I feel like this is the same rhetoric as not using disabled, disordered, fucked up, etc etc on yourself because other people have bad connotations and think that the only way anyone can use them is negative.
By the way, those are all terms I have used on myself and the things I make (as in the crafts I make are fucked up because they're made by me, they're not perfect and often they're not average either so I like calling them fucked up)
This also reminds me of my mother who always tells me not to call our cat fat because I'm being mean to her apparently.
Our cat is healthy but absolutely a giant cat (like 15 pounds!) and fluffy (with loose skin) so whenever she lays on her side she looks like a very fat baby (think chubby human baby if they're cute to you) and I tell her about how fat + adorable she looks whenever she lays on her side. (I'm not showing a picture because I'm slightly worried my family would be able to find it)
Also my mother has accused me of being degrading towards myself and the stuff I make because I call it fucked up. I am fucked up, the same woman (my mother) has called me fucked up and I've basically have been told my entire life that I'm weird, fucked up, and that there's something wrong with me.
If I can reclaim any other kind of insult, why not this one? What is so uniquely bad about this one that I'm not even allowed to call myself it?
I don't know if I would be considered deformed, maybe in the brain or somewhere you can't immediately tell by looking at me but I can't move the way "normal" people can, the people who have little to no impairment. Everyone has always been able to tell that, I'm slightly better at hiding it now but I can't hide it forever.
I mean, you can tell it from just looking at pictures of me. My ID picture is the most prominent (my two lazy eyes in opposite directions {one's super far off and the other is off enough to be noticeable}, a permanent head tilt because my brain won't process what I'm looking at if I don't have my head tilted, my face always slightly sagging from poor motor control, etc)
I'd say the one that comes out the most noticeable is whenever I hold things in my mouth (or just smile weird/"typically") my whole face twitches kinda fast, the muscles to move my cheeks and stuff I mean. People have commented on it / made weird faces at it a whole bunch and it's always something like "what are you doing?" (bewilderment usually) or that face some people make when they have to see weirdos in public (it's disgust, also I say weirdos because that's all they'll see us as, not like disabled, alternative, or anything)
I was truly hoping that this-is-ableism was just a type of person to not actually comment on a post (hence why it didn't say anything on the paraphilia ones) but not even checking this one? To see if they're even right about no deformities/etc?
I get differing opinions on use of insults and stuff but this is a "don't use this in reference to me as I don't like it" rather than "calling someone this is always bad, even if it's yourself". Forgive me for a second because I am starting a tangent and will be saying some things.
Tw for slurs, particularly the f-slur (indicates gayness), the t-slur (indicates transness), and the d-slur (indicates lesbianism)
If you try to apply it to slurs which may have a similar history to the term deformity like faggot or tranny then no one can, should, or should want to call themselves that and yet I know of people where that's the only label they'll use (sometimes providing their own alternative term if they know some friends don't like to say it or boundaries on who can actually call them it)
(I don't know the history of the term deformed but substitute the particular slurs how you would like, I use those two as one, I am both gay and trans, and two, those are the only ones I have personal experiences with as compared to some others I could technically reclaim but wouldn't actually feel right about using)
Hell, I'd say we should reclaim these terms as individuals who have complex emotions, both regarding the term itself and its use.
I barely use tranny because I felt for the longest time it didn't apply to me. I wasn't obviously transgender, hell, most people who'd call someone it as an insult don't even know that transmasculine exists (and they definitely don't know the naunces of plurality and intersex-ness in regards to it)!
To say that last part as in, tranny felt like it didn't apply to me because I wasn't a binary trans woman and back then (like 7-9 years ago now) that's all there was really, binary trans people. Height of people being accused of being "transtrenders" with trans men fighting against hella erasure and throwing others under the bus because that was what felt like the only way to make us be accepted.
I had worried for maybe a year about being a "transtrender". Honestly, I'd reclaim that one if I felt like it was being given more grace when it was seen but it's too heavily connected to transmedicalists that I don't think it's worth the effort.
Faggot is one that is a little weird for me to reclaim. I mean, now that I pass as a man most of the time (still obviously off somehow but I don't know if trans is what comes to people's mind, especially transmasculine) it feels a little more genuine and closer to me but. I've only really started passing consistently recently, like the past 2 years at most, when I started to grow a beard.
The d-slur for lesbians feels closer to what people see me as and closer to what I experience but, I'm definitively not lesbian. Or well, not in the expected ways anyway.
I identify with tranny because it feels very close to how I was treated for my gender non-conformity throughout my entire life (before too masculine for a little girl and now, too off to be a man but has a the scary features that make you one {loud, bearded [at times], weird looking [referring to the ID picture comments where ugly means dangerous], too confrontational, etc etc}) (too off to be a man as in, I wear my hair long with softer curls {sometimes}, my tones are a performance for the other person's comfort {men never care about others obviously [sarcasm]}, bubbly/cheerful, wears thigh highs with basketball shorts, etc etc)
I identify with faggot because well, that's what people see now. What else would they see when they see a person who's slightly effeminate and is "obviously supposed to be a man"? I mean, a freak but I'm usually called a freak for other reasons (usually not positive unless I'm saying it to myself)
I feel like I can't identify with the d-slur (indicates lesbianism) specifically because the way most describe it as a slur for lesbians. And I mean, it is, definitely. But the reason I was called it was never because they thought I was a lesbian.
It was usually because I was too loud, too caring for things they thought I shouldn't be, far far too queer and mentally ill, etc etc. I've been called a d-slur for being a feminist, for sharing that I wanted to be referred to with he/him while it was obvious I wasn't a man, for saying that I did like women while also being openly trans, and for some other things I can't remember / don't want to remember.
But, I'm not a woman, right? Well, not exactly woman and definitely not close enough to be calling myself a lesbian or d-slur without a whole ton of people switching to she/her and thinking I'm a trans woman instead.
Also on the topic of slurs and reclaiming them. Queer, also was a slur but has been reclaimed enough that most people don't consider it a slur. I don't considered disordered to be anything like an insult and I don't always remember that others can consider it an insult (also the same reason I accidentally tell people how their behaviors and trauma are connected)