I liked the manga’s overall premise and the main character, but something went wrong starting with the zombie island arc, and then it started to really annoy me how the manga tried to make me blame a kid who was totally dependent on his father and mother figures for the mess that was created by fully aware adult men.
I feel like I can't interpret it the way the author intended?? Are you supposed to trust the text more than what’s shown through the events and illustrations??
Like, sure, Yuichi makes some scary faces, but he cares about his friends and shows mercy even to his rivals, and he’s only cruel to the absolute scum. But the text says “Ooooh! He’s eeeevil!” And so I’m supposed to think of him as evil??
As a child, he’s portrayed as smart and talented, but dependent on his father and mother figures (like, you know, a normal kid). I’d even say that young Yuichi is more dependent than the average child of his supposed age. And his “villainous traits” are deliberately cultivated and encouraged by Shiba, who is the one who carries out the Tomo Dachi Game. But the text says “Yuichi was evil from the start!" and "He’s actually to blame for all of Shiba’s crimes!” And why on earth should I blame a child for the cruelty and corruption of grown ass men? I just don’t get it at all.
“He was betting on both betrayal and trust at the same time.” But in reality, most of his strategies are based on absolute faith in his friends: that Tenji won’t give up, that Yutori will do what she believes is best for him, that Shibe will come to a woman’s aid, and that Shiho will act in accordance with her own sense of “justice.” I never once got the impression that he could choose anything other than his friends. So instead of looking at things from Shiho's perspective and wondering if Yuichi betrayed them or not, I see Yuichi's friends as idiots and traitors (also they are so useless).
“Oh, he’s ready to kill such-and-such” He’s not ready to kill anyone. He shot a dangerous jerk, but managed to maim him so weakly that the guy quickly regained consciousness. And during the coin toss, when winning would have meant he’d have to kill someone’s kind caring father, his hand wavered. And this despite the fact that originally he wanted to win, otherwise Satone would have seen right through him.
And that "brilliant" ending. Why were all the problems swept under the rug? Why did we spend so many pages dwelling on the conflicts between the friends and how they were losing their minds, but weren’t shown how they healed and mended their relationship? And why are there no negative consequences for anyone except of the main villain? Maria isn’t in jail and Kokorogi isn't in a mental hospital??
And the epilogue... Yuichi is still unstable and ready to run away from his friends?? The one and only image in the last chapter hinting that they’ll patch things up, and then it all goes to hell? Then, didn't the manga itself criticize vigilantism, but now Yuichi is a vigilante himself?? Second, having friends in the game directly affected Yuichi’s results, and still his methods were quite questionable, with stress making them even harsher. Yuichi, who is ready to abandon his friends because he “isn’t worthy of being with them,” is a danger to civilians more then bad guys is a danger to himself actually.