Love Letter to Stranger Things #7
Show appropriate trigger warnings: child and partner abuse
Thank you for Joyce Byers.
I actually have a lot of feelings about Joyce, for personal reasons I won't explicitly share here. I think she is an excellent look at a mother though, especially one that was able to get her kids out alive with the domestic abuse from her spouse.
Ao apologies in advance this is bound to be more of a rambling letter.
We can infer some things about Lonnie, mostly that he uses physical intimidation/force to cause feelings of fear and helplessness (the way he pushes Jonathan into that wall, and Jonathan's reaction says multitudes), that he was emotionally abusive (the way he referred to Will), and manipulative (the whole coming back for the money thing/not actually wanting to spend time with Will).
Aside: I'm not sure if Jonathan checking the trunk is indicative of past abuse, or just Jonathan extrapolating from past abuse joined to the fact that Will was missing. Either way, I really don't want to look too hard at that.
We also know Joyce has some sort of anxiety attacks, based on some of Jonathan's words/actions (you cant shut down now scene) and even some of Lonnie's (how easily he convinces Joyce she is over-reacting) too.
As much as I hate that Joyce let Lonnie back into her home, it isn't uncommon for partners in domestic abuse situations to fall back with their abuser multiple times.
The point I am trying to make is that Joyce is clearly flawed. Joyce is realistic. I really appreciate this as so many times women breaking from partner abuse situations are put on this weird pedestal/victim glorification thing...
I don't think I am describing it correctly. It's like super gratuitous victimization or like "look at how wonderful this person is, how could anyone ever hurt them, look at how they are suffering-look at how they suffer" without really focusing on other aspects of their character or like, the fact that they made it out-they are a survivor. It's such a complex dynamic-surviving abuse that is- especially when children are witness to the dynamic also targeted. It's a road filled with doubt and guilt and fear and confidence/drive and just...
...I still don't think I am conveying my thoughts correctly. I hope some of my meaning is clear, though.
What I'm trying to say is, thank you for making Joyce have flaws and for showcasing some of this back and forth dynamic while still demonstrating how strong and loving Joyce Byers is.
Some abusers are attracted to these strong confident people-thrilled that they can exert power and control over this person; bend them to their will. And I think, the abusers also come to hate their targets a bit for it, even though the breaking was also their goal?
Anyway, Joyce is strong. I just really want to emphasize this. We don't know how, we just know Joyce is raising her two boys without Lonnie directly in the picture. This takes strength.
This is a point I really want to make about Joyce. We know the Byers weren't well off even with Lonnie in the picture- the Byers house is dated (but loving) and Lonnie lives somewhere even less prosperous.
Joyce is raising her 2 kids in the 80s by herself.
Women couldn't even own credit cards in the USA until 1976.
No fault divorce didn't happen until 1969- with the 1970s seeing a surge of divorces.
Based on these bits of information we can infer that Joyce left Lonnie probably as soon as she was able to provide a bit of financially stablity.
Joyce had young kids. She had to weigh the danger ot them about leaving an abusive spouse, especially one that was already physically intimidating (abusive) with them. Joyce had to weight being able to feed and clothe them on her own. Leaving an abusive partner here wasn't just about her- she had kids.
Leaving an abuser is the most dangerous step. Abuse is about control. There is nothing worse (to an abuser) than an abuser losing control over their target, their property. This is when people are most likely to be killed.
...That scene where Jonathan searches Lonnie's trunk for Will...
I have a lot of feelings on Joyce. She chose (?) to have kids with an abusive person. Her oldest child was parentified. She didn't protect her kids, or rather couldn't protect her kids until after the abuse had wormed its way into them.
And Joyce spends so much of her screentime "making up" for these "mistakes". I'm actually not saying this is a good thing. Overcorrecting is definitely a thing in situations like this- it doesn't nullify the abuse or even make up to those abused what they have suffered.
And that is why I love Joyce. Not because she is fiercely protective of her children. Not because her love for them is so obvious and definite and unconditional. Not because she is a badass. Those she is all of those things. I love her for this most important aspect: she is human.
Joyce is so, so human. She is so, so flawed. And so, so wonderful.
Joyce was created to be more than a victim, more than just a mother making up for years of guilt, more than just a virtuous mother.
Aside: this is why (though season 3 gives me serious issues with Hopper) her relationship with Hopper is so important. Her relationship with Bob was charming and sweet. And Bob was important too as he reminded her of her fire and passion- that it was okay and even venerable to be fierce. But Bob and her never came across as exceptionally passionate despite how loving they clearly were. Women, and mothers, are so often put into that Madonna/Mary complex that putting her with Hopper and still have her be Jonathan and Will and even El's mother (before she was even offically her caretaker) is such a great acknowledgement that mothers are just people too. People with love and passion and flaws.
So yeah, Stranger Things, thank you for creating Joyce as a fully rendered human being.
A human that is trying her best to navigate this scary, fluctuating world while keeping her loved ones safe.
Something we all strive towards.