Neoclassicism in Les Miserable; or, Why Grantaire and Enjolras Were Probably Banging
I thought the Grantaire/Enjolras shipping was something for the hell of it. Not really based in reality, but it kinda fits, itâs fun, shipping is fun, no one was harmed in the making of this ship, Victor Hugo might be turning in his grave but hell heâs dead, la de da.
Nope, Victor Hugo actually compares Grantaire to Hephaestion, Patroclus, Nisus, Pollux, Eudamidas, and Pechmeja. Letâs look at these people in history for a moment. Their names all appear in partnership with another person, with the exception of Eudamidas and Pechmeja. If you donât care about them, skip the next paragraph.
I researched Eudamidas and Pechmeja, but couldnât find any trace of their partners⊠Eudamidas turns up vague mentions of a brother, but he was a pretty obscure person in Lacedemonian history. He shows up in a few things passingly. Pechmeja, full name I think Ange Pechmeja, might have been a poet, but all pages found on him were in French. Which I do not speak, read, or write.)Â
So thereâs these different kinds of relationships in Greek culture that basically throw out the whole âyou can be friends or romantic partners and THAT IS ITâ thing that the Western world so loves to perpetuate (Iâm not really a fan). Very briefly, when you say âGreek Loveâ, it refers to pederasty, involving the âactiveâ lover, the erastes, and the eromenos/pais, the âboyâ, which Wikipedia tells me is an affectionate name, not actually referring to age. No, it isnât pedophilia, thatâs a different, modern term. My sources involve Wikipedia and various classes, so make of it what you will). Suffice to say, the general (grumbled) consensus is that oftentimes these relationships were romantic, close, and often sexual in nature. It wasnât really âgayâ as we now know the identity, but it was a same-sex relationship. It didnât exclude them from sleeping with women, either. Sexual identity was very different.Â
Anyways.
Patroclus and Achilles were one such pair. Acknowledged by Plato and Aeschylus to be lovers, their status is of course, still in limbo, as Medieval Christianity erased any sense of homoeroticism, while Shakespeare embraced it in Troilus and Cressida. The problem with all these relationships being called such is that centuries of various cultures and historians glorifying or condemning homosexual relationships cloud things quite a bit. All I can really say with certainty is that some historians believe they were more than Good Friends.Â
Hephaestion and Alexander the Great were one of these pairs. Look them up. Thereâs about 8 primary sources in the entire world regarding Alexander, possibly less. Not a ton of reading. They were never acknowledged as lovers in the primary sources, however, they did compare themselves to Patroclus and Achilles, who at the time, were believed to be in a relationship, see above paragraph.Â
Nisus and Euryalus were yet another pair, in Virgilâs Aeneid. Their love is acknowledged by Virgil as following the Greek Love pattern of relationships, and is called âpiusâ, or honorable.Â
And Pollux and Castor were brothers. They donât particularly fit this theory, but the implication is that Grantaire and Enjolras were very close, I believe.. They were twins.Â
The original quote is referring to Grantaire,
âThere are men who seem born to be the opposite, the reverse, the counterpart. They are Pollux, Patroclus, Nisus, Eudamidas, Hephaestion, Pechmeja. They live only upon condition of leaning on another; their names are continuations, and are only written preceded by the conjunction and; their existence is not their own; it is the other side of a destiny which is not theirs. Grantaire was one of these men. He was the reverse of Enjolras.âÂ
- Victor Hugo, Les Miserable, pg. 651
So basically Victor Hugo said that these two were intimately close, possibly banging, in the Greek Love sort of way.Â
It is also worth mentioning that Napoleon Bonaparteâs rule coincides with the neoclassicist movement in France- that is, the idolization of Greco-Roman culture. For example, the Josephine, or empire, waist on womens dresses was to create a Greco-Roman statuesque silhouette. Les Amis are all, of course, definitely not loyalists (as this is what caused Marius to fall out with his grandfather, among other things), and Marius himself turns into a fervent supporter of Bonaparte (despite being several years too late to do anything about it).Â
In conclusion, they were probably banging, or at least very emotionally intimate, and Victor Hugo implies as much. The End.
So this, this took off again. This was written four years ago you guys, like holy hell who found this. Iâm not even in the Les Mis fandom anymore. Iâm not even in fandom much at all. That said, I did end up a sociologist, and historical discourse analysis is my fucking jam, hence this addition with brand new information.Â
The wonderful @draaaaaagoooooons messaged me, to 18-year-old-meâs great satisfaction, to tell me who the fuck Pechmeja was, as they are a native French speaker and can read these sources. It turns out Pechmeja was Jean de Pechmeja, a writer, poet, and professor. He was known mostly for his friendship with a guy named Dubreuil.
The original essay-post was written about references to Patroclus and Achilles. You can see where this is going.
They were childhood friends, from the region of France where Hugo writes that Enjolras and Grantaire are from. Pechmeja moved to Paris to study, but got sick, so Dubreuil moved to go live with him and take care of him. They were basically life partners, shared everything, etc.
Fast forward a bit, now Dubreuil is sick, yikes. Pechmeja takes care of him so intensely that it gets like, talked about. Dubreuil wouldnât let anyone take care of him but Pechmeja, turning away all other visitors.Â
This being 17th or 18th century France, healthcare sucked, Dubreuil dies. Bummer. Pechmeja inherited everything, but either he also inherited Dubreuils illness or he died of a broken heart, 20 days later. Itâs said that he requested that Dubreuilâs grave be left open in order to be buried with him.
So theyâre buried together, thereâs a stone on their grave detailing their devotion to each other. They pretty much just didnât live without the other.Â
Referring back to the original postâs point, Grantaire was compared to Pechmeja in the original Les Miserable text.Â
Jesus, Victor Hugo: ease up on the foreshadowing. Â


















