Calum doesn’t know how to tell her. At no point could he ever remember the way he’s always felt about him being something that someone else had asked for. At least not romantically. He was sure Gavin would have had a field day with his psyche if he’d really let him. Tell him that it didn’t have to be romantic. His self hatred came from a time when hating him had become a form of someone else’s entertainment. Something that went much further than just any of his past romantic relationships. The “why” behind the comfort he felt in the dark. But he couldn’t say any of that outloud. He didn’t want her to think he was defending himself. He didn’t deserve that. So instead he nodded, his bottom lip pulled between his teeth to keep his mouth shut as he tried to swallow every word she said despite the knot that had taken over the back of her throat. “I-I know..I know you wouldn’t want that I didn’t… I.. It wont happen again..” He said again, trying to control the shake in his voice that was miserably giving him away. “I swear I didn’t Day… I didn’t… I never would have… I don’t know why… I’m just.. I.. I’m really sorry.” He said again, this time his eyes stinging again as he forced himself to look at her again. Hoping that at least this way, seeing how she was feeling would stop him from crying. It wasn’t fair to her. He knew that. This wasn’t supposed to be about how he was feeling.
At her next question, looking at her became that much harder. That was what he was asking. Something that felt so foreign. That he’d rejected once so long before and now like a hypocrite was wanting the very same thing. “I… yeah I guess. I’ve… never really been in a situation like this before and I know it’s selfish and I went about it in a really fucked up way but I didn’t think it was possible to be… capable of this? Or to be able to feel things like this.. And it’s not an excuse. I know that it’s just… kind of where I’m at and I don’t know what to do but yes… I really I don’t want to lose either of you.” He said rambling it off and feeling his entire body tense like the air had been sucked out of it when he finished. The rest of the room felt like it’d melted away and he was nothing more than a table away from slipping and his fingers had to slip down to grip the edge of the chair to try and stay grounded while his mind grew ever closer to igniting. Her questions were like punches to the gut. Questions that he didn’t want to admit the answers to because he hated himself for them. Made him want to sink in on himself if it wasn’t going to make it that much more obvious that he was failing at this.
“I want to…” He confessed, through a voice that no longer sounded like this own. “I want to stay the night with you Day. I want to try that.” He said again, despite the parts of him that knew staying a night away from Callie was going to cause him anxiety like he’d never experienced. It didn’t change that he wanted it. He wanted to know what it was like to fall asleep curled up beside her, with her head on his chest. To know the same things that helped her sleep that he’d learned with Callie. How she liked to be woken up in the morning. All thoughts that he wanted so desperately and at the same time felt a powerful sense of guilt attached. “I want both Day.. I wanna stay the night with you… or at least try and find a way to make that work.. And yes I wanna do breakfast and naps and things like that with you too… I don’t want to take anything off the table. I don’t want you to feel like you’re some second choice. That’s not true. I really care about you.” He said as he finally let his arms curl back in on himself. The anxiety getting the better of him as he contemplated how much longer he could sit without stepping out for air to avoid the more than likely implosion welling up inside of him. “I just didn’t know I was capable of feeling like this until it’d already happened..” He added, as his eyes moved back to the glass of water on the table. He was unsure if he could recall when it arrived in front of him, but reached for it to try and feel anything other than the sense of impending doom that had started to wrap itself around him.
Every time the shake in his voice sneaks through she feels an undeniable sickness in the pit of her stomach. Like she’s being a bully, like she’s in the wrong. Is she? Is she asking the wrong questions, is she being unfair? He seems so fragile, so innocent and panicked before her. Over the past few months she’d gotten used to feeling like a safe space for him and now she was causing earthquakes in his spirits. “I’m sorry,” she whispered. “I’m sorry, I’m not...I promise I’m not trying to make this harder. I just...” she gestured helplessly, at no particular person or thing, at the empty space around her. “I don’t know what I need to hear. I don’t know...what I need to ask or get off my chest.” It was foolish that she wanted there to be a resolution right here at this table. Something said that suddenly made all the tension leave, made this all okay. They could come to turns with this new reality and make it functioning before their food even got here.
And that...that thought made her pause. That thought, subconscious and rolling up on her like an ocean wave you had turned your back on, told her something important. That she wanted to figure it out. She did. She wanted to try and be okay with this.
“I get it,” she murmured, finally reaching out across the table to take his hand in hers. “I get it. I don’t...I don’t think you set out with some plan to woo people at the same time. It...it just happened. It just happened and you didn’t know what to do with it all. I believe you, Calum.” This whole conversation had never been about questioning his intentions. It had been about trying to figure out what this reality was going to look like, if it was something that she could live with. He talks about wanting to spend the night with her, wanting her and them. She is a second choice. There’s a truth in that, but it doesn’t have to be a dealbreaker, it doesn’t have to be an apocalyptic truth. Second choices were still choices after all. They held value. They mattered. “I care about you too,” she whispered, voice quivering with emotion. She releases his hand just as he pulled his arms back in on himself, and the fear bubbles up again, not in the same place though. “I care about you and I’m...I’m trying to figure out what the right thing to do is. I don’t want to hurt you Calum. I can’t promise that I can do this, that I can be okay with this. I can’t make a promise cause I don’t know how this is going to feel, how it’s going to feel to be in this with you. If...if for some reason we get part of the way into this and I realize I can’t...I can’t make it work I don’t...fuck I don’t want to hurt you.” She wipes a wayward tear that’s trying to escape down her cheek. “But then if...if I end this right here right now I’m hurting both of us because...that’s not what I want. I...want you. I love you. I’m in love with you, Calum.”
He looks like someone who needs protection, but she has to take a breath and remind herself that he’s a grownup. She can’t make choices for him. “I...I think I want to try. If you’re sure that’s what you want. If you tell me that’s what you want to do, and that you understand there’s a chance I may not be okay with all this, I may not be able to get there with it. Then I...I’ll trust you, Calum. I trust you. And we can try to...to figure out how to do this together. Like...like sketching rough drafts of a design. We just go slow, be careful, use a light hand so we can make changes.”