Hey, words from an actual former homeless person here.
Those people you see who make you uncomfortable? Those arenât homeless people, theyâre beggars. Well, some of them are also homeless. Some of them are not. NOT ALL HOMELESS PEOPLE ARE BEGGARS. (Also, theyâre not all addicts, though some are. You literally know nothing about a beggarâs life except that they are beggars.)
Beggars have a uniform like any other kind of worker. They have to look as bedraggled and dirty and pathetic as possible. If you gave a beggar a chance to shower and wash their clothes, you would be damaging their earning potential. They make their money by manipulating the feelings of people who donât know much about poverty. That means they have to play to stereotypes, some of which are like a hundred years out of date.
When I was homeless, I did not beg. (I stole, dealt with charities, sometimes even worked. Yes, you can be homeless with a full-time job. Iâve worked 60 hours a week and been homeless. And I mean sleeping in a car or a tent homeless, not on somebodyâs couch homeless, though thatâs an under-counted form of homelessness. I asked for food once or twice, but I didnât look like a beggar.) I kept myself clean. I looked like anyone else. That person you pass in the store, on the bus, someone who looks just like anyone else, they could be homeless. The sales clerk who helps you for minimum wage. They could have lost their apartment because you canât pay rent on that salary.
Iâm not saying thereâs anything wrong with begging. And itâs true that some people do actually just look like that because due to mental illness or addiction they sincerely canât take care of themselves. Some of them are honestly nothing more than scam artists who have no real need, though, playing off peopleâs sympathy for those who genuinely do need help. But letâs assume that you were giving these to an actual homeless person.
- soap is not that difficult to come by if you are so inclined to have/use it. Many public bathrooms have it. Homeless shelters will give you a bar of it. If you have $10 or so for a truck stop shower, soap is provided. Running water is a lot more difficult.
- believe it or not, they may already have a toothbrush and toothpaste, and if they donât, itâs unlikely they have any interest in using them. Homeless people commonly cache useful items wrapped in plastic in a bunch of hidden places. If you want to help the homeless, next time you find one of those caches, donât throw them away. I mean, think about it. If you had to start living on the street, would you stop brushing your teeth? I didnât either. Plus, if everyone gave homeless people one of these packs, theyâd have more toothbrushes than they did teeth. Same with the deodorantâone stick lasts a long time, and they give them to you in shelters. This kind of mismanagement and waste is incredibly frustrating. People are willing to flush money down the toilet to avoid helping you TOO much.
- food is nice! But keep in mind that not everyone can eat stuff you give them. Dietary restrictions like diabetes and Crohnâs unfortunately donât go away when you become homeless. Maybe this is why they were hoping for cash? Also, some (though not all) homeless people have access to food already through food stamps, soup kitchens, charities, etc. A granola bar is nice, but they likely have other problems. If they need food, they will usually have a sign asking for food, or ask for it verbally! Otherwise food might not be a problem for them.
- Iâve given medicine to beggars when it was asked for. Medicine can be super useful if you have a need of it. But when you donât have a place to put your shit, you realize what a luxury it is to be able to store shit you donât need at the moment. At best, it could go into one of those caches, if that individual uses caches, or into a shopping cart if they haul one of those around. Or in a car if they have one.
You know whatâs useful, lightweight, and portable? MONEY.
You know what money can be used for?
- the nightly fee of some pay-shelters to keep you out of the elements.
- minutes for a pay-as-you-go phone, which can be used for emergencies, scheduling appointments with therapists, doctors, and addiction counselors, even searching for jobs or housing. There is a TON of bureaucracy involved in getting help when you have nothing, and that shit burns through your minutes. Payphones? What is this, 1980? I still have and use a phone I bought while living in my car. It was $10.
- gas for a car, if they have one. (Commoner in rural areas.)
- a hot shower at a truck stop.
- medicine, including prescription medication.
- items that protect against the elements, in their size!
- transportation. News flash, no bus will let you on for pocket change.
- items you might not even think of, like pet food (some homeless people have pets!) sanitary napkins (even if they donât look femaleâremember how the homeless rates go up if youâre queer? Yeah.) condoms (possibly for sex work? Not something you want to assume though!) diapers (adult or otherwise! seriously! You donât know their lives!) or pretty much anything else THAT IS BOUGHT AND SOLD WITH MONEY.
Does that include cigarettes, drugs, and alcohol? You bet it does. But you know what, if thatâs what they need, youâre in no position to judge. Iâve never been through withdrawal, but Iâve seen people go through it, and itâs complete shit. If that were you, yeah, you wouldnât want to get drug sick, are you fucking kidding me? Offset it with a contribution to a rehab center, whatever helps you sleep at night.
And all this is assuming the person giving you a case of the guilts is actually homeless. When they may not be. And other people you donât notice around you almost surely are.
That uncomfortable feeling you get, though? That has a name. Itâs called INEQUALITY. It means that you know you have shit other people donât have access to. You probably have resources so that even if you were in trouble, thereâd be safety nets. You have the kind of money that you can buy a bunch of care packages to assuage this horrible guilt you feel every time youâre in bed in the rain and you know someone else out there isnât. Those feelings are right. The world shouldnât be this unequal. We shouldnât have houses standing empty while people live on the street. We shouldnât have food sitting in warehouses till it spoils while people starve. We shouldnât be punishing people for trying to medicate away the pain we gave them.
If you want to REALLY help the poor, go buy a pen and paper and write to your representatives. Stop blaming âgenerational welfare usersâ for being âleeches on the system.â Tell them you want to see real aid going to people in your community. Tell them to fund the mental health system, which is inadequate for the demand and constantly getting slashed. Tell them you donât want to see food stamps cut for bad grades! Tell them a stitch in time saves nine, and if they helped people who were losing their homes, maybe there wouldnât be so many homeless. Tell them to decriminalize drug use and prostitution. Tell them to support programs like Insite. Support universal healthcare, because youâd be surprised how many people end up homeless due to illness, either in themselves or a family member. If youâre ever in a position of power, such as a landlord or employer, donât discriminate against people who donât have a current address. Also donât discriminate against marginalized groups by race, gender, orientation, ability, etc. These people are more likely to end up homeless because of this BS. Check out charities in your area doing actual outreach with the poor, many of whom are not beggars and not visible. And if youâre going to give a beggar something, either ask them what they need or just give them fucking money.
You canât make that uncomfortable feeling go away with the wave of a magic wand. You canât buy exemption from the fact that you HAVE and others DONâT with some soap and granola.