I went to see the Army therapist, a friendly female officer, slightly older than the colonel. She said that she was a professional psychologist, and even though this chat had been arranged by my superior officer, I could speak freely, there would be no record, nothing I said would ‘leave the room’. She did know my file, so she knew how I got to where I was now.
I was, then, very vulnerable. The angry outburst by the colonel, with that threat of posting me somewhere far way in the jungle, for years to come, had shaken me badly. At the same time I couldn’t really get my head around my own feelings. Was this really what I wanted? A healthy young European 15-year old, wanting to 'serve and ‘obey’, wanting to kneel for Army officers, polish their floors, polish their boots, stand to attention for hours holding a briefcase? No social life, no interaction with other cadets? Uniform every day? Standing to attention in your own room, to fill the time before you could go to bed? I knew I did all that because I wanted to do that – but at the time I never knew exactly what made me want it.
The meeting would have a profound effect, perhaps even a devastating one.
‘I understand you’ve had a bit of a discussion with your commanding officer?’
‘Yes Ma’m. About my duties, mostly, Ma’m. It’s just too much for me, Ma’m, it’s too much work, I can’t deal with it all, and I’m really alone in that house, and ... ’
‘Well, I have to serve the colonel, but I also have to take care of his son, and I have no idea how to do that, I mean I can’t raise that boy to be a soldier, make him obey every little order, I can see he’s not happy with all that.’
‘I see. That may be a burden to you, indeed. Let’s take a step back, if I may. I know from your file that your school cadet corps went to national finals, you went to conviviality meetings, you volunteered for Elite Camp, you were proud to go there a second time. Your superiors note that you never failed to do the honorary guard at night, your behavior was always exemplary, and so on – am I wrong to think you wanted to be a real cadet and do everything that means, including serve senior officers?’
‘Yes Ma’m, but I guess I didn’t quite understand what that would mean, I mean I was fine with doing Mess & Household in Camp or in the Officer’s Mess, but now it seems the colonel is going to make this my career, or at least what I have to do for the next years.’
‘Well, my parents and I had other ideas about what to do after school, go back to Europe with my family, go to university maybe, not this life.’
‘Yes, but at the same time, you chose this life?’
‘Well, yes, but now my officer says I could now be posted anywhere, or even as a regular soldier somewhere in the jungle for years…’
‘And you don’t like that prospect?’
‘No Ma’m, I mean I am a good cadet, but I can’t be just a soldier somewhere in the jungle for the next years, I mean I’m not even a Malay national, Ma’m.’
‘What would you like to see happen, then?’
‘I don’t know, Ma’m, I mean I don’t want to throw in the towel, I love being a cadet, I love the uniform, everything, but maybe I should be sent home, figure out a way to live with Dad, maybe with a housekeeper, just do cadet drill at school, like the other boys.’
‘Before we get to that, let me ask you something else. You have sworn an oath of obedience only a few months ago. What does that mean to you now?’
‘Well, I was proud to do that, but I think now I didn’t really know what it meant, I also didn’t understand what it meant that the Army was now my legal guardian, and not my Dad, so there is the big mistake, Ma’m.’
‘A mistake, perhaps, cadet.’
‘Let me ask you another thing. You’ve been a cadet for almost four years now, first in school, then in the Program. At every step you were taught to follow orders, to be obedient, to serve.’
‘I believe you were part of a group of boys who chose to wear the uniform at all times, is that right?’
‘Yes Ma’m, a bunch of us at school, we were very keen to do well in cadet drill, Ma’m. It became a bit of a game for us, I guess, we outdid each other in looking perfect, that kind of thing.’
‘So what does obedience mean to you, now?’
‘Well, … I guess… I’m still young, 15, so I’m not really an adult, still a child, in a way, and I have to accept that I have to learn things, how to deal with my superiors, or my betters, how to be a good member of society, things like that, and I guess I have to obey what other people tell me to do, until I am older.’
‘Hmm, yes, but that sounds very… practical to me. Didn’t you feel anything else, when it comes to obedience?’
‘Something stronger than just doing what your teachers tell you to do?’
‘Can you tell me when you felt that?’
That came out surprisingly easily.
‘When I was in Camp, doing these endless drills, in the heat, you know, long marches, my brain just went numb at times Ma'm. It just shut down, all I felt was the rhythm of the march, left right left right left right, and all I could see was the neat hairline of the cadet before me, marching, and all I could think of was that at the end of the march we’d have uniform inspection and even after 20K my tie had to be in its proper position and did I need a haircut perhaps…’
‘What do you mean by numb?’
‘Well, yes, Ma’m, something like that, it was sometimes… as if my body was just my body, marching as ordered, dressed as ordered, and my body was just sort of carrying my brain, but it was not important what I was thinking or feeling, my body just carried on…’
‘If I were to say that this numbness means that you internalised obedience, at that time, what would you say?’
‘I suppose that was what it was, maybe, Ma’m, it was just… It was numb, but… I don’t know, it was also clear, natural, simple. I stopped thinking, I guess.’
‘Indeed. So looking back at what you’ve told me about your life now, with this family, trying to be a good house servant, a good Mess&Household servant, and do your schoolwork at the same time, everything about it indicates that you find it easy to obey orders, to do as you’re told.’
‘I don’t know really, Ma’m.’
‘I think you do. I think you’ve told me about that moment of clarity, marching in the jungle, to tell me that this is what is on you mind now – you struggle with your duties in the colonel’s household, and you are confused by your reluctance to really engage with those duties, and at the same time you remember that clarity, the moment everything made sense to you. So now something is holding you back, right? Could that be true?
I had to think about that, for a bit. Clearly the therapist knew exactly how to dig deeper into my feelings, pushing all the right buttons.
‘I don’t mind work, Ma’m and I don’t mind orders, Ma’m, but it’s just too much, and then the boy… I really don’t think I can go on doing this, Ma’m.’
‘I disagree, cadet-student. I can clearly see you are selling yourself short. You are a wonderful cadet, and a very promising one too, precisely because of this experience. The one thing that gets in your way, I think, is that you still have an idea of yourself as ‘better’ than all the rest.’
‘And I believe this is what your superiors have been telling you before. You are a foreign national, or you were one, and you’ve grown up in rather privileged circumstances, these diplomatic services. People probably liked you, and told you you were a special boy, perhaps?
‘Well, yes, it was just how we lived, Ma’m, I was expected to do well, dress decently, we had school uniforms of course…’
‘Right. And in cadets you discovered that discipline and order and obedience are really what you needed, what you wanted to experience. Am I right?’
She was right. She nailed it. And then she went even deeper.
‘So now things are difficult for you. Without your own family, away from your old life, in this very disciplined household. And you suddenly feel you can’t obey anymore? Is it the work, or is it your pride?’
‘Well, no, or I don't know, I just can’t do it all, in that house, Ma’m. Even when I’m doing everything right I get corrected and punished, and the colonel keeps adding chores and duties, and it takes all the time I need for laundry and housework, and for schoolwork, and then the son comes home and just drops everything, takes off his uniform, which is not allowed, and goes on playing videogames, and…’
‘Yes, yes. I’m aware that you have a lot on your plate. I think a word to the colonel about that is in order, leave that to me, cadet-student’.
‘Really Ma’m, that would be great, Ma’m, but I still think that I…’
‘Yes, cadet-student, I know you want out, you want your Dad.’
Again, tears in my throat.
‘But that’s not going to happen, cadet-student.’
‘No, son. For me, and I think for the colonel, but certainly for the Army, it would be a terrible waste. I can see that by just looking at you: you’re uniform is spotless, the knot in your tie is perfect, the crease in your sleeves is sharp, you are the very image of a good cadet. They have all invested in you, made it possible for you to be who you really are, a wonderful cadet, who will become, perhaps, in the near future, a wonderful servant to someone high-up. Surely you understand that it would be wrong for us to change course now, cadet?’
‘Do you understand, cadet-student?’
‘But that’s not the main reason. You are going to stay, and serve, because the hard truth, cadet, is that that is what you really are.’
‘You are going to face up to that truth, cadet, and you’ll embrace it, and you’ll let your superiors take you to where you really need to be.’
‘Face the truth, dear boy: you are not special. You are nothing, yet. Don’t be afraid of that. Just follow what’s really inside you. Tell me yourself, cadet student. Let me hear it from you. Tell me what you are.'
By now I was close to tears, and shaking. I felt the answer come up inside me, undeniably, I was going to say it, and then I said it.
'Ma'm, I want to be a good cadet, Ma'm.'
'And I want to serve my superiors, Ma'm'
‘Because I’m nothing, Ma’m. Just stupid Ma’m.’
‘I’m a proud stupid boy, Ma’m. I just need someone to teach me, make me obey and serve, Ma’m’
In tears, now. She let me sob a bit.
‘So this resistance of yours, against what the Army and the colonel are asking from you, what’s that?’
‘It’s stupid and wrong, Ma’m. I’m so sorry, Ma’m’
'Again, please say so yourself, cadet student. Let me hear it from you.'
[By now I really was crying.]
'I'm... I want to be a good cadet, Ma'm. I want to serve my superiors, Ma'm.'
'Because I want to be obedient, Ma'm.'
'Please Ma'm, I want to be an obedient boy, Ma'm.’
She finally let me be. I sat and sobbed.
‘Well, that was quite the confession, cadet. I’m pleased that you were ready to let it all come out.’
‘Now, dry your eyes, blow your nose. I have feeling you’ll feel relieved after this, cadet. Now, as I said, everything we talked about is private, of course, but I will have a word with the colonel about your concerns regarding his son – it may be wise to leave the actual parenting to him, I think. And then you must settle down and do the work as ordered, cadet-student. No more tantrums'.
‘So, I hope that clears things up for you, cadet?’
‘What’s your first task when you get home?’
‘Home, Ma’m? I guess serving the family at dinner, Ma’m’
‘Good. But I also recommend that you ask permission to speak to the colonel, and tell him what you told me, apologise for your request. I’m sure he’ll see reason. Just remember that march, looking at the cadet in front of you. Nothing else. You are a cadet, you serve. Nothing else matters. I know that you will be happy that way.’
I was just too exhausted and stupefied to say anything else. I got up and came to attention, so she could dismiss me.