A Court of Silver Flames (A Court of Thorns and Roses #4)- Sarah J. Maas
-Background: I read the first 3.5 (counting the novella as .5) ACOTAR books over the winter partially in preparation for ACOSF, but also because I wanted too. I don’t dislike Nesta. She isn’t my favorite character, but if she manages to no try to solve every mental breakdown with painting a picture, she’ll already be higher up on the list than Feyre. This supposedly also was more of an adult/new adult book than the previous installments, so I may or may not have to start going back to church once I finish it, because lets be honest the first ones were a different breed.
-Part 1: Novice (Pg 1-268): I’m not hating it. Its been almost 300 pages and to be completely honest there hasn’t been a ton of conflict. I don’t know where the rest of the book is gonna go. Like we’ve had some spiciness.. we’ve had some character development (Nesta is mentally an alcoholic, but not actively participating… She’s too lazy to go to town). Feyre isn’t playing a main role (I’m happy for that, some of you won’t be). I’m not mad, but this section could have been broken down into probably 150 instead of 250. Lots of foreshadowing but it’s gonna be tough to pull all of the pieces together.
-Part 2: The Blade (Pg 271-509): Replacing Feyre’s “it was so beautiful, I couldn’t have painted it even if I tried” from the original trilogy is “like calls to like” as the repeated phrase that makes me incredibly violent. There is a pregnancy storyline (not Nesta) that is also stepping on every one of my nerves. I do not care. I don’t care about Elain either and for some reason she continues to play a role. We are getting real spicy, but it isn’t that big of a difference from the first three. It isn’t 0 to 100 in comparison, its really more like 75 to 100. The only thing that changed for the most part was that now since its marketed as NA/Adult is that SJM can use the f-bomb. Nesta has made some friends, they have a smut book club and I’m here for it. Otherwise, this part of the book could have been split in half, and the second half could have been shorted significantly. There has been a ton of past-shadowing (is that a word? Hinting at a past event) but we still don’t know what happened. There’s 250 pages left, so a lot could be resolved, but I’m not having high hopes for a neat-ribbon-tied conclusion.
-Part 3: Valkyrie (Pg 513-647): Not a whole lot is happening. We had ACOFAS 2.0 kinda, with another winter solstice party. The is a lot of training again, a lot of reading, a lot of ** scenes. But overall, nothing major is happening. There was an important plot point towards the beginning, but most of this part could be cut out. It’s getting repetitive. Frankly, the last 100 pages (Part 4) looks like its gonna be one specific issue that isn’t related to the overall main conflict. I don’t know when SJM started writing this, but its been a while since ACOWAR was published, and ignoring ACOFAS… it’s been almost 6 years between books 3 and 4. I feel like this could have been fleshed out better considering the amount of time she had to think about the future.
-Part 4: Ataraxia (Pg 651-751): This was a little hunger games-ey, there was a trial that no one was expecting. The big threat that was tied over from ACOWAR and a major plot point was solved in a single (very short) chapter. Everything ended pretty much. There isn’t any issue that will lead into a future book.
-Overall: This book didn’t feel like a final draft. Either everything was not fleshed out enough, being very on the surface; or too much was included. I’m not disappointed, but I did expect a little bit more. Unless the synopsis for the future installments draws me in, I probably won’t be reading it on release day. There are 2 more full length books (#5,6), and one more novella (#3.2- is what it’s called on here). All I ask is that the next two books are NOT about Elain. Feyre getting it on, okay fine. Nesta, I’m here for it. I have zero interest in Elain and Lucien, give her a garden off the page and everyone will be happy. 3/5 stars.












