of the way, and pushing your panties to the side.
āyouāre so pretty and wet baby girl.ā he said as he ran his fingers from your clit to your hole.
he pushed your legs up more, Billy grabbing them the rest of the way and pulling back, your socks and shoes closer by your face.
you were truly exposed in Stuās living room for anyone to see.
a warm wet lick met your clenching heat.
āohhh fuck Stu. pleaseā¦ā you begged. Billy groaned over you before he reached down to play with your nipples.
āyouāre so soft.ā he whispered.
the noise of the random horror movie playing drowned out your whimpers and their praises from anyone in the other rooms.
Stu groaned into your pussy. pulling back from it with his lips pink and wet.
āshe tastes so fucking good Bill.ā he said staring intently at Billyās eyes.
with that Billy pinched your nipples as lent over to kiss him making you loudly moan.
pulling away, he started shushing you and rubbing your legs as Stu started back swirling his long tongue around your clit.
ānot too loud baby.ā he said with a glint in his eye.
suddenly Stu completely moved back and sat down on the edge of the couch. Billy leaned forward and pushed you up with him.
āass up baby girl.ā Billy said before roughly putting your face in Stuās lap and angling your hips up to meet his. looking up you saw Stu rubbing himself.
āhere babes.ā he said before angling and tapping your plump lips with his dick before sliding the head into your warm mouth, groaning in the process.
you started to lick and suck on him before you could hear and feel Billy pushing into into you.
you moaned around Stuās length while Billy muttered your name. you were so tight and so wet from Stuās previous teasing.
he started quickly thrusting into you. his force pushing you deeper and deeper into Stuās lap.
āfuck baby.ā Stu moaned as he watched you spit all over him before taking him back down your throat. you all had to be quick and quiet.
you didnāt get the memo though when Billy did a particularly deep thrust into you that hit your spot.
āshitttt daddy!ā you yelped as hell repeatedly hit that spot over and over. ābill I wanna cum. I wanna cum please.ā you said as you shakily reached a hand back up to stroke Stu.
Billy pulled your hips up higher before pushing his hand into the middle of your back. Stu tweaked at your nipples while his head was thrown back and he panted.
you started babbling and moaning uncontrollably as you felt him hit your spot over and over again, your pussy gushing around him. both of your juices pooling between your thighs and at the base of his dick.
āshhh sweetheart.ā Stu kept telling you. āI know it feels good, but Sidney would cry if she saw you like this. Tatum would throw a fit and Randy would be crushed.ā he told you as he pushed your hair back and out of your beautiful face.
you bit your lips as his thrusts made your eyes roll back. it was getting closer and closer and Stu could tell by your hand repeatedly stalling along with your constant moving.
ācum all over his dick sweetheart.ā Stu encourage you.
āthatās it baby. cum for me pretty girl. thatās It baby.ā Billy said as he grabbed at your neck to pull your back up to him.
your legs were shaking and in pain but you could feel your high coming.
ānut all over this dick baby. itās yours sweetheart. let it go.ā Billy groaned into your ear. reaching a hand down fo run tight circles around your puffy clit.
when it hit you squeezed your eyes tight and whined as your pussy spasmed around Billyās dick. your cum leaking onto the couch.
āmmmm fuck.ā Stu mumbled as he watched you cum around his best friend.
you felt Stuās cum splash on your titties and Billy cum in you.
you started to buck against Billy from the overstimulation and his final strokes.
ātake all of it baby. you can do it.ā he said grinding his hips into your ass. his hand slid from down your neck, and onto your chest. wiping up Stuās cum and bringing it all to your lips.
āyou look so pretty all fucked out like that.ā Stu said pulling your face up to see him and pushing your hair back and out of your face once again.
your eyes were watery and your lips were plump as they sucked Billyās fingers. Stuās cum at the corner of your lips.
Stu dreamily gazed at you before his eyebrows raised.
āoh yeah, oh yeah.ā Stu said suddenly remembering the predicament before hand.
āwhat?ā Billy asked as he pushed his fingers deep in your mouth. smiling when a tear fell and you gagged.
āthe game dude.ā Stu said quickly zipping up his pants and grabbing at you to fix your clothes back on properly. his knuckles running against your sensitive nipples when he brought your tank top up. squeezing at your boobs once done and then grazing at the tops of your tired thighs when trying to fix your skirt.
āshit!ā Billy muttered suddenly pulling out of you making you bend over in a heap. he picked your panties up off the floor and turned you around to put them on you. he noticed your pussy leaking and clenching around nothing. after pushing the panties up he tapped your pussy. him and Stu laughing at your body trembling.
āI want you to wait on this couch, sit in those panties, and feel me drip out of you.ā he said as he repositioned his own clothing.
Stu bent down and kissed you. āI know you can still taste me on you. just sit there, like the good little slut you are, and look pretty.ā he told you as he stood back up to his full height.
Billy then went down to kiss you too. once he unattached himself they both gave you a one over.
āyou look tired sweetheart. take a nap.ā Stu suggested.
āready or not!ā Billy called into the air.
āhere we come.ā Billy and Stu both yelled.
izzy806
andulkaphoto
tangentwithtanner
yousharknotpass
romaincrisis
