GAMERS!!!!!!!!!!!
So a new idea has popped into my head which I'm sure is not an original idea BUT I do really like the idea I haven't seen this a lot but has anyone thought about the mane 6 and trolls yet?? I tried looking some up ideas and didn't see that much fanart! There's a lot of fanart of the mane 6 with their classpects though ( which I have my own opinions about ) ANYWAY I wanted to give my own take of the mane 6!
hi aspen. you're wrong, here's why;
Twilight Sparkle gives off way more violet blood vibes and it makes more sense than teal, BECAUSE, despite teal bloods being known for being law students and studious students, nerd little guys, her being a violet makes more sense. Back in Equestria, her studiousness was Not expected as it would be with teals, and she was the odd one out in her group (or here now. blood). Her starting out with a higher social status too makes sense as Equestria is THE place, and her being a violet gives her a connection to the violet from homestuck Eridan, because she's the Element of MAGIC. SHES MAGIC!!!!! She's very easily a violet blood. tThank you for getting Seer of Blood correct
Pinkie pie being a gold blood does NOT make sense i DOOONT CAAAAREE. Also. You just ripped away her entire backstory because shes the BARD OF DOOM. She was raised on a fucking ROCK FARM and it was GREY and SAD. No bee farm does not subsitute for the rock farm, bee farms are nice and useful, rock farms aren't. She was poor, sad, and started out ROUGH. This is why she's a RUST BLOOD and Doombound, she's rust due to the working class and also PSIONICS. It makes much much more sense for her psiojics being of rust blood origin since they're already known for their mind psionics, since gold bloods psionics are primarily known for being combatative. Also; battery? No. She was never a battery and never will be, thats not her character arc. Continuing on with the Bard of Doom, she in no way just magically brings hope around and is huge in belief, she's huge in Parties and being The Life and punching the sadness away. She's a Bard of Doom because her parties are to break away the doom in peoples life, just as she did leaving her rock farm: But she's not a lifebound because she still embraces her rock farm life and her doomboundedness
i don't have any strong opinions on apple jack as i still don't understand or character or arc well, but personally she's an easy bronze blood to me since she's literally an apple orchard farmer. Maybe a psionic-less gold blood but she's Not an olive. i can agree with heartbound since the only other thing i can think of for her is bloodbound
now rainbow dash's character is a bit hard to translate into alternia because she's like middle class, big on athletisism, And has a super confident personality. This gives off a lot of different blood type vibes, but i'd have to go with indigo due to the amount of atheletism, but she doesn't give the vibe of a highblood at all. ESPECIALLY a cerulean, girlie is a pegasus she has 0 magic no psionics. MAYYBE wings mutation. maybe. MAYBE. Her being a breathbound makes sense, but not a rogue. I can *see* her being a rogue, but I just think another class could fit her better, she never really starts out with an overabundance of freedom and gives it to others, more so she radiates freedom but also gets rid of that to make sure she commits to her commitments, and boy does she COMMIT. i think prince of breath, as her element IS loyalty and she's incredibly hard working towards her goals, she doesn't just flimsy around as john does
Rarity is not a lime blood, you do not see her being a minority in any way in the show and is quite privileged, THOUGH, not privileged in the high blood sense. See, she's a jade blood Because she definitely has a huge maternal side to her with her little sister Sweetie Belle (there was a whole episode about it. come ON) and no I'm not gonna say she's a high blood either because of the episode where she Does get a taste of the high blood life and it is Not for her and it never Was her. She's a jade blood, because whilst she's got the fashion sense and mindset of a high blood, she does simple mother-like things and is much more down to earth. I 100% see Sylph of Space and have no objections. Okay I'm back-trackinf rn since i just finished writing this all but them looked back at my original message and i put rarity as a cerulean. I think it can go either way tbh, maybe? Cuz like, i can SEE cerulean as a viable option, but she's not mean enough to be a bitch. The main thing with her being cerulean is her prideful vibes, but she deeply cares and SHARES, something that ceruleans never do, but jadebloods dont explicitly do that wither aside from the communal hives and group things. Idk! She's not a lime tho
Fluttershy's a hard one, i can't for the life of me figure out her aspect. She's not a lifebound despite the whole nature thing because life also comes with prosperity and wealth, things that she does not emulate. I think she just has to be a Ragebound because it's what fits her the most, but i can't give a clear class for her. And for blood type, i guess i can see jade but. tbh she's a lime. YEAH she's a lime, lime blood fits her natural pull towards animals and things "abnormal", and the fact she lives in a little hut ways away from the town. she's Odd, she's Different, but she has the lime blood calmness to her and the kindness. descendent of jesus type mf
Hi Windows! Sorry, but I ain't reading all that
I'm happy for you tho
Or sorry that happened
/ref /j hehehe I hope you got that ANYWAYYYYYYSSS I will now rebuttal :33
BEFORE I GO ON none of this is supposed to be mean spirited or taken as gospel or some shit, mostly just me expressing my thoughts and feelings about the topic!! <333 I just want to say that some points you bring up are pretty valid! With Pinkie's bloodcaste and classpect I totally get where you're coming from with her backstory, and I did not forget about that! I mainly focused more on her abilities and personality. For her classpect I initially thought of her as a space player but thought Rarity deserved that title more since she has a creative eye more than Pinkie does. So I thought a hopebound would fit better due to how she is a big motivator in the group, going based on her own ideals. Like in season 1 episodes 10 "Swarm of the Century" and 15 "Feeling Pinkie Keen" where she applies her beliefs and her own instincts to an unfortunate situation, though in ep 15 she leans more into the heir class as she knows something is going on but isn't quite sure what it is, so she follows this feeling to figure out what it is. Heirs tend to let their aspect influence them rather then them influencing their aspect. So with Pinkie she lets her beliefs with what she knows and her sense to influence her decisions and how she acts towards other ponies and her friends! But I totally see where you are coming from with her being a bard of doom, I believe both of these classpects make sense in their own rights! Now with the bloodcaste the reason I picked gold instead of rust was due to the difference in the psionics, but upon doing more research I can totally see how Pinkie being a rust would make more sense. Though instead of her being able to move objects she would be able to detect them! I really like that idea! But personally I like the thought of her being a goldblood from a design standpoint better, makes a good excuse for her hair to be fluffy hehe With Rainbow I totally agree that rogue is not the best suited class; I've seen others classpect her as either a knight or thief but in truth I don't think a prince of breath suits her either. In the show, even if she is the element of loyalty she is very independent and sure of herself. Even at some points going against her friends to prove points! But she always there for them when she needs them. In season 1 episode 16 "Sonic Rainboom" even though Rainbow was very nervous to compete against Rarity because of her popularity, she still saved her in the end instead of leaving her to fall. And you might be thinking that this is proving your point, and it does! But the reason I don't believe Rainbow is a Prince of Breath is because she would be destroying her own freedom and the others around her. And that's definitely not the case! Now that I'm thinking about it, she might be a witch, lol! I have to agree with you she's very tough to classpect.
With AJ a lot of people categorize her as a bronzeblood BECAUSE OF SKYLLA!!!!!!!! This is why they also make her a time player!!! Because Skylla is already the troll version of AJ!! But I wanted to go against that- but it's hard due to her having a lot of the qualities of a bronzeblood! So yes, I ABSOLUTELY see her as a bronzeblood. But the reason I see her as an olive is because with bronzebloods they tend to be clingy and a bit desperate for companionship once you get closer to them, they are also a more introverted bloodcaste. Where as olivebloods are more outgoing and go out of their way to help others! When Apple Jack meets new people she isn't off putting or keeping to herself, she welcomes them with open arms! We see this exactly when she first meets twilight. Another thing with olivebloods is that they are resilient, while bronzebloods are a bit more flaky. Olives tend to truck through things better than any of the other bloodcaste, making them a great help with hard tasks! AJ is known for getting the dirty work done and doing it right.
So now that I've gotten the formalities out of the way, I have to address The stuff I absolutely HAVE to disagree on.
We'll start off in order; I can see why you believe Twilight is a violet blood, but sea dwellers are royalty. Even if she becomes royalty later on she definitely doesn't start off as a princess! Violetbloods are ASSHOLES! Twilight is not an asshole, she just cares about her goals and ambitions! With your take on wanting her to be a highblood that is more serious in her demeanor, why not a purpleblood? She could be a purpleblood who focuses not on the religion of the mirthful messiahs, but the powers they hold! But, I digress. I believe she is most likely a tealblood due to how she acts and holds herself. Teals have a very straightforward way of thinking and believe that it's their way or the highway, in a moral sense. In the first episode of the whole series she figures out that a horrible event is about to unfold, but no one takes her seriously. But when it does unfold she feels a sense of responsibility of fixing it due to her knowing the most about it. If she was a highblood and said that shit? She would've probably taken more seriously. ESPECIALLY if she was royalty!! But no. She's just a unicorn who cares too much about her studies! Typical! And with her running after the villian and these other ponies coming to help her, she discovers that with others help and care she can achieve so much more than she could've before!
While I can agree that Rainbow is hard to classpect, she was NOT hard to assign a bloodcaste in my head. See, Rainbow may be athletic but that does not mean she is strong. In season 1 episode 13 "Fall Weather Friends" it is CLEAR that Rainbow is fast, not strong. AJ is CLEARLY stronger than her, but Rainbow is clearly faster! And they are both athletic! So, it would honestly make more sense if AJ was indigo more than Rainbow being one. Another thing is the difference in personalities. Indigos are more 'excitable' and tend to jump from interest to interest. While with cobalts/ceruleans they are much more goal focused and tend to have tighter relationships with other trolls. Rainbow's main thing is her very intense interest in the wonder bolts, that's what she wants to be! She does everything she can to become one and eventually does! She is also the element of loyalty, so having those tight-knit connections mean a lot to her! Another thing about ceruleans is that you would rather want them on your team rather than against you, as they tend to be pretty competitive and will do whatever they can to win. Which you can't deny, Rainbow would 100% do the same thing. Another piece of evidence in "Fall Weather Friends" is that she will actively cheat to win!! Yes, AJ did the same thing but Rainbow started cheating first! Using her wings to move faster while AJ is an earth pony and can't do shit like that! Also Rainbow is very Vriska coded if she wasn't so loyal LMAO
Now, with Rarity and Fluttershy you flip flopped them! Which was.. an interesting take! /lh
I'll start with Rarity. I would say Rarity is privileged in beauty, not money. Rarity is a hard working pony who wants to be apart of the rich life. She wants the fame. But she does not start with these things! She makes all of her own fashion and happily flaunts it! With you making her a Jade instead of a Lime threw me off, like, she is WAYYYY too emotional and talkative to be a Jade. Jadebloods are known for being more proper and quiet, while limebloods are known for having exaggerated feelings and expressing themselves. Rarity may be proper and knows how to 'act right,' but that's because she knows the culture of privileged people. The way she acts in front of people she looks up to compared to with her friends is DRASTICALLY different. This is very apparent in season 2 episode 9 "Sweet and Elite," as it is very apparent to the audience that she was very nervous about not looking like a privileged to people in social power. So nervous that she began LYING to make herself look better to them. Even going as far to lie to her own friends to gain more social points with the rich rather than go to her own friend's birthday!! Like girl is DESPERATE for that good life!! Would a jadeblood do that?? HELL NAH they already got so much responsibility they don't give a fuck about social status. But limebloods?? ALLLL over that shit!! Karkat, who is a MUTATED LIMEBLOOD has a deep care for quadrants! Rarity has the same infatuation, but with having a rich life!! And she has an affinity with making outfits!! HEY, JUST BECAUSE SHE IS A SYLPH OF SPACE DOES NOT MEAN SHE IS KANAYA!!!! RAH!!!!!!!!1
Now, the ONLY way I could see Fluttershy being a limeblood if she LACKED her aspect, so honestly if she was a Bard of either Rage or Heart. Because, like I said before, limebloods are the MOST emotional of the bloodcaste. ALSOOOOO I hate the idea that the Life aspect is associated with money!!!! FUCK THAT!!!! Money/wealth should not be in the same category as a LIVING aspect. You know what life should represent?? ENERGY!!! And guess what? Fluttershy struggles with energy, and deep down she knows that, but tried her best to show her excitement!! In Rainbow's section earlier I mentioned the episode "Sonic Rainboom." Well, Fluttershy shows a clear point to this, with the pretty well known clip of her saying 'yay!' Rainbow over and over again tries to encourage her to become louder and use more spirit, but every time she tries to force it it doesn't come out as energetic as Rainbow would like. And Fluttershy genuinely thinks that she is being loud!! So later when she ACTUALLY yells in excitement it is no where near forced!! So, she has the potential, she just doesn't know how to use it in a controlled manner! Which, this can be argued that this would make her a maid! Which I could totally see, as she typically has to rely on other factors or ponies to give her life! Another example of one of these moments is in Season 1 Episode 7 "Dragonshy," where she is very obviously scared of the dragon and does not want to interact with it. But with her friend's motivation ( and some force ) she goes with them! After they anger the dragon and it knocks them all down, Fluttershy gains the courage to face the dragon face to face and tell it off! She wouldn't have done ANY of this if it wasn't for her friends bringing her along. Oh man I haven't even talked about her blood color yet LMAO Remember how I said that Jades are proper and quiet? Yeah, THAT'S Fluttershy!!! Fluttershy is a pretty neutral party who doesn't get involved with conflict unless ABSOLUTELY necessary. Also, Jades are typically very organized and smart. You may think, 'Oh! Then Twilight should be-' NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!! Yes, Twilight is smart and organized but in a more checklist and book smart kind of way. Fluttershy is organized with all of her chores with the animals MEMORIZED! She's not as obsessed with organization like twilight is ( another point for lack of energy ) but she still has her shit together!! And she is smart due to her natural empathy and common sense! She listens and learns through ponies and animals, not through reading materials ( Which can also be argued that she is a mage AHEM )! Jades are also known for being shy to strangers and are slow to open up! 'But Aspen that means she could be a bronze-' YES YES I KNOW!!!!! I know that blood color fits her the best I DON'T CARE!!!!!!! You know what you should consider??? FLUTTERBAT!!!!! RAINBOW DRINKER!!!!!! THE POTENTIAL!!!!!! And with Jadebloods she could be very easily outcasted!! Like, that is a pinpoint of her character!! If she was already a Bronzeblood she would be expected to be good with animals!! It makes no sense when you think about it!! With Jadebloods she's supposed to be good with grubs and wrigglers, but in season 1 episode 17 "Stare Master" we can see that she isn't the best with kids!! Yes, eventually she gets the cmc undercontrol. But in the beginning? Nope! No control over them! Which this can be tagged under Page, as she 'confidently' stated that she could handle them. But after being alone admitted that should could not!!
JESUS CHRIST THIS TOOK ME LIKE OVER 3 DAYS TO THINK AND WRITE ABOUT LMAO
Anyways I hope this cleared up my process a bit better!! But cast the main 6 as whatever you like, I value yours and others opinions!!! <333
btw i am sick rn so my ass is not gonan give a good reply
yes j got the refernexe. hell yes .
pinkie pie is better Aesthetically as a fuchsia, it makes more sense for her fluffy hair as a rust cuz in ny brain aradia has fluffy hair. and ive never seen a fluffy haired goldblood. she also is Not the main motivator of the group, shes the comic relief. ur still wrong but thars ok
ur right ab rajnbkw not destroying the freedom of herself and others and yes i was thinking exactly "ok but ur proving my point", i thought of witch but shes never really been controlling. i do not know
also i get why olive, just let her be a mudblood, olives r too well known 4 being feline lovers and criminals
ur wrong ab rarity, be better
wgen u said "so this makes her a maid" i audibly went "huh? what?" because that's a PAGE. also, 100% understand flutterbat and im giving u a pass 4 that. though u dont know what a jade blood is, u obviously dont own an airfrier . (and by air fruer i mean play friendsims and hiveswap) ALSO! it wasnt Energy that RD was lookin 4, it was rage and confidence, those arent associated with the life aspect at all, more like... oh look it says it eight therr! RAGE! page of rage, get owned
OH YEAH ALSO TWILIGHT yeah ur fuckin wrong cuz i had thought about purple twilight and absolutely not cuz her having the potential to be a clown? PLEASE. and also; she WAS a fucking asshole!! she didnt care about her friends in equestria DID U NOT SEE THE EPISODE SHE DIDNT GO TO HER BEST FRIENDS BDAY PARTY?????
i want 2 draw htme now .when im not leaking snot from my nose
