Where the Truth Lies (2005)
“Where the Truth Lies” takes the viewer on a two-part journey stretching from the east coast to the west coast and covering a great deal of scandal in between.
We begin with Vince Collins (Colin Firth) and Lanny Morris (Kevin Bacon). They are a two-man team beloved by Americans in the 1950’s. Success, fame, mob ties, fancy hotel rooms and a scandal.
The movie’s beginning finds the comedy duo flying to New Jersey from Miami. They’ve just arrived when the naked body of a student from Miami, who had been writing an article about the famous comics thus intimately involved with both men, appears in their hotel bathtub. Though she’d been researching the two, the police find no other tie from Vince and Lanny to Maureen O’Flaherty (Rachel Blanchard) and the case is ruled death by overdose.
Cleared of any wrongdoing, the duo splits anyway. No further information is uncovered about Maureen’s death and both men fade into the background as the case turns cold.
We flash forward fifteen years. In the 1970’s, Karen O’Connor (Alison Lohman) is charged with helping write the biography of Vince Collins. In attendance at the very event in Miami that started the scandal connecting Vince and Lanny to Maureen, Karen was fascinated to learn the real truth behind that scandal.
As she begins writing for Vince, chapters from a tell-all about the duo’s history, written by Lanny Morris, are sent to Karen from none other than Lanny himself. Intrigued, she happens to meet Lanny on a flight, but conceals her true identity. The two have an affair, but Karen is ultimately exposed later in Los Angeles when Vince and Lanny arrange to meet each other.
Threats, blackmail, drugs, sex and betrayal lead Karen down a dark road with Vince and Lanny as she discovers the nasty truth of what the two did decades ago in Miami. Ultimately, the writer has loyalty to neither man and chooses to expose the truth on her own terms.
Colin FIrth's Role:
Vince Collins is a dark character. One half of a famous comedy duo in 1950’s American, he hides a secret about his private life that threatens to destroy him. Unwilling to be exposed, he is willing to go as far as he must to protect his image.
Firth deviates from his traditional character in this role. In “Where the Truth Lies,” Firth is far from the lovable, stuff Brit. He is dark, he is brooding, he is desperate. Vince Collins is outwardly attractive and inwardly haunted by his sexuality and the truth of his participation in Maureen’s death.













