1.What is the issue/problem you will be focusing on and why is it a good topic for thesis? (Reference your discussions with experts and audience members) (500-750 characters)
An economics professor in China has suggested that Chinese men share their wives with men who can’t find their own.
This idea comes from Xie Zuoshi, a professor at the School of Economics and International Trade at Zhejiang University of Finance and Economics.
Tens of thousands criticized his idea in social media. They say Mr. Xie’s proposal is immoral and an insult to women.
A teacher in Beijing, Yu Baoyu, says the professor is treating woman as if they are a product that a husband can share or rent. This teacher adds, “I am surprised he has the audacity,” or nerve, to say such things in public.
The United Nations has determined that imbalances in the sex ratio of a population at birth should usually fall between 2-5%; ratios outside this range are considered abnormal. According to the United Nations Population Fund report, China’s population in 2005 had reached 119 male births for every 100 female, and even exceeded 150:100 in a few provinces and rural areas.
This has been the situation for more than 30 years, and now China is in a period where social problems brought on by gender imbalance are common, which will exert a profound long-term influence on China’s population and social development.
Throughout history China has structured society around patriarchal families, giving men an advantageous position in inheritance of property, living arrangements, production of offspring and family rights. Women were reduced to a low position in the family and society; after marriage, women mainly lived under the authority of their husbands, and the ideas that men are superior to women, and that sons are the surest means of providing for one's old age, were allowed to flourish. In addition, China’s traditional culture (which is based on Confucianism) lays strong emphasis on the importance of having sons. These practices and views are the heart of the preference for sons in Chinese families.
In the last twenty years, China’s fertility rate has been rapidly declining and the total fertility rate is lower than the replacement level. In populations that strongly favour sons, a decrease in the fertility rate is often accompanied by an increase in the imbalance between the birth rates of the two sexes.
On the whole, China is still an underdeveloped society in the process of transformation, in which the social security system is far from comprehensive in cities and nearly non-existent in rural areas. There is a relatively large disparity in education, employment and participation in politics between women and men in China. Moreover, the formulation and implementation of several policies related to economic and social development were carried out without regard to gender equality, causing the position of women in society, economy and politics to remain low. These factors create concrete incentives for Chinese families to favour sons.
China has a population imbalance between men and women. This imbalance, has left about 30 million adult men without wives. So, how to find their own wife?
Why is it a good topic for thesis? In the course syllabus, as we mentioned : “In the three Thesis classes over three semesters, students will identify and research a social innovation issue, develop insights and a theory of change around that issue, engage the community in the iterative development of an intervention to effect that change and finally build & share a component of that intervention.”
In my thesis, because of the natural law of population reproduction, consequences of imbalances in the sex ratio at birth have an accumulative effect and are transmitted in a way that spans multiple generations; such consequences will not show immediately but gradually appear once the generation concerned has grown up. Even assuming that the sex ratio at birth returns to normal, the consequences of the previous imbalance will last for a long period of time rather than disappearing right away.
In averting 400 million births since 1980, as the Chinese government claims the policy has, it violated numerous human rights. Tens of millions of baby girls have been aborted or abandoned, leaving China with one of the most uneven sex ratios in the world. Women — particularly the poor, who cannot afford the steep fines needed to have second children — have been forcibly subjected to abortions, sterilization or I.U.D. Insertions.
For this social issue, I can use some skills and tools I have learned to talk about several directions. For example: feminism, the influence of the two-child policy, Chinese traditional culture, marrige... And I can engage the community in the iterative development of an intervention to effect that change and finally build & share a component of that intervention. So I think this is a good topic for thesis.
2.What communities will you be looking to engage? (250-500 characters)
Dengfeng, Henan Province,
Shanghai.
Chinese city
Chinese village.
Yichang, Hubei Province: Hubei Province, where Yichang is located, is often one of the provinces with the most imbalanced sex ratio at birth in China. However, Yichang is one of only two or three prefecture-level cities in the province with normal sex ratio at birth, and has moreover maintained a relatively stable and normal sex ratio at birth for the past 20 years.
Dengfeng, Henan Province: Dengfeng is under the administration of Zhengzhou, Henan Province, where imbalance of sex ratio at birth is a long-standing problem. 99% of village administrative units distribute resources to villagers under the principle that women marry into the man’s family: men are permanent villagers and enjoy various perks (such as homestead rights, proprietary fields, land compensation, collective welfare etc.); women are regarded as “temporary villagers” and subject to many restrictions.
SHANGHAI — News that the Chinese government would relax the one-child policy — one of its most sweeping, intrusive and defining — has been widely welcome.
Chinese city: Beijing, Guangzhou, Shenzhen, Chengdu, Dalian.
Chinese village: Shanxi, Dengzhuang, Linfen, Anhui, Hefei.
3.What are some research approaches or concept forms you are interested in experimenting with during the thesis process? (250-500 characters)
I had a few requests to summarize the entire experience, so here goes.
And I have my tool kit and 9 steps model of frame creation in research.
1.Before proposing a solution, make sure you gather insights from people. The first step is talk about the problem with people, not design.
2.Before you start the creative process, question if the identified problem is a symptom or an upstream problem. Question, why, why, why.
3.Don’t change your topic because you can’t find a solution.
4.Make sure you prototype over and over and over.
5.When suck, talk to others. Ask other people’s point of view or advice.
6.Don’t fall in love with the solution, fall in love with the problem.
7.Detail 4 research activities you did this semester and what key insights you learned from them.
9 steps model of frame creation in research
Analyzing the history of the problem owner and of the initial problem formulation.
Analyzing the probelm situation: what makes this hard?
Analyzing the inner circle of stakeholders
Exploring the borader field
Investigating the thems in the broader field
Identifying patterns in the thems to create frames
Exploring the possible outcomnes and value propostions
Investigate the change in practices required for implementation
Draw lessons from the new approah and identify opportunities.
For my thesis, in the field, The broader field of possible stakeholders also includes children, educational establishments (schools, universities), teachers, parents, family, culutre, gender, marrige, money, economic, society, hospitals & care facilities, etc…
4.Detail 4 research activities you did this semester and what key insights you learned from them.
Research activities: Determine the topic. Investigation questionnaires were designed and the various causes of 10 women of artificial abortion were analyzed to obtain related materials. Interview, insight.
Last month, , I interviewed a Chinese young man who have girlfriend.
Linjie: “ what do you think about the 40 million singman can not find their own wife?”
The young man: “ they are not good enough. They are loser.”
Linjie: “ Ok, according to your logic and you situation, now you’ve already have a girlfriend. You “good enough”. So can you share some idea or way to help the 40 million singman find their own wife?”
The young man: “ If I tell them how to find wife or girlfriend, what will happen to me? I can’t find girlfriend or wife.”
My god!!!! This is Social Darwinism!!!!
And some old generation told me: “ Linjie, you are too young. You can not understand us. As parents, according to our logic: with fewer available women, parents have a much stronger incentive to save to make their sons attractive marriage prospects, as do the sons as they mature and enter the marriage market.
The marriage market is becoming very competitive with so few girls. The resulting pressure might incentivize men and parents with sons to increase savings in order to have a competitive edge in the marriage market.
Marriage competition may also be partly behind China's surge in home prices. since the groom's side is traditionally expected to consecrate the union with a house or apartment.
5.Detail 4 research activities you will be engaging in over the summer. What questions will you be looking to answer or get more information on?
Contrastive analysis:
For example:
the bachelors living in cities / the bachelor living in villages
--- Attitude
--- Causes
--- Values
--- What's your criterion to choose a wife?
--- why you make this criterion?
--- solution
--- ......
Sons are seen as more valuable, especially in the countryside, because they have been traditionally responsible for caring for their parents in old age.
There is another part of the marriage from the old to the emptiness is, after all, there is a saying called "bring up their children to old age."
But can this really be true? Could it really be that simple?
So many years have passed since the liberation, while many feudal thoughts still root in many people's minds, especially in the choice of the sex of birth.
A looser one-child policy may be progress. But it might also allow traditional patriarchal values to rear up again, and keep some women down.
So many problem waiting for me to slove. Let me find the answer in this summer vacation.
School of Visual Arts New York City
Design for Social Innovation
Linjie Deng