Let me explain to you something.Â
[clipped for length]
lmao oh my god is any of this actually seriousÂ
this is basically one long tl;dr that means âyeah, ray said an awful, gross, dehumanizing slur that he knows is offensive, and refuses to apologize for, and laughs at people getting upset over according to his ask.fm response to someone asking about it, but STOP ATTACKING HIM!!! THE REAL VICTIM IS RAY!! NOT THE TRANS PEOPLE WHO ARE HURT BY THIS!! THE MAN WHO HAS A LARGE PLATFORM TO HURT PEOPLE AND THE POWER TO REACH MORE PEOPLE WITH THIS BULLSHIT IS THE REAL VICTIM IN ALL OF THIS!âÂ
look, i donât know where youâre at in this fandom, but the people i follow here are all calling all of this shit out all the time. apparently you donât follow the same people, because if you did, you wouldnât propose the ridiculous strawman situation that you are where everyone is somehow âout to getâ ray and doesnât care about anyone else pulling bullshit. the only reason ray gets the most shit is because heâs the one that pulls shit the most. no one in this company is perfect, but no one in this company does this shit with this much frequency, either.Â
the idea that ray âdidnât knowâ that word is harmful is laughable at best, but even if that was true and he realized it after, his response to the ask.fm question should have been âwow, iâm sorry, i didnât realize,â instead of laughing it off like he really did.Â
"iâve yet to see someone calmly explain to him why thatâs bad." one, considering you also think no one else calls rt out on their shit as a whole, iâm disinclined to agree with your judgement, because you seem to be willfully blind to when this all goes on, but rest assured that people have been calling him out, politely or otherwise, since last fucking year about this kind of stuff. people have been explaining to him for a long time - he just hasnât listened, and straight-up refuses to.Â
now, see, the apologism in your post is annoying enough, and exactly what this fandom is talking about when we say that ray and his fans are increasingly shitty, but what really annoys me the most about this is your insistence that the onus is on the people actually hurt by this to explain why theyâre hurt instead of on him to stop. your argument relies on complete ignorance of anything thatâs actually going on, as well as a decent amount of tone-policing and derailment. if youâre really so attuned to the rt fandom as you think you are, youâd have read pieces on tone policing, but since you havenât, let me break it down for you -Â
Asking marginalized groups to be kind and polite to people who throw slurs at them does absolutely nothing. For one, itâs incredibly hard to âbe kindâ to people who are throwing around jokes at the expense of your existence, because itâs your, you know, actual life and lived experiences that you canât just separate yourself from. And two, oftentimes people donât want to change, and no amount of politeness is going to get them to change - these attitudes are deeply internalized, and it takes more than a âplease stopâ to get people to recognize why what theyâre doing is wrong. (Funnily enough, the RT fandom - that I know, anyway, I donât know what corners youâre in, but itâs probably around Apologism Junction and Make Excuses Alley - has made post after post after post after post about this, but apparently this is all Greek to you.)Â
But mostly, hereâs the thing - marginalized people shouldnât have to be nice to get respect and to get people to stop perpetuating awful shit. Slurs are wrong and degrading no matter how âniceâ someone is in asking for them to stop. People getting - rightfully - angry and emotional about someone who refuses to stop calling them names and has refused for a while, who knows exactly what heâs doing and keeps doing it, is not reason to dismiss their argument. Saying âBUT YOUâRE BEING MEEEAAAAN TO ME!â is not only fallacious as an argument, itâs ignoring the context of everything youâre arguing. These people have every right to be angry, and you expecting them to go up to someone who takes every chance to verbally abuse them and treat him with kid gloves, as if heâs not a grown-ass man who can handle this shit, is disgusting. Itâs like the analogy of stepping on someoneâs foot - it doesnât matter if you step on someoneâs foot accidentally or on purpose, it doesnât matter if theyâre angry at you for doing it; either way, itâs on you to stop stepping on their foot, not on them to politely explain to you why foot-stepping is harmful.Â
What youâre doing when youâre demanding people take a specific tone is controlling. Youâre trying to set the boundaries and standards that the argument will take, youâre trying to control the information and how itâs spread, and youâre basically saying âIâm perfectly capable of treating you as a human being, and I fully recognize how much youâre hurting, but Iâm going to hurt you even more because I donât like your tone.â Right away, youâre demanding (from a position of privilege, because these things donât affect you, and thus you can be âcalmâ about it) that everyone give you the information in the most palatable way to you, instead of hearing the raw truth from them. Not only that, but youâre also setting yourself up as the arbiter of what âniceâ entails. Youâre setting yourself up in such a way that itâs easy for you to move the goalposts of the argument as you see fit instead of coming to these people with an open mind, which tells me that you donât actually care about the issue at hand or understand the mechanics and details of oppression and privilege - you want to come to the conclusion you already decided, pre-argument, to support, which is ignoring everyoneâs actual lived experience so you can defend your favey-baby.Â
There is no way you can defend him from this kind of shit. Itâs been going on for a long time now, and the fact that you think âhe still somehow doesnât know what a slur is, despite choosing to say them over and over, and that zero people have tried to explain it to him in this timeframe, even though 1) they have and 2) as cited above multiple times, tone-policing is bullshitâ is a more logical answer to whatâs happening than anything else, that tells me yet again that your judgement is all about protecting some guy who occasionally makes you laugh in a video instead of the people who are actually hurt by a dude spreading these messages around on platforms where anywhere from 347,000 followers to 3 million subscribers can hear them.Â
If you can come back to me with an argument that doesnât tone police and that I canât google an easy rebuttal to in five minutes that also doesnât pay the .01 seconds of lipservice to âhe said something bad, OKAY, I CONCEDE, BUUUUUUUUT,â Iâd love to hear it. But I probably wonât, because youâll either ignore every link, or take judgement with my ~tone~ and prove my point further.Â
















