Foodsy #436: Challah Bread French Toast
https://www.thekitchn.com/challah-french-toast-264194
🥖 French Toast Notes — Inspired by The Kitchn
I followed The Kitchn’s recipe for classic French toast, using challah bread. I especially liked their tip about using the oven method to dry out the bread — it’s a lifesaver when you’re short on time. Still, I’d like to try Keith’s method next time: simply unwrapping the challah and leaving it out for a day or two to naturally stale. It might produce a better texture and deeper flavor.
I realized I didn’t whisk the custard thoroughly enough. The eggs weren’t fully integrated, which made the texture a bit uneven. Next time:
Use a hand mixer or stand mixer for a smoother, more uniform custard.
Mix longer than I think I need to — aim for a silky, fully blended mixture.
Cooking Technique & Heat Control
The All-Clad frying pans heat up fast, and my first batch burned slightly even when following the “medium-high” recommendation. Going forward:
Try a lower heat (medium to low) setting.
Don’t adjust both heat and time simultaneously — test one variable first.
Watch for that golden brown stage carefully to avoid blackening.
Finding the right balance between soaking and sogginess is key. I plan to:
Use ¾-inch to 1-inch thick slices of challah for ideal structure.
Soak each slice just long enough to absorb custard without falling apart.
After soaking, place the bread on a wire rack (so it’s elevated and can dry slightly before frying). I’ll check with Brady about which of our racks works best.
A few flavor ideas came up while making this:
Try adding a splash of sherry or Chambord (Brady’s dad’s method vs. Brady’s preference) for depth or a hint of berry flavor.
Experiment with fruit syrups made from jam — a great way to use up jam jars and introduce subtle sweetness and complexity.
✅ Let challah dry naturally next time
✅ Whisk custard more thoroughly (use hand mixer)
✅ Lower the pan heat slightly
✅ Watch cooking time closely
✅ Use wire rack post-soak
✅ Test jam syrups for topping