Remembrance AU: Lost in the Façade
Double post tonight and back on track.
Warnings: Death ; Suicidal attempt and ideation ; Unrequited[?] Love
Words: 3.8k
Getting caught up in the affairs of the gods wasnât something you were ever hoping to do.
You remember being absolutely terrified when you saw the wooden pillar and a familiar blond sitting at the top. Remember cursing Tubbo once more at the exile of his best friend. Remembered how much you had thought it would be a mistake. Remembered trying your hardest to not make this possibility a reality.
It hadn't been easy to sneak around Dream's back to visit your little brother. It hadn't been any easier to convince Tommy to let you do so either. He was still upset at you, but you could never be mad at him for it. He was right. Siblings don't keep things from each other.
That's why, after knowing what Dream would do to him, it hurt more that he wouldn't tell you.
Dream was standing a bit to the side, laughing, despite the forlorn look on Tommy's face. The urge to kill him again flared in your stomach and you pushed it down. Tommy needed you more than you needed the green man's death.
You nearly flew to the two, hardly feeling your feet touch the ground when your heart was beating as hard as it was.
"Tommy? Tommy, what are you doing up there?" You barely heard his sigh, but he shrugged in response and you spun on Dream. The cool night air bit your cheeks, but your blood was colder. "What is he doing? Why are you just laughing?"
Dream crossed his arms in front of himself. "Oh please, [y/n]. You don't actually think he's gonna jump, do you? He's on one life left. He wouldn't."
You didn't hold the same optimism Dream did. You turned back to your brother, sitting atop the tower before you.
"Tommy? Tommy, please come down. You're scaring me!"
"What's the point, [y/n]?"
"The point is you need to be safe. Itâs going to be okay, Tommy. I promise, just come down and-â
âYouâre right, it is going to be okay.â He had always wondered what it was like to have wings. He remembered some things of previous lives when he had them, but he never remembered flying. Was this how it felt? The breeze brushing itâs icy fingers through his hair, trying to coax him to fall. Was this how you felt every time you were about to die?
âTommy!â He looked back down at you, scooting closer to the edge. You looked so small. He felt smaller. It was so hard to focus with all of the thoughts drifting through his mind. No one had come to his party, his interaction with Drista was⌠lackluster at best. No one cared. He wasnât in a position of power anymore, who could blame them. You, Ghostbur, and Dream probably only cared out of obligation. He could feel the mist from the sea on his face.
âTommy, all of us," you shot a glare at Dream, but the man stood there, unphased, "most of us love you, Tommy. We'd be heartbroken if you were gone."
"Then why has no one else visited?" Your heart felt heavy in your chest and your words died on your lips. You didnât have an answer for the blond. You could only look up at him with eyes that slowly became more glassy the longer he sat up there.
There were flashes in his mind. Ones of him finding Tubbo in another life. The time when he was a vigilante and they had lived together, the other continuously throwing him out of windows. The one where they had become fast friends during an apocalypse. The life where they had raced together and he had fallen down a cliff side.
Tubbo wasn't here for him this time.
The feeling of the breeze brushing through his hair made his back ache, longing for the lives where he had wings. He wondered if dying this time would be like when he and Wilbur were princes. He had awoken in an orchard that was so bright, so warm, he almost longed for the battlefield again. He couldn't remember the name of it now. Blue something? He remembered the morning glories that decorated it and the apple trees that littered the orchard he had awoken in. He remembered how sweet the fruits had been. Like gapples, but with the faint taste of honey. A small part of him hoped he would return there and wait for Phil once more until the next lifetime.
Another gust of wind blew past him and Tommy was shaken from his thoughts, only to hear the two conflicting voices below him.
"I know you just want attention, give it up, Tommy. This is why you donât scheme."
"Tommy, please come down. It's not worth it. Do not listen to Dream!"
"C'mon, just jump. I know you won't."
"You're worth more than just jumping, Tommy."
"You wanted me here, Tommy. I'm your only friend now."
"You are not his friend, Dream. You're manipulating him."
"I am just telling him what he needs to hear."
Tommy's breath hitched when you shoved the masked man before you. You didn't pvp. What were you doing?
"You are trying to use him. He is not a pawn you can just play with, Dream!"
"Oh, as if you are any better." Tommy watched Dream shove you back. "None of us know who you are, [y/n]. How do we know you're not just a pawn being used yourself against all of us? How do we know you're our friend? We all remember each other. You're a new player in a game where you don't belong."
He stood above you now, porcelain mask lifeless as he started to summon his own sword. "Let's see how many lives you actually have."
Tommy noted how scared you looked, staring back at Dream, but was shocked when you just looked up at him. "Tommy, please. You need to get down. And you need to run."
Dream's sword was in hand. "Tommy, you need to find somewhere safe. Anywhere safe. Please."
An uncomfortable feeling bubbled in his chest at your words. Like you knew what would happen next. Like you knew better and were telling him the future. How could you know when you wouldnât tell him anything?
"Tommy, you need to be safe. It's going to be okay."
The sun rose and when the light hit you, casting you in a golden glow, he believed you.
Even as Dream ran you through with his sword, he believed you. His chest flickered with long gone pain as he watched the metal disappear into your heart.
So he jumped, water bucket ready.
He landed feet away and began running as fast as he could through the underbrush. His brain was just screaming at him to go back for you. But he knew you wouldn't be there. You'd wake up in your bed here in a few seconds like every other time they had watched you die, and Dream would have him again.
He needed to find Technoblade.
When you returned to where Logstedshire once stood, you relaxed when you saw Dream still there and Tommy gone. Water pooled next to the pole and you knew he had listened to you. The man turned back onto you and you glared back. âYouâve made your last mistake, Dream.â
He didnât pursue you when you turned back to LâManburg.
Gods didnât need to hunt for anything more than fun or revenge.
"He's done it again, Phil!" You nearly screeched through clenched teeth as you slammed the heavy door that led into the angel of deathâs house. The immortal barely spared you a glance and continued writing in a small leather bound journal on his desk. Each stroke of the small quill made another perfectly crafted letter, absorbing his interest.
"Take a seat, mate." Phil's voice was bewitching and you immediately perched on one of the warm seats near the fire, sucking in a quivering breath. You took a moment to glance around the familiar home to maybe calm yourself, your sudden need of keeping your composure an agonizing task.
Phil was there when you had awoken on the floor of his home after speaking with Kristin, brimming with knowledge you shouldnât have known. The man had been alive the longest. Not quite dying, always just flitting between lifetimes on the black wings of his. He had confirmed everything when you had spoken to him about your new memories, comforting you in that special way only a dad could.
Now, as you sat in the comfortable armchair, you could see evidence of every timeline he had lived through and could pinpoint each one. A green plastic bottle, a pair of fuzzy dice, a painting of an unknown woman. She didnât look like Kristin. There were large wooden bookcases that climbed up the walls filled with great quantities of journals. How many stories did he have to tell? The fire glowing in the hearth set off a gentle glow accompanied by a warmth that made the home all the more pleasing to be in. A small carved board held a thin, dipped stick that burned on the end, causing a delightful scent of vanilla to waft around the room. You sunk into the soft piece of furniture, forcing yourself to relax just a little.
Phil watched you from the corner of his eye. He had seen you stalk across the snowy field and to his front door. You didnât look happy, but he didnât expect you to be. There was plenty happening on the server at all times between the same members that were at the heart of it time and time again.
He finished his thought, setting the quill aside and recapping his ink. Heâd have to go collect more soon, he was running low. Leaving the page to dry, he walked to the kitchen. His wings rustled gently as they brushed past various objects. You watched him, crossing your arms. âPhil?â
âYes, mate?â His voice was warm and just as sweet as the vanilla in the air. Fatherly.
âDoes itâŚâ You pressed your lips together, trying to properly word the sentence. âDoes me being around bother you?â
Philâs hands paused as he went to feed the furnace to warm a kettle of water. âWhy would you ask something like that?â
You shrugged, leaning further into the chair. You werenât sure if you were trying to hide from your own thoughts or if you were trying to hide from him. âDream just-â
âNow why would you listen to him? Do you honestly care what he thinks?â You wet your lips, thinking about it.
âKinda? I care what everyone here thinks.â There was a soft shifting as you heard Phil lean back against the counter. âSome more than others. But I do care.â
âThatâs not necessarily a bad thing. Keeps you in check from doing somethinâ really wrong.â You hummed in response. âWhat did he say?â
âHe said I donât belong here.â You heard a scoff.
âWell, we both know that thatâs not true.â You thought of Tommy up on the final remains of the territory he had been so proud of. Had he actually gotten away? You thought of Techno, now exiled in the tundra far away from where you sat now. What would he think of your choices? You thought of Wilbur -now Ghostbur- and how, despite you yelling at him being the last thing he heard, he still somehow seemed to love you. Why did he still try so hard when all you seemed to do was help with the aftermath?
A hot mug was pressed into your hands and you looked up at the only one who knew your secret.
âItâs chamomile tea. Itâll help.â You nodded at him, sipping carefully at the beverage. âTell me everything that happened.â
So you recounted everything that had happened that night until your entrance bright and early in the blond manâs house, including your threat.
âDreamXDâs probably not going to like that you threatened Dream.â
You could only shrug.
âWhat does it matter? Itâs not like killing me will do anything.â
âHeâs a god, [y/n]. They have their ways.â You sighed. They were definitely fickle folk. Kristin had been kind enough when you saw her, despite the near-constant migraine you were trying to slowly adapt to, and your few meetings with Drista hadnât been horrible. But you had never crossed paths with the powerful creation god. If he were anything like Dream himself, you would hate what your first encounter would be like.
âWhen Drista killed me, it was the same as usual, so Iâm not worried. I just canât believe I didnât see the signs of Tommyâs spiral.â
âWhen she killed you?â You nodded once more. He didnât ask anymore questions, and you didnât supply him with any more answers.
You didnât fear other gods after your experiences with the first two you had already been bad. They were not bad enough to deter you.
You had first met Drista when she and Tommy were finishing building the Intimidation Tower. It was an ugly thing, made out of cobblestone, and you knew that Wilbur hated that it gave away the location of the ravine, but it made Tommy happy. It made Drista happy. So you convinced Wilbur to just let it be. It made it easier for Tommy to come home when he was lost, anyways.
She had come around a lot more after that. Always attached at the hip to Tommy, always displaying godlike power, always causing mischief. She was decently polite to you, despite being younger than Tommy with a snarky attitude. But they were a good pair to watch. She always seemed to have fun with the blond, especially when he messed up. And despite how upset he seemed to be in the moment, he was always cheerful when he told you about the things he had done with her as you attached plasters to his cuts and salve to his bruises.
So why did you find her atop the intimidation tower without him?
You climbed your way up, sitting down next to her. âHey.â
She turned her head to look at you, the familiar mask hiding her expression. âWhat do you want?â
âKinda wanna know what youâre doing up here by yourself. Tommyâs asleep right now.â You watched her pull a leg up onto the ledge and hug it.
âIâm just thinking. Itâs different being around you all than my brothers.â
âBrothers?â She only nodded her head. âI know about Dream, who else is your brother?â
There was a slight shake in her hand as she moved her hair back. âYouâve already met him. Itâs DreamXD.â
You snickered. âDreamXD is your brother?â
âWell, yeah, why else do you think I have access to creative mode?â You hummed, looking back out at the rest of the world and away from her. You hadnât really questioned it. You didnât really question a lot of things about the semantics of this world. None of it ever made sense.
âThen what happened to Dream?â
âOh, he was made, not born.â You nodded.
There was a beat, then two. It sunk in.
âExcuse me?â You heard a laugh ring from her lips.
âWhy do you think we call him âClayâ sometimes? Why he doesnât have powers? Why he shifts from life to life like the rest of them?â You took silent notice of the way she said âthemâ and not âyouâ. âHeâs a creation with just as much of a soul as the rest of the players.â
You chewed on the thought. Did that make her a god as well? You didnât ask.
âThen what were you thinking about?â
âHow fragile you all are.â Your breath caught as you suddenly felt the air rush around you. You couldnât even scream before you hit the ground, hard. The pain only lasted a moment before a yelp was heard under you and you scrambled off the bed.
Tommy was looking at you with large eyes and you muttered a small âsorryâ.
He didnât even nod at you, just shifted further back against the wall. You could never chastise someone just looking for comfort. âYâknow, itâs a little inconvenient to have you take up my whole bed while Iâm out, Toms.â
âWhat the hell, [y/n]? I didnât even hear you come in!â
âWhat were you doing in my bed? I thought I saw you lay down in your own.â You took in the dark bags under his eyes and his messy hair. He didnât answer you, just looked away with a type of melancholy you knew youâd never hope to match. âThe nightmares again, huh?â
He huffed at you, lips turning down. âIâm sorry, I didnât realize I was such an inconvenience.â He shook his head, moving to crawl out. âThis was a mistake, I shouldnât have-â
You moved to block him, sitting on the edge of the shoddily crafted mattress as you grabbed him and pulled him back. âThat is not what I meant, and you know it.â You pushed him down gently and laid next to him with an arm across his shoulders. He squirmed in your grasp. âTommy, stop. Talk to me.â
The blond hesitated before rolling onto his side to look at you. He looked so very young in the dim torchlight. Why did he seem to have to grow up so fast in every timeline? You moved your arm to run your fingers through his hair and he relaxed under the touch.
âAre we doing the right thing? It feels like weâre on some continuous loop and I canât even tell if Iâm just doing this because weâre the good guys or because Iâm the little brother and I have to listen.â You hummed, scratching his scalp gently. âI always feel left out of the loop. And whenever Iâm let in, I never have a choice on whatever it is. For the most part, I am, in fact, an idiot. But I fully admit to it, which should count for something, yeah? Why does everyone keep treating me as if I were a child? And when they arenât treating me like one, theyâre acting like I have all the answers.â
You watched his lips tremble and he scoot closer to press his face to your chest and you held him there. âWhy canât they make up their minds? I donât know what Iâm doing. I donât-â His words broke as he held onto your shirt, pressing his face closer into you. âI donât-â
You slid your other arm under his head, holding him to you tightly. If you could save him from his own fate, you would have. You two may have not been bound by blood, but he was just as much your brother as he was Wilbur and Technoâs. You would die for him. You would kill for him. Youâd do just about anything he asked. Youâd protect him from anything.
The gods would have to wipe your existence from everything to get to the ones you loved.
Dream stood next to his brother, floating silently with identical masks. You werenât afraid of them, but your lip trembled despite your resolve. DreamXD cocked his head at you, as if he himself hadnât been the one to leave you next to that river and wasnât aware of your existence. You grit your teeth silently.
âXD.â You greeted. The godâs head corrected before he reached up to remove his mask. An âxâ scar crossed his face where his eyes should have been and he grinned at you. He recovered his face once more before blipping out of sight. There would be no fight from him today, but that was a warning.
âWell then, [Y/n], tell me. What do you think would happen to you if they knew your secret? Wouldnât it make you happy to be able to indulge in the privilege we all seem to have?â You paused, a second turning to a minute, and your heart started to sound like it was beating out of your chest. You considered the possibilities. âWell?â
Dream cursed, his brother now gone. Heâd have to do this himself. He too removed his mask and you steeled yourself, crossing your arms. You stared at Dreamâs face, bare from the smiling mask that everyone was so accustomed to, displaying the sneer he held special for you. Your back was straight. You were firm. Your gaze unwavering and directing back as much of a threat as his. "I can't understand why you don't like me. You basically built this land from the ground up, and you turn out to be like this?"
His lip curled and your eyes flickered to his lips for a moment before you were back to glaring into his eyes. "You better watch your tongue around me. You canât fool me with your little âno past livesâ act. And you canât make everyone like you. I know I donât."
"You're the first who doesnât, then. And just because you donât believe that I have no other lives doesnât mean you can go blabbing to the whole server either.â
âWhat makes me happy doesnât matter. If others like me for who I am now, Iâm fine.â This turned his curled lip into a full sneer, and you couldnât stand to look at him anymore.
âSee? This is why I donât like you!â He grabbed your shoulders, and it took every ounce of your willpower to not yank yourself away. âYou try to make everyone else happy and leave yourself in the dust! You canât just do that.â
You swore your heart skipped a beat when you looked back up at him, and your eyes connected once. He wasnât angry. He was worried. You couldnât tell if it was for you or for the lost potential, but it was something you had never expected to come from Dream of all people. âWhy do you care so much? This doesnât affect you.â
âAnything concerning my brother affects me.â
âHow does this affect XD?â He released you from his grasp.
âBecause you are an anomaly and you shouldnât be here.â
âThen why doesnât he do something about it? Or Kristin? Or even Drista?â You couldnât ignore the way he looked away, seemingly ashamed.
âBecause they canât.â
So what did it mean when the gods couldnât touch you?










