evcravensâ:
No, Grace answers, and she pensively wets her bottom lip with her tongue, which means she isnât done. Sheâs wandering the graveyard of her past decisions and picking through her thoughts like picking through old bones. If Everettâs supposed to feel bitter vindication that her reckless, selfish endeavors have failed to secure her satisfaction, it doesnât come.
Nothing much comes with Grace, nowadays.
He can never quite get a foothold on his feelings when sheâs around, strung in a limbo between brittle pity and rueful anger and wounded betrayal. It was so much simpler, once. Growing up in the Craven-Daly families, the rule went like this: when Everett and Grace were good, they were a peculiar sort of spectacular; when Everett and Grace were bad, they were a nightmare. Five minutes into an interaction heâd know instinctively which one itâd be for the day. Then came the distance that came with crossing the threshold into adulthood and leaving Grace behind in adolescence, and the grey area added in between.
Everett looks at her now, simultaneously readying himself for another ugly argument and knowing one wonât come. Pointless, she says. Yes and no. He plucks the cigarette from his lips with his now-bandaged hand and lets out another steady, languorous exhale. They wouldnât be having this conversation if Grace was truly happy, that much is right, but âÂ
âTheyâre not good people. Thatâs where youâre wrong.â Everett taps his cigarette, watching the tip dissolve into powdery ashes. He brings it to his mouth again. âWeâre not good people. None of us are, in this godforsaken city,â he mutters. If he gathered all the collective blood on their hands, he could drown himself in it, crimson and metallic and slick. Heâs long since stopped believing in any inherent goodness in Verona. Which is more commendable â for a good man to choose good according to his nature, or for a bad man to choose good against it?
Conversations with Alva spiral through his head. Religion. Morality. Original sin. His mother may have christened his middle name for Joseph, but lately, Everettâs felt more like Jacob, wrestling with God through the dead of night until his body is all but spent. Forever the question of what does it matter, forever the weight of sin still pressing thick on his shoulders. He wonders if heâll ever be relieved of either.
He wonders if Grace feels the same.
Theyâve always been different when it came to the Catholic masses theyâd sometimes attend together with their families as children â both with a certain lack of deep interest, though Everett always viewed religion with mild, if incurious, favor as opposed to Graceâs suspicion that bordered on disregard as she grew older. Always two sides of the same coin: tradition versus independence, duty versus freedom. Heâs always been able to predict, save a few occasions, the manner in which sheâll respond.
She surprises him this time.
I want Catia to be safe.
Everett stills, cigarette pinched between his fingers, trapped between his desire for reconciliation and the wary distrust still warning in his heart. I donât know if thereâs anything I can do anymore, sheâd said. Everett thinks of Lillian, and Maeve, and the flowers he leaves on their graves. Thinks of Vivianne, too, and how exhausting it is to harbor bitterness in his heart. He watches her for a long moment, green eyes gleaming under the low kitchen lights. âThen help me.â We could do this, together. âThough, youâd better speak with Catia yourself.â
He stubs out the last of his cigarette into the ash tray, then runs the towel under the warm water before squeezing it gently, one hand extended towards Grace. âHere. Your turn.â
Everett ashes his cigarette and proclaims judgement on them all - a whole city of sinners, pure black and white. She could argue, but itâs the truth: good is a relative term, shades of grey that exist only far from the light. She sees them because her soul has been stained - she knows he sees them too, since his is just the same. When a good man tells you he is damned, what can you, the wicked, say to deny it? How could you know goodness better than he?
Grace has long wondered about the people that flock to Verona - what draws them in to this bloodstained city, whose cruelty is whispered in the shadows beyond its borders? Who would choose this place for themselves, other than the vicious and the wretched? What does it make them, those that have clawed empires out of the bloodied earth, shared in the wealth borne of the slaughter of others - what then, if not the wickedest of all?
It had been easy for her to fall into the birthright the city had given her. Whatever moral soul her Catholic upbringing had attempted to instill had withered and died at the foot of the festering rage that had built up inside her for years - and yet she still hopes for redemption. She will turn her face to those worthy of adjudication and lay herself at their feet. She has begun already with Everett - her harshest judge, her most loving friend.
Help me, he says, and she knows she has been found worthy.
âYeah,â she says thickly, tears clogging her throat and threatening to spill. âYeah, Iâll talk to her.â Nearly a month later, she can still feel the weight of Catiaâs body in her arms, the warmth of her tears in her shirt. She thinks for the first time that her sister may want something from her that she is willing to give.Â
Everett stubs out his cigarette with a finality that has Grace straightening up, ready to steel herself for a return to normalcy, to a space beyond the bubble theyâve made of the kitchen, this space for revelations.
Your turn, he says instead, holding out his hand, and this is what breaks her.
It is an olive branch, this simple act of tenderness. A signal that she is worth tending to, worth caring for. She, used to the tenderness of dulled blades, grasps at this chance for healing like a drowning man.Â
Tears spill as she takes his hand and she shuts her eyes to them, surrendering herself to his machinations. The towel is warm and rough against the raw edges of the gash on her forearm, but Everettâs hands are steady and kind, efficient as he cleans the cut of the blood just starting to dry. She cannot look at him, cannot bear to see the gentle thing that has surely risen into his gaze. She feels a child again, crying frustrated tears onto Everettâs ever patient shoulder. Itâs like a dam has burst within her - she cannot stop.
Everett finishes with the towel and Grace sways into him, shoulders shaking as she muffles an involuntary sob into his shoulder. Itâs awkward and ungainly - him, still holding her injured arm, her silently willing her tears to stop, overwhelmed with a sudden urge to be close to him, carefree and cherished like they had been when they were young. âIâm sorry,â she whispers, ragged and raw. Sorry for the tears. Sorry for the years of frustration and pain. Sorry for what is probably still to come, the slips and cuts that come with a blade being sanded down. She heaves a shuddering breath. âIâm so sorry.â














