Title:
- Dear, Only -
Chapter Eight:
Love, It Was Enough to Recognize
(Chapter title is from the song Fall In Love by Phantogram)
àŒ» ✠â±â đđđŹđđđ«đ„đąđŹđ âⰠ⟠àŒș
Pairing: ed warren x lorraine warren x fem!oc (clarice chenn)
Warnings: supernatural horror, references to infant death + sacrifice, suicide, haunting imagery, scary moment with a tape recorder
Disclaimers:
A lot of the original lore from The Conjuring film has been added onto with real facts.
The idea that the real Bathsheeba Shermon killed an infant, practiced witchcraft, or even lived on the property is untrue. This idea was built by the real Lorraine Warren, who insisted Bathsheeba was the sole reason for the evil in the house and was later further dramatized by The Conjuring.
The real Carolyn Perron gave her journal to Lorraine Warren for information on the many apparitions and upon asking for it back, Lorraine Warren did not give it to her.
âWe bought the house from a man called Earl Kenyon,â  Carolyn explained. âI visited the property with the girls lots of  times before we bought it.â
Clarice sat  between Ed and Lorraine at the kitchen table. In front of them sat Carolyn and Rodger. A few moments ago, after Lorraine told them what she witnessed, Ed had sat them back at the table.
âDid anything happen when you visited the home?â Lorraine asked.
âNo,â Carolyn said, âWe fell in love with it. And Earl insisted that we buy the house. He said he raised his son here, that it was a good place to raise a family. It seemed perfect.â
âDid Mr. Kenyon disclose that the house was haunted before he sold it to you?â Ed asked.
Roger shook his head, âNo. We had no clue. Well, I mean, the first night we stayed here, he said, âFor the sake of your girls, keep the lights on at night.â But, you know, I just took that to mean it gets real dark at night. We have narrow stairsâ lots of places to trip.â
âI did ask him about the strange noises,â Carolyn said, âAnd he dismissed it by saying, âSwallows in the chimney, my dear.âââ
Clarice drew her eyebrows together and asked, âWhat did he mean by it?â
âChimney Swifts are a type of bird,â Lorraine explained. âThey roost in masonry chimneys and are a symbol of good luck. Protection.â
âWas he trying to tell you that the noises were caused by birds?â Clarice wondered.
âI donât know.â Carolyn said, âBut in my opinion, I think he knew the house was haunted. I mean, he lived here before us. There is no way he couldnât have known.â
âI think he was trying to maintain his reputation. Didnât want to tell us about the haunting because then people would think he was some crazy old man. And he needed the property off his hands.â Roger said bitterly.
âWell,â Ed began, âwhat we feel your house needs is a cleansing. An exorcism.â
Roger looked between all three of them, âAn exorcism? I thought that was something you only do to people.â
âNo,â Lorraine said. âNot necessarily, no.â
Carolyn quickly faced her husband. She grabbed his forearm and said, âWe need to get the girls out of here. We need to leave.â
Ed interjected, âI am afraid that isnât going to help. Lorraine, hon, why donât you explain what youâve been seeing?â Â
âIâve been seeing the dark entity that haunts your house and your land,â she explained, âI first saw it when we came through the door. It presented itself to me as a formless, rolling shadow. And it was clung to your back, Roger.â
Roger looked to his wife, his mouth open in a slight terror.
âI then saw it with the girls as you introduced them, Carolyn. It stood next to Andrea, and itâŠalmost seemed like it was standing to be introduced with them. It knows we are here and wants to be seen.â
âW-why?â Carolyn asked, âWhy would it want that?â
âItâs mocking us.â Lorraine explained, âWe are here in the name of the lord. It knows we are here to fight against it, and it believes itself to be a stronger power. UmâŠClarice, honey, tell them what you saw in your dream.â
Clarice folded her hands on top of the table. She decided, as she looked into Carolynâs terrified eyes, that she would only tell what was completely necessary.
âI felt this house latch onto your family. This entity, the same entity that Lorraine saw, presents itself to me as a heartbeat. And somehow, because of that, I can feel pieces of what it wants. I watched your family walk into this house the day you moved in, and as you did so, I felt the heartbeat of this entity quicken. Itâs excited  to do this to you.â
âDid you hear it when you came in the door? Was it, um, excited?â Roger asked, swallowing.
Clarice shook her head, âI didnât feel the heartbeat at that moment reacting to you. I also donât feel the entity at the same time Lorriane sees it. Whatever this thing is, it reaches Lorraine and I in a different way, â Clarice looked down briefly, â I donât fully understand it, but being here has made me think that I hear the heart loudest when I am closest to a spot in the house that holds significance to the entity.â
âAlthough our abilities are different, Clarice and I have both sensed that this entity is attached to you.â Lorraine said, âIt is feeding off of you.â
Carolyn covered her mouth with her hands. Her eyes were closed, and her eyebrows were furrowed, âAnd even if we leave⊠it will follow us?â
Ed nodded, his tone was empathetic, âSometimes a haunting can be like gum. Itâs just stuck to the bottom of your shoe. You know, you carry it with you.â
âYou have a lot of spirits in here.â Lorraine said, âBut this one is the one we are most worried about because it is just so hateful.â
âShould we, um, I donât knowâ call a priest?â Roger asked.
âI wish it were that simple,â Ed said. âPerforming an exorcismâŠitâs an archaic procedure. Itâs a sacred rite. It requires many years of training,â Ed said with a breath, â...and even then, Iâve seen it go terribly wrong.â
âWrong how?â Carolyn asked, âWhat could be worse than this? What could be worse than what itâs planning to do?â
Carolyn looked to Clarice as she answered, âAn exorcism that is done incorrectly creates a vulnerability when itâs being performed. This vulnerability enables the entity to exploit the rite. A priest at my church was underqualified and performed several exorcisms. During which each person was killed by the demon possessing them. One woman burst into flames from the inside out.â Â
âOh, my god,â Carolyn said, pushing her palms into her eyes.
âI donât mean to scare you,â Clarice said, âThat isnât to say there arenât qualified priests.â
âBut to even get that far, we will need the church to authorize it first.â Ed said, âThat means we need to do a thorough investigation, gather as much evidence as we can. We need to prove to the church that this is a legitimate haunting.â
Ed leaned back in his chair.
âThat is the hard part.ââ
As the group walked out of the front door, Ed asked, âRoger, have your children been baptized?â
âNo, we never really got around to that. I mean, as Carolyn said earlier, we arenât really a religious family. â Roger answered, shoving his fists into his pockets.
âThat is something you might want to look into,â Ed nodded. âOur presence could make things worse.â
âWhy?â Carolyn asked.
âLike Lorraine said before,â Ed replied, âwe bring God with us.â
Carolyn shifted a stack of documents in her hands before offering them to Lorraine.
âUm, here is all of the research Iâve done on this placeâ The history of the land, town records, blueprints. All of it,â she tipped the documents into Lorraineâs hands, âAnd uh⊠my journal. Iâve been keeping a record of everything thatâs been happening here in that book. It should be useful.â
âThank you, Carolyn.â
Before they all turned to leave, Clarice caught a look in Carolynâs eyes. Her green eyes were wide. Worried.
Clarice hesitated briefly before stepping forward. She then extended her hand and softly squeezed Carolynâs.
âGod showed me this vision for a reason, Carolyn. He wanted me to first find the Warrens, and then He wanted us to find you.ââ
Edâs hand was flat against his front door.
Lorraine gently guided Clarice through the doorway and into the dark entryway of their home.
For a moment, Clarice stood still, blinking in the dark a few times, trying to make out the unfamiliar shapes of the house.
The scent inside was familiar. Specifically, Clarice recognized it from standing next to Ed in the cellar. The house smelled of his suit coat and the soft perfume of Lorraine. Something with the notes of day lily, sugar, and tones of powder.
âJudy must be asleep,â Ed said quietly.
âWell, we did get home late,â Lorraine answered.
Lorraineâs hands met the collar of Clariceâs coat from behind, and together they worked to take it off.
Clarice turned her head to the side and made out the faint shape of Lorraine handing her coat to Ed, who set it on a coat stand.
âCome on, honey. Iâll guide you.â Lorraine whispered. Clarice felt Lorraineâs  hands move to cup her waist from behind before Lorraine began to navigate her through the sleepy house.
All three of them were careful to step very quietly. Through the darkness, somewhere distantly, was the soft ticking of a clock.
Then, suddenly piercing the dark, was a loud THUD. Clarice felt an extremely sharp pain radiate from her hip and, with a small gasp, inhaled a large intake of air.
The blunt force was caused by Lorraine just having accidentally crashed Clarice into something that had a very sharp corner.
Lorraine quickly steadied her hold on Clariceâs waist, pulling her in toward herself as if that would undo the collision.
âOh my, I am so sorry, dear.â Lorraine breathed, âAre you okay?â
When Clarice didnât immediately respond, Ed whispered, âLorraine, did you just drive the poor girl into a piece of furniture?â
âI think Iâm alright,â Clarice whispered, somewhat dramatically. She was playing in Lorraineâs guilt.
âGosh, where did I hurt you?â
âMy hip. But, honey, I'm fine.â
âWeâre going to check that. Iâll find some ointment for it or something.â
Clarice noticed that until they reached her room, Lorraineâs guidance had become extra careful. Ed had moved to the other side of her and as Lorraine cautiously turned her around the corner, she slightly bumped into him.
âThe grand tour can take place tomorrow,â Ed said as he moved forward to open the door.
Just as he reached in and turned on the light, another light from a bedroom down the hall cast a sliver of orange onto the wall. Â A small girl with chocolate brown hair stood in the bedroomâs doorframe.
âOh, weâve been caught,â Lorraine said playfully.
Clarice did not need an introduction to know that this was Judy Warren. Along with the sleepy, just-having-been-awoken expression, her face was a pretty and unmistakable blend of Ed and Lorraine.
âHi, honey,â Ed said. âDid we wake you?â
âHi, Daddy,â Judy said, her voice full of sleep. âWhat was that noise?â
âYour mother accidentally drove our guest into the table.â
âThatâs her?â Judy asked.
Lorraine looked at Clarice, her words sounded almost as if she were excited to show her off, âYes, honey. This is Clarice.â
Clarice smiled at Judy. She cleared her throat and perhaps too formally said, âUmâŠHello.â
They watched as Judy padded down the hall, her shadow dwindling as she neared. She rummaged in the pocket of her pajama pants for a moment. When she pulled her hand from her pocket, she held it in offering to Clarice.
A butterscotch lay in her palm.
âI saved this for you.â Judy said, âIt was the last one.â
Ed huffed out a small laugh from beside them.
âOh, sweetie,â Clarice took the sweet from the little girl's hand. âThank you.â
âThey are my favorite. Do you like them?â Judy asked.
âI love butterscotch,â Clarice replied. âVery much.â
âDo you like your room?â Judy asked, motioning to the open door.
âI haven't been inside. Will you show me?â Clarice asked.
In reply, Judy nodded her head and took Clarice by the hand.
The room was extremely charming. The air felt readied. Inhabited. It was like there had been such an anticipation for Clariceâs arrival.
The walls had lilies lined and patterned up and down, the petals were colored, accenting the walls with a light yellow.
âIâll go get your things from the car, Clarice,â Ed said, smiling before bending down and kissing  Judy on the top of her head.
âThank you,â Clarice said, before looking toward the rest of the room.
There were things, like a bouquet on the nightstand, lace cloth on the surface of the dark dresser, a Tiffany lamp that painted the walls with a warm array of colored light, but there was also room. Room that allowed Clarice to set down her things. There was an empty shelf on the wall, empty drawers in the dresser, and a porcelain jewelry tray sitting on top of it.
Lorraine noticed Clarice looking at the tray, so she picked it up and carefully held it in her palm. There were flowers painted with loopy stems on its border.
âThis one was mine,â Lorraine said, âBut I noticed that you were wearing jewelry the first time we met, so I put it in here for you.â Â
âOh, honey,â Clarice said, touching a hand to her chest. Her shoulder then raised in a coy shrug, Â âYou spoil me.â
Her focus then fell to the quilt that was draped atop the bed. It was a pretty fusion of orange, yellow, cream, and fruit. Patches of fabric were stitched to form the clementines, some whole and some sliced. Green fragments of fabric were quilted behind the fruit pieces, framing them in leaves. The quilt was such a small beauty. Such that she leaned down slightly and felt the beauty with her fingertips.
Clarice looked to Judy and Lorraine, who stood next to her and watched her with quiet anticipation, âOh, itâs gorgeous, you two. Just gorgeous.â
âMommy told you I helped her pick the blanket out?â Judy asked, her small forefinger moving along the stitching. She looked from the quilt to Clarice.
âYes, she did. And itâs perfect,â Clarice raised an eyebrow and looked between them, âNow, how did you two ladies know that clementines were my very favorite fruit?â
Lorraine only gave Clarice a small teasing smile and raised one shoulder in a shrug.
âI just had a feeling.â
Clarice turned and sat at the edge of her bed.
As soon as Ed returned to the room, straining against the weight of having brought all of Clariceâs luggage in one trip, he set the cases next to Clariceâs folded legs. Then, immediately, and with great importance, he picked up the poster of Elvis.
âWhere do you want this, darlinâ?â
Clariceâs lips twisted into a coy smile. She then, with an amused seriousness, inclined her head toward a vacant piece of wall.
The three ladies watched as Ed worked to hang the poster up, smoothing the paper against the wall.
âElvis Presley," Judy said with a fond recognition.
Clarice nodded her head, adoration lacing her voice. She sighed, Â âElvis Presley.â
As Ed was sticking the corners to the wall with tack, he became aware of something crimson and the unmistakable print of Clariceâs heart-shaped lips on Elvisâs cheek; he leaned back and observed it for a moment.
âWell now,â he said, âheâs a lucky fella.â
Clarice looked at what Ed was referring to, and her seriousness was replaced with a playful embarrassment. Lorraine giggled as Clariceâs hands flew once again to her face.
âGoodness, I hoped you wouldnât notice that.â
âOf course we'd notice.â Ed said, âI wonder how we missed it before.â
âItâs a kiss?â Judy asked, tilting her head up at the poster.
Clarice peeked through her hands to look at Judy.
Lorraine answered her daughter, âIt is a kiss.â
She leaned forward to observe the lipstick love on Elvisâs cheek, âItâs a pretty kiss too. What shade is that, Clarice?â
Clarice smiled, then paused, âItâs um-â Â
Lorraine looked down at her, âHm?â
âHm.â Lorraine hummed again, âSin. In. Satin.â
The warm light of the dining room chandelier poured over Lorraine and Clarice. Carolyn Perronâs research was scattered on the table before them: rolled blueprints, old town records, yellow newspaper clippings, and every documented history of the land. It must have taken her months to gather all of this information.
The two women sat on one side of the table and had their chairs drawn close together. They were close enough that Clarice often had to apologize for nudging Lorraineâs foot with her own.
Pouring over case files was something Clarice felt she could do very well. Years of being a librarian at Veravetil had taught Clarice how to efficiently move through documents. She knew how to scan each one and how to decipher the oldest ones. At the present moment, Clarice was holding Carolynâs journal in both hands and reading her loopy scrawl.
As well as an extremely talented chronicler, Clarice was realizing that this woman was also an artist. Many pages contained detailed pencil drawings of the apparitions Carolyn and her children had seen in  the house.  In bullet points next to them was what they did when they appeared.
âLook,â Lorraine said softly, bringing Clariceâs focus from Carolynâs journal. She was holding a silver locket in her hand.
Lorraine leaned close to Clarice, and together they looked at the picture. It was Judy, her dolly face framed in oval- shaped silver.
âJudy gave this to me. Just now, as I was putting her back to bed.â
Clarice took the locket in her fingertips. Lorraine, who wore the chain around her neck, pulled closer to Clarice.
âPretty girl,â Clarice said softly as she looked at the picture, âMuch like her mommy.â
Lorraine gave Clarice a soft, sideways smile.
âShe has one too. It has a picture of Ed and me.â
Clarice watched as Lorraineâs forefinger rimmed the pendant.
âYou know, honey, I think she likes you,â Lorraine said, looking from the picture to Clarice.
âReally?â Clarice asked.
It was extremely important to Clarice that Judy felt comfortable around her. As well as that, she had the slightly girlish desire to be liked by her.
Lorraine nodded and closed the locket, âYes, I mean, come on, the butterscotch?â
âIâm keeping that forever,â Clarice informed,âItâs going in my jewelry box.â
Lorraine smiled softly at that before her  focus drifted back to the table. To the piles and scatter of histories. Their goal was to take this and their experience at the house and, from that, make some sort of sense. So far, in the extreme morning hours, they had finally begun to make sense of it.
Ed came into the room. He was wearing his comfortable grey jacket over a white T-shirt.
âHey, ladies?â Ed said. He pulled some  headphones from his ears and held the tape recorder in his arms. âYou two are not going to believe this. Carolynâs voice did not record. At all.â
âWhat do you mean?â Lorraine asked as Ed pulled up a chair close to them. Ed quickly readied the tape recorder. He pushed play, and Clarice and Lorraine leaned closer instinctively.
The dull sound of the tape spinning filled the room until Edâs voice accompanied the noise, âMy name is Ed Warren. The date is January 1st 1971. I am sitting here with Rodger and Carolyn Perron, who, with their family, have been experiencing supernatural occurrences. Alright, go ahead.â
There was silence where Carolynâs voice should be. Clarice felt an uncomfortable pop in her ears as if she were suddenly moving to a high altitude. Â The three of them looked at each other as the tape recorder continued to spin.
After a few more moments, Edâs voice answered the silence, âJust begin from the first occurrence.â
Clarice looked to Ed, who watched the tape recorder spin in silence.
âI donât know,â Ed sighed, âI mean, the whole thing is like that. How have you guys been doing? Find anything?â
Lorraine looked to Clarice and then back at Ed, âYes. Weâve found lots. It is really no wonder this family is going through what they are.â
âShow me what you got,â Ed said, looking at all of the papers.
âThe history of the house is very rich,â Clarice began, her hand hovering over the table as she looked for a specific paper. Once she found it, she handed it to Ed, âThe original farmhouse was deeded in 1680, though the current structure was built in 1736. Which, by the way, Â predates the Declaration of Independence.â
âWow,â Ed said, nodding his head.
Clarice continued, handing him another paper, âIt was built by the Richardson family and was inhabited through centuries by different people. None of these families seemed to have any relevance to the haunting until the Sherman family.â
âIn 1863, a man named Jedson Sherman moved in with his wife, Bathsheba.â Lorraine said, âEd, Bathsheba is related to a woman named Mary Towne Estye. She was one of the women who were accused of witchcraft in Salem. She was hanged during the trials.â
âWow,â Ed said, again, looking down at a picture Lorraine was showing him.
When Lorraine began speaking again, her voice was suddenly careful. She breathed out, âJedson and Bathsheba had a baby. When that baby was 7 days old, Jedson caught her sacrificing it in front of the fireplace.â
Edâs eyes flicked to Clarice.
âWait,â Ed said, pointing to her, âYou⊠Didnât you say?â
Clarice nodded, and Lorraine answered for her, âDuring the first conversation we had with Clarice, she told us that she had felt a younger energy being burned alive.â
âAnd when I was in the house, I felt the baby again when I neared the fireplace .â Clariceâs thumb went to her mouth before she bit into the flesh, âI saw it.â Â
Lorraine reached over and gently lowered Clariceâs hand from her mouth. Her hand lingered on her wrist for a moment more before carefully continuing.
âAfter Bathsheba sacrificed her child, she ran out to that tree by the dock, climbed up the branch, and proclaimed her love to Satan. She then cursed anybody who tried to take her land and hung herself.â Lorraine said. âAnd the time of death? 3:07 in the morning.â
Clarice shifted in her spot, âThe fireplace. The tree. Those places are where I hear the heartbeat the loudest.â
Lorraine reached across the table and picked up a picture. She then pointed out a woman to Ed. âThis woman's last name is Walker. She lived there in the 1930s  with her son, Rory. Rory disappeared in the woods and now, as Clarice and I found out, shows himself to the littlest Perron girl, April. He told April that he had been killed. And after his mysterious disappearance, his mother killed herself in the cellar.â
Ed leaned back in his chair, âJesus Christ.â
âBut that isnât all. That was only the first of many deaths on this land.â Lorraine pulled out a large roll of paper, and as she spoke, pointed out different pieces of the land, âThe original two-hundred-acre farm was subdivided and sold off. One boy, who lived right about over here, drowned in a nearby pond. A maid who worked for the  neighboring home over here also committed suicide.â
âEvery single person who lived there, besides the man who sold the house to the Perrons, died,â Clarice said.
âWhy didnât he also⊠well, you know?â Ed asked, âI mean, they said he raised his family there.â
Clarice shrugged and shook her head, âLorraine and I think that he might have just gotten out just in time. But to then sell it to Carolyn, knowing that she has young children. To sell it to anyone after what he must have experienced in that house⊠I mean, itâs just awful.â
âWell, what about the other people who lived there?â Ed asked, âThe ones who lived there decades before?â
âCarolyn has answered that too,â Clarice said, flipping to a page in Carolynâs journal, âThey are there, but in a way that is very unlike the rest.â
âWhat do you mean?â Ed asked.
âEd, Iâve never seen anything like this,â Lorraine forewarned.
âCarolyn wrote that one afternoon while sitting in the parlor, she saw a mother laughing with her children as they prepared a meal. Alongside them were two men who were sitting at the table. At first, she thought that they were just apparitions,â Clarice followed the words on the paper with her finger as she spoke, âThat is, until one of the men turned his head and looked directly at her. He smiled and pointed her out to his friend. Carolyn then writes that in that moment she realized that she was the ghost to them.â
Ed sat slightly taller in his seat. âWait, what?â
Clarice read the pencil lines directly from the page, âCarolyn theorizes that, âThis land is a portal cleverly disguised as a farmhouse, where timelines can coincide.ââ
Ed looked at the women, and they looked back.
Clarice then jolted, as suddenly the tape recorder began playing unprompted. Immediately, all of their attention turned to the noise.
âMy name is Ed Warren. The date is January 1st 1971. I am sitting here with Rodger and Carolyn Perron, who, with their family, have been experiencing supernatural occurrences. Alright, go ahead.â
Through the static of the recorder, a deep moan erupted. Clarice felt like something had run a finger along her vertebral column.
âFrom the first occurrence.â
The moaning continued, this time swelling into a symphony of screams and howls. Clarice heard from somewhere within the mess of noise the screeching she heard by the fireplace. She heard the flicker of flame.
Clarice had the urge to cover her ears and apply deep pressure to block the noise. To hum something to focus on that instead of the torture of the baby.
Just as the noise began to become unbearable, Ed lunged over and turned the tape recorder off.
Silence filled the dining room as they all sat staring at the tape recorder.
Clarice slowly became aware of the  warmth of Lorraineâs hand on her wrist, although she could not recall when she had placed it there.
Meanwhile, Edâs hand still hovered over the recorder, just in case it began playing again.
ââIf you need anything at all, our bedroom is right down the hall,â Ed said, pointing, âItâs the furthest one on the right.â
The Warrens stood in front of Clariceâs door, which she was standing in the doorway of.
âAnd honey, if you have any more dreams, come wake us up right away,â Lorraine said.
âGoodnight, sweetheart,â Lorraine said, leaning down just slightly.
She held one of Clariceâs cheeks in the crook of her palm and then pressed her lips to the middle of her forehead.
âGoodnight, Lorraine,â Clarice smiled, suddenly just a little shy.
âSweet dreams,â Ed said, as the couple turned to leave.
Before fully leaving, he reached toward Clarice and brushed the tip of her nose with his thumb.