Reagents & Red Flags ~ Theo Raeken
Summary: As the pack are trying to work out Theo's true intentions, you stay late at the library, only to bump into the new arrival.
Warnings: Possible language, teasing, sarcasm.
The problem with chemistry wasnât the equations.
It was the fact that they insisted on multiplying the equations into forty-six different forms and then expected your sleep-deprived brain to understand all of them.
You were hunched over your notes at a corner table in the library - the same table you always used for studying, self-loathing, and pretending exams werenât real. Your hair was in a messy bun you didnât remember making. Your coffee was cold. Your patience was dead.
You stabbed your pen at your notebook.
âExplain why electrons hate me,â you muttered.
âThey donât,â a calm voice said behind you. âThey just prefer stability.â
Of course. Of course it had to be him.
You slowly turned, as if hoping you were hallucinating from caffeine withdrawal.
Theo stood there, hands in his pockets, head slightly tilted like heâd caught you mid-ritual sacrifice. His expression was unreadable in that infuriatingly quiet way he had, as if the entire world was a puzzle he was choosing not to solve yet.
You cleared your throat. âYou know, for a guy who allegedly doesnât sneak up on people, you sure do sneak up on people.â
He blinked once. âI said I donât try to. Not that I fail.â
You stared. ââŚAre you proud of that?â
âGreat. Wonderful. Iâll send you a badge.â
He didnât leave. Of course he didnât. He stepped closer, slow and deliberate, and your shoulders tensed before you could stop them.
Because of course he noticed.
His lips lifted - just a hint. âAre you afraid of me?â
You scoffed. Loudly. Immediately. Too immediately.
âPlease. Iâm afraid of failing my chemistry exam. You Iâm just⌠observing.â
His eyes glinted. âObserving. Thatâs what weâre calling it?â
âYes,â you snapped, then added, because you hated lying poorly, âI mean - youâre new. And mysterious. And no offence, but the pack is two conspiracy theories away from forming an official committee about you.â
Theo hummed, low in his throat. âAnd what does their committee think?â
âThat youâre shady.â
âAnd what do you think?â he asked, stepping closer.
You swallowed. âI think you have a suspiciously good skincare routine.â
That earned you a small laugh, soft and warm and completely unfair.
He nodded toward the chair across from you. âMay I?â
Then: ââŚFine. But if you steal my notes Iâll have to maul you, and I donât have the energy for that today.â
Theo sat with a quiet grace that made you feel like you were slouching even though you definitely were not.
His gaze flicked across your notebook. âChemistry?â
You bristled. âWow. Subtle.â
He lifted a shoulder. âYou were muttering threats at electrons.â
He leaned forward, elbows on the table, studying the page like he was reading without reading. âWhich section?â
You hesitated again. He was newer than a fresh ink cartridge. The pack didnât trust him. You didnât exactly trust him, either. But you trusted chemistry even less, and right now, one of them might actually help you.
You nudged the book toward him. âStoichiometry. Balancing equations. Which, by the way, is impossible. Iâm convinced the first chemist was just making things up and everyone else pretended to understand.â
Theoâs eyes softened - barely. âShow me what youâre stuck on.â
You blinked. âYou know chemistry?â
He raised a brow. âWhy does that surprise you?â
âBecause every time someone asks about your past, you answer like youâre being paid per vague sentence.â
Another soft laugh. He pointed at the first equation. âThis one. Whatâs confusing you?â
âStart with the reactants,â he said.
You stared hard at the page like it personally offended you. âTheyâre⌠reacting.â
âThat is not an answer,â he murmured.
âItâs an emotional truth.â
Theo shook his head - still amused - and slid your notebook slightly toward himself. His fingers brushed the edge of your paper, and somehow that tiny movement made your pulse jump.
You hated that he noticed. He always noticed.
He glanced up. âStill observing?â
âStill deciding,â you corrected.
He leaned back, folding his arms. âYouâre cautious.â
âAnd youâre smug about it.â
âYouâre a little smug.â
His smile widened by half a centimetre - huge, by Theo standards. âMaybe a little.â
You rolled your eyes, grabbed your pen, and pointed it at him like a weapon. âTeach me chemistry or leave. Those are your options.â
âThreatening me already?â
He lifted his hands in surrender. âVery well.â
Theo explained each step with slow, patient confidence. He didnât talk too much. Didnât talk too little. Just enough that you could follow the thread between his thoughts and the page. His voice was steady and low, calm in a way that made the tension in your shoulders ease without permission.
It was annoying.
Suspicious.
âŚNice.
You watched him more than you should have. His eyes tracked each number like he understood the logic on a level you didnât. He didnât fidget. Didnât hurry. He existed in this stillness that made everything else quiet.
When he finished balancing the equation, he tapped the notebook lightly. âYour turn.â
You bared your teeth at him. âIâm going to get this wrong on purpose just to spite you.â
âNo,â he said, voice dropping just a little, âIâm starting to understand you.â
Your brain went entirely blank. Like, flat-lined.
Theo noticed that too - of course he did - and he tilted his head.
âDid I say something wrong?â
âDonât-â You waved your pen wildly. âDonât say things like that. It sounds like flirting.â
âYES,â you blurted, then slapped a hand over your mouth.
âYou cannot flirt while I am failing chemistry. Itâs rude.â
He laughed again, this time actually audible. âYouâre very interesting.â
âBecause youâre doing the eye thing.â
âThe eye thing where you look like youâre observing me like a science experiment.â
âAh.â He leaned in slightly. âBut I like observing you.â
You choked on absolutely nothing. âTheo!â
ââŚDo you want me to?â
You glared at him so hard it couldâve melted steel. âI want you to stop being confusing.â
âIâm not confusing,â he said. âYouâre cautious. Iâm curious. It creates tension.â
âOh my god,â you groaned. âYou said tension like that on purpose.â
His smile was definitely teasing now. âMaybe.â
You forced yourself to look back at the notebook. âI hate you.â
You scowled. âShut up and watch me balance this equation.â
And when you got it right on the first try, Theo said softly-
Somehow, that felt like more trouble than chemistry ever could.
@mandmilovehim @onelesslonelygirlbieber6 @mingis-queen97 @lgbtq-girl @riowritesitall @lateej @christopherbangsnudes