Critical Lil Devil

Autistic, Bi, 17, I'm just a lil critical skeptic and you should be too Gale

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

@Cis Lesbians

Which term would you rather trans lesbians use? “Lesbian” or “Sapphic”?

I’m asking because trans lesbians face a lot of opposition to them using the term lesbian. So I was curious, if not lesbian than can they use Sapphic? Or is that a term only for cis lesbians and cis bi women?

Why or why not?

I’m alright with answers from anyone, even if you’re gendercrit. I’ll remain civil so long as you remain civil.

[kweerluigi-deactivated20231126]

Heterosexual will suffice

[pond-scum-princess-deactivated2]

Straight is a fitting term

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

No, It’s not.

But thanks for the input.

[pond-scum-princess-deactivated2]

Trans women can never be lesbians.  A male individual, regardless of gender identity, who likes female individuals exclusively is a heterosexual. 

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

Many lesbians disagree with you.

Trans women are women, and they can be lesbians.

That doesn’t change just because you say so, hun.

But thanks for the input. Echo-chambers are annoying, so It’s nice to get different opinions on this.

[colormecritical]

“Many lesbians disagree with you”

Read: “I only hear and accept the opinions of women who agree with me 😋

*pretends to be shocked*

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

If that were the case, I would never have asked this.

But misconstruing truths is what transphobes do best, so thanks for not breaking the mold.

[colormecritical]

There are so many lesbians in this thread that have expressed they do not want you to use either and you’ve ignored every request. Your actions speak for themselves and they’re screaming at the top of their lungs. But not listening to women is what males do ;)

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

And I have said time and time again I AM NOT USING THE DAMN TERMS.

I can feel attracted to men, MEANING I AM NOT A LESBIAN.

I have specifically said that it is up to TRANS LESBIANS on whether or not they listen to you people or listen to the ones telling them it’s alright to use the terms.

So, I am not “ignoring” these women. I am debating their opinions. Which I am allowed to do.

So fuck off with your misconstruing bullshit.

[colormecritical]

You’re not ignoring them yet you literally call any lesbian who explains to you that they aren’t ok with it transphobic? 😋 Your debating it yet once a lesbian says that they should refer to themselves as straight/heterosexual your automatic reply is that they shouldn’t (no explanation)? People have even suggested simply saying something along the lines of “female attraction” instead. You aren’t debating shit you just want lesbians to agree with you and the trans narrative, only to play victim when people don’t.

Being a lesbian refers to females who are sexually attracted to other females, not straight males in dresses who feel like women. A definition shouldn’t be considered offensive

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

I call them transphobic for misgendering and the aggression behind their words.

If you’re going to call trans women men, you’re going to be called what you are: transphobic.

So fuck off with your bullshit. Misconstruing my intentions doesn’t change what’s actually happening.

[colormecritical]

Well you called me transphobic and I didn’t fucking “misgender” you so….

Like sweetie something ain’t adding up

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

Oh no, you just misconstrued my words, misconstrued the situation, and were overall rude.

And then, the topper, you expected me to remain civil while you did all this.

So, maybe not transphobe. But rude piece of shit.

[colormecritical]

If anyone’s misconstrued you, that’s your own fault. I just read the situation for what it is ;)

[regina-geourge]

“Heterosexual” or “straight” should do.

[regina-geourge]

I can’t believe this zine isn’t satire, it comes off like one of those ridiculous tumblr blogs run by some middle aged man with greasy long hair wearing a dress who reblogs anime. Like I can’t believe someone wrote this completely seriously and thought it was good enough to waste money printing it, it’s so cringe.

[colormecritical]

I'm literally hollering. The "MythBusting" part really got me. Like let's just talk about about how they say that genes and chromosomes don't determin sex, yet as always never can actually explain what does and how sex is "so complex", other than using a literally birth defect.

And can we just talk about the clear appeal to authority with the quote? Someone saying that other unnamed scientists agree on something, doesn't validate anything. It's just to trick people into thinking this is scientific when it isn't.

Oh and they condemn "terfs" for using violence (which honestly is such a lie because the vast majority of the time it's the other way around), yet we can't judge the trans people who do 👼🏻😋 teehee. It's not like males in female spaces have ever posed a threat to women

But hey ho transphobe go sounds like a bop

[a-room-of-my-own]

The UK Ministry of Justice confirms at least 60 of 125 trans-identified prisoners in England and Wales have sex convictions.

— Who could have guessed sexual predators would take advantage of the gender identity laws? I mean this was *completely* unpredictable! 🙄

[colormecritical]

PuT eM iN wOmEn'S jAiLs!!!!

[radfemetc]

Trans prisoner charged with sex offences

[colormecritical]

This isn't even the first time and it definitely isn't the last

[thisispeaktrans]

And how is this not predatory? How is this behavior something to condone or be proud of?

[warriorforartemis]

He should absolutely be ashamed, and also scared. If I see a penis in my women’s locker room I will cut it off.

[terflies]

So, according to you

Women exposing their genitals by being naked in locker rooms is acceptable if they have a vulva.

Women exposing their genitals by being naked in locker rooms is predatory if they have a penis, regardless of the lack of any predatory intent.

Threatening trans women and mutilating women’s genitalia is morally acceptable so long as it’s a) a penis, and b) in a locker room.

No?

[star-fall-system]

There is a clear double standard here. I really don’t think people should be naked in locker rooms full stop (definitely not teens), but if it’s not predatory for two cis women to be naked around one another its no more predatory for trans women to be naked around other presumably cis women. Really, either it’s acceptable for everyone or it isn’t.

I have a personal hatred towards the idea that cis women are allowed to see each other’s bodies in some intimate way that men aren’t allowed to because the idea of “we’re all girls here” was used to normalise sexual abuse in my lifetime from an adult woman towards me, a presumed female child. This idea that cis women have some special access to each others bodies that others aren’t allowed holds a deep personal hatred from me and invoking it to be transphobic is really fucking disgusting to me

I mean, if nudity is normalised in some situations, fine, as long as those uncomfortable are afforded an out. But if it’s normalised for some and not others or in certain situations you should really question that. Why does the idea of teenagers or strangers seeing each other naked bother people only if they have different genitals? I guess there’s a degree of higher probability of attraction and therefore sexual misconduct but thats still going to happen in same sex environments (and is often used as an argument as to why gay people shouldn’t be allowed to change with str8 people, which we can all agree is homophobic)

How about nobody gets naked in certain settings without the prior consent of everyone involved, or else we normalise some degrees of nudity? In the meantime can we stop being transphobic about it? Thanks

[terflies]

Agreed. Notwithstanding person reasons (valid as they are), I don’t think it unreasonable to ask in general that people not be naked in shared spaces, including locker rooms.

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

It surprises no one that terfs have twisted this woman’s intentions.

Anything to make them seem the poor hapless victims they so obviously are, right? With their threats to chop off genitalia and their double standard bullshit. Such poor helpless victims. It really makes you cry.

[colormecritical]

So girls if you are replused or have trama by men and penis and use thr changing room as a safe space while you are vulnerable and exposed, just deal cisters, cuz sum womyn stand up ta p 😤😋

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

@Cis Lesbians

Which term would you rather trans lesbians use? “Lesbian” or “Sapphic”?

I’m asking because trans lesbians face a lot of opposition to them using the term lesbian. So I was curious, if not lesbian than can they use Sapphic? Or is that a term only for cis lesbians and cis bi women?

Why or why not?

I’m alright with answers from anyone, even if you’re gendercrit. I’ll remain civil so long as you remain civil.

[kweerluigi-deactivated20231126]

Heterosexual will suffice

[pond-scum-princess-deactivated2]

Straight is a fitting term

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

No, It’s not.

But thanks for the input.

[pond-scum-princess-deactivated2]

Trans women can never be lesbians.  A male individual, regardless of gender identity, who likes female individuals exclusively is a heterosexual. 

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

Many lesbians disagree with you.

Trans women are women, and they can be lesbians.

That doesn’t change just because you say so, hun.

But thanks for the input. Echo-chambers are annoying, so It’s nice to get different opinions on this.

[colormecritical]

“Many lesbians disagree with you”

Read: “I only hear and accept the opinions of women who agree with me 😋

*pretends to be shocked*

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

If that were the case, I would never have asked this.

But misconstruing truths is what transphobes do best, so thanks for not breaking the mold.

[colormecritical]

There are so many lesbians in this thread that have expressed they do not want you to use either and you’ve ignored every request. Your actions speak for themselves and they’re screaming at the top of their lungs. But not listening to women is what males do ;)

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

And I have said time and time again I AM NOT USING THE DAMN TERMS.

I can feel attracted to men, MEANING I AM NOT A LESBIAN.

I have specifically said that it is up to TRANS LESBIANS on whether or not they listen to you people or listen to the ones telling them it’s alright to use the terms.

So, I am not “ignoring” these women. I am debating their opinions. Which I am allowed to do.

So fuck off with your misconstruing bullshit.

[colormecritical]

You’re not ignoring them yet you literally call any lesbian who explains to you that they aren’t ok with it transphobic? 😋 Your debating it yet once a lesbian says that they should refer to themselves as straight/heterosexual your automatic reply is that they shouldn’t (no explanation)? People have even suggested simply saying something along the lines of “female attraction” instead. You aren’t debating shit you just want lesbians to agree with you and the trans narrative, only to play victim when people don’t.

Being a lesbian refers to females who are sexually attracted to other females, not straight males in dresses who feel like women. A definition shouldn’t be considered offensive

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

I call them transphobic for misgendering and the aggression behind their words.

If you’re going to call trans women men, you’re going to be called what you are: transphobic.

So fuck off with your bullshit. Misconstruing my intentions doesn’t change what’s actually happening.

[colormecritical]

Well you called me transphobic and I didn’t fucking “misgender” you so….

Like sweetie something ain’t adding up

[misshorrorotaku-deactivated2024]

Oh no, you just misconstrued my words, misconstrued the situation, and were overall rude.

And then, the topper, you expected me to remain civil while you did all this.

So, maybe not transphobe. But rude piece of shit.

[colormecritical]

If anyone's misconstrued you, that's your own fault. I just read the situation for what it is ;)

[nocountryforlesbians]

me when transwomen talk about what it means to be a woman, lesbian, or feminist

[multishippers-against-antis]

This is disgusting, glad op deactivated.

[the-erikalypse-deactivated20191]

Agreed. Fuck transphobes.

[colormecritical]

How is that even transphobic?? Y'all are so intent on erasing womenhood and lesbianism

[the-erikalypse-deactivated20191]

Trans women are real women.

Trans women can be lesbians.

We are not erasing women just because we exist.

Leave us alone.

[colormecritical]

Leave women and lesbians alone and we’ll leave you alone 😘

[the-erikalypse-deactivated20191]

Bitch, I didn’t even do anything. Your TERF ass came up to me and started shit, not the other way around. Are you gonna say that to all the people who got fucking murdered just because they exist. Usually by people like you who say this exact shit and use that exact line as your defense.

[colormecritical]

Can you list the times that "terfs" have killed trans people?

You came to this post sweetheart :) it's not the other way around.

And you have no right to be playing moral crusader pulling the dead trans card (of which the statistics are inflated and there is still more violence towards women) when you post incest porn.

[genderrude-blog]

https://mobile.twitter.com/fey_male/status/1049463113941245952

[colormecritical]

Remember when they said tht there was literally no reason to fear transwomen being in women spaces????? Remember????

[genderrude-blog]

https://mobile.twitter.com/fey_male/status/1049463113941245952

[colormecritical]

This will probably go through bc one this is #progressive Sweden where a man's feelings are more important than woman's safety 😋

[ak-pr4y]

[mothcub]

[shollymannon-deactivated2019032]

[hidingoutbackstage]

Mmmmm, delicious tea!

[shollymannon-deactivated2019032]

mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

source: @radafayscage​

full receipts here

[colormecritical]

These people literally paint lesbianism as being inherently gross! It’s ok to talk about how much you love pussy unless you’re a female than you’re fetishing genitalia right?? Like someone is literally replused by cock and you think they should just get over it???

[colormecritical]

Imagine having a minor come to you, saying they don't like cock and telling them they should just learn to love it ?? Like this is a fucking dystopia

[sahco]

makin` a beat

[captain-juuter]

What if the world of animal crossing was actually just a child’s vivid imagination

[queertcc]

terfs wish they were funny… sory ur not ur only jokes are abt mocking trans women like we get it 

[menstru8r-deactivated20210616]

thank you for your input tumblr user queertcc

[queertcc]

you are welcome tumblr user menstru8r

[menstru8r-deactivated20210616]

[shollymannon-deactivated2019032]

ok can we just end the trans women getting uterus transplants discourse? if uterus transplants ever become possible, do ya’ll not understand how organ donorship works? organ donorship is extremely rare, there are lists and i don’t think identity validation is a good enough reason to get on one of them, especially considering trans women do not have the physical capabilities to ever give birth, even if some hack dropped a uterus in them jesus christ

the fact that these people think they deserve a uterus transplant as much as infertile women or women who’ve lost their wombs to cancer or endometriosis or cysts, a uterus that they’ll never fuckin use, so they can “feel” more like a woman…..holy shit, just accept you’ll never be a female

[shollymannon-deactivated2019032]

me when a male tries to explain to me why he requires access to female spaces in order to feel safe and snug in his “gender identity”