Matt laughed, but there wasn’t much humour in it. He had always been morbidly entertained by irony, was all. “No, I’m pretty sure Karen ducked out when they mentioned putting on a mask and being a vigilante.” Matt wasn’t entirely sure, though. He wasn’t entirely sure of anything anymore. The firm had once seemed to be the one place where they could all be open, honest with each other, where they could be a family, part of every aspect of the others’ lives. Instead, it had been basically the exact opposite. Matt had been Daredevil, Karen was chasing down Frank, and Foggy was entertaining other job offers. They all had secrets, they had all lied at one stage or another, and that was what life summed up to, really. “Frank,” Matt said lowly, taking a long gulp of his drink. “Yeah, that’s – that’s also a story. He kind of saved my life, a while back. That was how I figured out he wasn’t in a box. Figured keeping his secret was the least I could do to pay it back.”
He wondered, sometimes, what it felt like to have relationships that weren’t as complicated as this. He wondered what it would be like to be a person that felt entirely one way or another, settling on hate or love, and not allowing the two to intersect. It seemed as if Matt had forever lived on that line, never knew when good enough was too much and vice versa. Foggy had tempered some of his bad decisions in the past, but only the ones that he had known about. Even at that, Matt rarely listened to his best friend as much as he should.
“I mean that I can do something,” Matt said. “I have these abilities, okay? I had an accident as a kid, now I hear the entire world so loud it nearly deafens me, every second of every day. I had an accident, but maybe it wasn’t an accident, maybe it was destiny. Maybe it was God telling me that I was meant to be more than just a kid from Hell’s Kitchen who had this insane idea of being a lawyer, of going to an Ivy League. I grow up, I get trained to do the things that I can do now, I keep training through the years because something, something deep down inside of me tells me that there’ll come a day when I’ll be able to use those abilities to help people. To stop anyone else going through what I did. To make amends for the people Dad hurt, maybe, if I can do that. So if I have these powers, if I have these skills, and the will to use them, and I don’t? That makes me just as bad as the people out there that want to hurt people, that kill people, that make them suffer. And I don’t ever want to be that person, Foggy. I can’t.”
There had never been a chance of Foggy, or Claire, or Karen, or anybody else talking Matt out of what he knew that he needed to do. It was beyond just wanting, now, and maybe it always had been. “No, no,” Matt said, shaking his head, feeling it go a little starry at the edges. God, how much had he drank? “I wasn’t doing … this. I was training. Maybe a bit of this. Elektra …” Matt paused, tapped his fingers against the edge of his glass, laughing lightly as he lifted it to his lips. “That was Elektra. We were showing each other what we could do. She got me, several times. The rest of the bruises, that was just sex.” Matt finished off that particular confession with a shrug, knowing that Foggy had bought the excuse that wasn’t quite an excuse a hundred times before. “Yeah, a name I’m not saying tonight,” Matt replied smoothly, even if it felt like the words should stick.
Honesty had never came easily to him. Matt doubted that it ever would. Too much honesty in one night and he bolted. He felt exhausted, like he had spent everything that he ever had to give. He didn’t want to be exhausted, didn’t have the luxury of allowing it. He would have to go out the next night, and the night after that, and protect people, protect his city. “I understand,” Matt said. “I get it. Still sounds like we’re married, though.” The joke cut itself off at the next words, and Matt felt as if the ice cubes - poor as they were in the bottom of his glass - had made their way down into his chest. “Maybe I don’t know how to love someone,” Matt said lowly. “Actually I – I know I don’t know how to love. Properly, I mean.”
Matt loved too much. He had always loved too much. The nuns had tutted over it, had touched the back of his head and said, ‘poor Matty,’ so many times that it nearly drove him insane. They thought he’d get his heart broken, and that would be him. They doubted how strong he could rebuild it back again, or the people who would let him do so, Foggy top of that list. “Only very intoxicated? Damn, because I am pissed,” Matt admitted. He needed to be, really, for this conversation. “I mean she’s back. Land of the living, just as she was, everything the same. A few things different, maybe, but she – her heart’s the same.” Still skipped a beat when she walked in and seen him, the only tell he had ever been able to cling onto. “I don’t know the ins and outs of it, but she’s back. And I’m – I’m happy about it.” If Matt could ever be truly happy, which he sincerely doubted.
“There are other things that are important to me too,” Matt said, “and you know about them.” Foggy had been the first person that Matt had ever really talked about his dad to, and definitely the first one that he had divulged his criminal leanings to. Even if the majority of Hell’s Kitchen had known, Matt knew that there was something to be said for him finally saying the words out loud.
The sound of the bottle hitting against the bar would’ve made him jump in college, the noise of it screeching in his mind for a second afterwards, but now, Matt sat perfectly still. “I’m listening,” Matt said softly, tilting his head towards Foggy as if that would make a difference. He could hear a pin drop ten blocks away if he tried, further now if he focused intently, though he preferred not to let that much stimuli in if he could help it. Foggy’s words were solid, they were laden with everything that they hadn’t said for years and everything that they had. “I can’t lose you either, Foggy,” Matt said, hoping that the desperation in his voice was anywhere close to Foggy’s, because he felt it deep down in his gut, even if he wasn’t the best at showing it. “I was trying to protect you from this. If you got hurt because of me, that…” He couldn’t even put into words how painful that would be, and he had gone to college specifically to be able to string any sentence together. “I can’t promise I’ll come back,” Matt said, “but wanting to?” He took a breath, thinking of all those dark days, all the hard weeks that he’d spent holed up in his dorm, in his apartment, in his office as the years moved on. “I can want to,” he said finally. “I want to want to, which is the first step, right?”
Matt, Karen, Frank, Foggy -- they were all tied up in each other. It was a hell of a story, but when you were living it, it felt more like a nightmare. Everything had gotten so tangled up and twisted around, the bond that used to keep them standing had become the thing choking them -- and Foggy hadn’t known what else to do but walk away. To issue the final ultimatum. A part of him had hoped it’d shock Matt, that it’d knock him out of whatever madness overtook him during the Castle case, that he’d never really let Foggy walk away. But he had. “Yeah, she’s not the only one,” Foggy whispered, picking up the empty bottle of eel and toying with it. Just to give his hands something to do. “You’ll have to tell me sometime,” he said, glancing over at Matt. “Maybe not right now. Considering we’re unpacking a lot and I’m fairly certain my head will explode if we go too much further into the twilight zone.”
Life was never meant to be this complicated. He knew he was signing up for a different life than his parents when he went to law school, but he thought it would be trials, not vigilante murderers coming back from the dead after those trials. He thought his biggest fights would be in the court room, not trying to convince his partner and best friend not to risk his life every night. He wished walking away had been as simple and clean a break as he imagined it -- but he couldn’t deny that even when they weren’t speaking, he’d been thinking about Matt. Wondering if he was okay. If he was alive.
Foggy inhaled, held his breath while Matt spoke. He wanted to understand, but the world Matt described -- that wasn’t his world. He didn’t hear everything, he didn’t see a world on fire. He saw a world that could be changed from inside the system, a world that had so much potential, even with all the crazy things happening every single day. Their lives had almost been normal once -- or at least, they had seemed normal once. “I’m not saying it’s a bad goal,” he said quietly, setting the bottle down. “I just -- I hope you know everything you’re getting into, everything you’ve been into. Because yeah, maybe it’s God’s plan or something, or maybe it’s just -- ya know, a freak accident. Maybe none of this really is your responsibility. You can’t fix the whole world by punching out bad guys.” But it was a foregone conclusion at this point. Matt Murdock was stubborn as hell, and there was no stopping him once he set his mind to something. “You’re not that person,” he said quietly. “You’re not. I just don’t want you to be a dead person, either. Martyrs get a nice mention in the history books, but they don’t ever seem happy.”
He leaned back, holding onto the bar to keep his balance. The reality was starting to hit him, settle into his stomach like a heavy weight. Really, that worry had never gone away. Foggy could pretend that with enough distance, he could forget, but how did you forget a guy like Matt Murdock? You just didn’t. “I knew she was bad news,” he said, shaking his head. “Didn’t I say that? I said that, I know I did.” His brow furrowed, and he bit his lip for a moment. “So if she was... helping you with this, if she knew about it all --” A fact that stung, just a little bit. Not only was Matt getting laid while Foggy wasn’t, but this random girl had known things about his best friend that Foggy wouldn’t find out for years. “Then what happened? Why did she leave?” he asked, because he’d never gotten a straight answer before. “Fair enough,” he whispered. “But you’re... okay, right?” he asked, a tiny note of desperation in his voice.
It was like the decision to forgive had already been made. The second they walked in here maybe, or maybe it happened months ago. Maybe it happened the day after Foggy walked away, and he’d just been too angry to see it. But Matt was right -- they were kind of married to each other. They were always going to be in each other’s lives, for better or worse. “Actually,” he said. “I got married yesterday. To Sharon Carter, remember her?” But his joke didn’t land any better than Matt’s, there was too much at stake right now. Foggy reached out, clasped a hand on Matt’s shoulder. “You’re a mess,” he agreed. “Like, eighty percent of the time. But hey, some girls dig that. And I’ve never seen anyone as passionate as you, Matt. You’ll figure it out,” he said firmly, like he was making a promise.
He was making a lot of promises in his head right now, couldn’t find the words to say them aloud. All he knew was, he was in this now. This weird, crazy life his best friend was going to live. Foggy couldn’t stop him from going down this path, but maybe he could make sure he wouldn’t walk it alone. “I was being polite,” Foggy said, scrubbing a hand over his face. “We are going to be very, very sorry tomorrow morning in court.” He shook his head, tried to process this brand new twist, and just sighed heavily. “I knew she was trouble. I mean, hooray for beating death and all, but...” He didn’t know how to feel about Elektra. She had broken Matt down completely in college, and when she returned to his life, she did it again. She left a wake of destruction in her path, but Matt fell for it every time. “And your heart?” he asked, biting his lip. “Does that mean you two are... you know, back together? Because as your newly reinstated best friend, I have to make my disapproval known.” Not that it’d make much of a difference -- and it was hard to deny something that would make Matt happy, even if it was fleeting.
Maybe all happiness was fleeting. After all, most people didn’t get a second chance at life. Once death took you, that was it. Maybe you just had to take what you could get while you had the chance -- and this felt like a chance. Foggy let out a long breath, not quite a sigh, just a moment to breathe. “Okay,” he said softly. “But you can get it, right? Why this would feel... the way it feels.” Neither of them had ever been great at talking about their feelings. Personally, he blamed society, for making men feel like the only emotion they were allowed to feel was anger. But he and Matt were more than just anger, they were more than negative, violent emotion. They had whole worlds inside them, and maybe Foggy wouldn’t ever understand every part of Matt’s world... But he’d sure as hell try.
They were both desperate tonight. Desperate to hang onto each other, even when the world wanted to rip them apart. Desperate to make each other understand everything that had been going through their minds during the Castle case, and maybe even before that. There was a lot of history to unravel, but Foggy felt like his feet were on solid ground for the first time during this conversation. “Then I guess we gotta stop lying to ourselves, huh?” he whispered, feeling the magnitude of it all hit him like a tidal wave. “I can take care of myself, you know. I helped an Avenger take down a whole group of street thugs the other night. On accident, and mostly I just cowered, but still,” he said, biting his lip again. He closed his eyes tight, but realistically speaking, he knew Matt was just being honest. “Okay,” he said again. “That’s what I needed to hear. Josie!” he called, holding up the bottle. “We’re gonna need another one of these to go, all right?” Josie rolled her eyes, but slid another bottle towards them. Foggy turned back to Matt, and stood up, enveloping him in a tight hug. “You’re a stupid asshole,” he muttered, voice muffled by Matt’s shoulder. “I needed to say that at least once. But fact is, you’re my stupid asshole, so -- your place or mine to continue this little catch up?”