The Inner Monologue of a One Night Stand
The guy you think you are in love with, the one you think you’ve been in love with for eight years, has been on tour all summer with a massive pop star, and he’s just told you he’s fucked more women in the past few months than he can remember.
Three years ago you kissed (once). He was so nervous and hurt from his ex that he stopped you when you tried to reach your hand inside his jeans. You really wanted to reach your hand inside his jeans.
Two years ago, he told you he was probably in love with you but you had a boyfriend and he’s politely never mentioned it again.
You had been thinking about him all summer, thinking he was the only good guy out there and how finally you were both single but now you feel a bit deceived after receiving his news. He is coming home soon and now you are less excited, less charmed, less interested. Suddenly, he feels like everyone else.
On a whim, you decide to text the person you’ve been sporadically sleeping with. He replies surprisingly fast and invites you over to his place. You’ve never been there before so you ask for an address, leave the party you’re at and head home to shave your legs in the sink.
This person you’ve been sporadically sleeping with is someone who isn’t really in your life but also isn’t totally out of your life. He’s a parenthesis, actually. Your friends don’t know anything about him, though they allude to the nameless, faceless men you have casually mentioned over the summer with raised brows while complaining about their boring boyfriends.
The guy you are about to see was very intentionally chosen for a quick hook up three months ago because you had completely cut off contact with your serious boyfriend. When the whole ordeal was finally over, you had dramatically convinced yourself nobody would ever sleep with (or love) you again. So you made a goal for yourself: to sleep with at least one or three people, you know, to move on.
“Time to move on,” like the song says.
The problem is you don’t know of anyone to sleep with. Since you’ve had a boyfriend you had stopped paying attention to any men around you and you aren’t as confident as you used to be. So you find this guy through a popular hook up app that most single people have downloaded and deleted and downloaded again on their phones, an app that you declare has destroyed romance.
The guy you choose on there is tall and cute. He likes sports (you think). He wears flip-flops. No, he doesn’t like to read and he can’t remember the last time he had been to a concert but that’s perfect. You want someone like this, someone who isn’t a musician or a writer. Someone who isn’t your type.
You want someone different than you.
Turns out he wants someone different than him, too. To him, you are a hipster, an artsy girl, a weirdo, and that turns him on a little bit.
When he asks you what you are looking for, you simply reply: transient validation through sex
…and he laughs at your honesty.
So after a string of flirty texts, you decide to meet at that lame bar on Hollywood. You find him attractive but conversation is whatever and after less than an hour, you leave. To your surprise, he texts you afterward saying he wished he had kissed you.
What the hell, you think, this is why you met him in the first place, right? You daringly invite him straight to your little apartment, saying: the door is open, come in, take a right at the end of the hall and don’t speak, just start fucking me.
Thinking back, you’re lucky you didn’t get killed.
But this is something you have wanted to do all your life and you’ve always been a fan of fulfilling fantasies. Turns out he is a good listener. He arrives quietly, enters your room, immediately kicks off his shoes and pulls off his shirt as you watch from your bed.
Pretty soon his lips, his body are on you. He doesn’t even fumble when he puts on the condom, he’s that smooth.
It all happens in less than twenty minutes.
He didn’t even say hello.
He doesn’t say goodbye either because that wasn’t part of the plan (no talking) but as he leaves, he places another condom on your desk and says,
To this day, that is still one of the hottest things a guy has said to you. You didn’t expect to actually talk again, his purpose now served, but you are both so blown away by how hot it was that you stay in touch.
You are both out of town a lot and have opposite schedules, but you manage to meet again.That night, the sex is just as good and you realize he is actually fun to talk to. He is surprised by how cool he finds you. This happens a few more times with months in between. Since you don’t like him and have nothing in common, you can go weeks without texting and not give a shit at all. Tonight at the party is one of those nights you decide to talk again.
You text him and he says right away: come over.
You haven’t seen him in awhile but you’ve been so busy with work and horny that this feels like a good idea. Because it’s LA, the electricity is randomly out on your entire block. So here you are, shaving your legs in the sink by candlelight and putting on lacy black underwear. You decide not to wear a bra.
You drive to his apartment and are surprised to find that he lives in a modern condo surrounded by palm trees, bougainvilleas and other equally fancy condos.
The air on this side of town is distinctly warmer than in your neighborhood. When he lets you in, you enter what can only be described as a bachelor pad. There is nothing in the living room except for a grey leather couch and a massive TV.
He offers you a water and courteously pours it in a glass as you watch and make small talk. You feel like he has his shit together because he uses a Brita filter. He looks cute and although he is going a little bit bald, you don’t mind. He is wearing flip-flops, something you made fun of him for before, basketball shorts and a tee shirt with the Nike logo.
He looks like the guy next door. He’s all-American, the kind of guy who would’ve made fun of you in high school. You notice how sterile the place is, not a single piece of clutter, not even a piece of mail or a misplaced shoe. Nothing on the walls. You search for signs of what kind of person he might actually be.
This is something you notice every time you talk. He is impossible to get to know and also doesn’t want to get to know you. Maybe this is on purpose. There’s a wall and you accept that because you are/he is just a fling.
The only book he owns is yours, which he secretly bought online after the first time he met you. He never told you if he liked it so you assume he didn’t read it, didn’t understand it or didn’t care for it. You always wanted someone to fall in love with you solely from reading one of your stories but it hasn’t happened. There are certain people you truly believe should be in love with you but they aren’t.
It’s eerily quiet as you sit down in his apartment, so quiet that you can hear that constant white noise that is stuck in your ears from all the loud concerts you’ve attended over the years.
Somehow, you begin talking about his “career.” Which is second photography assistant for reality TV shows and commercials. You ask him what the endgame is, what he wants to do because everyone in LA wants to do something.
He isn’t sure. Says maybe he will be a producer and when you ask him what that means, he gives an evasive answer. You don’t like guys who don’t have impossibly large goals but this doesn’t matter:
you are/he is just a fling.
You tell him maybe one day you will work in television too and with great delusion of grandeur you talk about all the TV shows you would like to be writing for. It seems, you think, that the universe owes you this. A paycheck for being a writer. Because why not?
Then you admit, as you sip on the filtered water, that the problem is you don’t have any fucking ideas.
What good is a writer without any ideas? You ask.
He laughs for the first time and you start to feel comfortable.
You cross your legs on his couch and then realize the leather is too nice for that and put them back down. You touch his arm and tell him he’s so normal; he doesn’t even have any tattoos. You mention you want to get another and he doesn’t ask you of what, just where.
You get up to use the bathroom and while washing your hands, you think to yourself how wonderful it is to be young and in Los Angeles and in this apartment with such an all-American dude, about to have hot sex. We’re all adults here now. You feel like you are watching this scene unfold from afar instead of being the main character.
You return and ask him to put some music on and after laughing at the few playlists he has made on his phone, you quickly pull together a couple of sexy albums, and finally the mood is set.
He jokes and says, “I thought you just came here to hang out.”
You can tell he is already hard through his flimsy basketball shorts (you have never been friends with the kind of guy who wears basketball shorts) and he leads you into his bedroom. There, he lights a candle and you have to reset the mood by playing music on your phone.
His bedroom is just as empty as the rest of his apartment and you glance around trying to find some sign of his personality. You feel as if you are in a catalogue for a furniture company. He asks you if you think his pillowcases should be grey instead of white. The whole room, his carpet, his bedspread, his walls are grey and you call him a bachelor.
He stretches out, all masculine and confident, already naked on top of his sheets. He watches you undress and calls you a hipster, with your skinny jeans, as you struggle to slide them off.
There’s nothing more to talk about so you walk over to the bed, let your lips hesitate for a moment in front of his, and then kiss. He’s admitted to you before he’s “not really a fan of foreplay” but you try to tease him anyway. You climb on top of him, your knee between his thighs, pushing rhythmically as you kiss his neck.
You make sure not to be sloppy with your mouth. You bite his bottom lip, you bite his nipples maybe a little too hard and work your way down. You kiss his torso in a way that makes his whole body arch toward you. He is quiet so it’s difficult to tell if he likes any of this.
You listen to his body instead.
When you finally go down on him, you make note that he has shaved down there and his hand is on your head trying to push himself deeper, faster. You slap him away and your slap says, “I’m in control.”
He has barely touched you but by the time you’re done, you’re so wet it doesn’t matter. He slips a condom on, again, smooth as fuck.
He’s on top of you and really, it all feels very passionate. The kind of sex that could trick you into thinking it means something if you aren’t careful. He goes really slow this time and he doesn’t feel as hard as before and you think to yourself that probably means
1) he thinks you are gross and ugly
or 2) he’s trying not to cum too soon.
This works in your favor because the pace is achingly slow, which is how you like to have sex, and after a few minutes you reach your hand between your thighs and tell him to go faster.
It isn’t long before you cum, hard.
In the back of your head, you think of your girl friends that say they can’t orgasm without an emotional connection and you think of that article on the Huffington Post that says there is no actual proof there is a g-spot and most women can’t have an orgasm during sex. You are grateful that none of these things pertain to you.
In fact, the opposite is happening. Every person you have slept with in the past year has been able to make you cum on the first or second try and quite easily. You attest this not to your sexual prowess or their skills but mostly due to the fact that
you know how to use your hand
3. you had thrown away your last bottle of Lexapro.
This, you think, is your reward for spending weeks in withdrawal, dizzy and nauseous as you weaned yourself off the drug. The drug that made you tired and asexual. The drug that turned your rail thin body into curves that you disdain. But it’s also the drug that saved your life when three years ago going to places like the convenient store or riding the train seemed like impossible feats, and you could only eat a tiny list of “safe” foods.
You want to bask in these small orgasmic victories now in case the panic attacks return, in case the depression returns, in case your shitty life returns, and you hope that they won’t because you’ve (mostly) gotten over your past and your fears and you worked really hard to do that.
After you orgasm, he asks you if you came, which annoys you because it’s quite obvious and then he is suddenly super hard, poking at your g-spot that the Huffington Post claims doesn’t exist, and you moan encouragingly while he asks you where he should cum.
“On my tits,” you say like a good girl playing bad.
He pulls off the condom and once again, is a great listener.
When he stands up and leaves the room to get you a towel, you turn to your left, where you realize the closet is actually a massive mirrored door. You look at your face and then your breasts and your stomach and your thighs as you cringe. You adjust your legs and arms in a way that might make you look sexier, skinnier but it’s hard to look cute with a puddle of cum all over you.
You give up. This is how you look. You remember he once told you being insecure was a major turn off yet he’s never called you hot, he’s never called you funny or smart, he’s never called you anything that might provide the fleeting validation one seeks from a meaningless lover.
Finally, he hands you a towel and then goes back into the bathroom for what seems like an hour, washing off his dick. Then you go in there and wash yourself too and pray that you don’t get a UTI because that’s how your body punishes you when you have sex with someone you probably aren’t supposed to.
You return to the bedroom and minor cuddling ensues where you scratch his back and he wraps his arms around you. This is your favorite part, you think. Not cuddling but the conversation that follows an orgasm. This is when the wall goes down.
He mentions that he would never date a girl who he slept with the first night he met her and that most guys wouldn’t. He says it makes her less desirable and makes guys want to put less effort in. He only likes girls who make him wait. All guys, he says, think like this.
Obviously, he has slept with you the first night so this feels a little awkward. You roll through the list of men you have dated and whether or not you slept with them the first night. You ask him if he’s ever been in love and when was the last time he had a serious girlfriend and the answer is yes, in high school he was in love (you say that doesn’t count) and his last girlfriend was 6 years ago, when he was 22 (also doesn’t count).
You say it’s obvious he has never been in love solely because he doesn’t understand foreplay and you are feeling a little offended that he has lumped you into a category of women he wouldn’t date (even though you don’t want to date him either) and wonder what other guys have lumped you into this category (probably everyone).
You remember last month how he wouldn’t fuck you because you were on your period and vaguely wonder: is he a misogynist?
He talks about how he once met a girl who he thought could be THE ONE; she had all these perfect qualities.
She was a teacher and liked to run and do yoga and cook and paint her nails to match his favorite sports teams and you wonder if his dick had really just been inside of you.
You don’t know how to steer the conversation away from this and start to feel beside the point. Then he asks you about the new guy you like, an Australian composer, and you try not to give many details. You stupidly had mentioned him at some point in the past few weeks. He is fishing to see if you have slept with him and you don’t want to answer.
This suddenly isn’t feeling fun at all. The vibe is off. You feel inelegant and like an idiot. You feel like, let’s just go ahead and say it, a slut.
Your immediate reaction is to flee.
Somehow, the conversation takes an even worse turn and he starts talking about his penis and how girls like his size. You instantly think to yourself how many girls? and you find yourself assessing out loud your own stupid fucking opinions on penis size and he is probably thinking to himself how many guys? if he’s thinking anything at all.
It is the least intimate conversation you can have with someone you have just been intimate with: lying there talking about other people you’ve slept with and other people you like more than the person you are with.
Suddenly, you feel very alone.
You are the most alone person in the entire world.
(Earlier, you had applauded yourself for being so sexually free. Now, you scold yourself for being in this situation, for giving life to this sort of relationship and conversation.
This is a constant push and pull for you: wanting to be sexually free and not giving a fuck but also wanting to take your time, to save yourself for someone who deserves it, who has earned it, to attract something more meaningful into your life.
But the bottom line is: you’re better than this.
This is worse than that empty feeling you had earlier today at the hair salon where the woman next to you gushes about how excited her husband and family and sorority sisters are that she’s pregnant. That was when you realized you hate everybody, you will never be happy, you can’t imagine ever wanting to be a mother, you can’t even imagine that feeling of what it’s like to be loved, romantically or otherwise.
In fact, you keep meeting people who hate love, who don’t believe in it, who avoid it, who curse it and each one of those people has taken a piece of you.)
He is lying on his back now, with one arm resting over his forehead. The candle is leaving a sinister glow on his face. By now, your vagina has dried up like the Sahara desert as your thoughts snowball. You say you are going to leave and he doesn’t even pretend to want you to stay a little longer.
You grope around the floor for your clothes, your once sexy underwear feels slimy and cold and when you find your jeans, you move to the corner by the door to put them on.
“I hate that mirror,” you say to him, pointing at the closet door you are avoiding while pulling up your too tight jeans, and he says he loves it.
Insecurity, it really is such a turn off.
He asks you if you are leaving and you say yes (isn’t that what you just said?).
Only slightly confused, he gets up and starts to dress and asks if you are parked far. He says he will walk you to your car. What a fucking gentleman.
You find your bag in his living room and head for the door while he is still pulling up those stupid basketball shorts.
You’re embarrassed for having emotions.
You say in a not so great tone that you don’t need him to walk you out but thanks. Finally, he catches that something weird is going on and asks from across the room if everything is okay.
You have already opened the door, one foot out, but you don’t want your voice to echo down the hallway so you close it for a second and pause. You can’t put your finger on this feeling.
“That just wasn’t very good post sex conversation,” you say and shrug. You realize he has now lumped you into another category: crazy girl…(and you really could care less).
His eyes widen and he says, “Oh shit, I didn’t mean to bum you out.” And you leave.
You are, needless to say, bummed out. Not about him but more about yourself and your suddenly bleak future of dating, of love, of connection, of adulthood, of your lack of feminism when it comes to your dead-end relationships.
You walk to your car trying to figure out what the hell just happened. You sit behind the steering wheel trying to shake the feeling of the evening and he has already texted you. He doesn’t ask why you left, just wishes you a good night in what feels like a weak attempt to salvage the past 15–20 minutes.
You start your car, put on Bob Dylan, and decide to take the long way home.*
from my new book book Stories for People Who Hate Love available on Amazon