In applying to the Guion-Miller roll, the question was whether applicants ancestry connected them to the Cherokee tribal body recognized as “parties to the treaties” of 1835-1836 and 1846, not simply whether any of the 45,857 applicants possessed Cherokee ancestry. To answer this question, the Guion-Miller Commission and the Court of Claims relied upon the concept of the “Eastern Cherokee Domain” as both a geographic and legal framework for determining tribal affiliation and treaty eligibility. Residence within recognized Cherokee communities, appearance on official rolls, and continued association with the Cherokee Nation became critical forms of evidence. Applicants unable to establish those connections often failed, regardless of longstanding oral traditions of Cherokee ancestry. Even now, this still confuses people. Descent from a former Cherokee tribal member does not automatically mean you will be recognized today as part of that tribe. It does mean that, genealogically, you are descended from a Cherokee. This article tries to explain the whole process to help you better understand the Guion Miller Roll.












