Hey! Dunno if you’re aware of this, but from your post on the 1st night of chanukkah where you mentioned wanting to see Nathaniel confirmed as Jewish in the show, there is reason the show doesn’t do that.
Astruc said in a tweet a few years ago that the show would not portray and explicit religious symbol or topics because french broadcasters are extremely strict about such content in children’s shows to avoid “proselytizing”. Astruc himself agreed, saying “I agree [with this decision] 100%. Religion = private matter.
This kinda boils down to France’s different cultural perspective around religious identity. Meaning we won’t ever see a Jewish, Muslim, or Christian character depicted the same way we do in America (or other English speaking countries idk if you’re American or not) because our understanding of representation around religion is a lot more accepting given how much religion plays a part in our society unconsciously.
France also doesn’t have a great track record with being okay with Muslim people. I don’t think antisemitism is a problem there the same way it is for Islamophobia, but definitely also an issue.
TLDR: France is not jumping for joy at the idea of kids being exposed to religion via TV and not their parents, and the show reflects that :(
It’s def weird for me (an American) to see queer characters, BIPOC characters, black autistic representation, disabled characters galore and not a single religious person 😭
Since you also said something about this @samcat0925
I'm actually well aware of this, I thought I implied it fairly well in the post itself that I knew France had a thing about it.
I just didnt want to really get in on that when it was a headcanons post
But since you're here, lemme give you the full context of my trip to France.
When I was 21, my very religious Catholic parents told me I could go to Europe for 2 and a half weeks, I just had to go as part of a pilgrimage. We spent 2 weeks in Italy and half a week in France. And I was very much pretending my hardest to still be Catholic cuz it was a free trip to Europe
When we got to France, we were doing a whole 3 days walking and camping thing from Chartes to Paris and we have a very specific itinerary that told us where we would be at the end of each night
I overhead the adultier adults gossiping at the campfire and complaining about how we had to change at least one of the campgrounds because of discrimination
I, of course, dont know how true they were being, cuz I was eavesdropping and really only knew foods in French at the time
But I remembered that shit
And I remembered all the other tiny details like the faces of waiters when we walked into a restaurant with our ladies covering their heads or when they also made a face when we ordered specific food
And I remembered flipping through the TV channels the one night we stayed in a hotel in France, trying to find something to watch, and the chaperone suggesting i give it up because I wouldn't find anything religious (i didn't care what'd I found honestly)
While I WISH that we could tell more easily when a character is Jewish or Muslim in a show like Miraculous Ladybug, I am well aware of the issues with that