Sorry if you've talked about this before but... Can I ask why you don't rate the vast majority of your works? I've read some of them and absolutely loved everything and I wondered why almost none were rated
It’s a fair question, and I don’t want you to take this as defensive or about you at all, but my real answer? I got so fucking tired of the rating/warning police, and the comments, and the anon messages.
To be clear: at no point was I mis-rating or warning my fics, either on purpose or unintentionally. But even with perfect tagging, even ao3 staff admit in documentation that there are grey areas in some fandoms, and situations where we have to use our best judgement because the interpretation is so varied across readers. And readers proved that. They asked for warnings based on how they felt, rather than how the fic fits into the tagging of the site itself.
When my fics first started getting a little traction, the rating/warning folks popped up and would argue with me about. everything. They didn’t like the rating and thought it should be something else, or they suggested certain warnings or archive tags I hadn’t included. I evaluated these requests and figured I was being nice indulging them, even though I genuinely didn’t think the tags were required or even in some cases, helpful.
At first these felt benign, but they got so much worse. I was bending over backwards changing the rating/warnings on a fic because one person asked. Some people were nice and phrased it as a request. Other people threatened to report me. They talked shit about me on tumblr if I didn’t make their changes, suggesting I was causing harm. They asked for highly specific additional tags that nobody had ever used or didn’t exist, which only created more confusion.
Then the requests got more and more bizarre — tagging sexual assault/rape because, for instance, in borderline Tim enters Bruce’s mind “and that’s basically mind rape.” People would complain about a rating on a WIP because that rated/warned content hadn’t been posted yet. People would insist that additional tags are mandatory (they’re not) and that I wasn’t doing enough.
We would be splitting hairs on if the death of the Waynes (mentioned briefly in passing, like almost all DC media does) needed the major character death warning (in my opinion, it doesn’t). Same thing for Jason - I understand if it’s on screen or vividly recalled, but do you need that warning for a fic where Jason makes a joke about having died? No.
Younger readers got freaked out about sex scenes and requested ratings that didn’t match the archive guidance (explicit vs mature, etc). Largely because I don’t think they understood the ratings in the first place. Teen rating is the equivalent of PG-13 - this doesn’t apply to my fics, but you can have a fade to black implied sex scene and that’s still Teen according to ao3’s tags.
I once got told I didn’t understand ao3 because I tagged a fic as “gen” even though a couple/pair appeared in the fic itself briefly. Which is ridiculous — gen rating doesn’t mean there isn’t any romance or romantic relationships. It just means the pairing isn’t the focus of the work.
I got so fucking tired of getting these comments. It really was nonstop for a few years. It made me stop replying to comments on my works. At no point was I ever tagging or warning in bad faith; I consulted ao3 guidance frequently and used my best judgement. And that still wasn’t enough.
“Just block them” — I know. But with dozens of fics up, it was impossible to keep up. Nobody would hear out my explanations. If they did, they rarely apologized for what they said before. It felt like every time I posted, I was bracing for something to be wrong with my fic. That felt awful :(
So yeah, I bumped up everything to the highest ratings/warning possible just for that to stop and to have peace of mind. Most of my fics are now unrated, and I use the “creator chose not to use archive warnings” warning on everything.
Why? Because no matter what the fic contains, or what a WIP develops into, I’m covered. I have warned to the highest possible degree, and there is no genuine issue with my tagging that can be reported or criticized. If someone has a problem, it’s because they clicked on the fic, not because I didn’t tag right. It shifted the onus to the reader.
I know this would come with a drop in readership and/or a lack of trust in me, and I accepted that. I know people feel like they’re taking a chance with me when they read those fics, and being wary is their right.
I also, for what it’s worth, tag explicitly chapter by chapter for works I know contain heavy subjects. Almost all of my current WIPs have those warnings, so people can make chapter by chapter decisions on what they’re comfortable reading. I also have provided ways for readers to contact me and ask additional questions about a warning or even to spoil the chapter for them before they read it. I’m more than happy to do that.
But in a world where a super personal, graphic fic about rape that I wrote which IS fully tagged, uses warnings, is warned for in the author’s notes, and has a rating, STILL gets comments about how they didn’t realize the rape would be so graphic or that I needed multiple types of rape tagged in the additional tags…I just can’t.
In short: I’m sorry, I wish I could tag as I see fit, but criticism from readers has exploded in recent years, and not just in this area. It’s too much of a cognitive load for me, it frustrates me, and I waste time I could be writing. So I have defaulted to the best option for my situation for the time being.